DOW-UAP-D124 — AAWSAP DIRD, Space Access: Where We’ve Been and Where We Could Go, March 2010
File DOW-UAP-D124 is a declassified pdf from Department of War, recording an incident dated 3/8/10 at Las Vegas, Nevada, published in Release 06 (2026-09-18). This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.
- File
- DOW-UAP-D124
- Agency
- Department of War
- Incident date
- 3/8/10
- Location
- Las Vegas, Nevada
- Released in
- Release 06 (2026-09-18)
- File type
Topics: AAWSAP & DIRDs
This document is a Defense Intelligence Reference Document (DIRD), a technical reference format used by the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) to capture baseline knowledge on a specific topic for later analytic use. DIRDs are best understood as reference and synthesis products rather than as original research. It is one of 38 DIRDs produced under the Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Applications Program (AAWSAP) between 2009 and 2011. Because AAWSAP’s scope permitted a broad range of supporting topics, not every DIRD in the series directly concerns aerospace systems or future threat assessment. The following summary reflects the DIRD’s scope and framing at the time of writing and should not be read as implying current validation of the concepts discussed.
This DIRD is a historical and conceptual survey of space access systems, contending that the main barrier to routine access to space is a failure to build durable, reliable, operational hardware and the supporting infrastructure needed for regular service to and from low Earth orbit. The report reviews earlier launch and aerospace concepts, especially reusable and aircraft-like approaches, and suggests that U.S. space access development became too strongly centered on expendable rockets derived from ballistic missiles rather than bespoke systems designed for repeated space access and payload delivery. Its central claim is that meaningful future progress will depend on creating a purpose-built space transportation infrastructure, including frequent round-trip capability and orbital support networks, rather than continuing to rely on one-off launch vehicles. Overall, the document presents a forceful case for infrastructure-first space development, though its characterization of past technological choices is more assertive than a fully neutral account of past U.S. space programming.
Open original file · WAR.GOV page
TL;DR
Even Vegas couldn’t gamble on one-off rockets, according to the 2010 report.
- DIRD pdf by DoW, March 2010, incident 3/8/10, Las Vegas, NV
- Survey of space-access history, emphasizing reusable hardware, infrastructure over expendable rockets
- No official conclusion in the file
AI summary
A 2010 unclassified report titled "Space Access: Where We've Been and Where We Could Go," prepared by the Defense Intelligence Agency's Acquisition Support Division, outlines historical and technical aspects of space access, including propulsion, hypersonic configurations, and materials. It covers space access strategies, historical U.S. space programs, and hypersonic glider configurations, mentioning the Saturn I and V, X-15, and NASP. The document discusses hypersonic glider and air-breathing propulsion configurations, vehicle designs, aerodynamics, and stability issues, referencing specific models like FDL-8 and X-24A. It includes technical data, equations, and figures from the 1960s and 1980s, comparing spacecraft design parameters and thermal protection systems. The text references UAP-related concepts like FDL-7C and MRS family configurations, heat transfer tests on a McDonnell Douglas Model 176 hypersonic vehicle, and a "Qu tube" with exceptional thermal conductivity. It also covers space access concepts, including LACE and KUN cycles, rocket and air-breathing systems, and historical aerospace vehicles, mentioning Russian aerospace cooperation and launch vehicle designs. The report includes early space vehicle designs, historical projects like the McDonnell Douglas TAV and NASP study, and unclassified UAP-related historical space access documents from March 2010, referencing reports from 1964 and 1965 about space stations, spacecraft, and propulsion systems.
Full text
Page 1
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFPICIAL USE ONLT
Defense
SSE Intelligence
DEEEE .
Reference
Document
Acquisition Threat Support
8 March 2010
ICOD: 1 December 2009
DIA-08-1001-006
Space Access: Where We've
Been . . . and Where We Could
Go
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Page 2
UNCLASSIFIED//FQA QFFl61alil l!ISI!! 91ft I
Space Access: Where We've Been . . . and Where We Could
Go
Prepared by:
Acquisition Support Division (DW0-3)
Defense Warning Office
D irectorate for Analysis
Defense Intelligence Agency
Author:
AAP Person 67
Administrative Note
COPYRIGHT WARNING : Further disseminat ion of the photographs in t his publicat ion is not aut horized.
This product is one in a series of advanced technology reports produced in FY 2009
under the Defense Intelligence Agency, Defense Warning Office's Advanced Aerospace
Weapon System Applications (AAWSA) Program. Comments or questions pertaining to
this document should be addressed tolAAP Person 1
I, AAWSA Program
Manager, Defense Intelligence Agency, ATTN: CLAR/DW0- 3, Bldg 6000, Washington,
DC 20340-5100 .
ii
UNCLASSIFIED//FQA QFFICl1'1k W&li 8HLY
Page 3
UNCLASSIFIED/;'FOR OFFI@IAL l:ISE OHL¥
Contents
Introduction ............................................................................................................v
Propulsion Perspective ........................................................................................... 1
Hypersonic Configuration Concepts ........................................................................ 2
Thermodynamics and Materials ............................................................................ 16
The Qu Tube ......................................................................................................... 23
Rocket Propulsion ................................................................................................ 25
Up-and-Down Operations ..................................................................................... 30
Launch Options .................................................................................................... 33
Atmospheric Variations ........................................................................................ 35
Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 37
Appendix A: Historical Perspective ....................................................................... 43
Appendix B: Aeropropulsion Integrated Vehicle ................................................... 46
Appendix C: TAV Operational Costs ............. ......................................................... 47
Appendix D: Landing Ellipses for Hypersonic Gliders ........ .. .................................. 48
Figures
Figure 1. Hardware Flow ........... .. ...........................................................................vi
Figure 2. Impact of Air-Breathing Rocket ................................................................1
Figure 3. HSVS Hypersonic Cruise Aircraft Showing True Skin Temperature ........... 3
Figure 4. Hypersonic Rocket- Powered Glider Hypersonic Air- Breathing Cruiser ......4
Figure 5. Delta-Lifting Body Designs .......................................................................5
Figure 6. Martin Marietta X-24 A & B Research Gliders ............................................7
Figure 7. Detailed Design Analyses Show the Weight Trends are as Much a
Function of Configuration Family as Lift-to-Drag Ratio ............................9
Figure 8. High-Performance Hypersonic Glide Aircraft .......................................... 10
Figure 9. NASA Langley Wing-Body Configuration WB-004 with Critical Areas for
Wing Bodies Identified ...........................................................................11
Figure 10. FDL-7C/D and FDL-7MC Lifting-Body Configuration .............................. 12
Figure 11. FDL-7C/D with a DuPont Retractable Inward-Turning Inlet ................. 12
Figure 12. Comparison of FDL-7C/D and Model 176 .............................................. 13
Figure 13. Sufficient Cross Range (L/D) Means There is No Waiting to Return ..... 14
Figure 14. Hypersonic Glider Characteristics .........................................................15
Figure 15. Both Delta Planform Lifting Body (Dynasoar) and Model 176 Offer
Superior Landing Performance .............................................................16
Figure 16. McDonnell Aircraft Company Roll-Bonded Titanium Structure .............. 17
iii
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFICIO! 11 55 ON! X
Page 4
UNCLASSIFIED/ /POI': OPPIEIJct t:191! BHL'f
Figure 17. Model 176 in the McDonnell Douglas Hypervelocity Impulse Tunnel .... 18
Figure 18. FDL-7C/D, Model 176 Entry Temperature Distribution ......................... 19
Figure 19. Even At Mach 12, Embedded Vortices in the Boundary Layer Alter the
Local Heat Transfer ..............................................................................19
Figure 20. Thermographic Phosphor Image of Model 176 at Near-Maximum
Angle of Attack .....................................................................................20
Figure 21. From L/D Maximum to Maximum Angle of Attack, There Is Always a
Cool Sub-layer Adjacent to the Wall .....................................................20
Figure 22. This 1988 SEP Bordeaux SiC/SiC Panel Could Sustain Temperatures of
up to 3,000°F ........................................................................................21
Figure 23. UBE Corporation's Tyranno Cloth ..........................................................21
Figure 24. A Porous Nickel Tip Oozing Water ........................................................21
Figure 25. FDL ASSET Flight-Tested From Orbital Speeds to Evaluate 1960s
Materials ..............................................................................................22
Figure 26. Heat Pipe Shuttle Leading Edge Designed and Built by McDonnell
Douglas Astronautics ...........................................................................22
Figure 27. Boost-Glide Strategic Vehicle with Pratt & Whitney XLR-129 Rocket
Engine Installed ...................................................................................25
Figure 28. XLR-129 ...............................................................................................25
Figure 29. Two Rocket Air-Breathing Rocket Cycles to Mach 5.5 ........................... 27
Figure 30. HOTOL Evolution: From Aerodynamic Optimum Configuration to
Practical Launcher Configuration .........................................................27
Figure 31. LACE Air-Breathing Rocket ...................................................................29
Figure 32. The FDL-7 Class of Vehicles ..................................................................29
Figure 33. Takeoff and Landing Speeds of Minimum-Sized Launchers ...................30
Figure 34. Horizontal launch Not Practical Unless Weight Ratio Less Than Four ... 31
Figure 35. Propellant Tanks That Are Not Reentry Vehicles Greatly Reduce
System Weight .....................................................................................33
Figure 36. Simple Horizontal Integration and Vertical Launch Provides Rapid
Launch Capability .................................................................................34
Figure 37. A Vertical Launch Complex Provides Vertical Toss Back Booster
Recovery and Horizontal Landing Facilities for the Hypersonic Gliders 34
Figure 38. A 1964 MDC Astronautics, St. Louis, Briefing ........................................35
Figure 39. Earth's Atmosphere ..............................................................................36
Figure 40. FDL-5 Scale Model of A Stage and One-Half..........................................37
Figure 41. The FDL-7 and Model 176 Class of Hypersonic Gliders ..........................37
Figure 42. Hypersonic Decelerating .......................................................................38
Figure 43. Where We Are Today ............................................................................39
Figure 44. Where We Could Be If We Can Recapture the Engineering Confidence
and Expertise of the Apollo/Saturn V Era .............................................40
Figure 45. TAV Operational Costs ..........................................................................47
Figure 46. Landing Ellipse .....................................................................................48
Tables
Table 1. Characteristics of Selected Flight Dynamics Laboratory Hypersonic
Glider Configurations During the 1958-68 Timeframe ...............................6
Table 2. Elements of the Space Infrastructure Shown in Figure 44 .......................41
iv
UNCLASSIFIED/ ;CfOR. OFFI&IAI: W&li &Ptklf
Page 5
UNCLASSIFIED/ fFOR OFFIE!IAL l::l!H! 8HL'I
Space Access: Where We've Been . . . and Where We Could
Go
Introduction
Development of commercial access to space by our budding space
faring civilization is a straightforward effort dominated by
propulsion and reliability. The initial focus should be on schedulable,
dependable access to and from low Earth orbit (LEO). For years we
have known the means to accomplish such a task but have lacked a
dedicated organized effort. The key requirement is to develop a
robust and not necessarily a low-cost infrastructure, without which
commercial exploitation of LEO and the moon will not be possible.
This is a matter of skill; operational hardware based on durable,
reliable, and demonstrated components; and operational systems. It
is not necessarily a matter of technology. However, technology
discovery and development are necessary for future space travel
beyond Earth's environs. This paper addresses these issues by
providing a running account of the historical details associated with
the development of the myriad systems proposed and tested to
provide access to space.
Among the many advances in space access that will be possible in
the future,1 the key technology developments will be in the area of
propulsion, because without these we are confined to our solar
system by flight times limited to a project team's functional life. The
Pioneer spacecraft were fortunate to be monitored for 20 years.
However, the issue facing our spaceflight organizations is the lack of
a durable, consistent, schedulable, and frequent hardware system to
and from space assets such as the International Space Station.
In October 1958, the author's job in the vertical wind tunnel at
Wright-Patterson Air Force Base abruptly changed; hypersonic and
high-temperature flows became a new focus. What was then the
Aircraft Laboratory was to become the Air Force Flight Dynamics
Laboratory (AFFDL), with a focus on space flight. Al Draper of the
AFFDL began working with a select group of aerospace firms on
hypersonic gliders. The initial requirement from the Air Force was to
quickly find operational access to space. Technology application,
hardware design and fabrication with an innovative application, and
extending the industrial capabilities of the time were very much the
issue, as exemplified by the Lockheed A-12/SR-71. When asked
about space access at the time, a group of Aerospace Corporation
V
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR. OFFICI CIs. flili Qllls.¥
Page 6
UNCLASSIFIED/ ,«POil Offl@IAL YSli QPU,¥
veterans responded, "It was not a technology issue; it was a
hardware issue."
In a keynote address to the Aeronautical Revolutionary Concepts
Workshop sponsored by the Vehicle Applications Panel of the
National Research Council and held at NASA Ames in July 1984,
then-Assistant Secretary of Commerce for Productivity, Technology,
and Innovation Dr. D. Bruce Merrifield identified the problem of
translating ideas into products as preparing technology for product
manufacture. Dr. Merrifield drew an analogy between this step and
Major League Baseball's farm system, which prepares skilled but
untrained players for the major leagues. The United States assigns
projects to accomplish technology tasks so the flow of production
ready hardware is always improving and is not fixed (see Figure 1).
Innovation Focus:
Preparation of Technology for Application
---r- - - - - 7 t o 1 0 y e a r s - - - - - ~ 1
- - - - - - ~ - •"-""••"_,
_ ,__
...;;.;.:,
.....:..,----,....-=----_-_-_ , - - -...,..
_.. --"'"'-"..........,
....
__ __
·····•..
Idea
Generation___., .__
._
__,
PrOCluct
Develooment
lnve~n
··•.
Translation
••······· ·····•• ..................... ...•• •·
100/o Cost
Gap in effective
preparation for
application
in United States
1983 Innovation In Aeronautics
Wortcshop, NASA AMES
.............
,••·
Prototype
and Pilot
Plant
I
lntenm
Manufacture
+
..
Commercialization ·.
··•....
ROLP
900/o Cost
' •,
• .................. ................• 1:i:t· f A••
No Gap in
transformation
to production
Or.O. Bruce Merrifield
Oeptment of Commerce
Assistant Secretary for Productiv ity,
Technology and Innovation
Figure 1. Hardware Flow
Saturn I and Saturn V could be readied for a moon flight in such a
short time because most of their hardware was based on a frozen
design, proven production processes, and adaptation of existing
hardware. Using a similar approach, current industrial capabilities
can create the next practical system for accessing space. In the late
1950s and early 1960s, the U.S. Air Force was working toward an
operational capability analogous to its B-52 fleets: flight operations
when required or "on demand." After NASA was assigned
vi
UNCLASSIFIED/ /iOA: OiilCIOls. n&li Qfslls.¥
Page 7
UNCLASSIFIED/ /Pelt err1e1J11t l:191!!! 9HL'I
responsibility for space access, that Air Force's focus switched to
surveillance, communication, and Global Positioning System
satellites.
In the late 1950s, there existed a predisposition-forced by the
military competition between the United States and the former
Soviet Union-to use rockets derived from military ballistic missiles.
That decision curtailed efforts to develop alternatives to chemical
rockets together with practical commercial developments. With the
orbiting of Sputnik, the aircraft path to space, as represented by the
X series of planes, ended with the X-15. With the X-15's demise, all
efforts to fly aircraft to space ended, replaced by the more familiar
(but less practical) strategy of loudly blasting to space with
expendable rockets derived from undertested ballistic missile
hardware, as documented in early failures.
Like their ballistic missile progenitors, current expendable rockets
can be launched only once. With the exception of the experimental
Delta Clipper developed and operated by William Gaubatz and the
late Pete Conrad, no operational launcher has ever successfully
aborted. In this context, a reusable launcher is simply an
expendable with some parts reused a few times. Thus, neither the
United States nor the Soviet Union/Russia has ever realized a truly
commercial approach to space travel, although the Soviets came
close to taking the first step with the since-terminated
Energia/Buran system. Both the United States and the Soviet
Union/Russia historically have generated a large number of concepts
that could fly directly to space and return on a sustained, frequent,
scheduled basis. An all-up air breather such as the NASP was to
solve that problem and fly directly to space and return. Developing
an operational mach 12 to 14 aircraft with air-breathing propulsion
presents a serious design, engineering, and fabrication challenge
analogous to the SR-71 Blackbird.
vii
UNCLASSIFIED/ ,,roA 8FFI&IAk WSE 8HLY
Page 8
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR: 9FFl@IAL WIiii QPIL¥
Propulsion Perspective
In exiting Earth's atmosphere, the propulsion system and configuration are inexorably
linked. A hypersonic glider exits the atmosphere on either a rocket booster or a first
stage of a two-stage-to-orbit aircraft. As such, it usually exits the atmosphere quickly,
and the key exit design considerations are the high transonic aerodynamic and the
mechanical loads encountered in the exit trajectory. Whether for a new rocket launcher
or the U.S. space shuttle, the phenomenon is the same: the peak mechanical loads
occur during exit. In this case, the exit aerodynamics are important but not vital. The
vital aerodynam ics and thermodynamics (aerothermodynamics) are in the entry glide,
where thermal loads are maximal and must be controlled. The vehicle must always be
controlled in flight so its attitude and direction are within limits set by the
aerothermodynamics. The angle-of-attack limits are very close for high-performance
hypersonic gliders, as their glide angle of attack is 11 to 15 degrees, not the 45 degrees
of the space shuttle. Even the Russian Buran had a lower glide angle of attack than the
shuttle; a TsAGI report given to the author by Vladimir Neyland shows it to have been
about 30 to 35 degrees. 2 Like the Buran, the high-performance glider is best controlled
by an automatic integrated fl ight control system that monitors the thermodynamic state
of the vehicle, as well as its aerodynamic and trajectory states. The sensor array
provides real-time information to the control system that can maintain the correct
attitude in a manner a human controller could not accompl ish. So it is this phase of the
flight that designs the hypersonic glider.
All
The exception is when powered by an
Rocket
air-breathing rocket (HOTOL, Skylon,
LAC E
Rooket
and LACE), which must remain lower in
the atmosphere until reaching the air
Aero Spike
Konst anbn FeotkIskov
breathing rocket transition to
conventional rocket. The configuration
for the air-breathing rocket is different,
as it must have a retractable air inlet in
the mach O to 5 range but does not
..._Under expanded
determine the vehicle configuration.
·,
The impact is significant, as the carried
Over expand'e<I
oxidizer is reduced in the heaviest initial
portion of the flight, as shown in Figure
5. 35 ton payload
2 for a Delta Clipper-type design with
334 ton
101 ton
TOGW
28.6 ton
15.9 ton
DEW
an aerospike nozzle tested by
678 m2
428 m2
Konstantin Feotkiskov. The example is
from a Senior Capstone Design Study
Figure 2. Impact of Air-Breathing Rocket
Team from Parks College, Saint Lou is
University, circa 1992, and is based on the engineering reports the author was
permitted to read from the library of Konstantin Feotkiskov, an aerospace designer and
cosmonaut. The question, as always, is, why bother with air-breathing systems at all if
they are that much of a challenge? The answer is to consider a partial air-breathing
system based on available hydrogen/oxygen rockets that operate to about mach S.S . It
operates in a flight region where the carried oxidizer quantities are the greatest. An
operational system is sought that is capable of a large number of fl ights per year. The
fewer resources required for launch, the greater ease with which the system can
operate and the greater potential to operate from more bases .
1
UNCLASSIFIED/ ,erQA QFFI&il.t.k WIiii &Ptllf
Page 9
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFl&IAk W&li 0PU,¥
The Russian design bureaus are to thank for arriving at a concept that eliminated the
noisy and hazardous air-breather takeoff and for increasing the operational flexibility of
the British HOTOL concept. Glebe Lozino-Lozinski had a concept for a spacecraft with a
7-metric-ton payload carried atop an Antonov An-225, with a second An-225 carrying
the liquid hydrogen and launch facilities and staff.3 The An-225 was in fact a mobile
launch facility; it could literally launch a satellite for any facility that could
accommodate a B-747 or an MDC-11. With Rolls Royce or General Electric engines, the
An-225 becomes a more easily maintained vehicle with better altitude performance.
The An-225's empennage is modified from the An-124's single vertical and horizontal
empennage to an 'H' configuration. This permits the powered hypersonic glider to
easily lift off the top of the vehicle, as the MBB Sanger wind tunnel test demonstrated.
Most commercial transport aircraft larger than ERJ 170 are potential mobile launch
platforms for space tourism, point-to-point cargo, or orbital facilities support. Most of
the commercial passenger equipment can be removed, with just enough equipment
remaining for a launch crew. The fuselage is strengthened and fitted with external
mountings for the hypersonic glider. The landing gear need not be modified, as the
same maximum weight as the commercial transport will be ma intained. The flight
control system would be adapted to automatically maintain the correct launch
trajectory until separation. A second modified transport would be modified to carry the
liquid hydrogen and liquid air to fuel the hypersonic vehicle, along with maintenance
and support crew. The intent is to use the automatic launch checkout the author
witnessed at Baikanour in 1988, wherein a Soyuz that arrived on its train carrier at
0500 hours launched carrying a Progress capsule at 1715 hours the same day. That
should make a local launch possible with in hours of arriving at the specified airport
launch departure site. These two elements can provide a commercial space launch
facility that requires no special or dedicated operational base.
Hypersonic Configuration Concepts
The configuration and the propulsion system are linked through aerothermopropulsion
integration. This approach is not new, as a wide spectrum of configurations and
concepts existed in the 1960s. One such McDonnell Aircraft Company concept is shown
in Figure 3. This potential operational mach 12 cruise vehicle was developed for the
U.S. government as a strike reconnaissance vehicle taking off from a U.S. Air Force
base. The concept was to provide on-demand reconnaissance in force operations.
However, as was the case with all such efforts in the 1960s, none of the aircraft derived
from the "flight-to-space" efforts reached a hardware stage. Individuals working on
these projects were convinced that the industrial capability existed to design and
fabricate these vehicles, and that such vehicles were technically feasible. The concepts
varied widely among different nations, but all had as their goal a transportation system
to space that had commercial potential. This discussion is provided to discriminate
between rocket-powered hypersonic gliders and hypersonic cruisers with an air
breathing propulsion system .
2
UNCLASSIFIED/ ;CFQR 0FFI&l.t.k Wliliii 8Plk¥
Page 10
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFl@IAL l::l!H! 8HL'I
-McDonnell Aircraft
Advanced Design Dept.
1958 to 1967
Mr. H. D.Altis , Director
Figure 3. HSVS Hypersonic Cruise Aircraft Showing True Skin Temperature
A wide variety of configurations for recoverable spacecraft are possible. But if the
requirements for a transportation system capable of traveling to and returning from
space are to be met, the configurations spectrum is significantly narrowed. Two basic
configuration types emerge. One configuration is for a hypersonic glider powered by
either rocket or air-breathing rocket cycle propulsion that can operate as air-breath ing
propulsion to mach 5.5 or less. A versatile variable-capture, inward-turning inlet4 can
be integrated with the vehicle configuration derived from the FDL series of hypersonic
gliders developed by the U.S . Air Force Flight Dynamics Laboratory (AFFDL) 5 and the
work of the McDonnell Douglas Astronautics Company. Because of the mass ratio to
orbit, these configurations are vertical takeoff and horizontal landing vehicles,
exemplified by the upper-left vehicle in Figure 4. This vehicle is usually an upper stage
in a two-stage-to-orbit rather than a single-stage-to-orbit vehicle.
3
UNCLASSIFIED/ /EAR OFFICIO I. Uiliii 0PUi!lf
Page 11
UNCLASSIFIED/ JFOR OFFICIJltL YSE 8PUslf
Rocket Powered
Hypersonic Glider
Combined Cycle
Airbreather Powered
Hypersonic Cruiser
Figure 4. Hypersonic Rocket-Powered Glider and Hypersonic Air-Breathing Cruiser
The second configuration is for air-breathing propulsion systems operating at between
mach 6 and mach 14 that require a propulsion-configured vehicle, where the underside
of the vehicle is an integral part of the propulsion system (forming most of the air
capturing inlet). This is typified by the lower-right vehicle in Figure 4. The thermally
integrated, air-breathing, combined-cycle configuration concept is derived from the
McDonnell Douglas (St. Louis) Advanced Design organization. The vehicle concept
initially conceived in the late 1950s and early 1960s was an air-breathing propulsion
configured vehicle accelerated by a main rocket in the aft end of the body, as shown in
Figure 3. The vehicle's underside is the propulsion system; the engine is in the engine
module.
Both basic shapes are functions of tau-that is, for a given planform area, the cross
sectional distribution is determined by the volume required. Tau was reported in
D. Kuchemann's book on supersonic aerodynamics 6 as:
'C =
Vtotal
splan
1.5
(1)
The only configuration discussed in the book in any detail is the rocket-powered
hypersonic glider. The hypersonic glider has greater near-term potential to become an
operational system, considering the failure of the National Aerospace Plane (NASP) to
reach a functional hardware stage.
4
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFICIO! 1!SE Ql!L¥
Page 12
UNCLASSIFIED/ fFOR OFFl&IAL YSIE er•tv
Whatever goes into orbit must enter the atmosphere many t imes if it is to be a
sustained-use vehicle . If it is to be a commercial vehicle, then the flex ibility to land
wherever the commercial customers are is essential. Consider how successful FedEx,
UPS, or DHL would be if there were only two pickup and delivery sites in the United
States and a few more elsewhere in the world. A ballistic capsule has even fewer
landing options, and a saltwater landing and recovery is too costly to be commercially
feasible. What is needed is a hypersonic glider with the flexibility to enter when
necessary, without waiting, and to land at different operational bases, just as a
transport might. There were three serious competitors in the United States with
respect to hypersonic glider configurations: the AFFDL at Wright-Patterson Air Force
Base, the McDonnell Douglas Corporation (MDC), and the Lockheed Corporation.
NASA Ames and NASA Langley were also generating hypersonic configurations, but
NASA's views on hypersonic gliders (fundamentally research and development projects)
and their glide range requirements differed from those of the three organizations listed
above. That difference is clearly exemplified by the difference between the operational
requirements of an experimental aircraft (such as X-1, X-2, X-1 0, X-15, or X-20) that
flies infrequently and at the convenience of the research organization and those of an
operational Air Force or Navy aircraft that must be able to fly on any day in almost any
weather when needed (also a Russian spacecraft operational rule). From the middle of
the 1960s to the early 1970s, the U.S . Air Force and NASA had disagreements over the
operational capability of these aircraft and their requirements. As a result, each went
its own development direction, and much of the originality and practicality of the AFFDL
concepts has not been reflected in the space access configurations developed by NASA.
There was a final attempt to apply the AFFDL's philosophy of a high lift-to-drag (L/D)
ratio delta planform configuration to the NASA space shuttle, as detailed in the article
"A Delta Shuttle Orbiter" in the January 1971 issue of Astronautics and Aeronautics. 7
Figure 5 shows the array of delta planform configurations the AFFDL considered during
the 1958-68 timeframe.
Figures. Delta-Lifting Body Designs. Array of delta -lifting body designs shows configuration is not limited to
high hypersonic lift-to-drag ratios, high cross range, and large size. 8
5
UNCLASSIFIED/ ,<FOR OFFI&IAL YSIE 8HLY
Page 13
UNCLASSIFIED/,CFOA OFFl€1Ak Uliliii ONkY
The AFFDL's approach was to design a hypersonic performance configuration that would
minimize the waiting t ime in orbit to return to the continental United States (CONUS).
This resulted in configurations with sharper leading edges and smaller nose radii than
found in NASA and Russian configurations. All of the material, structural, and
thermodynamic details related to the sharper configurations were tested and verified in
ground test facilities and flight tests (BGRV and ASSET). Characteristics of selected
AFFDL hypersonic glider configurations are identified in Table 1.
Table 1. Characteristics of Selected Flight Dynamics Laboratory Hypersonic
Glider Configurations During the 1958-68 Timeframe
#
Model
Observation
l
FDL-24B
Flat bottom, sharp leading edges, conventional tails, as
designed
2
All Body Glider, similar
to Russian BOR vehicles
Upnirned spatular nose, conventional tail s
3
ASSET
4
FDL-7MC
Test
vehicle
evaluate
aerodynamics,
to
thermodynamics and materi als, based on nose of
DynaSoar
Flat bottom , sharp leading edges, variable geometry
wing, ex perimentally developed tail X configuration
5
Blunt nose, wing-body
DynaSoar type configuration
6
Spaturlar Nose Version
of DynaSoar type
First integration of 2-dirnensional nose (less drag) on a
hypersonic glider (R.D. Newmann)
7
FDL-8
Flat bottom, sharp leading edges, outboard tails
8
HL-10
ASA Ames flat up-swept with bottom, ro und upper
body, high dihedral angle tai ls
9
X-24A
NASA Langley round body, high dihedral angle tails
LO
Star Body
based on Russian Star Body type configuration
Configuration 2 was a higher wing-loading, relatively blunt all-body with an upswept
spatular nose that is not unlike Russia's Bor series of Lozino-Lozinski hypersonic gliders.
When the author was at Wright-Patterson, interest in this waned quickly because of the
limited cross range available. Because of the longitudinal extent of the former Soviet
Union compared with the United States, the minimum L/D ratio to ensure a landing on
the continental land mass was less for the former Soviet Union than it was for the
United States-1.
Previous: DOW-UAP-D123 — AAWSAP DIRD, Positron Aerospace Propulsion, March 2010 · Next: DOW-UAP-D125 — AAWSAP DIRD, Inertial Electrostatic Confinement Fusion, March 2010
Same topic: title & summary match
Same location: Las Vegas, Nevada
- DOW-UAP-D174 — Utah Ranch Investigation Report, April 2010
- DOW-UAP-D166 — MUFON Reports Prepared for BAASS, November 2008
- DOW-UAP-D168 — BAASS Project Management Plan, December 2008
- DOW-UAP-D169 — BAASS Monthly Report, March 2009
- DOW-UAP-D170 — BAASS Monthly Report, April 2009
- DOW-UAP-D171 — BAASS Monthly Report, June 2009
Same period: 2010
- DOW-UAP-D114 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00003, May 2010
- DOW-UAP-D113 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00002, February 2010
- DOW-UAP-D115 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00004, May 2010
- DOW-UAP-D116 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00005, September 2010
- DOW-UAP-D133 — AAWSAP DIRD, The Space Communication Implications of Quantum Entanglement and Nonlocality, March 2010
- DOW-UAP-D134 — AAWSAP DIRD, Maverick Inventor Versus Corporate Inventor: Where Will the Next Major Innovations Arise, March 2010
Same release: Release 06
- DOW-UAP-PR159 — Historical Film of Reported UFOs, Utah, 1952
- LLE-UAP-PR001 — Unresolved UAP Report, Colorado, 2023
- LLE-UAP-PR002 — Unresolved UAP Report, Colorado, October 2023
- DOW-UAP-PR133 — Unresolved UAP Report, Middle East, 2025
- DOW-UAP-PR135 — Unresolved UAP Report, Middle East, 2025
- DOW-UAP-PR140 — Unresolved UAP Report, Middle East, 2022
Same agency: DoW
- DOW-UAP-D094 — Analysis of Flying Object Incidents in the United States, 1949
- DOW-UAP-D097 — Project Sign Progress Report, 1948
- DOW-UAP-D084 — US Army-Flying-Saucer-Study 1949
- DOW-UAP-D155 — Air Intelligence Information Report, Saudi Arabia, 1957
- DOW-UAP-D176 — Triangular UAP AARO Memorandum for Record, 2026
- DOW-UAP-D177 — Unresolved UAP Report, Catalina Island, 1955