Home › Archive › DoW

DOW-UAP-D126 — AAWSAP DIRD, Advanced Nuclear Propulsion for Manned Deep Space Missions, March 2010

File DOW-UAP-D126 is a declassified pdf from Department of War, recording an incident dated 3/11/10 at Las Vegas, Nevada, published in Release 06 (2026-09-18). This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.

File
DOW-UAP-D126
Agency
Department of War
Incident date
3/11/10
Location
Las Vegas, Nevada
Released in
Release 06 (2026-09-18)
File type
PDF

Topics: AAWSAP & DIRDs

This document is a Defense Intelligence Reference Document (DIRD), a technical reference format used by the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) to capture baseline knowledge on a specific topic for later analytic use. DIRDs are best understood as reference and synthesis products rather than as original research. It is one of 38 DIRDs produced under the Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Applications Program (AAWSAP) between 2009 and 2011. Because AAWSAP’s scope permitted a broad range of supporting topics, not every DIRD in the series directly concerns aerospace systems or future threat assessment. The following summary reflects the DIRD’s scope and framing at the time of writing and should not be read as implying current validation of the concepts discussed.

This DIRD examines advanced nuclear propulsion for crewed deep-space travel and argues that human missions beyond the Moon would require propulsion systems with both very high thrust and very high specific impulse, which the author contends are difficult to achieve with conventional chemical, nuclear-thermal, and nuclear-electric systems. The report focuses on concepts derived from Project Orion, the discontinued General Atomics nuclear pulse propulsion study sponsored first by ARPA and later by the U.S. Air Force between 1958 and 1965, in which a spacecraft would be driven by repeated nuclear explosions. In this case, the DIRD emphasizes small non-fission-triggered fusion explosions using deuterium, magnetic mirrors, and other unconventional ignition concepts intended to avoid the inefficiencies associated with small fission devices. It presents these ideas as a possible pathway to crewed missions across the solar system, while also linking them to broader visions of long-range human expansion into space. The document is exploratory in character and depends on several unproven ignition methods, enabling technologies, and engineering assumptions. Overall, it is a theoretical examination of fusion-based pulse propulsion concepts rather than as a documentary account of a technology nearing practical realization.

Open original file · WAR.GOV page

TL;DR

Nice that the 2010 paper propels more than Vegas’s slot machines.

  • DIRD DOW-UAP-D126, DoW, March 2010, Las Vegas, NV.
  • Discusses fusion-pulse propulsion using deuterium, magnetic mirrors, and non-fission ignition concepts.
  • No official conclusion in the file

AI summary

A 2010 unclassified document prepared by the Defense Intelligence Agency titled "Advanced Nuclear Propulsion for Manned Deep Space Missions" discusses technical aspects of nuclear propulsion, focusing on deuterium and fusion reactions. It outlines various propulsion methods, fuel sources, and energy production techniques, including thermonuclear rockets, deuterium-tritium and deuterium-deuterium reactions, and magnetic entrapment of fusion products. The document covers technical challenges, spacecraft design, and historical classified reports from 1970 and 1979. It includes equations related to plasma physics, magnetic fields, and nuclear energy, as well as references to scientists and concepts such as Freeman Dyson. The text explores advanced nuclear propulsion concepts like proton beam ignition, laser and explosive fusion ignition, and superexplosives, with a focus on deep space mission applications.

Full text

Page 2

UNCLASSIFIED//F&R 8FFIOIAL l!ISE 8HLY

Advanced Nuclear Propulsion for Manned Deep Space

Missions

Prepared by:
Acquisition Support Division (DW0-3)
Defense Warning Office
Directorate for Analysis
Defense Intelligence Agency
Author:

AAP Person 72

Administrative Note
COPYRIGHT WARNING: Further dissemination of the photographs in this publication is not authorized.

This product is one in a series of advanced t echnology reports produced in FY 2009
under the Defense Intelligence Agency, Defense Warning Office's Advanced Aerospace
Weapon System Applications (AAWSA). Program. Comments or questions pertaining to
this document should be addressed to lAAP Person 1
AAWSA Program
Manager, Defense Intell igence Agency, ATTN: CLAR/DWO- 3, Bldg 6000 , Washington,
DC 20340-5100 .

l

ii

UNCLASSIFIED//509 OFFICIAL 11 &ili Qtll.¥

Page 3

UNCLASSIFIED/ fFOA OFFIEIAk W&liii 8Ptl¥

Contents
Preface ....................................................................................................................v
Introduction ........................................................................................................... 1
Deuterium, Argon Ion Lasers, and Kev Superexplosives ........................................ 1
Magnetic Insulation and Inductive Charging .......................................................... 3
Magnetic Insulation ........................................................................................... 3
Inductive Charging .................................................................................................................................... 4
Deuterium as the Preferred Nuclear Rocket Fuel .................................................... 5
Magnetic Entrapment of the Charged Fusion Products and the Stopping of the
Proton Beam in Dense Deuterium .......................................................................... 6
Solution in Between Two Extremes ...................................................................... 10
The Nonfission Ignition of Small Deuterium Nuclear Explosives .......................... 13
Delivery of a Gev Proton Beam Onto the Deuterium Fusion Explosive .................. 15
Lifting of Large Payloads Into Earth Orbit ............................................................ 16
Neutron Entrapment in an Autocatalytic Thermonuclear Detonation Wave - a
Means to Increase the Specific Impulse and to Solve the Large Radiator Problem 18
Testing the Deuterium Microdetonation Concept .................................................. 20
Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 25
Appendix: Conjectured Metastable Superexplosives Formed Under High Pressure
for Thermonuclear Ignition .................................................................................. 26
Bombardment of a Solid Target With an Intense Relativistic Electron or Ion
Beam ................................................................................................................ 28
Hypervelocity Impact ....................................................................................... 28
Bombardment of a Solid Target With Beams or By Hypervelocity Impact,
Followed By a Convergent Shock Wave ............................................................ 28
References ........................................................................................................... 30

iii

UNCLASSIFIED/ /POil Offl@IAL YSIE 8Ptll/

Page 4

UNCLASSIFIED/ /Pelt eFFl@IAL l:ISIE 8HLY
Figures
Figure 1. Ignition With 107 -Ampere GeV Proton Beam ......................................... 11
Figure 2. Pure Deuterium Fusion Explosion Ignited With an Intense Ion Beam ... 14
Figure 3. Screening of the Spacecraft................................................................... 14
Figure 4. Superconducting "Atomic" Spaceship .................................................... 15
Figure 5. Argon Ion Laser Igniter ......................................................................... 17
Figure 6. Autocatalytic Thermonuclear Detonation Using a Soft X-ray ................. 18
Figure 7. Ordinary Marx Generator ....................................................................... 21
Figure 8. Super Marx Generator ........................................................................... 21
Figure 9. Artist's Conception of a 1.5-km-Long Super Marx Generator ................. 21
Figure 10. Detail View of a Section of the Super Marx Generator ......................... 22
Figure 11. Injection of GeV - 10 MA Proton Beam ................................................ 22
Figure 12. Showing a Few Elements of the Super Marx Generator ....................... 22
Figure 13. The Superconducting Toroidal Capacitor and Its Discharge Onto the
Target.................................................................................................. 24
Figure 14. Explosives ........................................................................................... 26
Figure 15. With Increasing Pressure, Electron-Bridges are Formed Between
Shells Inside Shells Melting Into Common Shells ................................ 26
Figure 16. p-d, Pressure ....................................................................................... 29
Figure 17. Inertial Confinement Fast-Ignition Configuration ................................ 30

Tables
Table 1. The Charged Fusion Products of a Detonation in Deuterium: Their
Energy and Velocity .................................................................................. 5
Table 2. Critical Ignition Currents for Thermonuclear Reactions ............................ 8

iv

UNCLASSIFIED/ /Felt 8Ffl@IAI: l:l&lii &PU.¥

Page 5

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFl@IAL l::l!H! 8HL'I

Advanced Nuclear Propulsion for Manned Deep Space
Missions
Preface
My interest in space flight dates to when I was about 10 years old and
received as a birthday gift a popular book about the feasibility of space flight.
From it I learned for the first time about Oberth and Goddard and of the
possibility of reaching the Moon with a multistage rocket. This occurred at the
same time that Hahn and Strassmann announced the discovery of nuclear
fission, with the possibility of an atomic bomb by a fission chain reaction.
Having been born in Germany in 1929, I received my Ph.D. in physics under
Heisenberg in 1955. Inspired by the 15-megaton hydrogen bomb test
conducted by the United States in 1952, I have been deeply interested in the
nonfission ignition of thermonuclear reactions by inertial confinement since
1954. At the time all fusion research in the United States was still classified,
but I had quite independently discovered the basic principles of inertial
confinement, the Guderley convergent shock wave, and the Rayleigh
imploding shell solutions. In 1956 I presented my findings at a meeting
organized by Von Weizsacker at the Max Planck Institute in Goettingen. The
abstracts of this meeting reside today in the University of Stuttgart library.
In 1958 I had delivered a paper at the 2nd United Nations Conference on the
Peaceful Use of Atomic Energy on Nerva-type nuclear rocket reactors. The
paper turned out to be of some importance as I was invited by the U.S.
government to come to the United States under "Operation Paperclip." In San
Diego I met Ted Taylor and Freeman Dyson, who were working on the famous
"Orion" nuclear bomb propulsion concept. This concept is generally credited to
Stanislaw Ulam, but I know from conversations I had with Heisenberg that a
similar idea had been presented to Heisenberg by Wernher von Braun in Berlin
in or around 1942. Because of my idea to use the Guderley convergent shock
wave solution for thermonuclear ignition, Ted Taylor and Freeman Dyson were
interested in my joining their group. But because at that time this work was
classified and I was not yet a U.S. citizen, this was not possible.
In 1967 I saw a new possibility for the nonfission ignition of thermonuclear
microexplosions by intense relativistic electron and ion beams, driven by a
high-voltage Marx generator. This ignition concept could be used not only to
control the release of energy by nuclear fusion, but also to propel a spacecraft,
replacing the pusher plate of the Orion concept with a magnetic mirror,
reflecting the plasma-fireball of the thermonuclear microexplosion (Reference
1, 2). This idea was adopted by the British Interplanetary Society in its 1978
Project Daedalus starship study, replacing a neutron-rich deuterium-tritium
(OT) thermonuclear explosive with a neutron-poor deuterium-helium3 (DHe3)
explosive (Reference 3). Unlike the OT reaction, in which 80 percent of the
released energy goes into neutrons, most of the energy in the D-He3 reaction
goes into alpha particles, which can be deflected by a magnetic mirror. But

V

UNCLASSIFIED/ ,'FOR OFFI&I.t.k Wliliii QfslL¥

Page 6

UNCLASSIFIED/ /PO" OPPICIJ!tt l:191! OHL'f
because He3 is not abundantly available everywhere, it was proposed to
"mine" it from Jupiter's atmosphere.
Studies have been conducted on spacecraft propulsion with the matter­
antimatter annihilation reaction, however, it is an enormous technical
challenge to produce antimatter in appreciable quantities. The idea of using
nano-gram amounts of antimatter for the ignition of fission-fusion
microexplosions appears to have credible potential, but even there the
production and storage of nano-gram quantities of antimatter pose serious
technical problems (Reference 4).
We have little reason to expect that new fundamental laws of physics that
could lead to a breakthrough in propulsion still await discovery. Very much as
America was discovered only once, it is quite possible that all the fundamental
laws of physics relevant to propulsion have been discovered, challenging our
imagination to find out if they are sufficient to invent propulsion systems that
ultimately might bring us to Earthlike planets of nearby solar systems.
I conclude this preface with an imaginary talk by Ted Taylor to Freeman Dyson
as recorded by the latter's son, George Dyson, in his book Project Orion - The
True Story of the Atomic Spaceship (Reference 5), followed by a dream of Ted
Taylor's. "Freeman's hope for the Orion had rested on the fact that there
seems to be no law of nature forbidding the construction of fission-free
bombs," and on the belief that "improvements in the design of the nuclear
devices (by reducing the fraction of total yield due to fission) might achieve
reduction factors of 10 2 to 103 • This belief in small, fission-free bombs has
largely evaporated." "One exception is Ted (Taylor). He remains convinced
that small, clean bombs could propel Orion - but he still fears more than ever
that such devices would be irresistible as weapons, until we outgrow the habit
of war. There are lots of different routes to that final result of a very clean
bomb." "Could you make a one-kiloton explosion in which the fission yield was
zero, which is bad news on the proliferation front, but could turn Orion into
something quite clean?" "Freeman thinks Ted is wrong - and Ted hopes
Freeman is right." I for my part think Freeman is wrong.
Many years later, shortly before his death, Ted Taylor reported: "I had a dream
last night, about a new form of nuclear weapon, and I am really scared of it."
He reported that when he woke up, he wrote down his dream, and it appeared
scientifically sound and feasible. What was it? We never will know with
certainty, but I have a guess: it is the possibility of chemical superexplosives
(explained in the appendix) powerful enough to ignite a thermonuclear bomb.

vi

UNCLASSIFIED/ /POil orr1e1s1tt tl!H! OHL¥

Page 7

UNCLASSIFIED/ ;'FOR OFFl&I.t.k Wlilii QNL¥

Introduction
As Hermann Oberth proved for chem ical rockets in his 1923 book The Rocket into
Planetary Space (Reference 6), this paper will try to prove for thermonuclear rockets
the following:
•

At the present state of science and technology one can build spaceships driven by
deuterium thermonuclear reactions, able to reach the outer limits of the solar
system.

•

Such spaceships permit the manned exploration of the entire solar system and
beyond, with the ultimate potential to reach nearby solar systems.

•

The cost in research and development to build such spaceships will be high but still
well within what is economically feasible.

•

Using the same physical principles as for deuterium fusion rockets will also lead to
the realization of clean nuclear energy, justifying the expenditures for these large
projects.

Deuterium can be used as the rocket fuel of choice in addition to any inert material that
is suitable as a propellant. This propellant material is available on most planetary
bodies and particularly on the comets of the Oort cloud. The main idea is that by
gradual radial expansion from the Sun by building bridges over the Oort clouds, which
presumably surround all suns, Earthlike planets in neighboring solar systems can
eventually be reached.
The first and most important step toward this goal is to reach the focus of the Einstein
gravitational lens at 550 AU (astronomical units). At this location, one can use the Sun
as the lens of a super telescope, an idea first proposed by Claudio Maccone in 1993.
Present knowledge is that there are planets in nearby solar systems that are likely
Earthlike planets. It is only with this gigantic telescope that one can determine if life on
these planets is possible. But because of the complexity of this task, a manned mission
to the Einstein gravitational lens focus is likely to be needed, possible only with
advanced nuclear rocket propulsion.

Deuterium, Argon Ion Lasers, and KeV Superexplosives
The goal is a spacecrah that can be refueled while landing on a planetary body, which
can be a planet, an asteroid, or a comet. With heavy water available on many planetary
bodies but in particular on comets, this suggests the use of deuterium (D) as the
thermonuclear rocket fuel. Ignition of deuterium though, is more difficult than ignition
of the deuterium-triti um (DT) reaction or of the deuterium-helium3 (DHe 3 ) reaction.
The DT reaction is the easiest to ignite, but 80 percent of the energy goes into
neutrons, which cannot be deflected by a magnetic mirror. In the DHe 3 reaction all the
energy goes into charged fusion products, but in a mixture of D with He 3 there are still
some neutron -producing deuterium -deuterium (DD) reactions. More important is the
fact that, unlike deuterium, He 3 is largely unavailable. There is some indication of He 3
on the surface of Moon. In the Daedalus starship study by the British Interplanetary

1

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR 8FFl@IAL t:191!! 8HL t

Page 8

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR err1e1J1tt U.!I! l>NLI
Society, it was proposed to "mine" He 3 from the atmosphere of Jupiter. In either case,
the cost to recover appreciable amounts of He 3 would be very high .
For the DD reaction, the situation is quite different because there the instantaneous
burn with deuterium of the T- and He 3 - reaction products of deuterium makes possible
a detonation wave in dense deuterium. In this detonation wave, only 38 percent of the
energy released goes into neutrons, compared with 80 percent for the DT reaction .
Deuterium can be extracted from water with relative ease in three steps :
•

Water is electrolytically split into hydrogen and oxygen.

•

The hydrogen gas, composed of H2 and HD, is cooled down until it liquefies,
whereby the heavier HD is separated by the force of gravity from the lighter H2.

•

The newly produced HD is heated and passed through a catalyst, spl itting HD into
H2 and D2, accord ing to the equation (Reference 7) 2HD---+ H2 + D2.

Since the gravitational field on the surface of a comet or small planet, from which the
D2 shall be extracted, is small, the apparatus separating the liquid HD from H2 must be
set into rap id rotation.
The comparatively small amount of energy needed for the separation can ideally be
drawn from a ferroelectric capacitor (for example, a barium-titanate capacitor with a
dielectric constant c: ::::: 5,000), to be charged up to many kilovolts by a small fraction of
the electric energy drawn from the deuterium fusion explosions through a magneto
hydrodynamic loop (Reference 2). One can also draw this energy from a small on - board
nuclear reactor requiring only a small radiator, slowly charging the capacitor.
Alternatively, one may store the needed energy in the magnetic field of a
superconductor.
For the launching of the spacecraft into Earth orbit, a very different scheme is
proposed. It requires special materials that are readily available on Earth but not on
extraterrestrial bodies serving as landing points to refuel the spacecraft. There the
primary resource is water from which deuterium is obtained.
In the Orion bomb propulsion project, a large number of fission bombs, or fission­
triggered fusion bombs, were proposed to lift the spacecraft into space. Since this
would release a large amount of highly radioactive fission products into the
atmosphere, it was one of the causes that killed Orion. Even though large payloads can
be brought into Earth orbit by chemical rockets, this rema ins very expensive, and an
acceptable less expensive nuclear alternative is highly desirable.
There appear to be two possibilities:
•

A laser driven by a high explosive, powerful enough to ignite a DT microexplosion,
wh ich in turn can initiate a thermonuclear detonation in deuterium (Reference 8) .

•

A second, more speculative possibility is the conjectured existence of chemical
kiloelectronvolt (keV) superexplosives. These are chem ical compounds formed under
high pressure, resulting in keV bridges between inner electron shells and able to

2

UNCLASSIFIED/ /POR. 0PPIE!IAL Y§E &PU.¥

Page 9

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOA QFFl&I.t.k WSI: 8,.kY
release intense bursts of keV X-rays capable of igniting a DT thermonuclear reaction,
which in turn could ignite a larger deuterium detonation.
To realize the first possibility, one might consider pumping a solid argon rod with a
convergent cylindrical shock wave driven by a high explosive (Reference 9). If the
argon rod is placed in the center of convergence and reaches a temperature of 90,000
°K, the upper ultraviolet laser level of the argon will be populated. Following this
heating, the argon cylinder radially expands and cools, with the upper laser level frozen
into the argon. The energy thus stored in the upper laser level can then be removed
from the rod by a small Q-switched laser, the resulting powerful laser pulse optically
focused onto a thermonuclear target.
To realize the second possibility, one would have to subject suitable materials to very
high pressure (Reference 10, 11). These energetic states can be reached only if during
their compression the materials are not appreciably heated, because such heating
would prevent the electrons from forming t he bridges between the inner electron shells.
Details of t he second possibility are provided in t he appendix.

Magnetic Insulation and Inductive Charging
Two concepts are of great importance for t he envisioned realization of a deuterium
fusion-driven starship:
•

The concept of magnetic insu lation, which permits the attainment of ultrahigh
voltages in high vacuum (Reference 1).

•

The concept of inductive charging, by which a magnetically insulated conductor can
be charged up to very high electric potentials (Reference 12).

MAGNETIC INSULATION

In a greatly simplified way, magnetic insulation can be understood as follows: if the
electric field on the surface of a negatively charged conductor reaches a critical field on
the order of Ee ~ 107 Vjcm, the conductor becomes the source of electrons emitted by
field emission. The critical electric field for the emission of ions from a positively
charged conductor is ~ 108 V/cm. Therefore, if in a high-voltage diode the electric field
107 V/cm , breakdown will occur by electric field emission from t he cathode to
reaches
the anode. But if a magnetic field of strength B measured in gauss is applied in a
direction parallel to the negatively charged surface, and if B > E, where E (like B) is
measured in electrostatic cgs units, the field-emitted electrons make a drift motion
parallel to the surface of the conductor with the velocity.

~

w

w

ExB

E

B2

B

v =c - - =c d

(1)

To keep vd/C < 1 then requires that E < H. Let us assume that H::::: 2 x 10 4 G, which can
be reached with ordinary electromagnets, means that E ~ 2 x 10 4 esu = 6 x 106 V/cm.

3

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR. 8Fflt1Jlct U:!I! OHLI

Page 10

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR. orrl@IAL YSE 8PtLlf
For a conductor with a radius of A- ~10m = 10 3 cm, an example for a small starsh ip
configuration, one can reach a voltage on the order of E ).. ~ 6 x 109 volts.

INDUCTIVE CHARGING
To charge the spacecraft to the required gigavolt potentials, we choose for its
architecture a large but hollow cylinder, which at the same time acts as a large
magnetic fie ld coi l. If thermionic electron em itters are placed inside this coil and the
magnetic fie ld of the coil rises in t ime, Maxwell's equation V x =---{11 c) aBjat induces
an azimuthal electric field inside the coil:

E

£ ¢

r •_
= --B ,
2c

(2)

where B = Bz is directed along the z-ax is, with r the radial distance from the axis of the
coil. In combination with the ax ial magnetic fie ld, the electrons from the therm ionic
em itters make a radia l inward -directed motion

(3)

E

By Maxwell's equation div = 4mie'!P, th is leads to the buildup of an electron cloud inside
the cyl inder, resulting in the radial electric fie ld

E, = 2nner

(4)

This radial electric field leads to an add itiona l azimuthal drift motion

(5)

superimposed on the rad iall y directed inward drift motion vr.
For the newly formed electron cloud to be stable, its maximum electron number density
must be below t he Brillou in limit:

n

< n max = B2/ 4n mc2

where mc2 = 8.2 x 10-7 erg is the electron rest mass energy. For B = 2 x 104 G, one
finds t hat n ma x ~ 4 x 10 13 cm -3 . To reach with a cylindrical electron cloud of radius R a
4

UNCLASSIFIED/ /POil orrl@IAL Y!H! OHL¥

(6)

Page 11

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFI@IAL YSE OHL¥
potential equal to V requires an electron number density n~v/ neR2 . For V = 109 volts
::::l 3 x 10 6 esu and R = 103 cm, one finds that n ~ 2 x 109 cm- 3 , well below nmax,

Deuterium as the Preferred Nuclear Rocket Fuel
To appreciate the importance of deuterium as the preferred and abundantly available
nuclear rocket fuel, one must consider the secondary reactions with D of the He 3 and T
reaction products from D-D fusion. Taking these reactions into account, one obtains
from 6 deuterium nuclei an energy of 26.8 megaelectronvolts (MeV) in charged fusion
products, made up of He 3 and H, and an energy of 16.55 MeV in neutrons. This means
62 percent of the energy is released into charged fusion products and 38 percent into
neutrons-a substantial improvement over the DT reaction, in which only 20 percent of
the energy goes into He4 .
Of interest also is the average velocity, averaged over the momentum of the charged
fusion products, because it is a measure of the maximum specific impulse, respectively
the maximum exhaust velocity:
6

_

L m;v;

v = ~i=~I _ _
6

(7)

I m;
i= I

-

For the six charged fusion reaction products (given in Table 1), one obtains v =
l.S x 109 cm/s.

Table 1. The Charged Fusion Products of a Detonation in Deuterium: Their
Energy and Velocity

Fusion Product

Energy [MeV]

Velocity lOY [cm/s]

Hej

0.8

1.23

H

3.0

2.40

H

14.7

5.30

He4

3.6

1.31

He4

3.7

1.33

T

1.0

0.80

5

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFI&I.t.k Wliliii Qfslk¥

Page 12

UNCLASSIFIED/ /P91t 9ffl@IAL YSE &P•tlf
Because the 6 charged fusion products are accompanied by 9 electrons, they have to
share their kinetic energy with 9 electrons. This reduces the maximum specific impulse
by the factor .J(6+9)/6 = m to ~ = 0.95 x 109 cm/s.
A reduction of the specific impulse does not occur if the electrons have enough time to
escape the burning plasma behind the detonation front; that is, in a time shorter than
the time for them to be heated by the charged fusion products.
The time needed for the electrons to be heated by the charged fusion reaction products
can be computed from the range Ao of the charged fusion products and their velocity v
in a plasma at the temperature T. For the He4 fusion products, the range is given by
(kT) 312
Ao= _a _ . , a = 2.S x 10 34 [cgs]
n

(8)

This time is
= Ao = a(kT) 312

'

v

(9)

nv

It then has to be compared with the time the electron can escape the burning plasma
behind the detonation front, given by
(10)
where ro is the rad ius of the burning deuterium cylinder, and ve the electron velocity.
One thus has
t e,c

-

T

V

nr0

= ----------

(11)

Ve a(kT) 312

Putting n = 10 23 cm-3 , T ~ 108 K with Ve~ 109 cm/s, V

~ 10 cm/s, one finds tescl-r~
9

2.5 'o . Therefore, tesc < r requires that 'o < 0.4 cm.
To reach the highest specific impu lse possib le, one should make the deuterium cylinder
as thin as possible.

Magnetic Entrapment of the Charged Fusion Products and
the Stopping of the Proton Beam in Dense Deuterium
If a fission bomb is used to trigger a thermonuclear detonation, so much energy is
available that almost any radiation implosion configuration is likely going to work. As an
example, one may place a fission bomb and a sphere of solid deuterium in a shell of
6

UNCLASSIFIED/ fFOR OFFI&I.t.k Y&E 8HLY

Page 13

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OPPICI"L U.!I! Grit I
gold, in the two foci of an ellipsoidal cavity. The radiation released by the exploding
fission bomb, by ablating the gold, launches a convergent shock wave into the liq uid
deuterium. With the temperature in the shock wave approximately rising as 1/ r , where
r is the distance of the shock wave from the center of the deuterium sphere, the
ignition temperature is reached at some distance from the center. But only if this
distance is larger than the stopping length of the DD fusion reaction products, typically
a few cm, is a radia lly outward-moving detonation wave ig nited. This configuration is
essentially the same kind of "hohlraum" (cavity) configuration used in the indirect drive
mode of laser fusion for a small DT sphere.
A configuration of this kind can still be used to burn deuterium if t he DT microexplosion
is used to trigger a larger deuterium explosion. For a starship that will depend on
deuterium as its only rocket fuel, this possibility is excluded.
But another possibility arises if the ignition is done with a 10 7 -ampere gigaelectronvolt
(GeV) proton (or deuterium) beam. If focused onto one end of a slender, cylindrical
deuterium rod, the beam not only can be made powerful enough to ignite the
deuterium, but its strong azimuthal magnetic field entraps the charged DD reaction
fusion products within the deuterium cylinder, launching a deuterium detonation wave
propagating with supersonic speed down the cylinder (Reference 13). There the fusion
gain and yield can in principle be made arbitrarily large, depending only on the length
of the deuterium rod.
The range of the charged fusion products is determined by their Larmor radius

a
r, = ­

B

(12)

where
C (2MAE/ 12
Q - ----e
Z

(13)

In equation (13), c, e are the velocity of light and the electron charge, M the hydrogen
mass, A the atomic weight, and Z the atomic number. Eis the kinetic energy of t he
fusion products.
If the magnetic field is produced by the proton beam current I, one has at the surface
of the deuterium cylinder the azimuthal magnetic field

(14)

Combining equation (12) with equation (14) and requiring that r, < r, one finds that

7

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOA OFFICiI.\k Wliliii O,.k¥

Page 14

UNCLASSIFIED/ /Pelt err1e1J11t l!ISl!!! eHt'I

(15)

l > le

where le = S a. In Table 2, the values for a and le for all the charged fusion products of
the DD reaction are compiled. For all of them, the critical current is below l e = 3.84
x 10 6 A. Therefore, with the choice l ~ 10 7 A, all the charged fusion products are
entrapped inside the deuterium cylinder.

Table 2. Critical Ignition Currents for Thermonuclear Reactions

Reaction

Fusion Product

Energy [MeV]

a [G cm]

le [A]

DT

He4

3.6

2. 7 x 10:i

1.35 X 10°

DD

He5

0.8

l.12 x 10:,

5.6 x 105

DD

T

1.0

2.5 x 10:i

1.25 X 10°

DD

H

3.0

2.5 x 10"'

1.25 X 10°

DHe3

H

14.65

5.56 x 105

3.84x 106

DHe5

He4

3.66

2.78 x 10:i

1.39 x 10°

For the argon ion laser configuration proposed for the launch into Earth orbit, where a
small amount of DT serves as a trigger for the ignition of a larger amount of deuterium,
the ign ition of a magnetic field supported detonation wave in deuterium is possible
there with an aux iliary high-explosive-driven megampere current generator, setting up
an axial magnetic field, by an azimuthal current around the rod. The charged fusion
products there are spiraling down the rod. The current needed to entrap the charged
fusion products are there on the same order of magnitude; that is, ~ 10 7 A.
For the deuterium-tritium thermonuclear reaction, the condition for a propagating burn
in a sphere of radius rand density p, heated to a temperature of 108 K, is given by
pr ~ l g/cm 2 . This requires energy of about 1 megajoule (MJ). For the deuterium
reaction, this condition is pr~ 10 g/cm 2 , with an ignition temperature about 10 times
larger. That a thermonuclear detonation in deuterium is possible at all is due to the
secondary combustion of the T and He 3 DD fusion reaction products (Reference 8). The
energy required would be about 10 4 times larger, or about 10 4 MJ-for all practical
purposes out of reach for nonfission ignition. However, if the ignition and burn are
along a deuterium cyl inder, where the charged fusion products are entrapped by a
magnetic field within the cylinder, the condition pr~ 10 g/cm 2 is replaced by
pz ~10 g/cm 2

where z is the length of the cylinder.

8

UNCLASSIFIED/ /felt 8ffl@IAI: W&li 8Ptl:¥

(16)

Text continues in the original file (37 pages).

Previous: DOW-UAP-D125 — AAWSAP DIRD, Inertial Electrostatic Confinement Fusion, March 2010 · Next: DOW-UAP-D127 — AAWSAP DIRD, An Introduction to the Statistical Drake Equation, March 2010

Same topic: title & summary match

Same location: Las Vegas, Nevada

Same period: 2010

Same release: Release 06

Same agency: DoW