Home › Archive › DoW

DOW-UAP-D133 — AAWSAP DIRD, The Space Communication Implications of Quantum Entanglement and Nonlocality, March 2010

File DOW-UAP-D133 is a declassified pdf from Department of War, recording an incident dated 3/30/10 at Las Vegas, Nevada, published in Release 06 (2026-09-18). This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.

File
DOW-UAP-D133
Agency
Department of War
Incident date
3/30/10
Location
Las Vegas, Nevada
Released in
Release 06 (2026-09-18)
File type
PDF

Topics: AAWSAP & DIRDs

This document is a Defense Intelligence Reference Document (DIRD), a technical reference format used by the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) to capture baseline knowledge on a specific topic for later analytic use. DIRDs are best understood as reference and synthesis products rather than as original research. It is one of 38 DIRDs produced under the Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Applications Program (AAWSAP) between 2009 and 2011. Because AAWSAP’s scope permitted a broad range of supporting topics, not every DIRD in the series directly concerns aerospace systems or future threat assessment. The following summary reflects the DIRD’s scope and framing at the time of writing and should not be read as implying current validation of the concepts discussed.

This DIRD reviews quantum entanglement and nonlocality with a focus on whether those phenomena might be usable as a means of faster-than-light communication between observers, especially for real-time space operations over interplanetary distances. The report surveys the relevant quantum experiments and no-signal theorems, then examines proposed communication schemes based mainly on momentum-entangled photons, including scenarios involving superluminal and retro-causal signaling. However, it repeatedly acknowledges that the central question remains unresolved experimentally, and it gives substantial attention to the coherence-versus-entanglement tradeoff and other features of standard quantum mechanics that may prevent usable signaling even if non-local correlations are experimentally validated. Overall, the document is an exploratory analysis of whether quantum nonlocality could conceivably support a practical communications application rather than a demonstration of prospective utility.

Open original file · WAR.GOV page

TL;DR

Even in Vegas, they couldn’t gamble away the signal problem.

  • DIRD D133, DoW, March 2010, Las Vegas, NV.
  • Analyzes quantum entanglement’s feasibility for faster-than-light space communications.
  • No official conclusion in the file.

AI summary

This document, titled "The Space Communication Implications of Quantum Entanglement and Nonlocality," was written in March 2010 by the AAWSAP DIRD. It explores quantum entanglement and nonlocality, focusing on their potential for superluminal communication. The text references experiments such as EPR and ghost interference, discussing polarization correlations, Bell Inequalities, and tests of quantum mechanics against local hidden-variable theories. It examines momentum entanglement, interference patterns, and the possibility of nonlocal signaling, considering its relationship with special relativity. The document also describes optical setups, photon detection methods, and theoretical implications, including retrocausal effects and potential paradoxes.

Full text

Page 1

UNCLASSIFIED//POR OFPICIAL USE ONLY
Defense
SSE Intelligence
DEEEE 4
Reference
ES OF Document
Acquisition Threat Support
30 March 2010
ICOD: 1 December 2009
DIA-08-1003-016
The Space-Communication
Implications of Quantum
Entanglement and Nonlocality
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLT

Page 2

UNCLASSIFIED//P'81t 8P'P'IClilct ~91! 9HLY

The Space-Communication Implications of Quantum

Entanglement and Nonlocality

Prepared by:
Acquisition Support Division (DW0-3)
Defense Warning Office
Directorate for Analysis
Defense Intelligence Agency
Author:

AAP Person 76

Administrative Note
COPYRIGHT WARN ING: Further dissemination of the photographs in this publication is not authorized.

This product is one in a series of advanced technology reports produced in FY 2009
under the Defense Intelligence Agency, Defense Warning Office's Advanced Aerospace
Weapon System Applications (AAWSA) Program. Comments or questions pertaining to
this document should be addressed to !AAP Person 1
L AAWSA Program
Manager, Defense Intelligence Agency, ATTN: CLAR/DWO-3, Bldg 6000, Washington,
DC 20340-5100.

UNCLASSIFIED//fQA QffiliCiliCL Pl&li QtlL¥

Page 3

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFI@IAk WSli OPtklf

Contents
Foreword and Introduction ....................................................................................iv
I. Quantum Entanglement, Nonlocality, and EPR Experiments ............................... 1
II. The Quantum No-Signal Theorems .................................................................... 4
III. Nonlocality Versus Special Relativity? ............................................................. 5
IV. Momentum Domain Entanglement and EPR Experiments .................................. 5
V. Coherence-Entanglement Complementarity ..................................................... 10
VI. Nonlocal Communication Versus Signaling ..................................................... 11
VII. A Transactional Analysis of the Nonlocal Communication Test ...................... 13

VIII. Superluminal and Retrocausal Nonlocal Communication ............................. 17
IX. Paradoxes and Nonlocal Communication ........................................................ 18
X. Superluminal Communication without Paradoxes ............................................ 19
XI. Example: Real-Time Earth Control of Mars Rover............................................ 20
XII. Another Superluminal Possibility: Nonlinear Quantum Mechanics................. 22
XIII. Conclusion ................................................................................................... 23
Appendix: Glossary .............................................................................................. 24

Figures
Figure 1. Schematic of the 1972 Freedman-Clauser Experiment ............................ 2
Figure 2. Schematic of the 1995 Ghost Interference Experiment of the Shih
Group ...................................................................................................... 6
Figure 3. Ghost Interference Position Distributions at X2 ....................................... 7
Figure 4. "Unfolding" the Ghost Interference Experiment ...................................... 8
Figure 5. Schematic of the 1998 Dopfer Experiment .............................................. 9
Figure 6. Thick-Source Effect ............................................................................... 10
Figure 7. Slit-Imaging Coincidence-Free Version of the Ghost Interference
Experiment to Demonstrate Nonlocal Communication ........................... 12
Figure 8. Transactional Interpretation Diagrams for Case 1 ................................. 15
Figure 9. Transactional Interpretation Diagrams for Case 2 ................................. 16

ii

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFI@I.t.k WSli 8Ptklf

Page 4

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFI@IAL WSE OHL¥
Figure 10. Slit-Imaging Coincidence-Free Version of the Ghost Interference
Experiment Demonstrating Superluminal and Retrocausal Signaling .. 17
Figure 11. A Superluminal Nonlocal Communication System in Which the
Communication Spans a Spacelike Interval ........................................ 20
Figure 12. Schematic of Earth-to-Mars Real-Time Control of a Rover ................... 21

iii

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOA 0FFl&l.t.L WSE OHL'/

Page 5

UNCLASSIFIED/ /P81t errl@IAL ~SI! 8HL'I

The Space-Communication Implications of Quantum
Entanglement and Nonlocality
Foreword and Introduction
This paper reviews quantum entanglement and nonlocality and considers the
possibility that this phenomenon could be used for sending observer-to­
observer signals. Such a demonstration would break several quantum "no­
signal theorems" in the physics literature. Nonlocal quantum signaling would
have far-reaching implications as an enabling technology for superluminal and
retrocausal signaling. Scenarios that might lead to nonlocal quantum
communication are described, and applications to retrocausal signaling and
real-time space communication are considered. Also considered briefly is the
nonlocal communication implications of nonlinear quantum mechanics.
Communication in space at the scale of the solar system is severely limited by
the space-time scale set by the speed of light. Light signals, whether in the
form of radio waves, microwaves, visible light, X-rays, or gamma rays, require
about 3.3 microseconds to travel a distance of 1 kilometer. A light signal sent
from Earth requires about 1.3 seconds to reach the Moon, between 4.4 and 20
minutes to reach Mars, and between 4 and 4.3 hours to reach Neptune,
depending on their orbital positions. This time delay makes real-time control
of remote space-based devices impossible and leads to the need for pre­
programmed robotic devices with enough "intelligence" to perform limited
operations with a minimum of remote control.
The burden of these limitations raises the question of whether there is some
way to speed up the space communications link. The conventional answer is
"No!," because the well-established special theory of relativity is viewed as
limiting signal transmission speed to the speed of light, with superluminal
communications strictly forbidden. However, as will be discussed in Section
III, relativity prohibits only certain forms of superluminal communication,
while other forms are not in conflict with relativity. One phenomenon that
appears, at least superficially, to exhibit superluminal aspects while
preserving compatibility with special relativity is quantum nonlocality, the
ability of quantum phenomena to enforce correlations between quantum
states over large separations in space-time.
When two photons emerge from a single quantum event, the state of one
photon may be subtly connected to that of the other. The classical view is that,
once separated, such photon states must be fixed according to mechanics and
conservation relations that act at the point of their origin, so that modifying
one later will not affect the other. In quantum physics, however, as borne out
by experiment (Reference 1, 2), the outcome of a measurement of the state of
one of the photons, even well after their point of joint creation, can affect the
state of the other photon. This connection is referred to as quantum
entanglement, a phrase first coined by Erwin Schrodinger (Reference 3).
Questions raised by the phenomenon of quantum entanglement are: (1) what
is the causal connection between entangled states, and (2) can the
phenomenon possibly be used for sending observer-to-observer signals? This

iv

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFI&I.t.k Wliliii QfslL¥

Page 6

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFI@IsT.tk WS& OPtklf
paper attempts to address these questions by taking a close look at quantum
entanglement, quantum nonlocality, the experiments that have explored them,
and proposed experiments to test the causal and faster-than-light
communication issues evoked by such physics.
Quantum entanglement describes the condition of separated parts of the same
quantum system in which each of the parts can be described only by
referencing the state of other parts. This is one of the most counterintuitive
aspects of quantum mechanics, because classically one would expect system
parts out of "local" contact to be completely independent. Thus, entanglement
represents a kind of quantum "connectedness" in which measurements on one
isolated part of an entangled quantum system have nonclassical consequences
for the outcome of measurements performed on the other (possibly very
distant) part of the same system. This quantum connectedness acting in
entangled quantum systems is called quantum nonlocality.
Nonlocality was first highlighted by Albert ~instein and his coworkers Boris
_fodolsky and Nathan ,Rosen in their famous EPR paper (Reference 4). They
argued that the nonlocal connectedness of quantum systems was unphysical
in that it implied a faster-than-light connection in apparent conflict with
special relativity. Despite their objection, quantum nonlocality has now been
demonstrated (see Section I) in many quantum systems (Reference 1, 2). In
the physics community, it is now generally acknowledged to be implicit in the
quantum formalism as applied to entangled systems, although there remain a
few Copenhagen "holdouts" who would require an explicit demonstration of
nonlocal signaling before admitting that nonlocality can be considered a real
quantum phenomenon.
The question investigated in this paper is whether quantum nonlocality is the
private domain of nature or whether it can be used in experimental situations
to send signals from one observer to another. As we will see, there is at
present no compelling answer to this question. However, it is clear that if such
nonlocal observer-to-observer communication were possible, it would have
far-reaching implications. In particular, it would represent an enabling
technology for superluminal (and retrocausal) signaling and communications,
and perhaps make possible the real-time exploration of the universe.

V

UNCLASSIFIED/ /rOR. 0rr1e11et U:!I! OHL I

Page 7

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFI&iIAk W&li OPlklf

I. Quantum Entanglement, Nonlocality, and EPR

Experiments
In the quantum mechanical description of elementary entities like photons, there is a
duality between the description as a particle and as a wave. Photons can be thought of
as traveling through space as waves but delivering energy (and other conserved
quantities) at detection as particles. By choosing the kinds of measurements made on
such objects, one can force wave-like or particle-like behavior to be exhibited in the
measurements results. Between the entangled parts of a quantum system (for
example, the emission of a pair of entangled photons), this wave-like or particle-like
behavior in a measurement on one part of the system may force similar behavior in the
other part. This is considered further in Section IV below.
The quantum entanglement condition is usually a consequence of some conservation
law acting within the system, so that the subsystems are connected by the conserved
quantities. For example, if two photons are emitted back to back in a joint state that
has zero angular momentum and positive parity, then whatever linear or circular
polarization state one photon is measured to have, the other photon must have an
identical polarization if measured in the same basis (linear or circular). This condition
must exist to ensure that the net angular momentum of the two photon states is zero.
In this situation, if the photons are measured for circular polarization, they must both
be in states of right circular polarization or in states of left circular polarization. Because
linear polarization is a coherent superposition of circular polarization states, if measured
in the vertical/horizontal linear polarization basis, they must be in the same vertical or
horizontal polarization state, and in the 45° left or right linear polarization basis, they
must be in the same 45° left/rig ht polarization state.
Classically, such a polarization correlation condition could in principle exist in some
particular polarization basis but not in all of the many possible polarization bases
simultaneously. This is the underlying physics of the Bell Inequalities (Reference 8),
which deal with the falloff rate of the correlations as the polarization basis of one of the
measurements is rotated in angle. The Bell Inequalities demonstrate mathematically
that the predictions of sem i-classical local hidden-variable theories are inconsistent with
those of standard quantum mechanics. Tests of such polarization correlations have
been the basis for a number of Bell-Inequality tests (or so-called EPR experiments), in
which the validity of the predictions of quantum mechanics and the inadequacies of
semi-classical local hidden-variable theories have been demonstrated to high statistical
precision (Reference 1, 2) .
It was later demonstrated (Reference 5, 6) that the issues surrounding a violation of
the Bell Inequalities could be separated into violations of either parameter
independence (the outcome probability of a measurement on one of a pair of entangled
particles is independent of the choice of parameters of a measurement performed on
the other member of the entangled pair) and violations of outcome independence (the
outcome probability of a measurement on one of a pair of entangled particles is
independent of the outcome of a measurement performed on the other member of the
entangled pair). The observation of a violation of the Bell Inequalities indicates a
violation of either parameter independence or outcome independence (or both).
Outcome independence is fairly evident in the quantum formalism, while parameter
independence is more elusive and depends on specific assumptions. Below, the

1

UNCLASSIFIED/ /rOR. 0rr1e11et U:!I! OHL I

Page 8

UNCLASSIFIED/ /P91t 9ffl@IAL WSE &P•Llf
implications of this dichotomy are considered in the context of the "no-signal"
theorems .
It is noted that there is some misinformation in the literature concerning the chronology
of successful EPR polarization correlation experiments, and here we wish to set the
record at least somewhat straighter. The experimental measurement that first
demonstrated a polarization correlation related to EPR nonlocality was performed by C.
S. Wu and I. Shanknov in 1949 (Reference 7), well before Bell's work and the
subsequent interest in testing Bell's Inequality. Wu and Shanknov showed that the
linear polarizations of back-to-back entangled gamma rays from electron-positron
annihilation (an L=O negative parity state) were anticorrelated, for example, if one
photon was polarized vertically, then the other was polarized horizontally. They did not,
however, investigate the falloff of the correlation with polarimeter angle, which is the
basis of Bell Inequality tests, nor did they depict their results as a consequence of
quantum nonlocality.

Almost two decades passed before the publication of John Bell's pivotal work (Reference
8) in 1964 and 1966. In 1972, Freedman and Clauser (Reference 1) performed the first
definitive Bell inequality test by measuring the polarization correlation of entangled
photons from a positive parity L=O atomic cascade in calcium. Their results were in
agreement with the predictions of quantum mechanics and were inconsistent with local
hidden-variable theories by 6. 7 standard deviations. A decade later, in 1982, EPR
measurements of the Aspect group (Reference 2) eliminated several "loophole"
scenarios that might constitute unlikely ways of preserving classical locality and again
demonstrated agreement with quantum mechanics and inconsistency with local hidden­
variable theories, this time by 46 standard deviations. In a more recent example of an
EPR experiment, the Gisin group (Reference 9) used the fiber-optic cables owned by the
Swiss Telephone System to demonstrate the nonlocal connection between EPR
measurements made at locations in Geneva and Bern, Swiss cities with a line -of-sight
separation of 156 km-a direct demonstration, if one was required, that quantum
nonlocality can operate over quite large distances.

Ca-OVEN
LENS

LENS

~

FILTER

POLARIZER 2

'~

_

_ _-..i

~

=--------i

~LE,
.....__

RI
POLARIZER I

DISC.
COINC .

f8
P.H.A.

ELAY

COINC.
TA.C.

Figure 1. Schematic of the 1972 Freedman-Clauser Experiment (Reference 1)

2

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOil OFFl@IAL W!H! 9HL1/

Page 9

UNCLASSIFIED/ /POK OFFICIAL tt.!I!! 8HL'f
Do these EPR experiments constitute a demonstration of the existence of quantum
nonlocality? There is more than one way of interpreting the implications of the
experimental results (Reference 1, 2), and one can find much discussion in the
literature as to whether it is locality or "realism" (the objective observer- independent
reality of external events) that has been refuted by these EPR measurements.
Noble Laureate Anthony Leggett of the University of Illinois recently pushed this issue
somewhat further (Reference 10). He demonstrated that by focusing on the falloff of
correlations with elliptical polarization rather than the linear polarization used in the Bell
Inequality EPR experiments, one can compare the predictions of quantum mechanics
with a class of nonlocal realistic theories that he constructed. The resulting Leggett
Inequalities can be used in the same way as the Bell Inequalities, but to test theories
incorporating nonlocal realism instead of local realism. Anton Zeilinger's group at the
Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information (IQOQI) in Vienna performed a
definitive test of the Leggett Inequalities (Reference 11). The results show that using
elliptically polarized entangled photons, the Leggett Inequalities in two observables are
violated by 3.6 and by 9 standard deviations. This is interpreted as a statistically
significant falsification of the whole class of nonlocal realistic theories constructed by
Leggett. The IQOQI group summarizes its results with the statement "We believe that
our results lend strong support to the view that any future extension of quantum theory
that is in agreement with experiments must abandon certain features of realistic
descriptions."
It is our view, however, that this is mainly an exercise in demolishing a "strawman."
Leggett's nonlocal realistic theories assume that when entangled photons emerge from
their emission source, they are in a definite state of polarization. It is well known that
when that assumption (and no others) is made, one does not observe the quantum
mechanical prediction of Malus's Law for the correlations of the photon pair.

However, Leggett solves that problem by assuming an unspecified nonlocal connection
mechanism between the detection systems that fixes the discrepancy. In effect, the two
measurements talk to each other nonlocally in such a way that the detected linea rly
polarized photons obey Malus's Law and produce the same linear polarization
correlations predicted by quantum mechanics calculations. Leggett then shows that this
nonlocal "fix" cannot be extended into the realm of elliptical polarization, and that
quantum mechanics and this type of nonlocal realistic theories give differing predictions
for the elliptic polarization correlations. In other words, the "reality" that is being tested
is whether the photon source is initially emitting the entangled photons in a definite
state of polarization. It is this version of "reality" that has been falsified by the IQOQI
measurements.

It is our view that this assumption, clearly inconsistent with the formalism of quantum
mechanics, is invalid, and that nature is both nonlocal and unrealistic, if by realism one
means that when entangled photons emerge from their emission source, they are in a
definite state of polarization. This very restricted definition of realism is not required,
and it is assumed that the intrinsic nonlocality of standard quantum mechanics is a
physical fact.
It is noted that the several polarization bases used in t hese ki nds of polarization EPR
experiments make demonstrating the quantum nonlocal connections straightforward
but also make it effectively impossible to use those connections for observer-to-

3

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR: OFFI&il.t.k W&liii OP•k¥

Page 10

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFI@IAk WSE OPtklf
observer signaling (Reference 12), because one would need to deduce from the arriving
photons the polarization basis that was being used in the distant measurements. This is
an aspect of the parameter independence mentioned above. While each observer is free
to choose a parameter that specifies the polarization basis (for example, circular
right/left, linear at any angle) for the measurement, he is not free to force the photon
into a particular state of that basis, as would be required for nonlocal communication.
However, measuring polarization correlations in a system with angular momentum
constraints is not the only way to demonstrate the nonlocal connection between the
entangled separated parts of a quantum system. Below, EPR experiments that use
momentum entanglement are discussed, and the question of whether such quantum
systems might provide a better vehicle for observer-to-observer nonlocal
communication is explored, because by using momentum entanglement, an observer is
able to force the photon into particle-like or wave-like behavior.

II. The Quantum No-Signal Theorems
As Einstein implied with his well-known "spooky actions at a distance" comment,
enforcement of quantum correlations across spacelike and negative timelike intervals
by nonlocality is very counterintuitive. It appears to imply the twin possibilities of
superluminal commun ication and of reverse causation through back-in-time
communication between observers. However, a number of authors (Reference 13) have
presented "proofs" that such nonlocal observer-to-observer communication is
impossible within the formalism of standard quantum mechanics. These theorems
assert that in separated measurements involving entangled quantum systems, the
quantum correlations will be preserved, but there will be no effect apparent to an
observer in one sub-system if the character of the measurement is changed in the
other sub-system . Thus, it is asserted, nonlocal signaling is impossible.
As mentioned above, EPR experiments can be viewed (Reference 5, 6) as
demonstrating violations of outcome independence or parameter independence or both.
Outcome independence cannot be used for nonlocal signaling, while parameter
independence can. Thus, any test of nonlocal signaling is, in effect, a test of the
parameter independence of quantum phenomena, and the no-signal theorems are
"proofs" of parameter independence.
Do these no-signal "proofs" really have the status of mathematical theorems? Perhaps
not. Recently it has been pointed out (Reference 14) that at least some of these
"proofs" ruling out nonlocal signaling are tautological, assuming that the measurement
process and its associated Hamiltonian are local, thereby building the final conclusion of
no signaling into their starting assumptions. Standard quantum mechanical Bose­
Einstein symmetrization in systems of bosons has been raised as a counter-example,
shown to be inconsistent with the initial assumptions of some of these "proofs."
Therefore, at least from some perspectives, the possibility of nonlocal communication in
the context of standard quantum mechanics remains open and appropriate for
experimental testing.

4

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFI@IAk WSE OHkl/

Page 11

UNCLASSIFIED//POil OFFI@IAk W&i 0NL¥

III. Nonlocality Versus Special Relativity?
If nonlocal communication is possible, would it be in conflict with special relativity, with
its well-known prohibition against faster-than-light signals? The answer is no.
The prohibition of signals with superluminal speeds by Einstein's theory of special
relativity is related to the fact that the definite simultaneity of two separated space­
time points is not Lorentz invariant. Since some hypothetical superluminal signal could
be used to establish a fixed simultaneity relation between two such points-for
example, by clock synchronization-this would imply a preferred inertial frame and
would be inconsistent with Lorentz invariance and special relativity. In other words, it
would be inconsistent with the even-handed treatment of all inertial reference frames in
special relativity.
However, if a nonlocal signal could be transmitted through measurements at separated
locations performed on two entangled photons, the signal would be "sent" at the time
of the arrival of the photon in one location and "received" at the time of arrival of the
other photon. By varying path lengths to the two locations, these events could be made
to occur in any order and time separation in any reference frame. Therefore, nonlocal
signals (even superluminal and retrocausal ones) could not be used to establish a fixed
simultaneity relation between two separated space-time points, because the sending
and receiving of such signals do not have fixed time relations. The transmission and
arrival instants of a nonlocal signal cannot be used for synchronization because the
transmission and reception instants are path- and delay-dependent variables.
To put it another way, the nonlocal connections of entangled photons lie along
segmented lightlike world lines that transform properly under Lorentz transformations.
Therefore, there is no conflict between nonlocal signaling and the Lorentz invariance of
special re lativity. On the other hand, the principle of causality (cause must precede
effect in all reference frames) appears very likely to be violated (or at least violate­
able) if nonlocal signaling is possible.
Is it possible that the universe does have some preferred reference frame, perhaps that
laid down by the cosmic microwave background or implied by Mach's Principle?
Perhaps, but if such a preferred frame existed, its existence could not be established by
nonlocal communication.

IV. Momentum Domain Entanglement and EPR
Experiments
Einstein's original objection (Reference 4) that quantum mechanics appeared to be
nonlocal was made with arguments based on a gedankenexperiment in the momentum
domain. However, almost all of the modern EPR experiments testing the Bell Inequality
and demonstrating quantum nonlocality have been performed in the polarization (that
is, angular momentum) domain, usually with linearly polarized photons. Interestingly, it
appears that if nonlocal quantum communication is possible at all, it may be more
easily achieved in the momentum domain of Einstein's original focus.
The optical process of spontaneous parametric down-conversion (Reference 15) turns
out to be a very useful way of generating photon pairs entangled in either the
polarization or the momentum domains. In this process, a photon from a "pump laser"

5

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOil OFFI&I.t.k W&li ONkY

Page 12

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR. OFFl@IAL l!ISE 8PU::Y
interacts with a nonlinear crystal and is transformed into two photons with energies and
vector momenta that add up to those of the original pump photon. Depending on the
type of down-conversion process, there are well-defined polarization correlations
between the entangled photons. The down-converted photons may also be easily
prepared in momentum -entangled states, because within the nonlinear medium, the
vector momenta of the down-converted pair of photons must add to give that of the
pump photon.
The first measurement using
momentum-entangled down-conversion
35 1 nm
photons that might be related to
nonlocal communication is the Ghost
Interference experiment reported in
1995 by the Shih group (Reference 16),
Ar Laser
shown schematically in Figure 2. The
experimenters used degenerate
collinear Type-II down-conversion of
351-nm UV pump radiation from an
BS
argon-ion laser passed through a 3f1
mm-long BBO (f3-BaB2Q4) crystal that
0
Slits
had been cut with the optic axis at a
phase-matching angle of 42.2° to the
pump beam to produce a pair of
collinear momentum-entangled 702-nm
photons with opposite polarizations. The
entangled photons emerge from the
Gating
crystal very nearly parallel with the
fiber
pump beam. The pump beam is then
split off from the pair using refraction in
a quartz prism (UV Prism), and the
Gated
entangled photons are separated with a
polarization-selecting beam splitter (BS)
that reflects the "extraordinary"
vertically polarized photon (e) and
Figure 2. Schematic of the 1995 Ghost Interference
transmits the "ordinary" horizontally
Experiment (Reference 16) of the Shih group
polarized photon (o) . Both photons are
passed through 702 ± 10-nm wavelength-selective filters (f1,2) and then detected
(D1,2).

6

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR. OFFICIJ!IL U:!~ Gilt I

Page 13

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR 8FFI@IAL l!IS! 8HLY
The experimenters demonstrated that
passing the vertically polarized photon
(e) through a double- or single-slit
system before detection at D1 produced
a "comb" interference distribut ion or a
"bump" diffraction distribution,
respectively, in the position X2 of the
horizontally po larized photon (o)
detected at D2 when the pair of photons
is examined in coincidence. I n other
words, the position distribution of the
straight-through photon shows patterns
characteristic of the single- or double­
slit system through which its tw in
entangled photon passed. Figure 3
shows the observed position
distributions for the two cases .

300

(a) Two slits

250

"'

C:
::,
0

200

0

Ql
(.)

C:
Ql

150

'C

·.:;
C:
·5

100

0

so
0 L _ _ , = . . J . - - - - ' - - ~ _ _ J _ ~ - - - - - ' - - - ~ - ' - - ~ . . . , _ _ ~~
·2
0
2
4
·8
·6
·4

'---'

De tec tor 2 position (mm)
500

"'

C:
::,
0
0

a,

(b) One slit

400

300

0
C:
Ql

From the viewpoint of nonlocal
~ 200
C:
·o
commun ication, we note that modifying
0
100
the slit system before D1 through which
the reflected photon passes, wh ich can
be thought of as the action of a
·8
·4
·2
0
2
4
"sending" observer, nonlocally causes
Detector 2 position (mm)
an observable change in the Xrposition
Figure 3. Ghost Interference Position Distributions

Text continues in the original file (32 pages).

Previous: DOW-UAP-D132 — AAWSAP DIRD, Advanced Space Propulsion Based on Vacuum (Spacetime Metric) Engineering, March 2010 · Next: DOW-UAP-D134 — AAWSAP DIRD, Maverick Inventor Versus Corporate Inventor: Where Will the Next Major Innovations Arise, March 2010

Same topic: title & summary match

Same location: Las Vegas, Nevada

Same period: 2010

Same release: Release 06

Same agency: DoW