O'Hare 2006: the tower tapes, the tower log and a disc no radar saw

On the afternoon of 7 November 2006, at about 4:30 p.m., United Airlines employees reported a dark, disc-shaped object hovering low over Gate C17 at Chicago O'Hare International Airport; they said it then shot up through the cloud deck, leaving a hole. The sighting became public on 1 January 2007 in a Chicago Tribune report by Jon Hilkevitch. The FAA, which first said it had no information, found a call about it on its tower tapes, said no controller saw the object and radar showed nothing unusual, and attributed it to a weather phenomenon without investigating further.

41.9742° N · 87.9073° W · United Airlines Gate C-17 · 7 Nov 2006

Source: FAA · Chicago Tribune

What the employees reported

The sighting became public on 1 January 2007, when the Chicago Tribune reported that United Airlines employees said a saucer-like object had hovered low over O'Hare International Airport for several minutes on 7 November 2006 before bolting through thick clouds and leaving a hole in the overcast. The paper said as many as a dozen workers reported it to the airline, that it was first seen by a ramp worker directing a plane back from Gate C17, and that it happened in daylight at about 4:30 p.m. [1].

According to the Tribune, all the witnesses described a dark gray, well-defined object, estimated at 6 to 24 feet across, with no lights and no sound, holding a fixed position just below the 1,900-foot cloud deck until it shot up into the clouds. The employees it interviewed spoke on condition of anonymity, and some said United officials had asked them to write reports and advised them not to talk about it [1].

A United manager told the paper he ran outside his office in Concourse B after hearing the report on an internal airline radio frequency. The Tribune added that the pilots of the plane at Gate C17 were also told of the sighting, and that one of them reportedly opened a cockpit windscreen to get a better view of the object, which was estimated to be hovering 1,500 feet above the ground [1].

It was like somebody punched a hole in the sky

— United Airlines employee, quoted in the Chicago Tribune [1]

The FAA's answer

The Tribune reported that the FAA first said it had no information on a sighting, then reversed itself after the newspaper filed a Freedom of Information Act request: an internal review of tapes turned up a call from a United supervisor to an FAA manager in the tower. Spokeswoman Elizabeth Isham Cory said no controllers saw the object, a preliminary radar check found nothing out of the ordinary, and the FAA was not investigating further. Its theory, she said, was a "weather phenomenon" involving a low ceiling and airport lights shining into the clouds. A United spokeswoman said there was nothing in the airline's duty manager log [1].

What the released records contain

The National Aviation Reporting Center on Anomalous Phenomena (NARCAP), a private group focused on aviation safety, obtained tower records through its own FOIA request and printed them in a May 2007 report. The FAA supplied three certified telephone recordings, all from United's ramp control, plus ground-control radio; the certifying technician stated that no other recordings involving the incident were found [5].

In the first call, which NARCAP times at 4:30 p.m., Sue in the United tower asked a supervisor named Dave whether he had seen a flying disc out by C17; he laughed and said he had not. Two more calls from United followed at about 4:47 and 4:52 p.m. [3]. The tower's Daily Record of Facility Operation logs Sue's inquiry at 2245 UTC (4:45 p.m.) with the reply that the tower had not seen it, and records the matter closed at 2303 UTC [2].

The inbound ground-control tape raises a timing question. At a point NARCAP times at 3:58:09 p.m., the controller told a Gateway flight to "use caution for the, ah UFO" [4]. At about 4:48 p.m. a caller identifying himself as United taxi mechanics told the controller, "Oh, we saw it a half hour ago," adding that they thought it was a balloon but were not sure [6]. NARCAP noted that the 3:58 remark comes earlier than the witnesses' own timings and could not resolve the difference [8].

Radar and the hole in the clouds

NARCAP's analysts reviewed FAA radar data and found no primary returns within a mile of Gate C17 at the time of the sighting [7]. The group argued that the lack of a radar return did not mean nothing was there [7], and its cloud analysis rejected a natural precipitation process as the cause of the hole, concluding that it could not be explained by conventional weather or aircraft [9]. These are the views of a private research group; the FAA made no such finding and did not investigate.

Retellings sometimes say the tower tapes or radar captured the object. The released FAA material consists of phone calls and controller remarks about a reported disc, and neither the FAA nor NARCAP found it on radar. The object was never identified, and the only official explanation offered, the FAA's weather theory, was given without an investigation [1][7].

Timeline

  • 2006-11-07 At a point timed 3:58 p.m., the ground controller warns a flight to use caution for a UFO. [4]
  • 2006-11-07 4:30 p.m.: United ramp control asks the FAA tower about a disc over Gate C17. [3]
  • 2006-11-07 2245 UTC (4:45 p.m.): the tower log records the inquiry; the item is closed at 2303 UTC. [2]
  • 2007-01-01 The Chicago Tribune publishes the sighting and the FAA's weather explanation. [1]
  • 2007-03-05 NARCAP receives the FAA's certified recordings under FOIA. [5]

Evidence & sources

  1. www.chicagotribune.com: Chicago Tribune, Hilkevitch, 1 Jan 2007
  2. www.narcap.org — p. 22: FAA tower Daily Record of Facility Operation
  3. www.narcap.org — p. 28: FAA recordings diagram; 4:30 p.m. call
  4. www.narcap.org — p. 32: Ground-control tape, 3:58 UFO remark
  5. www.narcap.org — p. 27: FAA FOIA package and certification
  6. www.narcap.org — p. 34: Ground-control tape, 4:47-4:48 p.m.
  7. www.narcap.org — p. 72: NARCAP: no radar returns near C17
  8. www.narcap.org — p. 15: NARCAP on the timing discrepancy
  9. www.narcap.org — p. 47: NARCAP hole-in-cloud conclusion

Last fact-checked: 2026-10-03. Every claim cites its source.

More cold cases