Home › Archive › DoW

DOW-UAP-D148 — AAWSAP DIRD, Detection and High-Resolution Tracking of Vehicles at Hypersonic Velocities, November 2010

File DOW-UAP-D148 is a declassified pdf from Department of War, recording an incident dated 11/20/10 at Las Vegas, Nevada, published in Release 06 (2026-09-18). This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.

File
DOW-UAP-D148
Agency
Department of War
Incident date
11/20/10
Location
Las Vegas, Nevada
Released in
Release 06 (2026-09-18)
File type
PDF

Topics: AAWSAP & DIRDs

This document is a Defense Intelligence Reference Document (DIRD), a technical reference format used by the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) to capture baseline knowledge on a specific topic for later analytic use. DIRDs are best understood as reference and synthesis products rather than as original research. It is one of 38 DIRDs produced under the Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Applications Program (AAWSAP) between 2009 and 2011. Because AAWSAP’s scope permitted a broad range of supporting topics, not every DIRD in the series directly concerns aerospace systems or future threat assessment. The following summary reflects the DIRD’s scope and framing at the time of writing and should not be read as implying current validation of the concepts discussed.

This DIRD surveys how hypersonic vehicles may be detected and tracked by exploiting the physical effects they create in flight, especially shock waves, ionized gas, hot surfaces, and turbulent atmospheric wakes. The report reviews a broad set of detection methods, including radar, infrared sensing, optical imaging, LIDAR, passive radio reflection, infrasound, and seismic techniques, and argues that the most effective systems will likely combine multiple sensor types, because each captures different features of a high-speed vehicle’s passage through the atmosphere. It presents radar and infrared sensing as the strongest existing tools for operational detection, while giving particular attention to wake-based methods such as LIDAR and passive radio techniques for improving tracking, identification, and discrimination of future hypersonic aircraft. The paper identifies hypersonic vehicles as an evolving surveillance problem in which future progress will depend on better multi-sensor integration, improved wake characterization, and novel signature-exploitation techniques.

Open original file · WAR.GOV page

TL;DR

November’s show in Vegas proved even slot machines can’t gamble with hypersonics.

  • DIRD D148, DoW, 11/20/10, Las Vegas, NV.
  • Surveys radar, IR, LIDAR, acoustic, wake methods to detect hypersonic vehicles.
  • Recommends multi-sensor integration; no definitive detection solution recorded.

AI summary

A declassified UAP document titled "Detection and High-Resolution Tracking of Vehicles at Hypersonic Velocities," issued by the Defense Intelligence Agency in November 2010, outlines hypersonic flow theory, detection technologies, and recommendations for tracking high-speed vehicles. It covers aerodynamic principles, including boundary layers, supersonic flow, and shock waves. The document discusses radar, optical, and acoustic methods for detecting hypersonic objects, including Doppler radar, infrared systems, and LIDAR. It explains infrared radiation emission principles, black body theory, and Planck's Law, as well as LIDAR and acoustic methods like laser Doppler velocimetry and infrasound detection. The text references hypersonic vehicles such as space debris, reentry craft, missiles, and hypersonic aircraft, and mentions historical U.S. defense programs and specific detection examples from the 1970s, 1990s, and beyond. It includes technical data on atmospheric properties, sensor development, and references to scientific publications and citations.

Full text

Page 2

UNCLASSIFIED//F8R: &FFIGl,liaL Mii QtPP X

Detection and High Resolution Tracking of Vehicles at
Hypersonic Velocities
The Defense Intelligence Reference Document provides nonsubstantive but
authoritative reference information related to iutelli ence to ics or methodolo ies.

Prepared by:
Technology Warning Division (DW0-4)
Defense Warning Office
Directorate for Analysis
Defense Intelligence Agency
Author:

AAP Person 83

{U) COPYRIGHT WARNING: Further dissemination of the photographs in this publication is not authorized.

This product is one of a series of advanced technology reports produced in FY 2010 under the
Defense Intelligence Agency, Defense Warning Office's Advanced Aerospace Weapons System
Applications (AAWSA) Program . Comments or questions pertaining to this document should be
addressed to !AAP Person 1
f AWSA Program Manager, Defense Intelligence Agency,
ATTN: JUIAF - 01/DWO-3, Bldg 6000, Washington D.C. 20340-5100

UNCLASSIFIED.'/FOR OliliiliGiliiliaL W&& 8HLV

Page 3

UNCLASSIFIEDH/ ONLV
Contents
Introduction.
Chapter 1: Theory Governing Objects in Flight 3
Subsonic Flow and Drag 3
Supersonic Flow. 6
Chapter 2: Hypersonic Compressible Flow Theory. 10
Chapter 3: Detection Technologies.. 11
Electromagnetic Methods 13
RADAR (Reflected Energy) 13
Doppler RADAR. 14
Radio Reflection Detection 15
Optical Methods . 16
Sky Cameras and Photographic Methods. 16
Infrared Detection 17
LIDAR.. 23
Acoustic and Seismic Methods 25
Infrasound 25
Seismic... 27
Chapter 4: Vision of Progress Over the Next 30 Years. 28
Detectability of New Hypersonic Aircraft.. 29
Recommendation #1 - Build a Database of the Wake Characteristics for Existing Aircraft
. 29
Recommendation #2 - Exploit the Detectability of Hypersonic Aircraft Based on the
Features That Allow Them To Fly Efficiently at High Speeds .... ... 30
Recommendation #3 - Explore the Detection of Vehicles Designed To Be Undetectable30
Recommendation #4 - Explore the Development of Novel Detectors... 31
Summary ...... 31
iii
UNCLASSIFIEDLFOR

Page 4

UNCLASSIFIED/fFOR. QFFIEl.t.L: Uii QD:I! X

Figures
Figure 1. Boundary Layer Development in Subsonic Flow about a Projectile ........................ 4
Figure 2. Subsonic Flow Past a Projectile ....................................................................... 5
Figure 3. Strauhal Frequency as a Function of Reynolds Number for Flow over a
Circular Cylinder .. .............. ............................ .. ...................................... ....... 6
Figure 4. Supersonic Flow Past a Wedge-Shaped Body .................................................... 8
Figure 5. Supersonic Flow Past a Blunt Body (Spheroid) .................................................. 8
Figure 6. Ratios of Mach Number, Temperature, and Pressure Across a Normal Shock .... ... 10
Figure 7. Hypersonic Vehicle Detection Techniques ....................................................... 11
Figure 8. Laser-Based Chronograph ... ......... ............. ....................... ............................ 12
Figure 9. Electromagnetic Spectrum as a Function of Wavelength ................................... 13
Figure 10. Schematic of a RADAR System ................................................................... 14
Figure 11. Radio Reflection Detector................ .. ......................................................... 16
Figure 12 . Energy Spectrum of t he Sun at 5,778 K....................................................... 19
Figure 13. Hypersonic Flow Past a Sphere... ................................................................ 20
Figure 14. Infrared Energy Spectra for Mach 3 and Mach 3.5 ......... ................................ 21
Figure 15. Peak Wavelength of the Infrared Radiation Emitted by Hypersonic Objects ........ 22
Figure 16. Peak Shock Layer Temperature for Hypersonic Objects .................................. 22
Figure 17. Schematic of a Pulsed LIDAR System ........................................................... 24
Figure 18. Mach Cone Generated by a Supersonic Object .............................................. 26
Figure 19. Comparison of Detection Technology for Hypersonic Objects ........................... 32

Tables
Table 1: Normal Shock Values for Mach 3 Flow ...............................................................9

iv

UNCLASSIFIED//EQA: QlililEl.t.L: W&&: O,.L'l

Page 5

UNCLASSIFIED/fFOR. QFFIEl.t.L: Uii QD:I! X

Introduction
An object is supersonic when its speed through the atmosphere is greater than the local
speed of sound . The Mach number is defined as the speed of the object divided by the local
speed of sound . For Mach numbers greater than 1 (supersonic flow), shock waves develop in
the flowfield and near the surface of the object due to the air's compressibility. Traditionally,
the lower Mach number limit for the so-called hypersonic speed regime is about Mach 5 (1. 7
km/sec). "Low hypersonic" values range between Mach 5 to about Mach 10, while "high
hypersonic" values range between approximately Mach 10 to Mach 30 or above. Mach 30
(10 km/s), for example, is close to Space Shuttle reentry velocity . Few objects can travel at
hypersonic velocities. The most common object that we see movin g at these speeds are
meteors entering the Earth's atmosphere. As meteors fall to the Earth's surface, their
velocities may reach 30 miles per second (48 km/s), 1 and their corresponding Mach number
as they enter the upper layers of the atmosphere will exceed 150. Meteors are preceded by
a bow shockwave as they compress the air immediately in their path. Temperatures and
pressures increase dramatically across the shockwave to a point where the gases in air ionize
and disassociate, leading to the emission of visible light and radio waves. These conditions
also lead to rapid heating of the meteor surface causing them to fracture and break up as
they enter the atmosphere. Optical and RADAR-based surveillance systems are now used to
scan outer space to detect asteroids and other objects with orbits that may lead them to
collide with Earth.
A second class of hypersonic objects includes reentry vehicles moving into the Earth's
atmosphere from orbit. In the case of a reentry vehicle returning from low-Earth orbit at
100 km altitude, the velocity of the vehicle will reach 8 km/s (about 5 miles per second).
The Mach number of this vehicle will exceed 26 .5 in the upper atmosphere. As the vehicle
moves through the atmosphere, flow-induced drag forces will slow down the vehicle; if the
vehicle has sufficient thermal protection, it can survive reentry and be recovered.
A third class of hypersonic vehicles includes the reentry payload used in ICBMs
(intercontinental ballistic missiles). The payload in these missiles is launched using a rocket
that boosts them above the atmosphere to a suborbital velocity. The payload velocity may
exceed 7 km/s as they reenter the atmosphere, equating to M > 23. The coupled high
velocity and high kinetic energy of these objects creates an ionized wake and shock wave
that can be used to detect their position and to determine their velocity. This information,
along with their ballistic trajectory, is used to locate their target and the time to impact.
A fourth class of hypersonic vehicles includes manned and unmanned rockets and aircraft.
The North American X-15, for example, exceeded a speed of 7,274 km/hr in 1964, equating
to about M = 6.5. This aircraft also exceeded 100 km in altitude on two occasions, qualifying
the X-15 as a spacecraft. The SR-71 Blackbird, an air-breathing strategic reconnaissance
aircraft, has exceeded Mach 3.2 at 80,000-ft altitude, and its actual maximum speed may
have reached into the hypersonic flow regime. Other real and conceptual aircraft capable of
reaching hypersonic speeds include the alleged Aurora SR-91 (Mach 4 to 6), the Boeing X51, an unmanned Mach 6 scramjet, the HTV-2 from the DARPA Falcon project (designed for
M=20 flight to low-Earth orbit), the HyperSoar (M = 12), the Russian Leninetz Ayaks, and
the Skylon (designed for single-stage-to-orbit flights). Certain rockets are also designed to
travel at hypersonic speeds. The Patriot missile, for example, travels at Mach 5, a high
speed necessary for it to be able to intercept and destroy other missiles while they are in
flight.
1

UNCLASSIFIED//EQA: QlililEl.t.L: W&&: O,.L'l

Page 6

UNCLASSIFIED/fFOR. QFFIEl.t.L: Uii QD:I! X
There are a number of different techniques available to detect hypersonic objects and to
determine their position, velocity, and trajectory. These detection methods can be broadly
divided into electromagnetic, optical, and acoustic/seismic methods. Each method relies on
the properties of the surface of the object to reflect incident radiation or upon the properties
of the hot ionized gases caused by the bow shock and entrained into the object's wake. The
theory of external fluid flow around objects in subsonic, supersonic, and hypersonic regimes
will be reviewed and various detection methods will be compared in this report.

2

UNCLASSIFIED//EQA: QlililEl.t.L: W&&: O,.L'l

Page 7

UNCLASSIFIED/fFOR. QFFIEl.t.L: Uii QD:I! X

Chapter 1: Theory Governing Objects in Flight
Many of the detection technologies for hypersonic aircraft are based on the properties of the
air flow around the object. The flu id mechanics affecting supersonic and hypersonic aircraft
are well described in textbooks on compressible flow by J.D. Anderson;2•3 subsonic flow,
including the affect of boundary layers, is covered in the textbook by F. M. White. 4
Hypersonic flow usually refers to the reg ime where objects are moving faster than Mach 5,
but technically refers to the Mach range where pressure, temperature, and density ratios
across shock waves reach constant values, and this does happen at about Mach 5. Fluid flow
changes dramatically at Mach 1 defined at the point where the velocity of a projectile, V,
equals the local speed of sound, a, in the atmosphere:
M ='!_
a

(1)

Flow regimes are defined by the following:
•

M < 1, subsonic flow

•

M = 1, sonic flow

•

M > 1, supersonic flow

•

M > 5, hypersonic flow

The speed of sound varies with temperature and with t he type of gases in the atmosphere. A
simple equation for the speed of sound includes the ratio of specific heats, y, the gas
constant, R, and the temperature, T:

a=.JyRT

(2)

For air at room temperature, y = 1.4, R = 287 J/kg -K, and T = 20° C or 293 K. The
subsequent speed of sound is 343 m/s (1,125 ft/s or 767 mph). It is easier for a projectile
to exceed the speed of sound at higher elevations since the temperature of the atmosphere
is lower, reducing the speed of sound and the subsequent velocity necessary to break the
sound barrier.
The viscosity of the fluid flowing around an object induces drag and retards its forward
motion. Supersonic flow has some of the viscous characteristics of subsonic flow, but adds in
the complication of shock waves. To understand the nature of how a projectile affects the
flow of fluid around it, consider the case of a subsonic projectile.

SUBSONIC FLOW AND DRAG
Subsonic flows, such as the flow shown in Figure 1, are heavily influenced by collisions
between molecules of air and the surface of the projectile. The equations for this interaction
were first developed by Sir Isaac Newton in the seventeenth century, where he determined
that fluids have a property called "viscosity" that is the cause of drag on projectiles. The key
parameter that affects subson ic fluid flow is the ratio of viscous forces to inertial forces,
where inertial forces are associated with the tendency for a moving fluid to keep moving in
the same direction. The ratio of these two forces is defined as the Reynolds Number, Re.
3

UNCLASSIFIED//FQA: QlililEl.t.L: W&li ONL'l

Page 8

UNCLASSIFIED/fFOR. QFFIEIA.L: Ulii Qt!! X
Re = viscous forces= VD
inertial forces
v

(3)

In this expression, V is the velocity of the projectile, D is its effective diameter, and v is the
kinematic viscosity of the fluid. As flow passes over the projectile in Figure 1, viscous forces
are especially strong near the surface where the velocity changes from zero at the surface of
the projectile to the free stream velocity.
Direction of Flow
. - - - - Streamlines

<- ________
Boundary Layer

--

-----

Velocity D

ibution within

the Bounda

ayer

-------,, ,
''

''
\

\

\
\

I
I

Figure 1. Boundary Layer Development in Subsonic Flow About a Projectile.

The region where this transition in velocity occurs is called a "boundary layer," which grows
in thickness as flow moves along the surface from the nose to the rear of the projectile.
The boundary layer forms around the surface of the projectile and "separates" from the
surface at the back end of the projectile. Pockets of fluid spill off of the back end of the
projectile and form rotating pockets of fluid called Strauhal eddies or vortices. These eddies
"shed" from the surface at a rate that is strongly dependent upon the Reynolds number in
the flow. Figure 2 demonstrates that these eddies form a "wake" downstream of the
projectile that can extend far into the flu id.

4

UNCLASSIFIED//EQA: QlililEl.t.L: W&&: O,.L'l

Page 9

UNCLASSIFIED/fFOR. QFFI El .t.L: Uii QD:I! X
Boundary Layers
Strouhal Eddies or

Streamlines

Vo rtices

Projectile

Direction of Flow

Figure 2. Subsonic Flow Past a Projectile.

Visible examples of a "wake" are the contrails observed in the upper atmosphere when water
vapor in the exhaust of jet aircraft freezes into ice crystals, highlighting the wake generated
by the aircraft and its engines. In still air, the wake can be visible for many miles behind the
aircraft.
The wake rapidly becomes turbulent as it extends downstream. The Strauhal eddies are
detectable and have a shedding frequency that is expressed in terms of the Strauhal
number, St = f D/V, where f is the Strauhal shedding frequency (hz), D is the diameter (m)
of the projectile, and V is its velocity (m/s) through the air. The Strauhal number is a
function of Reynolds number, as shown in Figure 3. By measuring the Strauhal frequency,
the velocity of the projectile can be determined with moderate accuracy.
At low speeds, and corresponding low Reynolds numbers, the flow is "laminar" where
streamlines move in smooth "laminae" or layers over projectiles. At high Reynolds numbers,
the fluid flow becomes unstable and forms a widely distributed set of small eddies defined as
"turbulence." In turbulent flow, rapid mixing of the flow in the wake, even in the boundary
layers, will occur.

5

UNCLASSIFIED//EQA: QlililEl.t.L: W&&: O,. L'l

Page 10

UNCLASSIFIED/fFOR. QFFIEl.t.L: Uii QD:I! X

St= 10/V

0 - ~ ~ - - - - + - - ~............f - - ~ ~ - ~ f - -..........- ~ ~ - + - - - ~ ~......

1.E+0l

1.E+02

1.E+03

1.E+04

1.E+05

1.E+06

1.H07

Re 0 =VD/v

Figure 3. Strouhal Frequency as a Function of Reynolds Number for
Flow Over a Circular Cylinder.

The high velocities present in the wake generate low pressures on the downstream side of
the projectile that pull the projectile backwards into the wake. Th is is defined as "wake" or
"form" drag and is a predominant cause of drag forces on aircraft or on any obj ect moving
through the atmosphere. The viscous forces that create the boundary layers on the surface
of a projectile also contribu t e a small amount of drag, usually referred to as "skin friction."
Boundary layers and wakes also affect supersonic flow, but the effect of shock waves tends
to be the predominant mechan ism affecting flow around supersonic projecti les. Total drag
force, Fo, exerted on projectiles or aircraft is usually summarized by th is equation:

(4)
The drag force is dependent upon the density of the air, p, the frontal area of the aircraft, Ar,
the aircraft velocity, V, and the drag coefficient, Co. The drag coefficient is a function of the
geometry of the aircraft and the two "dimensionless" groups, Mach number, M, and Reynolds
number, Reo, that relate inertial, viscous, and elastic forces in the flow:
C 0 = f (Re 0 , M , geoniet ry)

(5)

Drag coefficients for various types of aircraft and projectiles are obtained from theory, from
computational fluid mechanics, or, most commonly, from experiments in wind tunnels.
These coefficients are usually presented in tables or in graphical form. 5, 6 , 7

SUPERSONIC FLOW
Air is predominantly made up of molecules of nitrogen (78%) and oxygen (21 %). At room
temperature, air behaves as an ideal gas where the density, p, the pressure, p, and the
temperature, T, are related through a gas constant, R, which is a property of the air. The
ideal gas law gives the relationship between these values. The gas constant for air is
R = 287 J/kg-K.
6

UNCLASSIFIED//FOR QlililEl.t.L: W&li ONL'l

Page 11

UNCLASSIFIED/,SFOR. QFFIElal L: 1!ii 011! X
(6)

p = pRT

It is possible to statistically model the motion of the molecules of oxygen and nitrogen in air,
and their kinetic energy, KE, can be determined based on the mass, m, of each molecule and
the temperature of the gas.
KE =_!.mV 2 ='i kT
2
2

In this equation, k is the Boltzmann constant (1.3807 x 10-23 J/K).
velocity of air molecules based on the temperature of the ai r .

(7)
We can ca lculate the

(8)

Or, for the average velocity of a molecule:

V= ✓ 8=T

(9)

For air near sea level (p = 101,320 Pa, T = 293 K) the average velocity of molecules in air is
463 m/s or 1,035 MPH. This value is just a little higher than the speed of sound in air (343
m/s or 767 MPH) as computed earlier. These molecules only travel a short distance before
they collide with each other. This distance is defined as the "mean free path " given by the
symbol A.
(10)
In this expression, d is the diameter of a molecul e, which is approximately 0.3 nanometers.
For air at 20° C and 101,325 Pa, the mean free path (A) is approximately 100 nanometers or
about 333 molecular diameters.
When the supersonic projectile in Figure 4 moves through the air, molecules of nitrogen and
oxygen in the air bounce off the vehicle's surface and collide with other molecules of air a
short distance away. At the speed of sound, these molecules are not moving fast enough to
get out of the way and a large number of molecules pil e up along a straight line that
emanates from the nose or leading edge of the projectile as a "shock wave."
Supersonic flow in the atmosphere labeled as region 1 passes through the shock and moves
para llel to the surface of the body. The flow "expands" through a Prandtl-Meyer expansion
fan at the end of the airfoil and speeds back up to its original Mach number. Flow in the
boundary layer separates from the end of the airfoil and forms a highly turbulent wake
downstream of the airfoil. The wake is also composed of Strouhal eddies that ca n subsist in
the air long after the airfoil has passed by. The flow density, pressure, and temperature
increases dramatically across the bow shockwave and returns to the original Mach number
downstream of the airfoil.
For a blunt-nosed object, as shown in Figure 5, the magnitude of the impact that the
shockwave has on the flow is easier to explain. For a blunt object, the shock detaches from
the surface of the object into the freestream in front of the object. Since the orig inal flow
moving at M1 is traveling at 90° with respect to the shock near the nose of the object, the
shock in this reg ion is referred to as a "norma l" shock. The properties across a normal shock
7

UNCLASSIFIED//FOR 0661El.t.L: W&&: OttLY

Page 12

UNCLASSIFIED/fFOR. QFFIEl.t.L: U&i QD:I! X
are described by the Rankine-Hugoniot equations, which yield the ratio of certa in
thermodynamic properties.
Expansion Fan

Bow Shockwave

Region 1

Figure 4. Supersonic Flow Past a Wedge-Shaped Body.

Turbulent Wake

Detached Shock

Expansion Fans

Blunt Body

Figure 5. Supersonic Flow Past a Blunt Body (Spheroid).

8

UNCLASSIFIED//FQlil QlifilEIAL: Wlili O,.L'l

Page 13

UNCLASSIFIED/fFOR. QFFIEIA.L: Ulii Qt!! X
These equations can be expressed in a form where the ratio of density, temperature, and
pressure across the normal shock are a function of the upstream Mach number, M1.

(11)

(12)

Pz = 1 + ~ ( M 12 - 1)
P1

(13)

r+ 1

Pi = -<r-+t) M 12
-Pi

(14)

2 + (y - 1) M i2

As an example, if the object shown in figure 4 is traveling at Mach 3 through air at sea level,
the pressure in the reg ion between the nose of the object and the shock changes as shown in
the following table:

Table 1: Normal Shock Values for Mach 3 Flow
Freestream
Values

Ratio of
Properties
Across the
Normal Shock

Values
Downstream
of the
Normal Shock

M 1 =3

M2/M 1 = 0.158

M2 = 0.475

p1 = 101,325 Pa

p/p 1 = 10.333

p 2 = 1,047,000 Pa

T1 = 293 K

Ti/T1 = 2.679

T2 = 785.0 K

= (2o·q
p 1 = 1.293 kg/m 3

= (s12·q
p 2 = 4.976 kg/m 3

p/p 1 = 3.857

For a normal shock, the Mach number on the downstream side of the shock is always
subsonic, and in th is example, the Mach number abru ptly drops from M1 = 3 to M2 = 0.475.
The temperature always increases across a shock, and for a Mach 3 flow, the temperature
rises from room temperature at 20° C up to 512° C. It is apparent that, for supersonic
aircraft traveling at this speed, the fuselage and wings will need to be made of materials that
can withstand the high temperatures and the dramatic pressure increase of 10.333. Shocks
are always accompanied by significant increases in pressure, temperature, and density in the
flow across the shock.
Flow about an Ogive or wedge-shaped airfoil as shown in Figure 4 can be analyzed in a
will affect the flow and the formation of
similar fashion; however, the wall deflection angle,
the oblique shock wave that surrounds the airfoil.

e,

9

UNCLASSIFIED//EQA: QlililEl.t.L: W&&: O,.L'l

Page 14

UNCLASSIFIED/fFOR. QFFIEl.t.L: Uii QD:I! X

Chapter 2: Hypersonic Compressible Flow Theory
Hypersonic flow is typically assumed to apply to objects traveling at M > 5. Figure 6 shows
that, for Mach numbers above 5, the ratio of Mach numbers across the shock approaches a
constant va lue of 0.378, although temperature and pressure ratios contin ue to increase. In
hypersonic flow, the bow shock, or Mach angle, /3, approaches the half-angle, 0, of slender
airfoils and the drag coefficient reaches a constant value that does not change with Mach
number. The drag coefficient actually becomes a simple function of the half-angle of the
airfoil, and the boundary layer is squeezed between the shockwave and the airfoil surface.
150

•I

'

- 09

•

- 0.8

' ..

100 - ~ . . - + - - - + - - - - + - - - - - i e - - - - - + - - - + - - - - + - - - - + - - ' - - - -l0.7
T nllio( M )

- 06

• .....

·-- .. ·-···-·•--1111---

- 0.5 M z( M )

...

..

,

P,mio( M )

.. • •• • • "' • • • • • • • • • .- 0.4

50

- 03
- 0.2

OL
I

.-~-. -;;;
-·· -~· --~----~· -···
J ·-,·~
2

3

4

d : : : : :l :±::t::c J-o. J
5

6

7

9

1S

M

Figure 6. Ratios of Mach Number, Temperature, and Pressure Across a Normal Shock

In hyperson ic flow, the Rankine-Hugoniot equations, which are based on the perfect gas law
(p = pRT), fail to predict the real behavior of air at extremely high temperatures. Equation
12, for example, predicts a temperature of 29, 787° C in the air near the surface of a blunt
obj ect traveling at the reentry Mach number of 26.5, wh ile the actual temperature on ly
reaches 7,600° C. The reason for this discrepancy is due to ionization of molecu les of air as
electrons are stripped away by the high temperatures tha t exist across the shock. Some
energy is used to produce this ionization, and above temperatures of 550° C, equation 15
does not accurately predict air temperatures due to shocks. Ionization is responsible for the
glowing wake that follows reentry vehicles and meteors as electrons rush to recombine with
ions releasing x-rays and visible light. The ionization also interferes with radio transmissions,
but provides a convenient way to identify hypersonic objects due to the emitted light. A
"rule of thumb" is that the peak shock layer temperature in degrees kelvin is 1,000 times
larger than the aircraft speed in km/s. By this standard, a reentry veh icle at 8 km/s
(Mach 26.5) would have a maximum shock layer temperature of 8,000 K. At temperatures
above 2,000 K, nitrogen and oxygen gas in the form of 02 and N2 will disassociate into
individual ions, consuming more energy from the flow.

10

UNCLASSIFIED//EQA: QlililEl.t.L: W&&: O,.L'l

Page 15

UNCLASSIFIED/fFOR. QFFIEl.t.L: Uii QD:I! X

Chapter 3: Detection Technologies
Hypersonic objects passing through the Earth's atmosphere leave traces that can be
observed using a number of detection methods. The bow shock introduced by such objects
The ionized air
reflects and refracts radio waves, RADAR pulses, and visible light.
surrounding the object also creates electromagnetic interference that is visible on RADAR and
the emitted visible li ght in the wake is observable in photographs. The shock and turbulent
wake also create low frequency sound that can be sensed by ground-based sensors. These
detection methods can be characterized as electromagnetic, optical, and acoustic and seismic
as shown in Figure 7. Each method will be discussed along with the limitations and
advantages for the detection of hypersonic objects passing through the atmosphere.
Electromagnetic
RADAR
Energy Reflection
Doppler RADAR
Radio Reflection Detection
Optical
Sky Cameras and Photographic Methods
Infrared Detection
LIDAR
Chronograph
Acoustic and Seismic
Infrasound
Seismic
Figure 7. Hypersonic Vehicle Detection Techniques.

One of the fundamental tools for detecting the velocity of high-speed objects is the
chronograph.
These devices are used to measure the velocity of automobiles using
pneumatic tubes, and simple systems using laser diodes or LEDs are used to measure the
Figure 8 outlines a laser-based chronograph that is commercially
velocity of bullets.
available for measuring the velocity of projectiles in two-stage gas guns capable of speeds in
a vacuum of 12 km/h, or approximately Mach 36 if the projectile passed through air. As a
high-speed object passes through the first laser beam followed rapidly by the second,
photodetectors sense the change in intensity of the laser beam and send these signals to a
storage oscilloscope or to a counter. The time delay between the two signals, Lit, is used to
find the velocity of the object based on the distance between the two photodetectors, L.
Digital clocks are capable of accurately measuring time delays to within a fraction of a
nanosecond (10·9 seconds), so chronographs are capable of very high accuracy in
determining the velocity of objects. As noted earlier, their use at gun ranges or in high­
speed gas guns requires that the path of the hypersonic object must pass through the laser
beams for the chronograph to be effective, which limits their usage for the detection of
hypersonic aircraft except at instrumented test ranges.

11

UNCLASSIFIED//EQA: QlililEl.t.L: W&&: O,.L'l

Page 16

UNCLASSIFIED/fFOR. QFFIEl.t.L: Uii QD:I! X

~

~--- --~
:

Hypersonic
Aircraft

c===-

Storage

l

scope

Photodetectors

''
'
''

'''
'

Oscillo­

:

Test Range

llL
: ..

~ Laser

/

111:

lit

1

D
Velocity= L/llt

~ ~ ~ams

/ ~

Lasers

Figure 8. Laser-Based Chronograph.

Currently, the best devices for the detection of hypersonic vehicles are based on the
reflection of radio and microwave radiation through RADAR and upon the detection of
infrared energy emitted by the ionized gases surrounding high-speed vehicles and in their
wake. Optical and RADAR methods are also based on electromagnetic energy, yet make use
of different parts of the electromagnetic spectrum as shown in Figure 9. Longer wavelength
photons, or quanta of electromagnetic energy, have less energy than short wavelength
photons. As a result, detection of short wavelength radiation tends to be more line-of-sight
as in infrared or other optical methods. Longer wavelengths, used in RADAR, tend to bend
around the Earth and can provide over-the-horizon detection of ICBMs, reentry vehicles, and
other hyperson ic vehicles.

12

UNCLASSIFIED//EQA: QlililEl.t.L: W&&: O,.L'l

Page 17

UNCLASSIFIED/fFOR. QFFIEl.t.L: Uii QD:I! X
Electromagnetic Spectrum
Wavelength
1nm

Type of
Radiation
x-rays

10nm
100nm

Ultraviolet (UV)

lµm

Visible Light {0.4 to 0.7 µm)

l0µm

Near Infrared

lOOµm

Thermal Infrared

1mm

Far Infrared

10mm

Microwaves

100mm

Radar

lm
10m

Rad io Waves

100m

AM Radio

Figure 9. Electromagnetic Spectrum as a Function of Wavelength.

ELECTROMAGNETIC METHODS
RADAR (Reflected Energy)
RADAR, or "radio detection and ranging," has been heavily used since World War II for the
detection of aircraft and sea vessels. First patented by Christian Hulsmeyer in 1904, this
technique was first demonstrated by Nikola Tesla in 1917; RADAR was exploited in the
defense of Britain through the Chain Home RADAR network initiated in the late 1930s. 8
RADAR uses an antenna or a dish to transmit pulses of microwaves or radio waves toward a
potential target. Energy reflected from the target is collected by the antenna and the time of
flight of the transmitted and reflected signals yields the distance to the target. Early RADAR
systems emitted radia t ion in the high-frequency band (HF) from about 10 to 30 MHz.
Modern systems can operate well above 300 GHz.
As a single pu lse travels at the speed of light toward a target, the time delay between the
generation of the pulse and the time that its echo is received is 2L/c where L is the distance
to the target and c is the speed of light. For a target located 30 km from the source, the
time delay is 200 microseconds, an easily measurable delay. By using microwave radiation
emitted from a dish, target distance and bearing can both be measured.
While it was possible to use low-frequency radio waves ( ~30 MHz) for RADAR systems in the
1940s, the wavelength of t hese waves (100 meters) made it difficult to resolve small targets,
includ ing aircraft. This made it desirable to develop systems t hat could operate at higher
frequencies. UHF energy (300 to 1,000 GHz, 0.3- to 1-meter wavelength) radiation is used

Text continues in the original file (46 pages).

Previous: DOW-UAP-D147 — AAWSAP DIRD, Ultracapacitors as Energy and Power Storage Devices, November 2010 · Next: DOW-UAP-D149 — AAWSAP DIRD, MHD Air Breathing Propulsion and Power for Aerospace Applications, November 2010

Same topic: title & summary match

Same location: Las Vegas, Nevada

Same period: 2010

Same release: Release 06

Same agency: DoW