DOW-UAP-D131 — AAWSAP DIRD, The Role of Superconductors in Gravity Research, March 2010
File DOW-UAP-D131 is a declassified pdf from Department of War, recording an incident dated 3/23/10 at Las Vegas, Nevada, published in Release 06 (2026-09-18). This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.
- File
- DOW-UAP-D131
- Agency
- Department of War
- Incident date
- 3/23/10
- Location
- Las Vegas, Nevada
- Released in
- Release 06 (2026-09-18)
- File type
Topics: AAWSAP & DIRDs
This document is a Defense Intelligence Reference Document (DIRD), a technical reference format used by the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) to capture baseline knowledge on a specific topic for later analytic use. DIRDs are best understood as reference and synthesis products rather than as original research. It is one of 38 DIRDs produced under the Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Applications Program (AAWSAP) between 2009 and 2011. Because AAWSAP’s scope permitted a broad range of supporting topics, not every DIRD in the series directly concerns aerospace systems or future threat assessment. The following summary reflects the DIRD’s scope and framing at the time of writing and should not be read as implying current validation of the concepts discussed.
This DIRD is a historical survey of efforts to determine whether superconductors might play a role in producing, detecting, or modifying gravity-related effects in a laboratory setting. It reviews the main theoretical and experimental lines of work in that area and attempts to connect superconducting materials with gravitational-wave or propulsion-related concepts. Because the topic is highly contested within the scientific literature, the report spends substantial attention on experiments of disputed value and on controversial theories, especially claims that rotating or energized superconductors might generate anomalous gravitational effects. Overall, the document treats the subject as an exploratory research area with potentially major implications if any real effect were verified, while also making clear that the evidentiary base remained weak, that prominent claims had not been convincingly replicated, and that both the underlying theory and the experimental record remained deeply disputed.
Open original file · WAR.GOV page
TL;DR
Even 1992’s spin-disk couldn’t convince anyone beyond the lab.
- DIRD DOW-UAP-D131, DoW, March 2010, Las Vegas, NV
- Surveys superconductors’ alleged gravity effects, theories, disputed experiments, e.g., Podkletnov 1992
- No official conclusion in the file
AI summary
A classified report titled "The Role of Superconductors in Gravity Research," prepared by the Defense Intelligence Agency's Acquisition Support Division in March 2010. It discusses gravity waves, gravitoelectromagnetism, and historical developments in superconductor research, including Podkletnov's 1992 claim of a gravity shield using a spinning superconductor disk. The document covers theoretical work by Li and Torr, experimental challenges, unconfirmed claims of gravitational shielding, and ongoing debates about gravitational effects. It references experiments, academic conferences, publications, and private communications related to superconductors and gravity modification.
Full text
Page 2
UNCLASSIFIED/ /l'Clt Cl'l'ICl,CL t,91! OHL I
The Role of Superconductors in Gravity Research
Prepared by:
Acquisition Support Division (DW0-3)
Defense Warning Office
Directorate for Analysis
Defense Intelligence Agency
Author :
AAP Person 75
Administrative Note
COPYRIGHT WARN ING: Further dissemination of the photographs in this publication is not authorized.
Th is product is one in a series of advanced technology reports produced in FY 2009
under the Defense Intelligence Agency, Defense Warning Office's Advanced Aerospace
Weapon System Applications (AAWSA) Program. Comments or questions pertaining to
this document should be addressed to !AAP Person 1
AAWSA Program
Manager, Defense Intelligence Agency, ATTN: CLAR/ DW0-3, Bldg 6000, Washington,
DC 20340-5100.
I,
UNCLASSIFIED/ }FQA QliFiliCiliOL Pl&li QIIL¥
Page 4
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR: 8ffl@IJllt t:191!! l>flt I
The Role of Superconductors in Gravity Research
Introduction
This paper is a historical survey of the role superconductors have played in the
recent search for laboratory-scale manipulation of gravity. The invention of
superconductors and, in particular, the recent development of high
temperature ceramic superconductors have provided the impetus for pursuing
a connection between gravity, electromagnetism, and, in particular,
magnetism and matter in the solid state. The discovery of yttrium-barium
copper oxide (YBCO) YBa2Cu301 ceramics able to superconduct at liquid
nitrogen temperatures allowed many laboratories around the world to
fabricate these superconductors in various experimentally useful sizes. True
Meissner repulsion was obtained by cooling them using relatively cheap liquid
nitrogen rather than liquid helium. For the theoretician, the possibility of
considering the superconductor being a macroscopic quantum object as a
reality rather than a fantasy suggested several avenues for developing
theories connecting gravity and gravity-like forces to engineerable matter. For
the experimentalist, extrapolations from these theories suggested there might
actually be gravitational disturbances in the laboratory that would be
amenable to measurement, assuming all necessary precautions were taken to
exclude artifact.
iii
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOA QFFI&IAI:: WSE 8HL'/
Page 5
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOA QFFI@IAL l::ISI!!! er~t I
Gravity Waves
A distinction should be made between gravitational waves, the gravitational "force,"
and anomalous forces. Currently, work on gravitational waves is divided into two more
or less distinct realms: low frequency (less than a few hundred Hz) and high frequency
(greater than ~ several tens of kHz). The existence of gravitational waves of any
frequency is a natural outcome of Einstein's theory of general relativity (GR). The
search for low-frequency gravitational waves currently utilizes large, heavy, and long
metal bars as detectors together with interferometers, strain gauges, and
accelerometers in an attempt to detect quadrupolar gravitational waves from
cosmological sources, such as binary stars. The general idea is that if a large mass of
precisely known dimensions is effectively isolated from the surrounding environment
(such as Earth) by means of special vibration and other isolators, the masses will
interact with the small-amplitude gravity waves emitted by large masses in the cosmos
and their lengths will change, but by extremely small amounts. UGO, LISA, VIRGO,
DECIGO (Japan), and CEGO {China) are some of the acronyms given to these
experiments. They are primarily attempts to verify the existence of these waves to
further solidify the understanding that GR gives us about the nature of space and
matter. Several researchers consider that high-frequency gravitational waves (HFGW)
will be produced in the laboratory under certain conditions in the near future (Reference
1). These researchers have a considerably more ambitious view of the future than the
low-frequency gravitational wave researchers, including the use of HFGW for
communications, telescopy, microscopy, and possibly propulsion. Some consider that
the production and detection of these waves will be mediated, or at least assisted, by
superconductors (References 2, 3). Current research on the link between HFGW and the
manipulation of gravity for propulsion is at present only theoretical. If gravitational
waves can interact with and be converted into forces in laboratory-scale matter, it is
hoped that those forces would be manifest not as gravitational forces per se, as these
gravitational forces would be exceedingly small and difficult to unequivocally detect in
the laboratory, but rather as electromagnetic or ponderable nongravitational forces,
thus making them more amenable to detection by electromagnetic means.
Gravitoel ectromag netism
The gravitational "force" arises from the tendency of one body to accelerate toward
another. (Force is in quotation marks here merely for simplicity and ease of use when
comparing gravity with other forces, as many other gravity-like forces can be easily
confused in the laboratory with actual gravitational attraction.) The physical explanation
for gravitational attraction has been elusive at best. Several notable attempts at novel
explanations have recently been published. Puthoff (Reference 4) developed an idea
originally put forward by Sakharov (Reference 5) that posits gravity as a Casimir-like
attraction arising within the universal sea of fluctuating electromagnetic interactions,
sometimes called zero-point fluctuations. Alzofon (Reference 6) presented an
engineering approach to interacting with gravity by means of altering nuclear entropy
using a technique associated with electron paramagnetic resonance called dynamic
nuclear orientation-that is, enhanced polarization of the magnetic moments of
nucleons by interaction with pulsed polarized electron spins. Hughes (Reference 7)
analyzed the Kopernicky Conjecture, which holds that gravity is nothing other than the
slight difference between forces of coulomb attraction and repulsion. However, none of
these researchers appealed to the special form of matter constituting superconductors.
1
UNCLASSIFIED/ /P"91l 9P"P"l@IAL l::ISI!! 8HLY
Page 6
UNCLASSIFIED/ /POlt err1e1J1tt U.!I! er\tt I
The "attraction" of modifying gravity-whether your own, your spacecraft's, or that of a
nearby large mass-for propulsive purposes lies in two general categories of effect:
•
The modifying, neutralizing, or negating of the gravitational attraction of a nearby
body, typically Earth.
•
The provision of propulsive force or impulse to a spacecraft based on manipulation
of the same underlying physical phenomenon that forms the basis of gravity.
The theoretical and experimental attempts outlined in this paper deal with both these
possibilities.
In experiments designed to produce a gravity-l ike force or to interact directly with a
local gravity field, the researcher has to be looking for extremely small deviations from
a null result. Observations to date demonstrate that interactions between gravity and
electromagnetic fields, given the field densities and strengths available to even the
most well-equipped laboratory, are many orders of magnitude smaller than those
required to begin to see such forces. Braginski et al. (Reference 8) showed that
ordinary matter cannot be used to generate measurable gravitational fields in the
laboratory. The standard edict against such things as gravity shields can be summed up
by noting the absence of negative gravitational mass, at least in this sector of the
universe, resulting in the relative "gravitational permittivity/permeability" being unity in
normal matter. Therefore, demonstrating that a new force, whether gravitational or
not, has been discovered in the laboratory will require an intense effort to provide
proof. This implies being able to distinguish between true gravity-like forces and gravity
interactions and a host of prosaic effects masquerading as these forces . A list of
potential artifacts attendant on such experiments can be found in Reference 9.
General relativity introduces a metric tensor theory of gravity, and while it does not
explain the fundamental physical basis of the gravitational attraction between two
bodies, it does allow the prediction of a large range of interactions between bodies.
Simi larly, Maxwell's vector equations do not explain the fundamental basis for
electromagnetic interactions but do allow us to predict the outcomes of such
interactions. It is possible to reformulate the tensor format of GR into a simple vector
format that is val id only for a subset of GR conditions, namely in the weak field
approximation and for nonrelativistic velocities. Using perturbation theory, for example,
to compute the equations of motion in the simplified GR equations results in terms that
have direct analogs in Maxwell equations where electrical current flow is rep laced by
mass flow, for example. Forward (Reference 10, 11) was among the first to investigate
this analog. One term is analogous to the Biot-Savart-like magnetic fie ld and is
generally referred to as the "gravitomagnetic field" (and also sometimes as
"gravitational frame dragging" or the "Lense-Thirring Effect") and has the dimensions of
s- 1 . Another term is analogous to the electrostatic coulomb field and is referred to as
the "gravitoelectric field." Essentially, the gravitomagnetic field produces a force
between currents of flowing matter, while the gravitoelectric field produces a force
between masses themselves (the Newtonian gravitational field). Sometimes the term
"gravitoelectromagnetic field" is used to refer to both the gravitoelectric and
gravitomagnetic fields.
Gravity is thus composed of a (Newtonian) velocity-independent field and a
(gravitomagnetic) velocity-dependent field analogous to the electric and magnetic fields
2
UNCLASSIFIED/ /fOll Offl@IAL YSE 8HLY
Page 7
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR: 8FFI@IAL l!ISI!!! er~t a
in electromagnetic theory. The simplified GR/Maxwell equations show that there is also
a Faraday-like law of induction that can generate Newtonian gravitational fields from
time-varying gravitomagnetic fields.
Modern attempts to confirm the existence of the gravitomagnetic field include highly
accurate laser ranging of the Earth-Moon distance (Reference 12), as well as the launch
of the Gravity Probe B satellite (Reference 13).
Historical Timeline
In order to aid future researchers, it is instructive to follow the general historical
development of the modern search for a link between electromagnetism, matter, and
gravity. This outline will include both theoretical and experimental aspects, expanding
and emphasizing experimental issues where appropriate. Because of space limitations,
not all of the many contributions to the field can be highlighted. The reader is
encouraged to consult the source references cited in this paper to obtain a fuller
appreciation of the amount of effort that has been expended in this area of physics.
Podkletnov and Nieminen (Reference 15) published what is considered the first possible
evidence for an experimental link between high-temperature liquid nitrogen (LN2)
superconductor effects and gravity, allegedly in the form of a gravity shield. Many
scientists since then have cast considerable doubt on their findings. Notwithstanding
these severe criticisms, since the publication of this paper, many other researchers
have considered that the experimental search for gravity-related forces could be taken
out of the realm of pure speculation and onto the laboratory bench. Podkletnov's
apparent experimental success has in turn prompted some theoreticians to consider
fresh approaches to investigating superconductors as a special form of condensed
matter capable of modifying and/or producing such forces.
It would be a breakthrough of the first order to discover a repeatable, laboratory-scale,
heretofore hidden connection between gravity, special forms of matter that can be
created in the laboratory, and electromagnetism that would possibly unlock the door to
new transportation systems, new energy sources, and a host of other earthly benefits,
not to mention professional accolades and untold wealth for the technology developers.
However, the rush to be the first to successfully find a repeatable and verifiable link
between superconductors and gravity has produced many casualties. Theoreticians
have made assumptions to force their theories to explain the putative experimental
results. Most experiments have been literally thrown together with little thought paid to
the myriad traps and pitfalls that litter the minefield of experimental physics in this
uncharted territory. This is primarily due to the expectation that the sought-after forces
will be extremely tiny and hard to distinguish from prosaic influences.
The most prominent, albeit controversial theoretical work on creating laboratory
detectable gravitomagnetic fields via high-temperature superconductors was initiated
by Li and Torr (Reference 16-18). Their work expanded on earlier work by DeWitt
(Reference 19) and Ross (Reference 20), who considered modifications to the London
equations, which relate supercurrent (that is, Cooper pair) flow to electric and magnetic
fields in and around a superconductor, to include gravitomagnetic fields. Dewitt showed
that a time-varying gravitomagnetic field must arise owing to the presence of magnetic
flux quantization in superconductors. Dewitt's work was expanded on by Ross, who
3
UNCLASSIFIED/ /fOll 8FFI@IAL WS& 8PUslf
Page 8
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR 8FFI€il.t..L l:ISE 8HLV
produced a modified set of London equations. These papers laid the theoretical
foundations for the later work of Li, Torr, and Tajmar, for example .
In the late 1980s while at the University of Alabama, Douglas Torr was examining
neglected areas of physics, including aether theories and experiments, as well as
gravitational wave antennas, the subject of a paper awarded the Gravity Research
Foundation's "First Award" in 1989. In 1991, Torr and Ning Li pub lished a paper on the
effects of a gravitomagnetic field on superconducting matter (Reference 16). Ordinarily,
all magnetic fields are excluded from the interior of a superconductor because of
Meissner expulsion . However, by solving the coupled Maxwell, GR, and London
equations for the internal magnetic and gravitomagnetic fields of superconductors
exposed to external gravitomagnetic and magnetic fields, they predicted a small
residual internal magnetic field. This in turn produces an internal gravitomagnetic field.
The fields are related to one another by the Cooper pair mass-to-charge ratio. The
gravitomagnetic field penetration depth is larger than the normal magnetic field depth.
A year later the same authors presented papers at a meeting of the American Physical
Society (Reference 17). Buoyed by the apparent success of their previous analyses,
part of the title of one presentation was "A Theoretical Basis for a Principle of
Electrically Induced Gravitation." In this paper, they used coupled Ginzburg-Landau
equations to calculate the relative strengths of the electric and gravitational fields in
superconductors in the presence of magnetic and gravitomagnetic fields. They
concluded that under certain circumstances, a secondary gravitational field could be
induced inside a superconductor and "provide a basis for the electrical generation of
gravitational fields in the laboratory."
Then came the bombshell. A Russian materials scientist on staff at the Institute of
Materials Science at the Tampere University of Technology in Finland published a paper
in 1992 on an apparent gravity shielding experiment using a spinning superconductor
disk (Reference 15). In the mid-1980s, the lead author, Evgueny E. Podkletnov, had
published several papers on ceramics while at the Institute for High Temperatures in
Moscow. He later moved to Finland, where he completed his doctorate under then
Director of the Institute of Materials Science Pentti Kettunen. Podkletnov's thesis was
on preparation of pure YBCO wh iskers by magnetron sputtering, and he was producing
this material for powder-in-tube high-temperature superconducting wire for a local
business concern . According to Kettunen (Reference 21), the spinning disk experiment
was not actually performed at the institute but rather was conducted by Podkletnov and
others "after hours." Kettunen also confided that although he was aware of the
existence of the gravity shielding experiment through " so many others" telling him
about it, he never witnessed it himself. He did confirm the story Podkletnov later told
about discovering the shielding effect by watching the smoke from a coworker's pipe
float up exactly in the "shadow" of the spinning disk. The disk was apparently made in
Russia for sputtering purposes and brought to Finland .
The coauthor of the gravity shielding experiment, Risto Nieminen (this Risto Nieminen
is emphatica lly not the more famous professor of computational physics currently at
Helsinki University of Technology), was a technician working at the Institute of
Materials Science during Podkletnov's time there. He was not involved in Podkletnov's
experiments but noted (Reference 22) that they were likely conducted at either the
Tampere Institute of Technology's Department of Electrical Engineering or the Institute
of Physics. To this day, he is still not sure why he was asked to coauthor the paper,
4
UNCLASSIFIED/ /fOR: 8FFI€il.t.k Uili Ql"IL¥
Page 9
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFl&I.t..k WSI: OPtklf
except possibly for his proofreading skills. Strangely, the only persons who contacted
Podkletnov in the mid-1990s about the paper were the Ital ian theoretical physicist G.
Modanese and this author. Podkletnov claimed he had never heard of the work of Li and
Torr prior to publishing the paper.
According to the 1992 paper, the essence of his experiment was the high-speed
rotation of a relatively large ( 14. 5-cm diameter x 6-mm thick) YBCO sintered ceram ic
superconducting disk in the vapors of liqu id helium {LHe). The disk was levitated by
Meissner repulsion over a large support electromagnet immersed in LHe that was
powered by a variable-frequency supply from 50 Hz to 106 Hz. At the diametrical
periphery of the disk were positioned two additional but smaller electromagnets also
powered by variable frequency supplies. These two "rotational" electromagnets were
used to spin the disk in some unspecified manner. A small nonconducting, nonmagnetic
test mass was suspended from an analytical balance about 15 mm from the top of the
disk. Subsequent information from Podkletnov indicated that to obtain the maximum
stable test sample weight loss of about 0.3 percent, the optimum conditions required
operation of these two electromagnets at frequencies of 10 5 Hz and disk rotational
speeds of several thousand rpm.
Apart from the difficulty believing, on purely theoretical grounds, that such an
enormous weight loss was possible, there was considerable doubt about the validity of
the observations based on experimental issues. Among many other concerns, a few
comments regarding the cryostat are in order. The only information on the physical
configuration of the experiment is given in the sketch provided in Reference 15.
Referring to that figure, it is difficult to believe the only thing separating the vapors of
LHe in the cryostat from the laboratory atmosphere was a thin plastic film. Ordinarily,
so much water vapor and other gases would have condensed on the outer surface of
the film as to render it completely opaque, thus making the observation of the disk
extremely unlikely. If the cryostat was actually designed roughly per the sketch in the
article, the LHe would be boiling so vigorously that it would rupture any film unless
adequate He gas escape was provided . As pointed out by dePodesta (Reference 23),
thermal currents and buoyancy changes above such a cryostat would be so severe as to
render the determination of the weight of a test mass suspended only 1.5 cm above the
disk (and therefore only a few mm above a separating film covered with ice) virtually
impossible. This was an entirely unsatisfactory cryogenic design for the purpose.
Important issues such as how the disk was balanced, how it was prevented from
rupturing at high speeds, how much power was used to operate the coils, and what
means were employed to prevent the balance from being affected by the magnetic
fields from the coils were not addressed in the article. Nevertheless, the article caused
experimental ists around the world to try to duplicate the essence of the experiment,
generally in an overly simplified manner. All started out using the less costly LN2
approach with either fixed or rotating permanent magnets and small ( 2- to 3-cm
diameter) disks purchased commercially. Several researchers, including Gonnelli at
Turin Politecnico (Reference 24), Woods at the University of Sheffield (Reference 25),
and this author witnessed very sl ight apparent weight changes while the disk was
passing through its critical temperature, Tc. However, in most cases, the effect was so
close to the noise that further experimentation was not considered. At a private
unpublished meeting (see below) hosted by Professor R. Gonnelli at the Turin
Politecnico in April 1999, however, Podkletnov made it clear that unless the exact disk
formulation was followed, high-frequency magnetic fields were employed (not
~
5
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR. OFFI&I.t.k W&& &Ptklf
Page 10
UNCLASSIFIED//POll Offl@IAL YSlii &P•tlf
permanent magnets), and a larger disk was spun at lower temperatures, the shielding
effect would be extremely small.
The experiment has remained controversial since its publication. Very few scientists put
any stock into it at all. Most damning to Podkletnov's case was the complete lack of any
supporting evidence that the experiment had ever actually taken place.
As the Podkletnov article began to slowly circulate, Li and Torr published another article
(Reference 18) expanding on their earlier investigations in an attempt to outline the
physical mechanism underlying the production of a gravitomagnetic field inside a
superconductor. Basic to their consideration was an assumption of near-zero magnetic
permeability in the superconductor and the requirement of coherent alignment of lattice
ion spins in conjunction with a time-varying applied magnetic vector potential field.
With this understanding, they determined values for laboratory-scale induced internal
gravitomagnetic fields and external gravitoelectric fields and how these fields could be
maximized. However, in 1994 Kowitt (Reference 26) claimed that their 1992 and 1993
results were not credible owing to their assumption of near-zero permeability inside a
superconductor. However, Li and Torr rather effectively countered shortly thereafter,
and Woods (Reference 3) also called that criticism into question. Later, however, Harris
(Reference 27) argued in a more effective critique that Li and Torr's previous results
were erroneous because they assumed arbitrary (and extremely small) distances from
the lattice ion to the observer, thus producing unreasonably large effects. In fact, Harris
pointed out that the correct estimation of the induced gravitoelectric field outside a
superconductor is some 20 orders of magnitude smaller! No evident rebuttal has been
forthcoming from Li or Torr.
At about this time, Torr and Li parted company, although both continued to work in the
area. In 1995, Li was sufficiently convinced that she now had the answer to producing
an artificial gravity field that could be measured outside a superconductor that she
approached R. Kaczor at NASA to fund further development of her version of the
theory. By this time the Podkletnov paper had been "discovered," and a few forward
thinking NASA scientists determined that perhaps it was time to initiate some research
in the area. After all, now there was a peer-reviewed theoretical basis for a peer
reviewed experiment. Also at this time, this author and colleagues began preliminary
experiments in Toronto after contacting Podkletnov. Our approach was to attempt to
reproduce the 1992 Physica C spinning disk experiment with additional data from
Podkletnov but using a better cryogenic design with the possibility of mechanically
spinning the disk. This author and colleagues started manufacturing our own large
YBCO disks in house.
The following year, while still at the Tampere University of Technology's Institute for
Materials Science, Podkletnov and Vuorinen attempted to publish updated spinning disk
experiments in the British Journal of Physics D Applied Phys Vol. 29 (1996), but the
paper was withdrawn in a cloud of controversy. It was later published on the Internet
(Reference 28) under the authorship of Podkletnov and Levit and then Podkletnov
alone. Vuorinen and Levit had coauthored papers on ceramic processing with
Podkletnov previously. This new experiment involved a large AC levitated 27 -cm
diameter bi-layer sintered YBCO disk spun to 5,000 rpm using two-phase high
frequency radiofrequency (RF) "rotation" fields and allegedly showed gravitational
shielding in the few percent range. The cryostat design was somewhat better in that
there was considerably more shielding of the test mass from buoyancy and thermal
6
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOA OFFitl.t.k W&lii &P•kY
Page 11
UNCLASSIFIED//FOA OFFl€1Ak Wiili 0NLY
current effects. There was no independent confirmation that th is experiment actually
took place . Vuorinen and Levit had disappeared from the scene when this author asked
Podkletnov whether they were ava ilable to discuss the experiment. Nevertheless, this
author arranged for Podkletnov to visit the Toronto laboratory for preliminary
consultation on the experimental design to replicate his 1992 Physica C resu lts.
Meanwhile, a 1997 Un iversity of South Carolina press announcement declared that
investors were being sought fo r a "Gravity Generator" t echnology based on
confirmatory experiments apparently underway at the university involving nonrotating
high-temperature superconductors and RF co ils. Th is machine would "rep lace the
wheels of a car...lift and propel aircraft, drive generators more efficiently and produce
gravity-free environments on Earth." Evidently, the work of Douglas Torr, who had
recently taken up a post there, was the basis for the announcement. Unfortunately, the
excitement was short-lived, as a subsequent announcement was issued stating that the
previous announcement was " premature ."
In preliminary experiments at NASA, Kaczor, Li, et al. failed to see expected shielding
effect in a Podkletnov-li ke experiment (Reference 29). However, they were using a
small, commercially ava ilable disk levitated above permanent magnets at LN2
temperatures. Undeterred, they pressed on, buoyed by the Internet publication of
Podkletnov's previously rejected paper and discussions with Podkletnov himself. The
following year, Noever and Kaczor (Reference 30) published the results of their
investigations into nonrotating superconductor disks irradiated by radiofrequencies from
1 to 15 MHz and detected a very weak gravity increase. This finding was lat er shown by
the same authors to be t he likely result of an instru mentation artifact (Reference 31) .
In 1999, this author was asked to present the state of the Toronto experimental
replication to the assembled physicists and eng ineers at the April 1999 Turin Politecnico
meeting. Gonnell i and others presented their initial find ings of a tiny possible weight
change in test samples suspended above a disk as it passed through Tc. Also
presenting was G. Modanese, who had been formulating his own theoretical
explanations for the Podkletnov results. Podkletnov described how the "gravity
shielding" effect was discovered . Apparently his group had made large sputtering target
disks of YBCO for the aforementioned single-crystal processi ng, and to ensure t he
correct uniformity and porosity, the disk was set into rotation (presumably
mechanically) while being levitated over a "supporting solenoid." Th is allowed quick and
complete scanning of the target's surface by means of a sma ll , movable test magnet
suspended above the rotating disk and connected to an analytical chem ical ba lance.
When the smoke from a technician's pipe inexplicably appeared to rise above the
apparatus, they considered the possibil ity of gravitational shielding and subst ituted a
nonmagnetic, nonconducting test mass for the small suspended magnet. Note that the
normal rotational speeds for magnetron sputtering are in the tens, not thousands, of
rpm .
Podkletnov went on to describe his first experiments with the so-called high -voltage
"gravity beam" apparatus. An array of sing le-crystal wh iskers of YBCO was grown on a
small (few cm 2 in area) substrate using a technique later commercialized by materials
scientists (Professors Kettunen and Tiainen) at the Tampere University of Technology.
Th is plate was placed upright in a small LN2 dewar and electrically attached to a small
(~200-kilovolt) van de Graaff machine. A grounded metal annular disk was placed a
few centimeters laterally away. The whole assembly was placed in a large bell jar that
7
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOA QFFIEiIAL Y!H! 9HLY
Page 12
UNCLASSIFIED/ /POlt err1e1J1tt U.!I! er\tt I
was evacuated and back-filled with argon to prevent YBCO degradation by water vapor.
When the static machine was operated, a light blue planar "discharge" was seen to pass
from the superconductor array to the annulus. At this instant, a pencil standing upright
on a table in an adjoining room and separated from the experiment by a thick concrete
wall fell over.
Around this time, Koczor had raised some NASA funding to commission the commercial
fabrication of a 27-cm bi-layer disk conforming to Podkletnov and Levit's 1997
specifications. Podkletnov visited the Toronto laboratory for a second time to assess the
Previous: DOW-UAP-D130 — AAWSAP DIRD, Technological Approaches to Controlling External Devices, March 2010 · Next: DOW-UAP-D132 — AAWSAP DIRD, Advanced Space Propulsion Based on Vacuum (Spacetime Metric) Engineering, March 2010
Same topic: title & summary match
Same location: Las Vegas, Nevada
- DOW-UAP-D174 — Utah Ranch Investigation Report, April 2010
- DOW-UAP-D166 — MUFON Reports Prepared for BAASS, November 2008
- DOW-UAP-D168 — BAASS Project Management Plan, December 2008
- DOW-UAP-D169 — BAASS Monthly Report, March 2009
- DOW-UAP-D170 — BAASS Monthly Report, April 2009
- DOW-UAP-D171 — BAASS Monthly Report, June 2009
Same period: 2010
- DOW-UAP-D114 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00003, May 2010
- DOW-UAP-D113 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00002, February 2010
- DOW-UAP-D115 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00004, May 2010
- DOW-UAP-D116 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00005, September 2010
- DOW-UAP-D133 — AAWSAP DIRD, The Space Communication Implications of Quantum Entanglement and Nonlocality, March 2010
- DOW-UAP-D134 — AAWSAP DIRD, Maverick Inventor Versus Corporate Inventor: Where Will the Next Major Innovations Arise, March 2010
Same release: Release 06
- DOW-UAP-PR159 — Historical Film of Reported UFOs, Utah, 1952
- LLE-UAP-PR001 — Unresolved UAP Report, Colorado, 2023
- LLE-UAP-PR002 — Unresolved UAP Report, Colorado, October 2023
- DOW-UAP-PR133 — Unresolved UAP Report, Middle East, 2025
- DOW-UAP-PR135 — Unresolved UAP Report, Middle East, 2025
- DOW-UAP-PR140 — Unresolved UAP Report, Middle East, 2022
Same agency: DoW
- DOW-UAP-D094 — Analysis of Flying Object Incidents in the United States, 1949
- DOW-UAP-D097 — Project Sign Progress Report, 1948
- DOW-UAP-D084 — US Army-Flying-Saucer-Study 1949
- DOW-UAP-D155 — Air Intelligence Information Report, Saudi Arabia, 1957
- DOW-UAP-D176 — Triangular UAP AARO Memorandum for Record, 2026
- DOW-UAP-D177 — Unresolved UAP Report, Catalina Island, 1955