Kaikoura 1978: what the RNZAF and DSIR files concluded
On the night of 20/21 December 1978, the crews of two Safe Air Argosy freighters on night cargo runs reported multiple unidentified lights off the Kaikoura coast, some appearing to follow the aircraft on radar. Wellington Air Traffic Control logged simultaneous unknown radar returns. On 30–31 December an Australian TV news crew, led by reporter Quentin Fogarty, boarded a second Argosy flight to investigate and captured 16 mm motion-picture film of bright objects. The Royal New Zealand Air Force investigated; the New Zealand Defence Force released its UFO files to the public in December 2010.
42.4084° S · 173.6814° E · Kaikoura coast · 21–31 Dec 1978
Source: NZ · NZDF Archive
Two nights, one investigation
The RNZAF's own report sets out the basic facts. On the nights of 20/21 and 30/31 December 1978, Wellington air traffic control radar and the crews of Safe Air Argosy freighters, both visually and on the aircraft's radar, made many unidentified sightings off the east coast of the South Island [1]. The Civil Aviation Division of the Ministry of Transport told Air Staff about the first night mid-morning on 21 December. Defence had historically kept a 'low profile' on such reports, but because of the number and nature of that night's reports the Director of Civil Aviation specifically told his staff to inform it [1].
Air Staff asked to be called if anything similar happened again, but the memo meant for the air traffic control centre was never delivered, so the events of 30/31 December reached Air Staff only the next day [1]. After heavy media coverage, the RNZAF decided to fly an Orion surveillance flight over the area on the night of 2/3 January 1979, and a Defence investigation began at the same time [1]. Witnesses were told it was not a judicial enquiry, and the credibility of their statements was taken at face value [1].
20/21 December: returns off the Clarence River
On the first night, Wellington radar asked Argosy captains to look at returns it was painting in the Clarence River area [2]. The same radar also tracked a steady return that moved out from Wellington, stayed stationary for 35 minutes and then appeared to 'track' the second southbound Argosy at about 0328. Told of a strong return about 25 miles to port, the crew saw a very bright light they described as a bright orb, pear-shaped, with a reddish tinge that then turned white. It looked stationary to the eye but seemed to follow the aircraft on its radar, and the crew could not confirm that the light and the radar return were at the same range [2].
Later, about 50 miles north-east of Christchurch, the captain saw five consecutive blips on the aircraft radar trace a path towards the aircraft over five seconds and veer sharply to port, while the co-pilot saw a flashing white light, like a strobe, follow the same path. The report worked out a speed of about 10,800 mph and suggested a meteor, or a 'double bounce' radar contact caused by ducting [3]. On the ground at RNZAF Base Woodbourne, the orderly officer saw three lights at 2350 that he first took for a Bristol Freighter [3]; the report judged it highly improbable that these lights and the radar returns were connected [4].
This sighting, above all others during the night, caused the crew considerable consternation!
— RNZAF report on the 20/21 December flights [3]
30/31 December: the filmed flight
At 11:46 pm on 30 December, Captain Bill Startup and co-pilot Robert Guard left Wellington on a newspaper delivery run to Christchurch. With them were Australian reporter Quentin Fogarty and a film crew, cameraman David Crockett and his wife Ngaire, who ran the tape recorder; a Melbourne TV station had commissioned them to film a story about the earlier sightings [9]. Crockett shot 16 mm colour film of the cabin, the lights of Kaikoura and bright objects seen ahead and to the right, while Wellington radar reported targets near the plane. The aircraft's own radar was not used on the way south [9].
On the flight back north from Christchurch, the crew watched a light with 'the appearance of a squashed orange' that, measured against a thumb at arm's length, looked about two inches long [5]. Between 35 and 40 miles from Christchurch the captain turned towards it. The image on the aircraft radar moved to 10 miles away and then held the same position relative to the aircraft for a few minutes, before the light appeared to go above, behind and below the aircraft. Christchurch radar was working but reported nothing, and Wellington radar reported no unidentified contact in that area [5].
What the RNZAF concluded
For the bright light of 20/21 December the report's answer was Venus, which was rising within a few minutes on the same bearing; DSIR experts said the conditions could have made it look large, bright and orange [2]. It found the 31 December light also consistent with an unusual view of Venus, although the sighting came at about 0225 and Venus did not rise until about 0328; DSIR advised that super refraction could make the planet visible earlier. It offered an atmospheric inversion layer for the light's apparent movement around the aircraft, and called the radar return probably spurious or a ship [5].
The report also pointed to the radar and the sea. Wellington's radar had been giving anomalous returns for months, possibly after a recent modification that tilted its head down by one degree, and conditions favoured freak propagation of radio and light waves [2]. Some 50 Japanese squid boats had sailed from Wellington between 19 and 28 December on a track almost identical to one plotted by Wellington radar, each putting out about 200 kW of light when fishing [3]. The report acknowledged the crews' evident concern: they did not seem prepared to accept that they might have seen Venus, though neither did they believe they had seen a visitor from outer space [4]. Its final finding, signed by the Director of Operations, a wing commander, was that the few sightings still inconclusive might be explained once investigations were completed [6].
Almost all the sightings can be explained by natural but unusual phenomena.
— Director of Operations, RNZAF report [6]
The scientists' view, and its limits
DSIR's interim report reached a similar view. It found that most substantive sightings occurred from about 3 a.m., looking east and low on the horizon, and that these fit the rising of Venus but not the planet's normal appearance [7]. It put Startup's main sighting shortly after 0230, some 10 minutes before Venus should have risen at the aircraft's altitude, and called the description classic for a strongly refracted planet [7]. The RNZAF report's figures put the sighting about an hour before Venus rose; DSIR's put it about ten minutes before [5][7]. DSIR also saw little merit in analysing Crockett's 31 December film further, because the recorded image was almost entirely due to imperfections in the Argosy's window [7].
On the night of 7/8 January a DSIR officer watched many unidentified returns at the Wellington control centre, while three ground parties on the Kaikoura coast, in radio contact with him, saw nothing to suggest they were anything other than known targets or spurious returns [8]. But DSIR listed two pieces of data that did not fit its pattern: the pulsating light that approached Captain Vern Powell's aircraft on 20/21 December with an on-board radar return, at an estimated 15,000 km per hour, and the large on-board radar signal on Startup's flight, indicating an object keeping station at about 16 km. It suggested meteorite showers for the first and an atmospheric mirror reflection for the second [8].
Popular accounts often describe Kaikoura as officially unexplained; the file's reports instead attribute almost all of the sightings to Venus, ships' lights and spurious radar returns, while DSIR left two radar-linked observations outside that explanation [6][8]. An independent 1979 summary of the 30/31 December flights by Bruce Maccabee is also kept in the file [9].
The file
The papers sit in Defence file AIR 1080/6/897, 'Investigations of Unidentified & Radar Sightings East Coast South Island – December 1978', opened in 1978 and closed in 1981 [10]. It holds RNZAF interviews with people involved, technical reports from DSIR and other scientific experts, and an independent report of the sightings by the NZ UFO Studies Centre. The NZDF declassified it in December 2010 for public release; access to the original file remains restricted until 2051 [10].
Timeline
- 1978-12-21 Wellington radar asks Argosy crews to check returns off the Clarence River; a crew reports a bright light their radar appears to track. [2]
- 1978-12-21 Civil Aviation Division informs RNZAF Air Staff mid-morning. [1]
- 1978-12-30 Startup's Argosy leaves Wellington at 11:46 pm with Quentin Fogarty and a film crew aboard. [9]
- 1978-12-31 Flying north from Christchurch, the crew turn towards a large light at about 0225; Christchurch radar reports nothing. [5]
- 1979-01-02 Night of 2/3 January: RNZAF Orion surveillance of the area; a Defence investigation is launched at that time. [1]
- 1979-01-08 Night of 7/8 January: DSIR watches Wellington radar; Kaikoura coast ground parties see nothing to match returns. [8]
- 2010-12 NZDF declassifies file AIR 1080/6/897 for public release. [10]
Evidence & sources
- NZ-AIR-1080-6-897-Volume-1-1978-1981 — AIR 1080/6/897 Volume 1: RNZAF investigations of unidentified and radar sightings, east coast South Island, December 1978 (Kaikoura) — p. 191: RNZAF report: introduction
- NZ-AIR-1080-6-897-Volume-1-1978-1981 — AIR 1080/6/897 Volume 1: RNZAF investigations of unidentified and radar sightings, east coast South Island, December 1978 (Kaikoura) — p. 193: RNZAF report: radar, 21 Dec light, Venus
- NZ-AIR-1080-6-897-Volume-1-1978-1981 — AIR 1080/6/897 Volume 1: RNZAF investigations of unidentified and radar sightings, east coast South Island, December 1978 (Kaikoura) — p. 194: RNZAF report: squid fleet, radar blips
- NZ-AIR-1080-6-897-Volume-1-1978-1981 — AIR 1080/6/897 Volume 1: RNZAF investigations of unidentified and radar sightings, east coast South Island, December 1978 (Kaikoura) — p. 195: RNZAF report: 20/21 December summary
- NZ-AIR-1080-6-897-Volume-1-1978-1981 — AIR 1080/6/897 Volume 1: RNZAF investigations of unidentified and radar sightings, east coast South Island, December 1978 (Kaikoura) — p. 197: RNZAF report: 31 December flight north
- NZ-AIR-1080-6-897-Volume-1-1978-1981 — AIR 1080/6/897 Volume 1: RNZAF investigations of unidentified and radar sightings, east coast South Island, December 1978 (Kaikoura) — p. 199: RNZAF report: conclusions and signature
- NZ-AIR-1080-6-897-Volume-1-1978-1981 — AIR 1080/6/897 Volume 1: RNZAF investigations of unidentified and radar sightings, east coast South Island, December 1978 (Kaikoura) — p. 135: DSIR interim report: findings, Argosy film
- NZ-AIR-1080-6-897-Volume-1-1978-1981 — AIR 1080/6/897 Volume 1: RNZAF investigations of unidentified and radar sightings, east coast South Island, December 1978 (Kaikoura) — p. 136: DSIR interim report: radar, unexplained data
- NZ-AIR-1080-6-897-Volume-1-1978-1981 — AIR 1080/6/897 Volume 1: RNZAF investigations of unidentified and radar sightings, east coast South Island, December 1978 (Kaikoura) — p. 19: Maccabee 1979 summary of filmed flight
- NZ-AIR-1080-6-897-Volume-1-1978-1981 — AIR 1080/6/897 Volume 1: RNZAF investigations of unidentified and radar sightings, east coast South Island, December 1978 (Kaikoura) — p. 1: NZDF release cover sheet
Last fact-checked: 2026-10-03. Every claim cites its source.
More cold cases
- Belgian wave 1989–90
- Cash-Landrum 1980
- Caso Manises
- Chiles–Whitted 1948
- Condon Committee 1966
- Cosford 1993
- Coyne helicopter 1973
- El Bosque 2010
- Falcon Lake · Stefan Michalak
- Gimbal 2015
- JAL Flight 1628 over Alaska
- Levelland 1957
- Lubbock Lights 1951
- Mantell 1948
- McMinnville 1950
- Nimitz "Tic Tac" 2004
- O'Hare International 2006
- Operação Prato 1977
- Phoenix Lights 1997
- Rendlesham Forest 1980
- Robertson Panel 1953
- Roswell · Project Mogul
- Shag Harbour · Nova Scotia
- Socorro · Lonnie Zamora
- Stephenville · Texas
- Tehran 1976
- Trans-en-Provence
- Travis Walton · Snowflake
- Trindade Island 1958
- Valensole 1965
- Varginha 1996