Stephenville 2008: witness reports, an Air Force correction and a radar study
On the evening of 8 January 2008, residents around Stephenville and Dublin in Erath County, Texas, reported a large, silent object with bright lights flying low and fast. Witnesses quoted by the Associated Press included Erath County Constable Lee Roy Gaitan and pilot Steve Allen. The Air Force Reserve first said none of its aircraft were in the area, then said on 23 January that ten F-16s from the 457th Fighter Squadron had been training nearby that evening. A study of FAA radar data obtained under the Freedom of Information Act by researchers with the Mutual UFO Network (MUFON) reported unidentified returns, an interpretation no government body has confirmed.
32.2207° N · 98.2023° W · Stephenville · Erath County, TX · 8 Jan 2008
Source: FAA radar · MUFON FOIA
Lights over Erath County
On 14 January 2008 the Associated Press reported that several dozen people around Stephenville, Texas, including a pilot, a county constable and business owners, said they had seen a large, silent object with bright lights flying low and fast; some said fighter jets were chasing it. Most of the sightings were reported for the night of 8 January [1].
Steve Allen, a freight company owner and pilot, told the AP that the object he saw was a mile long and half a mile wide. Erath County Constable Lee Roy Gaitan said he first saw red glowing lights and then white flashing lights moving fast, but could not see what they were attached to, even with binoculars. Machinist Ricky Sorrells described a flat, metallic object hovering about 300 feet over a pasture behind his home in Dublin, which he said he had seen several times; the report does not tie his sighting to 8 January [1].
I didn't see a flying saucer and I don't know what it was, but it wasn't an airplane
— Constable Lee Roy Gaitan, to the Associated Press [1]
From "no aircraft" to ten F-16s
In the same AP report, Maj. Karl Lewis, a spokesman for the 301st Fighter Wing at the Joint Reserve Base Naval Air Station in Fort Worth, said no F-16s or other aircraft from his base were in the area that night and suggested the lights were airliners catching the setting sun. Officials at Dyess and Sheppard Air Force Bases also said none of their aircraft were there [1].
On 23 January, CNN reported, an Air Force Reserve news release said an error had been made: ten F-16s from the 457th Fighter Squadron had been on a training mission in the Brownwood Military Operating Area between 6 and 8 p.m. on 8 January. Lewis attributed the mistake to an internal communications problem between offices at the base, and the release named the jets as the cause of the lights [2].
In the interest of public awareness, Air Force Reserve Command Public Affairs realized an error was made regarding the reported training activity of military aircraft
— Air Force Reserve news release, 23 January 2008, as quoted by CNN [2]
The FOIA radar study
Radar engineer Glen Schulze and Robert Powell, the Mutual UFO Network's director of research, sent Freedom of Information Act requests to the FAA and to military bases. The FAA's Fort Worth Air Route Traffic Control Center answered on 19 February 2008 with a CD of radar data [7], which the authors describe as about 2.8 million returns from five radar sites covering 4 to 8 p.m. [3]. The base released a logbook of the 457th Fighter Squadron that was mostly blacked out [3], and told Powell that the jets' onboard recording cartridges from 8 January had been overwritten [8].
In their MUFON report the authors traced ten jets from the Fort Worth base through the area in sorties of four, four and two, with only the lead aircraft using transponders, at about 15,000 to 17,000 feet over Stephenville [4]. They worked from 17 witness reports, withheld the witnesses' names for privacy, and credited Stephenville Empire-Tribune reporter Angelia Joiner with bringing many of them forward [10].
They also described returns without transponders near the witnesses' lines of sight: two detections after 6:15 p.m. which, if they were the same object, implied about 2,100 mph [4][5]; a slow target tracked for more than an hour on a course toward President Bush's Crawford ranch, 10 miles away when the data ended at 8 p.m.; and a return moving north at 1,900 mph at 7:26 p.m. [5].
What the data can and cannot show
The authors concluded that a real, physical object was present and that it was not any known aircraft. They also acknowledged that each high-speed return could have been a coincidental radar hit [6]. FAA primary radar does not measure an object's size [3], and the report notes that the nearest FAA antennas were not expected to see anything below about 2,700 feet near Stephenville because of the curvature of the earth [9].
Popular accounts often say FAA radar confirmed a giant craft. The FOIA data contain no size information, and much of the low-level flight that witnesses described would have been below the nearest antennas' coverage, so the links between radar returns and sightings rest on the MUFON authors' matching of times and directions.
No government body investigated the sightings; the AP noted that the Air Force no longer investigates UFOs [1]. The Air Force Reserve's training-flight explanation and the MUFON radar study remain the two documented positions on what was seen over Erath County [2][6].
Timeline
- 2008-01-08 Evening: residents around Stephenville and Dublin report bright, silent lights. [1]
- 2008-01-14 AP reports the sightings; the 301st Fighter Wing says none of its aircraft were in the area. [1]
- 2008-01-23 An Air Force Reserve release says ten F-16s were training nearby that evening. [2]
- 2008-02-19 The FAA sends Fort Worth Center radar data in reply to Schulze's FOIA request. [7]
- 2008-03-27 The 10th Air Force tells Powell the jets' recording files were overwritten. [8]
Evidence & sources
- www.nbcnews.com: AP, Angela K. Brown, 14 Jan 2008
- edition.cnn.com: CNN, 23 Jan 2008: Air Force correction
- zenodo.org — p. 5: MUFON radar report: FOIA data, logbook
- zenodo.org — p. 6: MUFON: ten jets, transponder use
- zenodo.org — p. 7: MUFON: unknown radar tracks
- zenodo.org — p. 47: MUFON report conclusions
- zenodo.org — p. 75: FAA FOIA reply letter, 19 Feb 2008
- zenodo.org — p. 67: Air Force FOIA reply, 27 Mar 2008
- zenodo.org — p. 11: MUFON: FAA radar low-altitude limit
- zenodo.org — p. 31: MUFON: witness reports, names withheld
Last fact-checked: 2026-10-03. Every claim cites its source.
More cold cases
- Belgian wave 1989–90
- Cash-Landrum 1980
- Caso Manises
- Chiles–Whitted 1948
- Condon Committee 1966
- Cosford 1993
- Coyne helicopter 1973
- El Bosque 2010
- Falcon Lake · Stefan Michalak
- Gimbal 2015
- JAL Flight 1628 over Alaska
- Levelland 1957
- Lubbock Lights 1951
- Mantell 1948
- McMinnville 1950
- Nimitz "Tic Tac" 2004
- O'Hare International 2006
- Operação Prato 1977
- Phoenix Lights 1997
- Rendlesham Forest 1980
- Robertson Panel 1953
- Roswell · Project Mogul
- Shag Harbour · Nova Scotia
- Socorro · Lonnie Zamora
- Tehran 1976
- The Kaikoura Lights
- Trans-en-Provence
- Travis Walton · Snowflake
- Trindade Island 1958
- Valensole 1965
- Varginha 1996