Home › Archive › DoW

DOW-UAP-D127 — AAWSAP DIRD, An Introduction to the Statistical Drake Equation, March 2010

File DOW-UAP-D127 is a declassified pdf from Department of War, recording an incident dated 3/11/10 at Las Vegas, Nevada, published in Release 06 (2026-09-18). This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.

File
DOW-UAP-D127
Agency
Department of War
Incident date
3/11/10
Location
Las Vegas, Nevada
Released in
Release 06 (2026-09-18)
File type
PDF

Topics: AAWSAP & DIRDs

This document is a Defense Intelligence Reference Document (DIRD), a technical reference format used by the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) to capture baseline knowledge on a specific topic for later analytic use. DIRDs are best understood as reference and synthesis products rather than as original research. It is one of 38 DIRDs produced under the Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Applications Program (AAWSAP) between 2009 and 2011. Because AAWSAP’s scope permitted a broad range of supporting topics, not every DIRD in the series directly concerns aerospace systems or future threat assessment. The following summary reflects the DIRD’s scope and framing at the time of writing and should not be read as implying current validation of the concepts discussed.

This DIRD introduces the Drake Equation, a well-known thought framework for estimating how many communicative extraterrestrial civilizations might exist in the galaxy. It reformulates the equation in statistical terms, arguing that the usual approach of assigning fixed values to its variables is too simplistic because major inputs are uncertain and are better modeled as probability distributions. Using that approach, it concludes that, if one accepts the underlying logic of the Drake Equation, the estimated number of communicating civilizations should be treated as a range of possible values, and that the likely distance between neighboring civilizations can likewise be expressed statistically rather than as a single figure. The document is primarily a mathematical and methodological exercise, and its worked examples rely on assumed values to illustrate the framework rather than to establish a firm astrophysical estimate. Overall, it is an attempt to formalize uncertainty within the Drake framework rather than an attempt to bound the actual likelihood, prevalence, or proximity of extraterrestrial civilizations.

Open original file · WAR.GOV page

TL;DR

Vegas dice aren’t the only odds they crunched in March 2010.

  • DIRD PDF by DoW, March 2010, Las Vegas, NV
  • Introduces statistical reformulation of the Drake Equation
  • Concludes numbers and distances should be expressed as ranges, not single values

AI summary

A classified document titled "An Introduction to the Statistical Drake Equation," prepared by the Defense Intelligence Agency's Acquisition Support Division, discusses the Drake Equation and its statistical generalization. It covers methods for estimating the number of extraterrestrial civilizations in the galaxy, including factors like star count, planet formation, and civilization longevity. The text explores uncertainties in the Drake equation and proposes a statistical approach, referencing a 2008 paper on the topic. It includes mathematical derivations, probability distributions, and lognormal properties, discussing the distance to extraterrestrial civilizations in light years. The document references UFOs and unidentified objects and includes equations, numerical examples, and statistical analyses. The text was prepared in March 2010.

Full text

Page 2

UNCLASSIFIED//P81t 8FFIEIAL Y&E &ttbl/

An Introduction to the Statistical Drake Equation

Prepared by:
Acquisition Support Division (DW0-3)
Defense Warning Office
Directorate for Analysis
Defense Intelligence Agency
Author:

AAP Person 80
Administrative Note
COPYRIGHT WARNING: Further dissemination of the photographs in this publication is not authorized .

This product is one in a series of advanced technology reports produced in FY 2009
under the Defense Intelligence Agency, Defense Warning Office's Advanced Aerospace
Weapon System Applications (AAWSA) Program. Comments or questions pertaining to
this document should be addressed t o !AAP Person 1
~ AAWSA Prog ram
Manager, Defense Intelligence Agency, ATTN: CLAR/DWO-3, Bldg 6000, Washington,
DC 20340-5100.

ii

UNCLASSIFIED//F8R 8FFl61tlib Wlilli Qtlb¥

Page 3

UNCLASSIFIED/ /POil OFFl@IAL WSli 0Nk¥

Contents
1. Introduction .......................................................................................................iv
2. The Key Question: How Far are They ? .............................................................. 4
3. Computing N By Virtue of the Drake Equation (1961) ........................................ 7
4. The Drake Equation is Over-Simplified ............................................................. 10
5. The Statistical Drake Equation ......................................................................... 11
6. Solving the Statistical Drake Equation By Virtue of the Central Limit Theorem
(CLT) of Statistics .......................................................... ,.................................... 13
7. An Example Explaining the Statistical Drake Equation ..................................... 15
8. Finding the Probability Distribution of the Et-Distance By Virtue of the Statistical
Drake Equation ................................................................................................. 18
9. The "Data Enrichment Principle" as the Best CLT Consequence Upon the
Statistical Drake Equation (Any Number of Factors Allowed) ........................... 23
10. Conclusions .................................................................................................... 23
Appendix A: Proof of Shannon's 1948 Theorem Stating That the Uniform
Distribution is the "Most Uncertain" One Over a Finite Range of
Values ............................................................................................. 25
Appendix B: Original Text of the Author's Paper #IAC-08-A4.1.4 Entitled the
Statistical Drake Equation ............................................................... 28
References ........................................................................................................... 55

iii

UNCLASSIFIED/ fEOR OFFICIO! 11SF ON! X

Page 4

UNCLASSIFIED/ /POil OFFl@IAI:: WSli 0Nk¥

An Introduction to the Statistical Drake Equation
1. Introduction
SETI (an acronym for "Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence") is a relatively
new branch of scientific research, having begun only in 1959. Its goal is to
ascertain whether alien civilizations exist in the universe, how far from us
they exist, and possibly how much more advanced than us they may be.
As of 2009, the only physical tools we know that could help us get in touch
with aliens are the electromagnetic waves an alien civilization could emit and
we could detect. This forces us to use the largest radiotelescopes on Earth for
SETI research, because the higher our collecting area of electromagnetic
radiation is, the higher our sensitivity is (that is, the farther in space we can
probe). Yet, even by using the largest radiotelescopes on Earth (the 310-meter
dish at Arecibo, for instance), we cannot search for aliens beyond, say, a few
hundred light years away. This is a very, very small amount of space around us
within our galaxy, the Milky Way, that is about 100,000 light years in diameter.
Thus, current SETI can cover only a very tiny fraction of the galaxy, and it is
not surprising that in the past 50 years of SETI searches, NO extraterrestrial
civilization was discovered. Quite simply, we did not get far enough!
This demands the construction of much more powerful and radically new
radiotelescopes. Rather than big and heavy metal dishes, whose mechanical
problems hamper SETI research too much, we are now turning to "software
radiotelescopes," where a large number of small dishes (ATA = Allen
Telescope Array, and ALMA= Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array)
or even just of simple dipoles (LOFAR = Low Frequency Array) using state-of­
the- art electronics and very- high-speed computing can outperform the
classical radiotelescopes in many regards. The final dream in this field is the
SKA ( = Square Kilometer Array), currently being designed and expected to be
completed around 2020.

2. The Key Question: How Far are They?
But still, the key question remains: how far are they?
Or, more correctly, how far do we expect the NEAREST extraterrestrial civilization to be
from t he Solar System in the galaxy?
This question was first faced in a scientific manner back in 1961 by the same scientist
who also was t he first experimental SETI rad io astronomer ever: t he American, Fra nk
Donald Drake (born 1930). He first considered the shape and size of the galaxy where
we are living: the Milky Way. This is a spiral ga laxy measuring some 100,000 light
years in diameter and some 16,000 light years in thickness of the Ga lactic Disk at half­
way from its center. That is:
The diameter of the galaxy is (about) 100,000 light years, (abbreviated ly) i.e., its
radius, R Gala.1y , is about 50,000 ly.

iv

UNCLA SSI FIED/ /FOR OFFI&IJ.k Wili Ql'II.¥

Page 5

UNCLASSIFIED/ /fOR OFFI&IAk Wlii QPU,¥
The thickness of the Galactic Disk at half-way from its center, h a " 1t'-'Y ' is about 16,000 ly.
The volume of the galaxy may then be approximated as the volume of the
corresponding cylinder, i.e.

(1)
Now consider the sphere around us having a radius r. The volume of such a sphere is
V o ur _ Sphere =

4 ( Ef Distance ) 3

3n

-

(2)

2

In the last equation, we had to divide the distance "ET_Distance" between ourselves
and the nearest ET civilization by 2 because we are now going to make the
unwarranted assumption that all ET civilizations are equally spaced from each
other in the galaxy! This is a crazy assumption, clearly, and should be replaced by
more scientifically-grounded assumptions as soon as we know more about our Galactic
Neighborhood. At the moment, however, this is the best guess that we can make, and
so we shall take it for granted, although we are aware that this is a weak point in the
reasoning.
Furthermore, let us denote by N the total number of civilizations now living in the
galaxy, including ourselves. Of course, this number N is unknown. We only know that
N ~ 1 since one civilization does at least exist!
Having thus assumed that ET civilizations are UNIFORMLY SPACED IN THE GALAXY, we
can then write down the proportion:
V a a/a.,y

V o ,, r _ Spher e

(3)

-- = -~-

N

That is, upon replacing both (1) and (2) into (3):
2
i'l" R Ga /axy h =

N

Dis __
lance )
-4 i'l" ( _Ef- _
3

3

2
1

The last equation contains two unknowns: N and ET_Distance, and so we don't know
which one it is better to solve for.
However, we may suppose that, by resorting to the (rather uncertain) knowledge that
we have about the Evolution of the galaxy through the last 10 billion years or so, we
might somehow compute an approximate value for N.
Then, we may solve (4) for ET_ Distance thus obtaining the (AVERAGE) DISTANCE
BETWEEN ANY PAIR OF NEIGHBORING CIVILIZATIONS IN THE GALAXY (DISTANCE
LAW)

5
UNCLASSIFIED/ ;'FQA QFFICiIPL. !Iii 011! Y

(4)

Page 6

UNCLASSIFIED/ /fOR OFFI&IAk Wlii QPU,¥

Ef_ ff,stance (N) =

3 6 R2
h
Ca!a,y

VN

C

VN

(5)

where the posit ive constant C is defined by
C = V6 R ~ala.,y h ca /axy ,., 28845 light years .

(6)

Equations (5) and (6) are the starting point to understand t he orig in of the Drake
equation that we discuss in detail in Section 3 of th is paper.
Let us just complete this section by pointing out three different numerical cases of the
distance law (5):
•

We know that we exist, so N may not be smaller tha n 1, i.e., N ~ 1. Suppose then
that we are alone in the galaxy, i.e., that N=l. Then the distance law (5) yields as
distance to the nearest civilization from us just the constant C, i.e., 28,845 light
years. Th is is about the distance in between ourselves and the center of the galaxy
(i. e. the Galactic Bulge) . Thus, this result seems to suggest that, if we do not find
any extraterrestrial civilization around us in these outskirts of the galaxy where we
live, we should look around the Galactic Center first. And this is indeed what is
happening, i.e., many SETI searches are actually point ing the antennas towards the
Galactic Center, looking for beacons (see, for instance ref. [1]).

•

Suppose next that N=l000, i.e. there are about a thousand extraterrestrial
communicating civilizations in the whole galaxy right now. Then the distance law (5)
yields an average distance of 2,885 light yea rs. This is a distance that most
radiotelescopes in Earth may not reach for SETI searches right now: hence the need
to build larger radiotelescopes, like ALMA, LOFAR and the SKA.

•

Suppose finally that N=l00000O, i.e., there are a million communicating civilizations
now in the galaxy. Then the dist ance law (5) yields an average dista nce of 288 light
years. Th is is with in the (upper) range of distances that our current rad iotelescopes
may reach for SETI searches, and that justifies all SETI searches that have been
done so far in t he first fifty years of SETI (1960-2010).

In conclusion, interpolating the above three special cases of N, we may say that the
distance law (5) yields t he following key diagram of the average ET distance vs. the
assumed number of communicating civilizations, N, in the galaxy right now (Figure 1):

6

UNCLASSIFIED/ J'FOA. OFlilCI0 I. P!SE ON! X

Page 7

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFIEiIAk Wlii QPU,¥
Av era ge DIST A CE o f the nea res t ET c iviliza tion vs . th e ASSUM ED NUMBffi of ET c ivilizations in th e Gah
200
Cl)

0:::

<(

UJ

>­

175

!­

:I:

0

:i

.!::

150

!'.l

g

~

125

!'l

=

l

100

\

750

500

' "--

~

250

0

0

I 00000

200000

300000

400000

500000

600000

700000

800000

900000

I000000

ASS MED NUMB ER of civiliz ations in the Galaxy (that is, Nin the Drake equation)
Figure 1. DISTANCE LAW; i.e., the Average Distance (plot along the ver-1:ical axis in light years) Versus
the NUMBER of Communicating Civilizations ASSUMED to Exist in the Galaxy Right Now

3. Computing N By Virtue of the Drake Equation (1961)
In the previous section, the problem of finding how close the nearest ET civilization may
be was "solved" by reducing it to the computation of N, the total number of
extraterrestrial civilizations now existing in this galaxy. In this section the famous
Drake equation is described, that was proposed back in 1961 by Frank Dona ld Drake
(born 1930) to estimate the numerical value of N. We believe that no better
introductory description of the Drake equations exists other than the one given by Carl
Sagan in his 1983 book "Cosmos" (ref. [2]), in its turn based on the famous TV series
"Cosmos." So, in this paragraph we report Carl Sagan's description of the Drake
equation unabridged.
"But is there anyone out there to talk to? With a third or a half a trillion stars in our
Milky Way galaxy alone, could ours be the only one accompanied by an inhabited
planet? How much more likely it is that technical civilizations are a cosm ic
commonplace, that the galaxy is pulsing and humming with advanced societies, and,
therefore, that the nearest such culture is not so very far away - perhaps transmitting
from antennas established on a planet of a naked-eye star just next door. Perhaps
when we look up at the sky at nig ht, near one of those faint pinpoints of light is a world
on which someone quite different from us is then glancing id ly at a star we call the Sun
and entertaining, for just a moment, an outrageous speculation.

7

UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFIEiIAk Wlii QPllsV

Page 8

UNCLASSIFIED/ /fOR OFFI&IAk Wlii QPU,¥
It is very hard to be sure. There may be several impediments to the evolution of a
technical civilization. Planets may be rarer than we think. Perhaps the origin of life is
not so easy as our laboratory experiments suggest. Perhaps the evolution of advanced
life forms is improbable. Or it may be that complex life forms evolve more readily, but
intelligence and technical societies require an unlikely set of coincidences - just as the
evolution of the human species depended on the demise of the dinosaurs and the ice­
age recession of the forests in whose trees our ancestors screeched and dimly
wondered. Or perhaps civilizations arise repeatedly, inexorably, on innumerable planets
in the Milky Way, but are generally unstable; so all but a tiny fraction are unable to
survive their technology and succumb to greed and ignorance, pollution and nuclear
war.
It is possible to explore this great issue further and make a crude estimate of N, the
number of advanced civilizations in the galaxy. We define an advanced civilization as
one capable of radio astronomy. Th is is, of course, a parochial if essential definition.
There may be countless worlds on wh ich the inhabitants are accomplished linguists or
superb poets but indifferent radio astronomers. We will not hear from them. N can be
written as the product or multiplication of a number of factors, each a kind of filter,
every one of which must be sizable for there to be a large number of civilizations:

•

Ns, the number of stars in the Milky Way galaxy.

•

fp, the fraction of stars that have planetary systems.

• ne, the number of planets in a given system that are ecologically suitable for life.
•

fl, the fraction of otherwise suitable planets on which life actually arises.

•

fi, the fraction of inhabited planets on which an intelligent form of life evolves.

•

fc, the fraction of planets inhabited by intelligent beings on which a communicative
techn ical civilization develops .

•

fl, the fraction of planetary lifetime graced by a technical civilization.

Written out, the equation reads
N = Ns • jjJ • ne • fl ·ft · Jc· fL

All of the f's are fractions, having values between O and 1; they will pare down the
large value of Ns.
To derive N we must estimate each of these quantities. We know a fa ir amount about
the early factors in the equation, the number of stars and planetary systems. We know
very little about the later factors, concerning the evolution of intelligence or the lifetime
of technical societies. In these cases our estimates will be little better than guesses. I
invite you, if you disagree with my estimates below, make your own choices and see
what implications your alternative suggestions have for the number of advanced
civilizations in the galaxy. One of the great virtues of this equation, due to Frank Drake
of Cornell, is that it involves subjects ranging from stellar and planetary astronomy to
organic chemistry, evolutionary biology, history, politics and abnormal psychology.
Much of the Cosmos is in the span of the Drake equation.
8

UNCLASSIFIED//FQA QFFICiIPL. !Iii 011! Y

(7)

Page 9

UNCLASSIFIED/ /fOR OFFI&IAk Wlii QPU,¥
We know Ns, the number of stars in the Milky Way galaxy, fairly well, by careful counts
of stars in a small but representative region of the sky. It is a few hundred billion; some
recent estimates place it at 4 x 10 11 . Very few of these stars are of the massive short­
lived variety that squander their reserves of thermonuclear fuel. The great majority
have lifetimes of billions or more years in which they are shining stably, providing a
suitable energy source for the energy and evolution of life on nearby planets.
There is evidence that planets are a frequent accompaniment of star formation: in the
satellite systems of Jupiter, Saturn and Uranus, which are like miniature solar systems;
in theories of the origin of the planets; in studies of double stars; in observations of
accretion disks around stars; and is some preliminary investigations of gravitational
perturbations of nearby stars. 1 Many, perhaps even most, stars may have planets. We
take the fraction of stars that have planets, fp, as roughly equa l to 1/3. Then the total
1.3 x 10 11 (the symbol
number of planetary systems in the galaxy would be Ns fp
means "approximately equal to"). If each system were to have about ten planets, as
ours does, the tota l number of worlds in the galaxy would be more than a trillion, a vast
arena for the cosmic drama.

~

~

In our own solar system there are several bodies t hat may be suitab le for life of some
sort: the Earth certainly, and perhaps Mars, Titan and Jupiter. Once life originates, it
tends to be very adaptable and tenacious. There must be many different environments
suitable for life in a given planetary system. But conservatively we choose ne=2. Then
the number of planets in the galaxy su itable for life becomes Ns fp ne 3 x 10 11 .

~

Experiments show that under the most common cosmic conditions the molecular basis
of life is read ily made, the building blocks of molecules able to make copies of
themselves. We are now on less certain grounds; there may, for example, be
impediments in the evolution of the genetic code, although I think this is unlikely over
billions of years of primeval chemistry . We choose fl~ 1/3, implying a total number of
planets in the Milky Way on which life has arisen at least once as Ns fp ne fl~ 1 x 10 11 ,
a hundred billion inhabited worlds . That in itself is a remarkable conclusion. But we are
not yet fin ished.
The choices of fi and fc are more difficult. On the one hand, many individually unlikely
steps had to occur in biologica l evolution and human history for our present intelligence
and technology to develop. On the other hand, there must be quite different pathways
to an advanced civilization of specified capab ilities. Considering the apparent difficulty
in the evolution of large organisms, represented by the Cambrian explosion, let us
choose fix fc = 1/100, meaning that only 1 per cent of planets on wh ich life arises
actually produce a technical civilization. This estimate represents some middle ground
among the varying scientific options. Some think that the equivalent of the step from
the emergence of trilobites to the domestication of fire goes like a shot in all planetary
systems; others th ink t hat, even given ten or fifteen billion years, the evolution of a
technical civi lization is unlikely. This is not a subject on wh ich we can do much
experimentation as long as our investigations are limited to a single planet. Multiplying
1 Carl Sagan was writ ings these lines back in the 1970's, when no extrasolar planets had been discovered yet. The
first such discovery occurred in 1995, wh en Michel Mayor and Didier Queloz, working at the "Observatoire de Haute
Provence" in France, discovered the first extrasolar planet orbiting the nearby star 51 Peg. This first extrasolar
planet was hence named 51 Peg B. Many more extrasolar planets were discovered around nearby stars ever since .
As of Apri l 2009, 347 extrasolar planets (exoplanets) are listed in the Extrasolar Planets Encyclopaed ia.

9

UNCLASSIFIED/ /POil Offl@IAL W&i 9Nls¥

Page 10

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFIEiIAk Wlii QPU,¥
these factors together, we find Ns fp ne fl fi fc ~ 1 x 109 , a billion planets on which
technical civilizations have arisen at least once. But that is very different from saying
that there are a billion planets on which technical civilizations now exist. For this we
must also estimate fl.
What percentage of the lifetime of a planet is marked by a technical civil ization? The
Earth has harbored a technical civilization characterized by radio astronomy for only a
few decades out of a lifetime of a few billion years. So far, then, for our planet fl is less
than 1/108 , a millionth of a percent. And it is hardly out of the question that we might
destroy ourselves tomorrow. Suppose this were a typical case, and the destruction so
complete that no other technical civilization - of the human or any other species - were
able to emerge in the five or so billion years remaining before the Sun dies. Then Ns fp
ne fl fi fc fl
10, and, at a given time there would be only a tiny smattering, a handful,
a pitiful few technical civilizations in the galaxy, the steady state number maintained as
emerging societies replace those recently self-immolated. The number N might be even
as small as 1 if civilizations tend to destroy themselves soon after reaching a
technological phase; there might be no one for us to talk with but ourselves. And that
we do but poorly. Civilizations would take billions of years of tortuous evolution, and
then snuff themselves out in an instant of unforgivable neglect.

~

But consider the alternative, the prospect that at least some civilizations learn to live
with technology; that the contradictions posed by the vagaries of past brain evolution
are consciously resolved and do not lead to self destruction; or that, even if major
disturbances occur, they are reveres in the subsequent billions of years of biological
evolution. Such societies might live to a prosperous old age, their lifetimes measured
perhaps on geological or stellar evolutionary time scales. If 1 percent of civilizations can
survive technological adolescence, take the proper fork at this critical historical branch
point and achieve maturity, then fl ~ 1/100, N ~ 107 , and the number of extant
civilizations in t he galaxy is in the millions. Thus, for all our concern about t he possible
unrel iabi lity of our estimates of the early factors in the Drake equation, which involve
astronomy, organic chemistry and evolutionary biology, the principal uncertainty comes
to economics and politics and what, on Earth, we call human nature. It seems fairly
clear that if self-destruction is not the overwhelmingly preponderant fate of galactic
civilizations, then the sky is softly humming with messages from the stars.
These estimates are stirring . They suggest that the receipt of a message from space is,
even before we decode it, a profoundly hopeful sign. It means that someone has
learned to live with high technology; that it is possible to survive technological
adolescence. This alone, quite apart from the contents of the message, provides a
powerful justification for the search for other civilizations.

4. The Drake Equation is Over-Simplified
In the nearly fifty years (1961-2009) elapsed since Frank Drake proposed his equation,
a number of scientists and writers tried to find out which numerical values of its seven
independent variables are more real istic in agreement with our present-day knowledge.
Thus there is a considerable amount of literature about the Drake equation nowadays,
and, as one can easily imagine, the results obtained by the various authors largely
differ from one another. In other words, the value of N, that various authors obtained
by different assumptions about the astronomy, the biology and the sociology implied by
the Drake equation, may range from a few tens (in the pessimist's view) to some
10

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFIEiIAk Wlii QPII.¥

Page 11

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFIEil.t.k W~i Q~lls¥
million or even billions in the optimist's opinion. A lot of uncertainty is thus affecting our
knowledge of N as of 2010. In all cases, however, the final result about N has always
been a sheer number, i.e., a positive integer number ranging from 1 to millions or
billions. This is precisely the aspect of the Drake equation that th is author regarded as
" too simpl istic" and improved mathematically in his paper #IAC-08-A4.1.4, entitled
"The Statistical Drake Equation" and presented on October 1st , 2008, at the 59 th
International Astronautical Congress (IAC) held in Glasgow, Scotland, UK, September
29 th thru October 3rd , 2008. That paper is attached herewith as Appendix B. Newcomers
to SETI and to the Drake equation, however, may find that paper too difficult to be
understood mathematically at a first reading. Thus, I shall now expla in the content of
that paper "by speaking easily." I thank the reader for his or her attention .

5. The Statistical Drake Equation
We start by an examp le.
Consider the first independent variable in the Drake equation (7), i. e., Ns, the number
of stars in the Milky Way galaxy. Astronomers tell us that approximately there should
be about 350 millions stars in the galaxy. Of course, nobody has counted (or even seen
in the photographic plates) all the stars in the galaxy! There are too many practical
difficulties preventing us from doing so: just to name one, the dust clouds that don't
allow us to see even the Galactic Bulge (i.e. the central region of the galaxy) in the
visible light (although we may "see it" at radio frequencies like the famous neutral
hydrogen line at 1420 MHz). So, it doesn't make any sense to say that Ns = 350 x 106 ,
or, say (even worse) that the number of stars in the galaxy is (say) 354,233,321, or
similar fanciful exact integer numbers. That is just silly and non-scientific. Much more
scientific, on the contrary, is to say that the number of stars in the galaxy is 350 million
plus or minus, say, 50 millions (or whatever values the astronomers may regard as
more appropriate, since this is just an example to let the reader understand the
difficulty).
Thus, it makes sense to REPLACE each of the seven independent variables in the Drake
equation (7) by a MEAN VALUE (350 millions, in the above example) PLUS OR MINUS A
CERTAIN STANDARD DEVIATION (SO millions, in the above example) .
By doing so, we have made a great step ahead: we have abandoned the too-simplistic
equation (7) and replaced it by something more sophisticated and scientifically more
serious: the STATISTICAL Drake equation. In other words, we have transformed the
classical and simplistic Drake equation (7) into an advanced statistica l tool for the
investigation of a host of facts hardly known to us in detail. In other words still:
•

We replace each independent variable in (7) by a RANDOM VARIABLE, labeled
D, (from Drake).

•

We assume that the MEAN VALUE of each D, is the same numerical value previously
attributed to the corresponding independent variable in (7).

•

But now we also ADD A STANDARD DEVIATION cr 0 ; on each side of the mean value,
that is provided by the knowledge gathered by scientists in each discipline
encompassed by each D,.

11

UNCLASSIFIED//FQA QFFICilOL. !!ii ONI X

Page 12

UNCLASSIFIED/ /fOR OFFI&IAk Wlii QPU,¥
Having so done, the next question is:
How can we find out the PROBABILITY DISTRIBUTION for each D; ?
For instance, shall that be a Gaussian, or what?
This is a difficult question, for nobody knows, for instance, the probability distribution of
the number of stars in the galaxy, not to mention the probability distribution of the
other six variables in the Drake equation (7).
There is a brilliant way to get around this difficulty, though.
We start by excluding the Gaussian because each variable in the Drake equation is a
POSITIVE (or, more precisely, a non-negative) random variable, while the Gaussian
applies to REAL random variables only. So, the Gaussian is out. Then, one might
consider the large class of well-studied and positive probability densities called "the
gamma distributions," but it is then unclear why one should adopt the gamma
distributions and not any other. The solution to th is apparent conundrum comes from
Shannon's Information Theory and a theorem that he proved in 1948: "The probability
distribution having maximum entropy ( = uncertainty) over any FINITE range of real
values is the UNIFORM distribution over that range," This is proven in Appendix A of the
present document.
So, at this point, we assume that each of the seven D; in (7) is a UNIFORM random
variable, whose mean value and standard deviation is known by the scientists working
in the respective field (let it be astronomy, or biology, or sociology). Notice that, for
such a uniform distribution, the knowledge of the mean value Po; and of the standard
deviation u 0 , automatically determines the RANGE of that random variable in between
its lower (called a;) and upper (called b;) limits: in fact these limits are given by the
equations
(8)

(the "surprising" factor ✓3 in the above equations comes from the definitions of mean
value and standard deviation: please see equations (12), (15) and (17) in Appendix B
for the relevant proof). So the uniform distribution of each random variable D; is
perfectly determined by its mean value and standard deviation, and so are all its other
properties.
The next problem is the following:
OK, since we now know everything about each uniformly distributed D;, what is the
probability distribution of N, given that N is the product (7) of all the D1 ?
In other words, not only do we want to find the analytical expression of the probability
density function of N, but we also want to relate its mean value f-lN to all mean values
µ
of the D;, and its standard deviation
to all standard deviations
of the D;.
,

u

N

0

u

,

0

12

UNCLASSIFIED/ fFOR: QFFICiIO L. lalii ODIL.¥

Page 13

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFI&I.t.k W~i Q~lk¥
This is a difficult problem.
It occupied the author's mind for no less than about ten years (1997 -2007).
It is actually an ANALYTICALLY UNSOLVABLE problem, in that, to the best of this
author's knowledge, it is IMPOSSIBLE to find an analytic expression for any FINITE
PRODUCT of uniform random variablesD; . This result is proven in Sections 2 thru 3.3 of
Appendix B (unfortunately!) .

6. Solving the Statistical Drake Equation By Virtue of the
Central Limit Theorem (CLT) of Statistics
The solution to the problem of finding the analytical expression for the probability
density function of N in the statistica l Drake equation was found by this author in
September 2007.

Text continues in the original file (55 pages).

Previous: DOW-UAP-D126 — AAWSAP DIRD, Advanced Nuclear Propulsion for Manned Deep Space Missions, March 2010 · Next: DOW-UAP-D128 — AAWSAP DIRD, Anomalous Acute and Subacute Field Effects on Human Biological Tissues, March 2010

Same location: Las Vegas, Nevada

Same period: 2010

Same release: Release 06

Same agency: DoW