Travis Walton, 1975: what the polygraph records do and do not show
On the evening of 5 November 1975, a seven-man forestry crew led by Mike Rogers was leaving a thinning job in the Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest near Heber, Arizona, when, they said, they saw a glowing object hovering above a clearing. Crew member Travis Walton, 22, walked toward it; the others said a beam of light threw him back, and they drove off. They reported him missing to the Navajo County Sheriff's Office that night, and he was searched for until he telephoned from a Heber phone booth shortly after midnight on 11 November. A state polygraph examiner, testing the crew mainly to rule out foul play, judged five of the six truthful; polygraph tests of Walton himself later gave conflicting results.
34.5108° N · 110.0784° W · Apache-Sitgreaves NF, AZ · 5 Nov 1975
A light beside a logging road
No sheriff's office or Forest Service file on the case could be found for this review. The earliest detailed account is the one published in November 1975 by the Aerial Phenomena Research Organization (APRO), a Tucson UFO group that worked closely with the Walton family. According to APRO, at about 6:15 p.m. on 5 November 1975 Michael Rogers was driving his crew along a rough logging road in the Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest, about 15 miles south of Heber, Arizona. The men had been thinning trees under contract to the U.S. Forest Service; the crew was Rogers, 28, Travis Walton, 22, Ken Peterson, Duane Smith, Allen Dalis, John Goulette and Steve Pierce [1].
APRO's field investigator reported that the men saw a glowing object about 15 feet across hovering silently 15 to 20 feet above a pile of slash, some 75 to 90 feet from the truck. Walton jumped out and walked toward it. The others said a narrow ray of greenish-blue light struck him and threw him backwards; terrified, they drove off, then went back within about 15 minutes and found neither Walton nor the object [2].
Search and suspicion
APRO wrote that the crew notified Navajo County deputy sheriff Chuck Allison in Heber at 7:35 p.m., and that 40 to 50 men searched a radius of about two and a half miles the next day without result. The sheriff's office tested the site for radiation on 6 November and, a deputy said, found no significant readings above background; no landing marks or other physical traces were found [2][3]. The skeptic Philip Klass, writing in 1976, put the report more than two hours after the sighting and named the officer as Under-Sheriff L.C. Ellison [6].
On 10 November, with Walton still missing, C. E. Gilson, a polygraph examiner with the Arizona Department of Public Safety, tested the six crewmen in Holbrook [2]. In his report to Sheriff Marlin Gillespie, as reprinted by APRO, Gilson said the purpose was to find out whether any of them was concealing an aggravated assault or homicide against Walton. Three of his four relevant questions dealt with injuring Walton or hiding his body; the fourth asked whether they had told the truth about seeing a UFO. He judged Goulette, Smith, Peterson, Rogers and Pierce truthful and called the sixth result inconclusive [5]; APRO identified that man as Dalis [2].
These polygraph examinations prove that these five men did see some object that they believe to be a UFO and that Travis Walton was not injured or murdered by any of these men
— C. E. Gilson, Arizona Department of Public Safety, report to Sheriff Gillespie [5]
The return
A few minutes after midnight on 11 November, Walton telephoned his sister's home from a booth at a Heber service station; his brother-in-law Grant Neff and brother Duane found him slumped on the floor of the booth [3]. As APRO reported his account, he woke on a table in a room with three hairless beings about five feet tall with large eyes, later met a man in blue clothing and a transparent helmet, lost consciousness when something like an oxygen mask was put over his face, and came to on a road near Heber as a disc-shaped craft rose above him [3].
Duane took him to Phoenix that day [6]. APRO said two physicians examined him at its request and that blood and urine tests showed no evidence of drug use. Walton did not keep an appointment for a polygraph test; APRO blamed reporters camped at the family home and the test site [4].
Polygraph results that conflict
In June 1976 Klass reported that Walton had taken an earlier test on 15 November 1975, given by John J. McCarthy of the Arizona Polygraph Laboratory, arranged by APRO's L.J. Lorenzen and paid for by the National Enquirer. Klass said he had examined McCarthy's consent form and his written report of 16 November, which found "gross deception" [6][7]. Klass noted that APRO's November bulletin, which covered that week, did not mention the test [7].
On 7 February 1976 Walton and his brother took tests from George J. Pfeifer which, according to published reports, they passed [6]. Klass wrote that Pfeifer's employer, Tom Ezell, told him the Waltons had dictated the questions and that the charts would not be readable either way [9]. Gilson himself told Klass that his test had been meant to establish whether a crime had been committed, and that its single UFO question "does not make it a valid test as far as verifying the UFO incident" [8].
The case is often summed up as one in which the crew passed lie-detector tests that confirmed an abduction. The records show a state test designed mainly to rule out a crime, one inconclusive result among the crew, and contradictory results for Walton himself.
attempting to perpetrate a UFO hoax, and that he has not been on any spacecraft.
— John J. McCarthy, report of 16 November 1975, as quoted by Philip Klass [7]
What the record supports
Klass also argued that Rogers had a motive: his Forest Service thinning contract was behind schedule and due for completion on 10 November 1975 [8]. APRO, for its part, reported that Walton's account had not changed in any detail [4]. Every source used here comes from one of these two opposing camps; none is an official record. Together they show that Walton was reported missing on 5 November, was searched for, reappeared shortly after midnight on 11 November, and that a state examiner found five crewmen truthful on narrow questions. They do not establish what, if anything, the crew saw.
Timeline
- 1975-11-05 About 6:15 p.m.: Rogers' crew reports a glowing object; Walton goes missing. [1]
- 1975-11-06 About 40 to 50 searchers comb the area without finding Walton. [2]
- 1975-11-10 C. E. Gilson polygraphs the six crewmen in Holbrook. [5]
- 1975-11-11 Shortly after midnight, Walton calls his sister's home from a Heber phone booth. [3]
- 1975-11-15 John J. McCarthy tests Walton and reports deception, according to Klass. [7]
- 1976-02-07 George J. Pfeifer tests Travis and Duane Walton. [6]
Evidence & sources
- archive.org — p. 1: APRO Bulletin Nov 1975: crew and setting
- archive.org — p. 2: APRO: sighting, report, search, polygraph
- archive.org — p. 3: APRO: site check, return, Walton's account
- archive.org — p. 5: APRO: medical tests, missed polygraph
- archive.org — p. 5: Gilson's DPS report, reprinted by APRO
- archive.org — p. 4: Klass 1976: summary, McCarthy test arranged
- archive.org — p. 5: Klass: McCarthy result and report
- archive.org — p. 10: Klass: Gilson interview, contract deadline
- archive.org — p. 6: Klass: Ezell on Pfeifer test
Last fact-checked: 2026-10-03. Every claim cites its source.
More cold cases
- Belgian wave 1989–90
- Cash-Landrum 1980
- Caso Manises
- Chiles–Whitted 1948
- Condon Committee 1966
- Cosford 1993
- Coyne helicopter 1973
- El Bosque 2010
- Falcon Lake · Stefan Michalak
- Gimbal 2015
- JAL Flight 1628 over Alaska
- Levelland 1957
- Lubbock Lights 1951
- Mantell 1948
- McMinnville 1950
- Nimitz "Tic Tac" 2004
- O'Hare International 2006
- Operação Prato 1977
- Phoenix Lights 1997
- Rendlesham Forest 1980
- Robertson Panel 1953
- Roswell · Project Mogul
- Shag Harbour · Nova Scotia
- Socorro · Lonnie Zamora
- Stephenville · Texas
- Tehran 1976
- The Kaikoura Lights
- Trans-en-Provence
- Trindade Island 1958
- Valensole 1965
- Varginha 1996