Home › Archive › Royal New Zealand Air Force
NZ-AIR-1080-6-897-Volume-1-1978-1981 — AIR 1080/6/897 Volume 1: RNZAF investigations of unidentified and radar sightings, east coast South Island, December 1978 (Kaikoura)
File NZ-AIR-1080-6-897-Volume-1-1978-1981 is a declassified pdf from Royal New Zealand Air Force, recording an incident dated Dec 1978 at Kaikoura, New Zealand. This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.
- File
- NZ-AIR-1080-6-897-Volume-1-1978-1981
- Agency
- Royal New Zealand Air Force
- Incident date
- Dec 1978
- Location
- Kaikoura, New Zealand
- File type
Cited in: Kaikoura 1978: what the RNZAF and DSIR files concluded
The New Zealand Defence Force file AIR 1080/6/897 Volume 1 (1978–1981) on the December 1978 Kaikoura sightings: radar returns and lights reported by Wellington air traffic control and Safe Air Argosy crews on 20/21 and 30/31 December 1978, correspondence, and the RNZAF's Report on Unidentified Visual and Radar Sightings East Coast South Island December 1978 (11 January 1979, from p.191). 206 pages. Released by the New Zealand Defence Force in 2010 under the Official Information Act. © Crown copyright, New Zealand; reproduced for non-commercial reference. Catalogue record: National Library of New Zealand.
Open original file · NATLIB.GOVT.NZ page
TL;DR
At 206 pages, even the lights got lost in the footnotes.
- RNZAF AIR 1080/6/897 Vol 1, released 2010, covers Dec 1978 Kaikoura east-coast sightings.
- Reports bright flashing lights, radar returns on 20/21 and 30/31 Dec, pilot interviews, film analysis.
- Most explained by atmosphere; some remain unresolved.
AI summary
A 1978 report compiled by the Royal New Zealand Air Force (RNZAF) details investigations into unidentified visual and radar sightings along the east coast of South Island, particularly near Kaikoura, in December 1978. The document includes interviews with pilots, technical reports, and analysis of radar and film footage. It describes sightings of bright lights, flashing objects, and radar targets, with some objects appearing lower than aircraft. Various explanations are considered, including atmospheric effects, celestial bodies like Venus, and radar anomalies. Some sightings are attributed to natural phenomena, while others remain unexplained. The report also covers technical details of radar equipment and includes a restricted section concluding that most sightings were caused by natural atmospheric conditions rather than unidentified aerial phenomena.
Full text
Page 1
Copy 14 of 36
NEW ZEALAND DEFENCE FORCE
UNIDENTIFIED FLYING OBJECTS (UFO) FILES
COPIES FOR RELEASE TO THE PUBLIC
File Number: AIR 1080 / 6 / 897 Volume 1
File Title: Investigations of Unidentified & Radar Sightings
East Coast South Island - December 1978
File Timespan: Opened: 1978 - Closed 1981
File Declassified: December 2010
Location of Original File: Held at Headquarters NZDF
Access to Original File: Restricted until 2051
File Contains: Interviews with people involved in the 1978
Kaikoura sightings conducted by the RNZAF preparatory to
the preparation of a formal report into these sightings. File
also contains technical reports from DsiR and other scientific
experts and an independent report of the Kaikoura sightings
by the NZ UFO Studies Centre.
Page 2
NEW ZEALAND DEFENCE FORCE
PUBLIC RELEASE OF UNIDENTIFIED FLYING OBJECTS
(UFO) FILES
These copied and redacted files of correspondence on Unidentified Flying
Objects dating from 1952 to 2009 have been Declassified and released to the
public by the New Zealand Defence Force under the Official Information Act.
Access to the original files held by Archives New Zealand is restricted up until
the year 2080 for Personal Privacy reasons. These copied files have had the
personal details of members of the public making UFO reports removed to
preserve their privacy. Personal details of service personnel and civilians
employed by the New Zealand Defence Force and other Government
Departments and Agencies have not been removed. No other information
has been removed or omitted from these files.
GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF FILES
Correspondence on Flying Saucers began in New Zealand Defence Force
files in 1952 and continued under different names, Unidentified Flying Objects
(UFO) and Unidentified Aerial Sightings (UAS) until the present. The files
contain reports of sightings by private individuals and military personnel,
investigations by Defence and other Government Departments and agencies
into these reports, newspaper clippings on UFOs and letters from individuals
who claim to be in touch with alien beings and craft.
While the files are in general date order from 1952 until the present some file
periods overlap with one another and the documents within each file are not
necessarily in strict date order. There can be duplicate documents within
each file and copies of the same documents (particularly media releases and
reports) can appear in different files.
ACCESS TO UFO FILES
These redacted files are available in hard copy from the Defence Library c/o
Headquarters New Zealand Defence Force Aitken St Wellington. They are
not available in electronic format.
Page 3
NZ DEFENCE FORCE AIR
AIR 1080/6/897 VOL. 1 DEPARTMENT:
File No.
SERIES: . GENERAL ADMINISTRATION,
ORGANISATION & MANAGEMENT -
CU_-9-8b10 BOARDS OF INQUIRY & SUMMARY
SUB SERIES: INVESTIGATIONS TE SIHLOL SSHOOV OE
SUBJECT: INVESTIGATIONS OF UNIDENTIFIED
VISUAL & RADAR SIGHTINGS EAST COAST
SOUTH ISLAND - DECEMBER 1978
File Opened: DEC 78 File Closed: JuL 81
Previous File: Subsequent File: :
CANDIS • • ••
OTHER RELEVANT FILES
Subject: File No.
WAS. 17/4/897 01
.preiously 39/3/3
CLOSED 0.
01 swaswhs
( DISPOSAL CATEGORY:
Page 4
STAFF IN CONFIDENCE
File No. AIR 17/4/897
Volume No. ONE 2
SUBJECT (Or NAME): COURTS OF ENQUIRY : INVESTIGATION OF
UNIBENTIFIED- VISUAL AND RADAR SIGHTINGS
EAST COAST SOUTH ISLAND DECEMBER 1978.
File Opened Dec 78 File Closed:. JUL 81
Previous File: Subsequent File:
OTHER RELEVANT FILES
Subject: File No.
..REPORTS...OF.U.F.O.'S. AIR 39/3/3
Copy of CaDmot tape held i Dops sate
Cleared, Date Cleared,
Folio Referred to Date Folio Referred to Initials
Initials
FICE D8S 9JuL81 a
PLANSI 11 MAR 08
Sup Reg (F) 11/3/09
25/6/59 a1m25/0
Page 5
VETTING RECORD SHEET
PLEASE COMPLETE ONLY ONE PAGE PER RECORD
NZDF STORAGE NO 8354
*HQ NZDE/ARMY/NAVX/AIR FORCE/JSO- FILE *Delete as appropriate
FILE NO 1080/4/897 LOCATION Z FRB
PART NO TYPE F NFM
(File or Non File Material)
Series BENBRAL AMUMLSIRATON AND MANALEMENT
SUb-SeriES BOARSOF INGURL AN SUMARY INNESMBATIONS
Date of first document 22/12/ 27 EAS LOAST SXUTH ISDANEEMBER 1978 Date of last document 121711981
Please Tick the Appropriate Boxes:
No NZ Documents on File No Foreign Source Classified Documents on File
No Classified Documents on File Some Foreign or Special-Source Documents
placed on restricted Parallel File
Some NZ (Non-NZDF) Documents placed on
NZ Documents Cleared for Access Restricted Parallel File
Some All Classified Foreign Source
No Classified NZ Documents on File or Documents Cleared for Access
OR
Release on 1 AN in the Year 2051
Review again before the Year 20
VETTING COMMENTS IF NECESSARY
Rile cains copy of the taikas Sglligs De78!
Tivephiggli, aid sxidod poper fud coneyondee
Felilinl to sthar sisbligs
Filratety DSIR.
PUBLIC ACCESS TO THIS FILE
IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PRIVACY
Ra-Vetting Commenced 2 /12/10 PROVISIONS OF SECTION 9 OF THE
OFFICIAL INFORMATION ACT 1982.
Re-Vetting Completed_2 /12/10 Dabia
SIGNED
STAMP (place relevant NZDF decision STAMP7here, zign and date) DATED. 2/12/10
Page 6
File Number 1080/689.7..Vol N...
FILE RELEASE STATEMENT
VETTING COMPLETED AND:
L No classified documents on file.
NZDF documents have been declassified
Other NZ Govt Dept classified documents have been eleared for access ~
Foreign Source classified documents have been eleared for access
Some foreign or special source documents have been placed on-a~
restricted parallel file (see separation sheets herewith recording transfer).
Other comments:
and.prciahed pper, aa kenepandens. relabed bother Sghings.
Signed.. Dah Date..12/..
For Headquarters New Zealand Defence Force
NB: Classified documents of other New Zealand
Departments where there is some concern about
declassifying them should be referred to the relevant
department.
Page 7
AUIIUN DIIDUI
ON COMPLETE ON RECORDS BELOW THIS *
PAPER
Personnel other than Registry staff are
NOT
to place documents below this paper.
Documents may be placed above this paper for action/filing.
Enclosure numbers are not to be issued.
NOTE:
1. The position of this sheet in file MUST NOT be
4 changed except by Registry staff.
2. File maintenance remains a Registry responsibility and
users are reminded that papers are to be filed/removed by
Registry staff only.
Page 9
174 1897
44/854
2 J0ly 1941
Mr Quantin,Fogerty
11 Metung St
Victopia 3103
AUSTRALIA
Dear quentin,
Thank you for your letter seeking a copy of the
report of Captain Randle concerning the light sightings off
the Kaikoura coast in 197i.
I have this day dispatched bwo copies of the report
to Captain Randle, along with a copy of this letter. Presumably,
as he has indicated his willingness to let you have a copy of
his report, he will forward a copy to you in due course.
Kind regards,
Yours faithfully,
.….…
GTCLARKE)
Wing Commander
lfy to beft Saulk Director of Public Relations
2ugestin be miy 7
lie to fod to fog
3/2/1 fo litis Atoff)
1.4
:.
i
Page 10
MINUTE SHEET Department:
Subject: File No...
KANKOURA UFO QNTNES Date:....
1. Ioith t eops of Vn msten
To ppand by Cipstain Randde. Lgis lend
We shodd setai te creginal
Gostoni Bandl stoudd pass On to
. Gnentin Jogartey tihatern tn trites bent
w shond snat dedien amgthnig to Iegardey.
2 Pleon sede Copin 8f the Joquty
leten snd yon Jrespore to bin ceand
Wo, Co
18Jmn87 Dafs
GYLES!
Item 504
Page 11
MINUTE SHEET Department:D/R
SUBJECT:STATEMENNT : LIFO SIGNTINIGI FileN. 4/3//
Date: -6
To Me se hthe bh gshing the
SASOY atutend gin t she Rnzte hy buft fukn
farsthk duing the omilution of the fort
Do we have this by the thin D ope.
report! 430 2 Y sufy of buft Rughh slukmend
e shenld ietenn in atil huld / /ul usttue te pue it
it to lunallk td to hi th wy r Fopy
alengrith thee
lotter. f. Note bay Dsps
We aon toduin otigrd and copy to ly bith
Randle. t cn pss o. t. Fagy 1DPR
-m 504 56519680
Page 12
11 Metung St
Balwyn
Victoria 3103
. Australia
June 10, 1981
Dear Geoff,
I hope this letter reaches you, as I have no way of
knowing whether or not you are still with the Ministry of Defence.
If you have moved on, and this letter is opened by someone in the
public relations section, then I hope they can act on my request.
I have written a book on the UFo sightings off the
Kaikoura Coast in December 1978 and it it has been accepted for
publication. My publisher is keen for me to expand the section
dealing with the December 21 incidents and I have written to a
number of the witnesses for additional information. One of those I
contacted was Captain John Randle who told me he had no desire to
go over the .whole thing again, so much later. However, he did tell
me that he supplied the RNZAF with a written summary of the incidents
and he said that if I was able to obtain that summary, or a copy, then
I could use the information. ' He told me that the RNZAF had indicated they would return
the summary, but apparently that has not been done. I would appreciate
a copy of the summary , or the summary itself. If you would like to
verify Capt. Randle's approval for me to use the summary, may I sugges
you contact him at I am working to a deadline and whatever your decision, I
would appreciate being informed as soon as possible.
Xindregards
Quentin Togarty Koufis
Page 13
NEW ZEALAND UFO STUDIES CENTRE (NUSC)
Dr.J.F.deBock
5 Ngahue Crescent,
ELSDON.
5 June, 1979 39/313
Ministry of Defence, REFERRED TO
Private Bag,
WELLINGTON. 1 2 JUN 1979
REGISTRY HEOTRS
Dear Sir,
Please find enclosed a copy of the provisional report made
by Dr.Bruce Maccabee on the Kaikoura UFO case. Through
our contacts with CuFOs (Centre for UFo studies) and MuFON
(Mutual UFo Network)in the USA, the report was forwarded to
us. In a personal letter, Dr.Maccabee requested us to send
copies to those who have been involved in the investigation.
Copies are being sent to DSIR, Met.Office, Civil Aviation,
Ministry of Defence, Carter Observatory and Wellington Air
Traffic Control.
Although Dr.Maccabee has released the copyright for some parts
of the report, we still have to emphasise its confidential
character. MuFON will publish the complete report, while the
magazine "Nature" will issue a more technical article on the
New Zealand case.
I would like to take the opportunity to inform you of the frequent
sightings reported to us. Most of which can easily be explained
after an initial investigation with the limited aids in our hands.
However, some sightings have to remain unexplained since we are
unable to obtain sufficient background information from such
institutions as yours. With this problem in view we would be
very grateful if you could advise us in future on those limited
unexplained cases. In several overseas countries this assistance
has led to the setting up of an advisory committee, with speciaiists
in various fields. The aim of the committee, which only meets
when necessary (perhaps twice a year) is to come to a natural
explanation of the more complicated sightings, to avoid the pubiic
phoning your institutions, and to reduce speculation that reported
sightings are Flying Saucers, space-ships and other types of so
called extraterrestrial manifestations.
We already have the promise of a representative from a few
institutions, and we would be grateful if you could consider your
participation as well in the advisory committee.
Page 14
- 2 -
3
if you wish to have additional information on similar set ups
in overseas countries, please do not hesitate to contact us.
I thank you in advance, and hope the report enclosed shows the
serious approach into this field of unidentified aerial phenomena.
Yours sincerely,
LF.De Bock.
Page 16
CONTENTS
1
Introduction
The Investigation m
Sources of Information
Sunmary of Events 9
Event Descriptions and Map Legend 15
Analysis of Events
Technical Details for the Flight South 30
Technical Details for the Flight North 33
:
Natural and Artificial Sources of Light 34
Analysis of the Wellington Radar Sightings 35
*
Analysis of Radar-Visual Sightings 46
∞www∞∞∞ww∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞wz∞∞∞ Analysis of the Film Obtained :nea Christchurch -patil anclya I
Analysis of the Film Obtained :last sequence-none dou yet
Appendices (where available)
A. Transcript of the Wellington Control Tower Tape
B.. Transcript of Quentin Fogarty's Tape
4.
—ww/
Page 17
7
.•
Sources of Information
The primary sources of information are the memories of
the eight witnesses who were involved. These memories contain
a wealth of information which, nevertheless, is "soft information".
However ., this case is unique for the amount of hard information
which was available after the events were over. The hard
information includes a. tape recording of the conversations
between the Wellington ATc Center and the aircraft. This recording
establishes an irrefutable time Iine for the events. Then
there is the tape made on the aircraft by Quentin Fogarty
(how many UFo sightings have information recorded in situ ?).
Although this tape cannot be exactly synchronized with the
Wellington tape, the approximate times of Fogarty's statements
can be determined from the content (he occasionally repeated
what Wellington had told the plane). Then there are scribbled
pencil notes by Dennis Grant, the Christchurch N.Z. reporter.
(He took the place of the cameraman's wife, Ngaire Crockett,
on the trip northd He was apparently the only one who actually
wrote anything down during the sightings. And finally, there
is the film, which is a veritable tour de force of UFo images.
The film contains pictures of airport lights (landings and
takeoffs), pictures of the airplane cockpit, pictures of
Quentin Fogarty at Christchurch Airport, and pictures of......
UFOs. The landing light sequences and the cockpit sequences
serve to establish that the film was taken from inside the
aircraft. A study of the edge numbers of the original film
(edge numbers are put on by the manufacturer) shows that they
are continuous, except for a change in film at Christchurch
(they needed a new roll for the journey north). Thus the film
is not a hoax. The landing light sequences provide color and
brightness information which can be used to calibrate the
film and the optical quality of the airplane window. All of
this hard information (acoustic and optical) is supplemented
by the memories of five witnesses on the aircraft at any time.
and one or two witnesses at the Wellington ATc( two witnesses
for part of the trip south, one witness at all other times).
As the interviews proceeded I found that the statements of the
various witnesses tended to complement rather than contradict
one another. There were some variations in descriptions of
events, etc., as might be expected from different observers
after a time lapse of over a month, but I found no outright -4.
contradictions. To my surprise (and delight) almost every new
*bit " of information I learned supported rather than contradicted
Page 18
·8
the previous "bits". From this wealth of information I have
abstracted a summary of the events which, when read in
conjunction with the "Event Descriptions and Map Legend"
will give the reader an overview of the N.Z. Radar-Visual
UFO case. The associated maps, Figures I and 2, show the
overall path of the aircraft as a dashed line. The T shaped
symbols represent the aircraft at various points along the
path and the numbers refer to events in the "Event" sheet.
The events are primarily those associated with radar
targets referred to by Wellington Arc. Specifically, the
location of the airplane each time Wellington referred to J
a target(or targets)is shown on the map. The locations
are believed to be accurate to within I or 2 miles. The
specific radar target.(s) associated with a specific position
of the airplane is (are) connected to the airplane symbol
by a line(s). The events that occurred as the plane flew
away from Christchurch(#2l-27) are reconstructed from the
witness statements about what they saw and what the airplane
radar screen showed. The path of the plane from Event # 25
to Event #27 is approximate and is subject to further
revision. The path of the object was estimated from witness
statements, airplane radar data, and from the image sizes
on the film. The film image sizes (except when defocussed)
are never larger then several milliradians in angular size.
Assuming that the object was of a fixed size , this means that
it never was closer than some minimum distance, probably about
1o miles, during the time it was being filmed . On the other
hand Fogarty remembers looking almost straight down on the object
out the right window (his last view of it) , and the captain is
quite certain that the plane passed over it. At these times the
cameraman was not able to film it because it was moving rapidly
with respect to the plane and because the film magazine and the
overall size of his camera made it difficult to shoot at large
downward angles (for example, the top of the film magazine could
have bumped some of the overhead switches in the cockpit).
The remainder of the airplane path (everything except 25-27)
is reconstructed from the standard flight plans and from the
memory of the Wellington Air Traffic Controller, Geoffrey Causer.
To obtain a good impression of the bewildering number of
unusual occurrances during those early morning flights I
suggest that the reader read the sunumary first and then read
.the "Event" sheet, paying rather careful attention to the details 4
of the events.
Page 19
9 Copyright, B.S.Maccabee
1979
Summary :of Events
(NOTE: all miles are nautical and times are local D.s.T.)
, ·· FLIGHT SOUTH
At 11:46 pm on December 30, 1978, a four-engine turbo prop Argosy
freighter left Wellington, N.Z., on a standard Saturday evening-Sunday
morning newspaper delivery run, from Blenheim, N.Z., to Wellington to
Christchurch, and then back to Blenheim. Aboard the aircraft were the
pilot, Captain Bill Startup, the co-pilot, Robert Guard, the
Australian news reporter, Quentin Fogarty, and a film crew which
consisted of the cameraman, David Crockett, and his wife, Ngaire,
wbo: Operated the tape recorder.
the reporter and film crew had been commissioned by a Melbourne Tv station vi'-
-to fly to Christchurch to obtain film footage for use in a news story about
a previous UFo sighting that had been made by pilots on a similar aircraft
flight. During the flight south the pilot and co-pilot observed lights
that were first seen in the direction of Kaikoura, from a point just
and.Event.Sheet Coincidentally, Wellington radar
picked up and reported targets which were in the vicinity of the plane.
It appears that at least two, and perhaps several, of these anomalous
radar targets were observed by the passengers on the plane.
color film,
-The cameraman obtained 16mm footage of the inside of the plane, the
lights of Kaikoura, and of anomalous bright objects that were seen occasion-
ally in the 12:00 to 3:00 (front to rightside) quadrant with respect to
the direction of travel. The reporter recorded on-the-spot comments and
descriptions and occasionally referred to statements made by Wellington Air Traffi
Control (Arc).The anomalous lights seen on the trip south were observed
to be mainly in the direction of Kaikoura or ahead of the plane, except
for one, which was seen off the right wing after the plane was south of
Kaikoura.
Radar targets that were reported to the plane by the Wellington
: ATc i"within about 20 miles of the plane as it travelled from a point just 4.
south of Cape Campbell to a point about 57 miles northeast of Christchurch.
The airplane radar was not used on the flight south.
One particularly interesting sequence of events involving
Page 20
10
Wellington ATc occurred just after the plane had turned toward
christchurch at a non-geographic reporting point called "Kaikoura
East" (see map). The plane had shifted to the Christchurch
communication frequency when Wellington saw a target appear
behind the plane about one or two miles (Event Sheet # 12 )
Wellington told the Christchurch controller, who asked the plane
to shift_back to the Wellington frequency. Wellington then told that
the plane\the target was about four miles behind them. About half
a minute later Wellington said there was a further target about
four miles to the right of the plane. About 45 seconds after that
Wellington told the plane that something was flying in formation
with it. . The plane and the unidentified target flew side by
side for at least half a minute, after which the radar target reduced
'to that of the plane alone (Event Sheet #l5 and 16). About a
minute later the plane contacted Wellington and reported
a"target", which was a flashing light, at the right of and
falling.behind the airplane.(Event Sheet # I7). Wellington
agreed that there was a target at the right of the plane that
was drifting behind as the plane moved forward.
The plane landed at Christchurch, N.Z., at 1:Ol AM,December 3]. While
newspapers were being unloaded the crew discussed the sightings with the
Christchurch radar operator, who described to the crew an anomalous target
that was not particularly impressive to him. In order to obtain more film
footage, Crockett and Fogarty.: decided to fly back to Blenheim. One of
the passengers, the wife of the cameraman, decided not to make the return
flight and her place was taken by a reporter from Christchurch,Dennis Grant, a
personal friend of the Australian reporter (the only person involved that the
Australian reporter had known before the flight).
FLIGHT NORTH
. The plane left Christchurch on its flight north to Blenheim at 2:l6 am.
About 3 minutes later, as the plane climbed through a low cloud cover, the
pilot, co-pilot, and cameraman, who were all in the cockpit at the time,
observed a bright yellow/white/orange light apparently at about their level,
which would appear and disappear through the tops of the clouds. It was 4.
between l0 and 30 degrees to the right of the aircraft, which was flying
northeast. This light was pointed out to the two reporters who arrived in
Page 21
11
the cockpit several minutes after the takeoff. The captain obtained a
strong return from his radar which was operated in its "mapping mode."
The size of the radar "blip" was estimated by the flight crew to have been
3 to 5 times larger thanthe blip from a large fishing boat. The flight crew
and the Christchurch reporter, who had a good view of the radar display and of
the object, repeatedly compared the direction of the bright light with that
of the target as indicated by the azimuth markers on the radar screen. They
assured themselves that the radar target and the bright light were in the
same direction. The radar distance was initially l8-20 miles. As the plane
proceeded along a straight northeasterly path and climbed to its cruising
altitude, the distance to the bright light gradually decreased, as indicated
by the radar, and the sighting line tended to move around to the right. By
the time the plane was about 1) minutes (32 miles) out of Christchurch at^of an altitude
1l,500 ft the bright light was about 70 to 90 degrees to the right of the
aircraft (southeast of the aircraft) and about 12 miles away and no longer
on the plane radar. All observers agreed that the object appeared to be at
a lower altitude than the aircraft, with depression angles below horizontal
estimated to be between 5 degrees and 30 degrees. The radarin the map mode
could only pick up targets with depression angles between about 3 and 15
below the centerline of the aircraft.
The cameraman obtained several minutes of film out the far right-hand
cockpit window during this period. Images on the film range from yellowish
white elliptical shapes with reddish fringes to overexposed, nearly triangular
and circular shapes. Typical angular sizes were on the order of l-2 milli-
radians. He also obtained several feet of film showing a cockpit meter just
below the image of the bright light. At about 12-13 minutes (35-38 miles)
out of Christchurch the plane reached 13 thousand feet and a speed of 2l5 knots.
At this time the flight crew decided to turn to the right toward the bright
light. As the plane turned, the sighting line to the object moved toward the
front-of the aircraft, but even after a turn of about 90 degrees, the object
*-Divide the distance to the object by looo and multiply by the
number of milliradians to find the size. For example, an angular 4.
size of l milliradian corresponds to an object size of l foot at
l000 feet: ( 1000 feet/l00o)x(1 millirad.) = 1 ft.
Page 22
12
was not directly ahead of the aircraft, as if the object had moved to the right.
The captain proceeded in a straight line along a southeast heading and again
the sighting line to the object moved from nearly directly ahead toward 90
degrees to the right as the plane flew. The depression angle below horizontal
was apparently very noticable at this time. The object was not picked up on
radar after the turn, even though the object was nearly ahead of the aircraft
immediately after the turn, which suggests that the depression angle was
greater than 15 degrees. After travelling on this new heading for 1 or A min-
utes, the captain began a turn to the left back toward his original flight
path, at which time the light was observed to move quickly to the left-front and
above the aircraft and then to the left and down and apparently below the air-
craft. The object was not seen again after the plane .completed its left turn.
During the time that this object was seen by the plane passengers, it was
not seen on the Christchurch or Wellingtqn radars. This may have been because radar
it was too low to be picked up by either,and/or because it was a weak target
for 50cm radar.
After the aircraft gained its original course and approached a point south-
east of Kaikoura, Wellington control tower again began to call the attention of
the flight crew to anomalous targets which were within 20 miles of the
plane as it travelled toward Cape Campbell. Occasionally, unusual bright lights at least
were visible in the directions indicated by the Wellington control, and in,one
instance the plane radar picked up a target that appeared to the captain to be
in the same position as that indicated by Wellington control. There were also
apparently temporal coincidences between appearances and disappearances of visual
and radar objects.
One particularly bright object that was seen as the plane
approached Cape Campbell was photographed by the cameraman. The
film shows a bright light which alternates in a regular,cyclic
manner from bright white to dim red and orange. It apparently
travelled in a series of loops, described as "rolling and tumbling"
by.the reporter ( see Event #33 ).
The plane landed at Blenheim airfield at about 3:lo A.M. 4.
Page 23
13
174
2
NELSON WELLINGTON
PICTON
COOK
BLENHEIM. € STRAIT
Approximate
24 hour
FIGURE 1 clock times
FLIGHT SOUTH CAPE
CAMPBELL 0010
3 0012
④ 0015
0016
173 0016:30
0017:30
CLARENCE 0019
RIVER 9
0022
KAIKOURA 10 0024
KAIKOURA
PENINSULA EAST 0028
0029
0029:30
0030
430
0030: 45
0031:30
150
0032:30
0035
0036:30
0101
CHRISTCHURCH
BANKS
PENINSULA.
(copyright,
B.S.Maccabee, 19
wwwwwmwww
Page 24
14
WELLINGTON
PICTON
NELSON
COOK
BLENHEIM STRAIT
'FIGURE 2 40 0259
FLIGHT NORTH 0257
0256
CAPE 08098
CAMPBELL 0255
0254
0253
34 0252
0251
0248:30
CLARENCE 668 0247
RIVER 0246
KAIKOURA ②9 0245
PENINSULA 28 0241
KAIKOURA
EAST
"MOTO ,
②7 0233
-Approximate path of plane
26 0231
(Estimated path of object 0229
)based on plane radar data
Cand witness statements. ②4 .0227
0221:30
CHRISTCHURCH 0218:40
0216
BANKS
PENINSULA 50 N.M.
(copyright,
B.S.Maccabee, 1979)
wwxr.o.ww
Page 25
15
Event Descriptions and Map Legend
Times are in local Daylight Savings Time and are accurate to
within one minute. Distances are in nautical miles (6o76 ft
or l.852 km). At the cruising altitude the plane travelled
at an air speed of about 3.6 miles/minute.
*
During the trip south the people aboard the plane were Captain
william Startup (s), First Officer Robert Guard (G), cameraman
David Crockett (Dc) , sound recordist Ngaire Crockett (Nc) and
reporter Quentin Fogarty (F). The Wilington Air Traffic Controller
was Geoffrey Causer (Gc). For part of the time the radar
technician, Bryan Chalmers (Bc) was also present. GC used a
radar scope which presented an MrI (moving target indicator)
processed radar picture; Bc operated a non-MTI display for part
of the time. The plane (P) is treated as an "entity" when com-
municating with Wellington radar (w). Christchurch is noted as CH.
During the trip north Nc was replaced by a Christchurch reporter,
Dennis Grant (DG).
This event listing is to be used with the especially marked maps
.(Figures 3 and 4).
TRIP SOUTH
EVENT DESCRIPTION
NUMBER
1 about 2354 (11:54 P.M.), Dec. 30, 1978 : the plane has
taken off and circled to head southand was at this time passing
over Wellington.
2 about 001o ( 10 min. after midnight), Dec. 31, 1978 (all
succeeding times are on this date) : the plane was passing or
had passed Cape Campbell. F,Dc, and NC were in the loading
bay working on a "standup" for the news story on the previous
UFO sightings when S and G first spotted lights in the direction
of Kaikoura. The plane had passed Io,ooo feet in. altitude and
was travelling at about I7o knots air speed (the ground speed
might have been about l8o knots since there was a slight wind).
4.
3 about Ool2 : the plane (P) contacted Wellington(w) and
asked "Do you have any targets in the direction of the Kaikoura
peninsula on your radar at about that range?" (approximately
w-wwvwww……w
Page 26
16
correct; the radio communications from the plane are difficult
to understand). W replied " There are targets in your one
o'clock (1:00) position (i.e., about 20-4o° to the right of
straight ahead) at, uh, 13 miles.....appearing and disappearing.
......At the present moment they're not showing......but were
showing about a minute ago." Gc had been noticing "weird"
targets east of the Clarence River area and the Kaikoura Coast
for as long as half an hour before the plane reported anything.
s and G reported seeing lights that would appear and then
disappear in an apparently random manner, which is consistent
with the appearance and disappearance of targets on the W
radar.