Home › Archive › DoW

DOW-UAP-D145 — AAWSAP DIRD, Aneutronic Fusion Propulsion I, November 2010

File DOW-UAP-D145 is a declassified pdf from Department of War, recording an incident dated 11/1/10 at Las Vegas, Nevada, published in Release 06 (2026-09-18). This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.

File
DOW-UAP-D145
Agency
Department of War
Incident date
11/1/10
Location
Las Vegas, Nevada
Released in
Release 06 (2026-09-18)
File type
PDF

Topics: AAWSAP & DIRDs

This document is a Defense Intelligence Reference Document (DIRD), a technical reference format used by the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) to capture baseline knowledge on a specific topic for later analytic use. DIRDs are best understood as reference and synthesis products rather than as original research. It is one of 38 DIRDs produced under the Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Applications Program (AAWSAP) between 2009 and 2011. Because AAWSAP’s scope permitted a broad range of supporting topics, not every DIRD in the series directly concerns aerospace systems or future threat assessment. The following summary reflects the DIRD’s scope and framing at the time of writing and should not be read as implying current validation of the concepts discussed.

This DIRD surveys aneutronic fusion as a possible advanced space-propulsion method, focusing on fusion reactions that release most of their energy in charged particles rather than neutrons and therefore offer potential advantages over more neutron-intensive fusion concepts, especially in radiation shielding, direct energy conversion, and thrust generation. The report reviews the underlying rocket physics, compares candidate fusion fuels and ignition conditions, and gives particular attention to proton-boron and related schemes, while also discussing Bussard’s concepts and other fusion projects as representative development paths. It also makes clear that the central obstacle remains ignition and sustained net-energy fusion under practical conditions, and it notes additional problems such as x-ray energy losses from the hot plasma, extreme temperature requirements, and the gap between theoretical specific impulse and what proposed systems had demonstrated experimentally. Overall, the document presents aneutronic fusion propulsion as an attractive long-range concept for deep-space travel, but one whose practical realization still depended on major unresolved advances in fusion engineering.

Open original file · WAR.GOV page

TL;DR

Even Vegas can't gamble on a fusion rocket that hasn't ignited.

  • DIRD D145, DoW, 11/1/10, Las Vegas, NV.
  • Surveys aneutronic fusion propulsion concepts and technical challenges.
  • No official conclusion in the file

AI summary

A classified Defense Intelligence Reference Document on aneutronic fusion propulsion, prepared by the Defense Warning Office's Technology Warning Division in November 2010. The document outlines nuclear fusion rocket designs, including aneutronic schemes, antimatter propulsion, and research needs for future space travel. It covers aneutronic fusion and antimatter propulsion, focusing on energy production, charged particles, and spacecraft design, with equations on rocket thrust, specific impulse, and the Tsiolkovsky rocket equation. The text discusses ion drives, photonic propulsion, radiation shielding, nuclear fission and fusion rocket designs, and various fusion propulsion methods. It includes discussions on aneutronic fusion schemes, antimatter propulsion, and speculative concepts like Heim graviphoton drives. The document analyzes mission types from LEO to interstellar distances and evaluates propulsion systems, including ion drives, nuclear thermal, and antimatter engines. It concludes with technical equations on relativistic rocketry and antimatter annihilation propulsion, mentioning CERN's research and speculative theories but no unidentified objects.

Full text

Page 3

UNCLASSIFIED/,'P81t 8ffl01ilrt YSE 8HLlf

Aneutronic Fusion Propulsion

The Defense Intelligence Reference Document provides nonsubstantive but
authoritative reference information related to intelli ence to ics or methodolo ies.

Prepared by:
Technology Warning Division (DW0-4)
Defense Warning Office
Directorate for Analysis
Defense Intelligence Agency
Author:

AAP Person 83

Administrative Notes:
(U) COPYRIGHT WARNING: Further dissemination of the photographs in this publication is not
authorized.
This product is one in a series of advanced technology reports produced in FY 2010 under the Defense
Intelligence Agency, Defense Warning Office's Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Applications....--.......
(AAWSA) Program. Comments or questions pertaining to this document should be addressed to (
· ---14A
-.E..! 'erson
Person 1
j AAWSA Program Manager, Defense Intelligence Agency, ATTN: JUIAF - DI/DWb- 3,i' •

IAAP

"'Bfclg 6000, Washington, DC 20340-5100.

UNCLASSIFIED//FQA QFFIGltliL W&& 9HL¥

Page 4

UNCLASSIFIED//POlt Offl@IAL WS& &NkY

Contents
Introduction ............................................................................................................v
Chapter 1: Theory ................................................................................................. 1
Rocket Propulsion .............................................................................................. 1
Comparison of Specific Impulse for Various Rocket Designs .............................. 5
Radiation Shielding ............................................................................................ 6
Subatomic Particle Mass, Velocity, and Energy .................................................. 9
Nuclear Fission Rockets .......................................................................................................................... 10
Chapter 2: Nuclear Fusion Rocket Design ............................................................ 13
Classic Nuclear Fusion Schemes ....................................................................... 13
Fusion Initiation Methods................................................................................. 14
Gravitational Confinement ............................................................................... 16
Magnetic Confinement Fusion (MCF) ................................................................ 16
Inertial Confinement Fusion (ICF) ................................................................... 16
Muon-Catalyzed Fusion .................................................................................... 17
Cavitation (Bubble) Fusion ............................................................................... 17
Rocket Design Using Fusion Energy ................................................................. 17
Chapter 3: Aneutronic Nuclear Fusion Schemes .................................................. 18
Chapter 4: Antimatter Propulsion ........................................................................ 20
Chapter 5: Aneutronic Fusion Propulsion Projects ............................................... 21
Nuclear Pulse Propulsion ................................................................................. 21
Other Aneutronic Rocket Designs ..................................................................... 22
Commercial Development....................................................................................22
Chapter 6: Speculation on Research Needs Over the Next 30 Years ..................... 25
Surface to Low-Earth Orbit (100 miles) .................................................................................................. 26
LEO to Mars (34 to 249 million miles) .............................................................. 27
ii

UNCLASSIFIED/fF&A &FFI&I:.l.k W&li &NkY

Page 5

UNCLASSIFIED//POR. Offl@IAL WSli Qptk\f
LEO to the Moons of Jupiter and Saturn (460 to 940 million miles) .................. 28
LEO to Alpha Centauri (4.22 light-years or 24.8 trillion miles) ......................... 28
Chapter 7: Conclusions ........................................................................................ 29
Appendix A: Relativistic Rockets ......................................................................... 30

Appendix B: Aneutronic Fusion Rocket ................................................................ 32
Appendix C: Antimatter Annihilation Rocket........................................................ 36
Appendix D: Relativistic Rocket Worksheet ......................................................... 38
Appendix E: Endnotes.......................................................................................... 41

Figures
Figure 1. Liquid-Fueled Chemical Rocket. ....................................................... vi
Figure 2. Mass Ratio Increases as Objects Approach Speed of Light .. .. .... .. ...... 2
Figure 3. Spherical Radiation Shield Surrounding Point Source ....................... 8
Figure 4. Nuclear Fission Rocket Design ........................................................ 11
Figure 5 . Schematic Design of a Magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) Generator ..... 13
Figure 6 . Nuclear Fusion of Deuterium and Tritium ....................................... 14
Figure 7. Low-Temperature Fusion Reactions ................................................ 15
Figure 8. Fusion Ignition Energies for D-T, D-D, and D-He3 ........................... 15
Figure 9 . Aneutronic Fusion Schemes ............................................................ 18
Figure 10. Fusion of Hydrogen-1 and Boron-11 Produces 3 Alpha Particles .. 19
Figure 11. QED Rocket Design ....................................................................... 23
Figure 12. Time Dilation at Relativistic Velocities .......................................... 31
Figure 13. Maximum Achievable Velocity Versus Fuel Usage ......................... 33
Figure 14. Acceleration and Rocket "Clock" Ratio Vs Mission Time on Earth .. 33
Figure 15. Spreadsheet for Sample Mission to Alpha Centauri........................34
Figure 16. Antihydrogen Atom........................................................................36

iii

UNCLASSIFIED/fF9A 9FFI&I:.l.k W&li Qptk\f

Page 7

UNCLASSIFIED//POlt Offl@IAL WS& 9Nk¥

Aneutronic Fusion Propulsion
Introduction
Space exploration is limited by existing propulsion technology. Up to now, chemical
rockets have been used to reach low-Earth orbit, the Moon, and the outer regions of the
solar system. Chemical rockets can use either solid or liquid fuel. Regardless of the
type of fuel, their design is similar to that shown in Figure 1. Oxygen is combined with
hydrogen or a hydrocarbon fuel in a combustion chamber where high temperatures and
pressures cause the exhaust to be ejected through a supersonic nozzle to provide
thrust to the rocket. The momentum of the fuel ejected through the nozzle provides
the force or thrust that accelerates the rocket forward.
There are many variations of chemical rockets, but they all suffer from the need to
carry copious amounts of fuel. Other methods have been proposed to decrease the
need to carry such a significant mass of fuel into space. Ion drives, for example, are
used to provide the very low thrust required to maintain satellites in Ea rth orbit. The
"fuel" that they carry is xenon gas accelerated by electric fields.
Nuclear fission propulsion has been proposed for space missions, and therma l nuclear
fission reactor rockets were constructed and tested at the Nevada Test Site through
Project Rover between 1956 and 1971. 1 I n these rockets, a nuclear reactor provides
heat to liquid hydrogen through nuclear fission and ejects the hydrogen gas through a
Laval nozzle to generate thrust. While these rockets must still carry hydrogen fuel as a
propellant, these rockets can provide more than twice the performance of chemical
rockets by using heat through fission rather than reactive chemicals. The results of the
72 reactor tests conducted under Project Rover were very promising and culminated in
the successful 12-minute test of the Phoebus-2A NERVA (Nuclear Engine for Rocket
Vehicle App lication) reactor that generated over 4 gigawatts of thermal power. One
problem associated with nuclear fission rockets is radioactive contaminants. These
contaminants in the exhaust make this technology impossible to use in launching
payloads from Earth. Additionally, for appl ications in space, radiation protection must
be provided for the crew by adding heavy shielding materials or by locating the crew as
far as possible from the reactor propulsion system.
Nuclear fusion, as opposed to fission, provides another potential propulsion technology.
In a fusion propulsion system, isotopes of light elements are fused together under
extreme conditions to form heavier elements, releasing large amounts of thermal
energy. This thermal energy can be used to heat liquid hydrogen to high temperatures
and expand it through a Laval nozzle to provide thrust in a manner similar to that
shown in Figure 1. Typically, isotopes of hydrogen and helium would be used in fusion
propulsion systems. Deuterium is an isotope of hydrogen and can be separated from
the hydrogen in water. Fusion reactions are difficult to initiate due to the high
temperatu res and pressures requ ired. Thermonuclear bombs, for example, combine a
fusion device with a nuclear fission bomb to provide the high temperatures required to
initiate the fusion reaction. Regardless of the conditions required to induce nuclear
fusion, the energy release is large. From propulsion standpoint, an advantage of fusion
over fission is that for a given amount of thrust, the fusion reaction requ ires less fuel
than either fission or chemical propulsion systems.
Fusion reactors using deuterium or tritium fuels are easiest to initiate; however, they
generate significant amounts of neutron radiation. This is a hazard for the crew on a
V

UNCLASSIFIED/fF9A 9FFI&I:.l.k W&li 9Nk¥

Page 8

UNCLASSIFIED//POR. Offl@IAI:: ~S& Qptk\f
space ship, and there is a high probability that neutrons produced by fusion reactors
would escape into space without providing much of their energy to a hydrogen
propellant. Other fusion reactions using isotopes of helium and lithium will generate
only charged particles, such as protons, that travel very short distances before giving
up all of their energy as heat. These "aneutronic fusion" reactions take place without
neutron production and decrease the need to carry large amounts of radiation shielding
material for the crew. The energy from charged particles generated by aneutronic
fusion can also be captured in conductive coils and converted directly into electricity.
Aneutronic fusion promises to be an important mechanism for future space propulsion,
although novel accelerator or laser systems must be researched and developed in order
to initiate, sustain, and control the fusion reaction.
Another futuristic method of spacecraft propulsion involves the use of antimatter.
Antimatter includes antiprotons, antineutrons, and positrons (anti-electrons). Although
this propulsion process may be the most efficient, antimatter has some drawbacks. For
example, antimatter is generated in only minute quantities at accelerator facilities
around the world. Although it has been captured and stored, containment remains a
problem . When antimatter combines with matter, it completely annihilates and
converts to energy, which then can be converted into heat for a propulsion system.
Antimatter reactions provide the greatest amount of energy per unit mass of any
potential fuel, but the ability to generate significant quantities of antihydrogen or
similar antimatter fuels at any accelerator facil ity is very limited.
The focus of this study is on aneutronic fusion propulsion. Integral to this study are the
topics of fuel, rocket design, and the organizations that research aneutronic fusion
development.

Uquld H,

LOX

I.Jwal-

Figure 1. Liquid-Fueled Chemical Rocket.

vi

UNCLASSIFIED/fF&A &FFI€il.t.k W&& Qptk\f

Page 9

UNCLASSIFIED//POlt Offl@IAL WS& &NkY

Chapter 1: Theory
ROCKET PRO PU LSION
It is difficult to compare propulsion technology without talking about how objects are
accelerated in space. Within Earth's atmosphere, aircraft use the air to generate lift
and thrust. Propellers or turbofans move a mass of air rearward and Newton's second
and third laws require that the momentum in this exhausted air is equal to a thrust in
the opposite direction. In equation form, the thrust, F, is equal and opposite to the
change in momentum over time.

Fm=- _ d(mv'
' / e.x.lrausr
dt

( 1.1)

The momentum of the exhausted air is equal to the mass of air times its velocity and is
provided by the propulsion system. The thrust can be used to accelerate a payload
according to the following equation:
w
m
F = m payload a

(1.2)

Here, thrust is equal to the payload mass times its acceleration.
This method of momentum transfer works well for aircraft operating within the Earth's
atmosphere; however, operating in space presents special problems. Space is nearly a
complete vacuum, and there is no air mass to accelerate, i.e., no "reaction mass" that
can be accelerated and exhausted at high speeds. In space, the reaction mass is
carried by the rocket in the form of propellant mass, which is expended as the rocket
accelerates.

m
m dm m
F = ma +-V
dt

(1.3)

In this equation, the thrust is provided by the momentum ejected from the rear of the
rocket, but the total mass of the rocket is decreasing as the fuel is burned up and as
propellant is lost. Examining equation 1.3, we see that there are two ways to increase
rocket thrust. The first is to increase the mass flowrate, dm/dt, typically measured in
kg/s (if mass flowrate is given in kg/s, then thrust, F, is given in newtons to maintain
consistency). Unfortunately, this requires carrying increasing quantities of fuel. For
flights to Mars, the outer planets, or to other star systems, it would not be possible to
carry such large quantities of propellant.
A second choice would be to increase V, i.e., the velocity of the ejected propellant
reaction mass. There is an upper limit, however, to how fast we can eject the propellant.
In his Special Theory of Relativity, Albert Einstein demonstrated that no object that has
any mass when at rest can be accelerated beyond the speed of light or 2. 998 x 10 8 m/s
in a vacuum. Einstein's relationship between an object's mass (m), its velocity (v), and
the speed of light, (c) is given in equation 1.4:

1

UNCLASSIFIED/fF&A &FFI&I:.l.k W&li &NkY

Page 10

UNCLASSIFIED//POlt Offl@IAL WS& &NkY

(1.4)
m=g

-

?

9

8
7

3

-

2

0.2

0.4

0.6

..---

/

I'

0.8

v/c
Figure 2. Mass Ratio (m/mo) Increases as Objects
Approach the Speed of Light.

Equation 1.4 is plotted in Figure 2; we see that as an object's velocity approaches light
speed its mass approaches infinity. Coupled with this, we see that as mass approaches
infinity, the energy required to move the mass also approaches infinity. Thus, it would
take an infinite amount of energy to accelerate an object to the speed of light.
Equations 1.2 and 1.3 indicate that the best propulsion system would use the least
amount of propellant but exhaust it at the highest possible velocity. Therefore, the
rocket engine that has the highest exhaust velocity requires that the rocket be the least
massive or carry the least amount of propellant. Unfortunately, this combination
corresponds to the minimum efficiency in terms of rocket power. The point here is that
for spacefl ight to anywhere other than near destinations, our present rocket technology
is insufficient.

2

UNCLASSIFIED/fF&A &FFI&I:.l.k W&li &NkY

Page 11

UNCLASSIFIED//POlt Offl@IAL WS& &NkY

Specific Impulse
To compare various propulsion systems and their fuel, rocket efficiency can be
represented by the amount of momentum that can be obtained per unit weight of the
propellant that is used. This is defined as the "specific impulse" (lsp ) and is measured
in units of seconds:

I

•,.,,

=

Li(m v • .,1w 11s,)

Li (ni g earth )

=

v ,x/11111 S/

(1.5)

g ea 1·1/t

Here, earth's gravitational acce leration, gearth, is 9.81 m/s 2 . As described earlier, the
best propulsion system is typically one that has the highest possible exhaust or
propellant velocity. High specific impulse, or correspondingly high exhaust velocity,
also produces low energy efficiency.
Table 1: Specific Impulse for Various Rocket Engine Types
En<1ine Tvpe

Ve (m/s)

Isa (s)

4 130

421

Solid Rocket

2, 500

255

Best Chemical Rocket Tested

5 320

542

Nuclear Therm al Rocket

8 340

850

Ion Thruster

29 000

3 000

VASIMR

290,000

30,000

Saturn V Rocket 2nd and 3rd Staqes
LH 2/LOX Liquid Fuel

F2/Li/H2 Chem ica l Rocket

The efficiency of a rocket can be defined as the ratio of rocket thrust to the power
required to generate the thrust. The resulting equations follow:

½(dm)
V
dt

Power = dE =
dt
2
Thrust =

2

e

(dm)
V
dt
'

3

UNCLASSIFIED/fF&A &FFI&I:.l.k W&li &NkY

(1.6)

(1.7)

Page 12

UNCLASSIFIED//POlt Offl@IAL WS& &NkY

r, = ( Thrust) = ]_

(1.8)

Ve

Power

In choosing a rocket engine, as the specific impulse (Isp ) or the exhaust velocity (Ve)
increase, the corresponding efficiency (TJ) decreases. The specific impulse for various
fuels varies widely as shown in Table 1. 2, 3

Tsiolkovsky Rocket Equation
For a spaceflight to Mars or other body, the exhaust velocity affects the time of flight
and the amount of fuel that is needed to change the velocity of the spacecraft. The
change in velocity (t-.V) can be expressed in terms of the initial mass of the rocket
(m ;n;t1a1, rocket+ propellant) and the final total rocket mass (m t;na1 rocket only):

~ V =V

exhaust

In (minilia/)

(1.9)

mfinal

The mass of propellant used to generate thrust is given by :
mpropellanr

= minirial - mfinal

(1.10)

(1.11)

m

- m

fina l -

~ V = g J [In [
O

sp

e~V / Vt'.r:lr ,rns r

(1.12)

'initia l

m i11i1ial]-

..!_

m fi11a/

R

(1 _m

fina l

J]

(1.13)

mi11irial

(1.14)

In these equations, R is the thrust-to-weight ratio and t is the t ime required for an
engine burn to produce a desired t-.V. These are the standard equations used for rocket
engine performance.

4

UNCLASSIFIED/fF&A &FFI&I:.l.k W&li &NkY

Page 13

UNCLASSIFIED//POlt Offl@IAL WS& &NkY
COMPARISON OF SPECIFIC IMPULSE FOR VARIOUS ROCKET
DESIGNS

Chemical Rockets
Chemical rockets burn solid or liquid propellant. The exhaust gas exits the rocket
through a Laval nozzle and generates thrust. Figure 1 provided the outline of a liquid­
fueled rocket using liquid hydrogen as the fuel and liquid oxygen (LOX) to combust the
fuel. Unlike turbofan and RAM engines, rockets are not airbreathing and must carry
their own oxidizer.
The Laval nozzle is a principle component of chemical rockets; its design is based on
compressible fluid flow theory. 4 In general, the nozzle is made up of contoured
convergent-divergent cross sections. Conical cross sections are also sometimes used .
Its purpose is to transform pressure energy into kinetic energy. Nuclear fusion rockets
may also make use of Laval nozzles by heating up a liquid propellant and ejecting it as
a supersonic gas. In subsonic flow, fluid can only be accelerated by decreasing the
cross-sectional area of the duct section t hat it is traveling through, as in a Venturi tube.
Once the velocity in a fluid reaches the speed of sound (Mach 1), the fluid can continue
to accelerate only if it is expanded. The Laval nozzle combines a converging section
where the flow is subsonic, a throat where the flow is accelerated to sonic speed (Mach
1), and a diverging cone where the flow is accelerated to supersonic speed. The
performance of a rocket is based on its thrust, where T = (dm/dt) x Vexhaust, and by
maximizing the exit velocity, the thrust reaches a maximum. The pressure of the
combusting gases in the combustion chamber directly affect the amount of thrust that
the rocket can achieve.
Whether a rocket is propelled by gases from combusting propellant or by gases heated
through a nuclear fission or fusion reaction, two equations determine the thrust of the
Laval nozzle. The maximum mass flow rate through the nozzle can be computed in
terms of the nozzle area (Athroat) the combustion or heated gas pressure (po), and the
heated gas temperature (To).

mJ

(d
dt

= Po ~hroa t

_
mu1m11m

'T

(1.15)

--..Jl. o

Vexhaust --

(1.16)

In these equations, R is the gas constant of the propellant gas and y is a
thermodynamic property of the gas called the ratio of specific heats. These equations
make it possible to compute the maximum thrust generated by a propellant gas
through a Laval nozzle based on the pressure and temperature of the gas in the
combustion chamber or heating tank.

5

UNCLASSIFIED/fF&A &FFI&I:.l.k W&li &NkY

Page 14

UNCLASSIFIED//POlt Offl@IAL HS& QptkY

Ion Drives
Ion thruster electrical propulsion provides a convenient and efficient method of
generating thrust. A gas that is easily ionized, such as xenon, is carried onboard as a
propellant. The voltage difference between an electrode and a metal screen accelerates
xenon ions toward the screen and out the back of the spacecraft, generating thrust.
The specific impulse of this kind of drive is about 3,000 seconds. It is relatively
common for satellites to use ion drives, generating minute forces measured in
millinewtons, to maintain orbit. Solar energy and radioactive decay are possible
sources of electric power for satellites in Earth orbit. In deep space, fusion or fission
reactors could provide electrical power. However, once the xenon propellant has been
expended, the ion drive is no longer useful.
Ion drives include the VASIMR (Variable Specific Impulse Magnetoplasma Rocket)
designed by the Ad Astra Rocket Company in Webster, Texas. This system uses two RF
radiowave antennae to couple energy into an ionized gas that is used for propulsion in
space. While ion drives are often used to help maintain orbit for satellites circling the
Earth, the VASIMR technology has been proposed for use in moving payloads
throughout the solar system. The specific impulse for this technology is cited as 5,000
seconds compared to ~3,300 seconds for typical ion drives. 5

Photonic Propulsion
Photons of visible light, infrared radiation, or x-rays can produce thrust through
momentum transfer, where the momentum of each photon is given by p = h/A (h =
Planck's constant, A = radiation wavelength). Photonic propulsion has been explored by
Y. K. Bae Corporation (http://www.ykbcorp.com ) who holds a patent on a photonic
laser thruster. These drives generate no contaminants and require a source of
electricity to produce photons. Their photonic laser thruster (PLT) uses an active
resonant optical cavity formed between two mirrors on a pair of spacecraft to generate
thrust. Photonic drives would be viable on fusion or fission -powered spacecraft if their
power output were used to generate electrical power that could provide light.

RADIATION SHIELDING
Radiation shielding will be important for astronauts traveling to the Moon, to the other
planets, and to other star systems. Radioactive particles and cosmic rays left over from
the big bang, radiation from supernovae, x-ray emissions from black holes, and a
constant flux of energetic protons from our own sun all contribute to the radiation dose
received by humans in space.
Radiation levels are typically measured in sieverts (Sv), expressing the amount of
energy deposited in human tissue from radiation. One sievert is equivalent to 1 joule of
energy absorbed for every kilogram of tissue. 6 • 7 An older unit, the rem (Roentgen
equivalent, man) is still in common use: 1 rem = 0.01 Sv. Sieverts are now the
international standard unit.

6

UNCLASSIFIED/fF&A 9FFI€il.t.k Y&li QptkY

Page 15

UNCLASSIFIED//POlt Offl@IAI:: HS& 8Ptk¥
The energy absorbed is strong ly related t o the amount of radiation damage done to the
tissue. On Earth, the magnetic field of the planet helps to shield people from most of
the effects of radiation from the sun, but cosmic radiation and terrestrial sources of
radiation (granite, potassium, radon gas) all contribute to an annual background dose
that everyone receives. The average annual dose of radiation in the United States is
about 2.5 mSv from background and another 1.0 mSv from other source, such as
dental x-rays, commercia l jet flights, and rad iopha rmaceuticals. The total annual dose
in the United States is approximately 3.5 mSv (millisieverts) per person.
In space, away from the protection of the Earth's magnetic field, the radiation dose
increases substantially to about 250 mSv per year. The radiation dose in space is
continuous, and the effects of being in space for extended periods of time may be
cumu lative. As a comparison, 2,000 mSv of rad iation in an acute dose can cause
significant medica l problems and 5,000 mSv is usually fata l. Leukemia and other forms
of cancer are possible for people exposed to chronic doses of radiation at the levels
encou ntered in space.
The logical conclusion wou ld be to carry radiation shielding into space to protect the
astronauts. The problem is that shielding is typica lly heavy and expensive. Four types
of radiation must be shielded:
1. Gamma Rays (y)
These are energetic forms of electromagnetic radiation (photons) and tend to
penetrate most materials. High -density metals, such as iron, lead, and
uranium are usually used to shield gamma rays.
2. Beta Particles (~ +, W)
These are electrons or positrons, the antimatter counterpart to electrons.
They are emitted by the radioactive decay of certain isotopes and through
nuclear fission. Because these are charged particles, they are fa irly easy to
stop with minimal sh ield ing.
3. Neutrons (n)
These uncharged particles are generated by nuclear fission and fusion. They
may penetrate metals, yet they can be slowed down until they decay in light
Typical shielding mat erial
materials that contain hydrogen or carbon.
includes water, paraffin wax, and po lyethylene blocks.
4 . Heavy Charged Particles (p, a)
Ions are atoms that have one or more of t heir electrons stripped from thei r
outer orbital. Due to their positive electric charge, ions are generally easy to
stop with in any kind of material, unless the ions are very energetic. Typica l
ions include protons, which are ionized hydrogen atoms, and alpha particles,
Cosmic radiation includes heavy ions
which are ionized helium nuclei.
emitted by explod ing supernovae and may include ions as heavy as iron
nuclei at extremely high energy.
7

UNCLASSIFIED/fFOA OFFI&I:.l.k W&& ONk¥

Page 16

UNCLASSIFIED//POR. Offl@IAI:: ~S& Qptk\f

Long-duration spaceflights will require copious amounts of water for the crew, and
water can be used to provide some shielding from neutrons for the astronauts.
Shielding material for gamma rays presents a weight problem. Lead is one of the best
shielding materials for gamma, but at a cost of about $10,000/lb to launch material into
space, lead shielding is expensive to use.
The International Space Station and other spacecra~ designed for long-term human
habitation usually have a small area that is heavily shielded to prevent excessive
radiation exposure to the crew during solar events.
In addition to the dangers of natural sources of radiation in space that can endanger
human health and safety, the propulsion techniques of nuclear fusion and fission
generate large fluxes of radiation. Neutron production is of special concern because
neutrons can penetrate metals and the structural material of space habitats.
The general equations that govern radiation shielding can help develop spacecraft
designs that will minimize radiation exposure. The intensity of gamma rays will
attenuate according to the following equation:
- µI'
A..()-A..
r - 'f-'i11irial e

'f-'

( 1.17)

In equation 1.17, the flux of gamma rays or neutrons, given in particles per unit area
per unit time, is represented by <P(r); ¢ 1n1t1a1 represents the initial flux without the
shielding; and µ is the linear attenuation coefficient, a function of the gamma ray or
neutron energy and the type of shielding material. The thickness of the material is
represented by r.
The radiation flux decreases with distance since photons or
radioactive particles typically expand outward through a spherical area of 4rcr2 as shown
in Figure 3. Equation 1.18 shows the relationship between total attenuation, particle
flux, and radiation exposure.

Figure 3. Spherical Radiation Shield Surrounding a Point Source.

8

UNCLASSIFIED/fF&A &FFI€il.t.k W&& Qptk\f

Page 17

UNCLASSIFIED//POR. Offl@IAI:: ~S& Qptk\f

e- p r

¢ (r) = </J; , , ; ,4; , , 12- B(µ r)
Tr r

(1.18)

The radiation flux is inversely proportional to the square of the distance from a point
source of radiation, such as a nuclear rocket engine. It also decreases through any
intervening radiation shielding material. The last term in equation 1.18, B(µr), is called
the "buildup factor"; it represents the process of reradiation following atomic collision
with shield ing material, thus contributing to the tota l radiation dose. This secondary
radiation is a problem for all spacecraft since cosmic radiation impacting the spacecraft
structural material can produce a cascade of secondary particles t hat can irradiate the
crew .
A standard technique to decrease the radiation exposure to the crew on a spacecraft
using nuclear fusion as an energy source will be to locate the crew as far away from the
engine as possible and place as much liquid hydrogen or other light shielding material
between the crew and the engine as designs allow. A simpler solution would be to use
nuclear fusion schemes that do not generate neutrons. These are the so -called
"aneutronic fusion" propulsion techniques.

SUBATOMIC PARTICLE MASS, VELOCITY, AND ENERGY
Atoms are composed of a small nucleus containing neutrons and protons, along with
electrons orbiting the nucleus in shells. The atomic number (Z) is equivalent to the

Text continues in the original file (50 pages).

Previous: DOW-UAP-D144 — AAWSAP DIRD, Cockpits in the Era of Breakthrough Flight, November 2010 · Next: DOW-UAP-D146 — AAWSAP DIRD, Aneutronic Fusion Propulsion II, November 2010

Same topic: title & summary match

Same location: Las Vegas, Nevada

Same period: 2010

Same release: Release 06

Same agency: DoW