DOW-UAP-D151 — AAWSAP DIRD, Cognitive Limits on Simultaneous Control of Multiple Unmanned Spacecraft, December 2010
File DOW-UAP-D151 is a declassified pdf from Department of War, recording an incident dated 12/15/10 at Las Vegas, Nevada, published in Release 06 (2026-09-18). This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.
- File
- DOW-UAP-D151
- Agency
- Department of War
- Incident date
- 12/15/10
- Location
- Las Vegas, Nevada
- Released in
- Release 06 (2026-09-18)
- File type
Topics: AAWSAP & DIRDs
This document is a Defense Intelligence Reference Document (DIRD), a technical reference format used by the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) to capture baseline knowledge on a specific topic for later analytic use. DIRDs are best understood as reference and synthesis products rather than as original research. It is one of 38 DIRDs produced under the Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Applications Program (AAWSAP) between 2009 and 2011. Because AAWSAP’s scope permitted a broad range of supporting topics, not every DIRD in the series directly concerns aerospace systems or future threat assessment. The following summary reflects the DIRD’s scope and framing at the time of writing and should not be read as implying current validation of the concepts discussed.
This DIRD examines how many unmanned spacecraft a single human operator could realistically supervise or control at once, using research from air traffic control and multi-vehicle remote piloting as rough analogs. The report argues that the practical limit depends heavily on task complexity: about 16 craft for simple monitoring or destination assignment, about 7 for moderately complex piloting or mission tasks, and about 4 for complex heterogeneous operations. It places particular emphasis on the operator’s ability to maintain a coherent mental “big picture” of multiple vehicles at once, and it suggests that automation and external displays can help by offloading working-memory demands, though not eliminating them. The document also highlights physiological workload measures as a possible way to detect or predict operator overload in real time. Overall, it presents multi-spacecraft control as a human-factors and systems-integration problem in which progress depends on managing cognitive limits through interface design, automation, and workload monitoring.
Open original file · WAR.GOV page
TL;DR
Even in 2010, multitasking still hit a four-craft ceiling.
- DoW DIRD D151, Dec 2010, Las Vegas: study on operator limits for multiple unmanned spacecraft.
- Reports ~16 craft simple monitoring, ~7 moderate tasks, ~4 complex operations limits.
- No official conclusion in the file
AI summary
A 2010 unclassified defense document titled "Cognitive Limits on Simultaneous Control of Multiple Unmanned Spacecraft" outlines research on human cognitive limits in managing multiple unmanned vehicles. It details three measurement approaches for cognitive workload: subjective, performance, and physiological, including EEG, NIRS, eye-tracking, and stress indicators. The text references studies on air traffic controllers, workload, task performance, and error sources, mentioning TRACON facilities and cognitive limits in managing multiple aircraft. It discusses research on air traffic control workload, physiological stress indicators, and adaptive automation, citing studies from 1996, 2003, and 2005. The document covers studies on controlling multiple unmanned spacecraft, including UAVs and cruise missiles, with interface complexity and automation levels affecting human workload. It includes references to studies on human factors, mental workload, and control of unmanned systems from 1978 to 2010.
Full text
Page 1
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR-OFI ONLY
Defense
a Intelligence
CEEA
Reference
Document
Defense Futures
15 December 2010
ICOD: 8 September 2010
DIA-08-1101-001
Cognitive Limits on
Simultaneous Control of
Multiple Unmanned Spacecraft
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR-OFF
Page 3
UNCLASSIFIED//F&R &FFIOIAl l118E 8Hl¥
Cognitive Lim its on Simultaneous Control of Multiple
Unmanned Spacecraft
The Defense Intelligence Reference Document provides non-substantive but
authoritative reference information related to intelli ence to ics or methodolo ies.
Prepared by:
Technology Warning Division (DW0-4)
Defense Warning Office
Directorate for Analysis
Defense Intelligence Agency
Author:
AAP Person 73
COPYRIGHT WARN ING: Further dissemination of the photographs in this publication is not authorized.
This product is one of a series of advanced technology reports produced in FY 2010
under the Defense Intelligence Agency, Defense Warning Office's Advanced Aerospace
Weapons System Applications (AAWSA) P~ra!i ~m= o:auestions pertaining to
~ AAWSA Program
this document should be addressed to jAAP Person 1
Manager, Defense Intelligence Agency, Al
:J A - u
0 - , Bldg 6000,
Washington D.C. 20340-5100
ii
UNCLASSIFIED//liQlil OliliiliCiliil,l Wili Qtlb¥
Page 4
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFl@IAL Y!H! 8HL'I
Contents
Summary................................................................................................................iv
Chapter 1: Introduction ......................................................................................... 1
Chapter 2: Measurement of Mental Workload ........................................................ 3
Subjective Measurements .................................................................................. 3
Performance Measures ....................................................................................... 4
Physiological Measures ...................................................................................... 4
Cardiac Function ............................................................................................ 5
CNS Measurements ........................................................................................ 6
Ocular Measurements..................................................................................... 6
Skin Measurements ........................................................................................ 7
Serum Levels of Hormones ............................................................................. 7
Chapter 3: Studies in Cognitive Workload for Air Traffic Controllers ..................... 8
Modeling the Air Traffic Control Task ............................................................... 15
Chapter 4: Studies in Command of Multiple Semi-Automated Vehicles ................ 18
Chapter 5: Discussion .......................................................................................... 22
Chapter 6: Conclusions ........................................................................................ 23
References ........................................................................................................... 24
Figures
Figure 1. One-dimensional Representation of Changes in Performance as Workload
Varies ..................................................................................................................... 2
Figure 2. Typical EKG Signal for a Normal Heartbeat .............................................. 5
Figure 3. Air Traffic Control .................................................................................. 10
Figure 4. Representation of Performance Results from Brookings Study.............. 13
Figure 5. Information Processing Model for a Human Operator............................ 16
Figure 6. Examples of Unmanned Military Vehicles .............................................. 19
Tables
Table 1. Variables used in Determining Complexity of the Traffic.................. 11
Table 2. Correlations among Physiological Variables ..................................... 14
iii
UNCLASSIFIED/ j FOR OPPICI.AL YSlii &PU,¥
Page 5
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFl@IAL Y!H! 8HL'I
Cognitive Limits on Simultaneous Control of Multiple
Unmanned Spacecraft
Summary
Space exploration 40 years into the future may include manned missions to parts of the
outer solar system. A possible scenario may include sending a small fleet of craft with
different primary missions. For example, a trailing spacecraft of nuclear powered
electromagnets designed to shield the manned part of the fleet from solar radiation;
halo spacecraft with powerful radars to scout for incoming objects; exploration and
mining craft, etc. The fleet could regularly travel out of unaided visual range of each
other, joining up when necessary for maintenance, exchange of materials such as fuel,
or other necessities. Piloting these multiple craft could be economically accomplished if
only one remote pilot on station at a time was necessary.
The cognitive limitation of a human astronaut and his ability to perform the multiple
vehicle piloting task is the focus of this paper as little work has been done in this
specific area. However, a large body of cognitive research on the limitations of object
supervision and tracking for the task of air traffic control (ATC) exists. Additionally,
there is an emerging body of research concerned with multiple unmanned vehicle
piloting for heterogeneous missions. These are the two areas reviewed in detail as they
relate to possible spacecraft missions.
Pilots develop an internal mental representation of the identity, position, mission, and
current direction of relevant objects. This is referred to colloquially as "the big picture."
The primary research question we seek to answer is whether there is a cognitive limit
to the number of objects that can be monitored and tracked within the big picture.
Secondarily, we seek to find whether this maximum number is limited by the
complexity of interaction; how those limiting factors are described, whether there is a
real-time objective measure that indicates when a pilot is approaching his maximum
capacity, and whether that capacity has been exceeded. The maximum number of
tracked objects is highly dependent on the complexity of the piloting and mission tasks
at hand.
Research is lacking in the area of cognitive limits on the number of spacecraft one pilot
could control given any mission scenario. Currently, two models are being used to
examine similar activities in air traffic control and remote piloting of multiple unmanned
vehicles. In both areas it has been shown the cognitive limits on the number of craft
capable of simultaneous control is 16 for simple destination selection, 7 for moderately
complex piloting and/or mission task completion, and 4 for complex heterogeneous
craft. While additional future research may help to increase the automation component
of aircraft and mission control, no current evidence exists to show that a complete
mental picture can be maintained for more than about 16 objects at one time, even
with external working memory augmentation. However, it has also been demonstrated
that physiological variables can be objectively employed to indicate overload. Nominal
success has been achieved in classifying physiological states near high workload thus
enabling both prediction and possibly prevention of overload.
iv
UNCLASSIFIED/ ;<FOA: OFFICiI.\k W&li 8Ptl¥
Page 6
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR QFFI&iIAk WS& 8,.klf
Chapter 1: Introduction
Due to the complexity, duration and numerous support requirements of future manned
deep-space missions involving exploration, mineral exploitation, and possible
colonization, a likely scenario will be the inclusion of unmanned fleets of support craft.
Coupled with other requirements, an intensive research program is needed to
investigate the cognitive limits on pilots and other operators responsible for the
simultaneous control of multiple unmanned spacecraft making up the support fleet; a
"fleet' approach is proposed in an effort to optimize safety and exploratory reach. This
research effort would also aim at maximizing the functional efficiency of the mission
and reducing the operation costs of unmanned vehicle fleets.
In this scenario there is much about the ancillary craft that are automated in both
navigation and mission. Many of them will not require full-time piloting but given that
they could be hundreds of miles from each other at any instant of time, they need
monitoring to prevent unseen system failure or collision from letting them just
disappear one day during the mission like a Martian probe. Accomplishing this
monitoring task and the occasional piloting task for multiple craft in the fleet could be
economically accomplished if only one remote pilot on station at a time was necessary.
We will focus here on the cognitive limitation of a human astronaut to perform the
multiple-vehicle piloting task. It is not a surprise that there is little work in this specific
area - in fact there were zero peer-reviewed articles in the major journals concerning
remote piloting of multiple spacecraft (published in the last 30 years). There is
however, a large body of cognitive research on the limitations of object supervision and
tracking for the task of air traffic control (ATC). There is additionally an emerging body
of research concerned with multiple unmanned vehicle piloting for heterogeneous
missions. These are the two areas reviewed in detail as they relate to possible
spacecraft missions.
When a pilot or ATC operator is in control of several craft they have developed an
internal mental representation of the identity, position, mission, and current direction of
each object tracked. This is referred to colloquially as "the big picture." This mental
representation is also called situational awareness. Keeping all of the information about
all of the objects straight as long as they are in scope is the goal.
The primary research question we seek to answer is whether there is a cognitive limit
to the number of moving objects that can be maintained in the big picture. Secondary
questions are whether this maximum number is limited by complexity, how those
limitations might be described, whether there is a real-time objective measure that will
indicate when a pilot is approaching their maximum capacity, and whether that capacity
has been overloaded.
For the current treatise we will consider only traditional humans as pilots. Cyborg
enhanced astrobots are a topic for another tome.
In discussing cognitive limitations, it is useful to introduce the concepts of task demand,
mental workload, and a simplistic model of multiple resource theory. For a given task,
the gross level of neural activity required is a representation of the mental demands of
the task. Of course, a complex task can demand varied resources such as visual and
1
UNCLASSIFIED// FOR OFFICIJl!tt tl!H!! 8,.klf
Page 7
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OSSICIAl WSE 8HLY
audio processing, and this is where multiple resource theory enters: different resources
can be considered independent if demands on one resource do not tax the availability of
capacity of the other. Performance of a task can be high or low: in general if spare
capacity is available, performance is high, and if capacity is limited or exceeded,
performance is low. Moreover, task demand enforces a fixed theoretical relationship
between mental workload and task performance: this is shown in Figure l.
Relationship between Workload and Task Performance
High
Performance
Workload
Low
D
Al
A2
A3
B
Task Demand
Figure 1. One-dimensional Representation of Changes in Performance
as Workload Varies. Task demand increases to the right. In the three A
regions, performance remains unchanged : A2 is optimal, where a trained
operator exerts minimal effort to maintain a set level of performance. At times
of low demand the operator exerts effort to maintain vigilance (Al) until
demand is so low, the subject disengages from the task (D). The workload curve
is not well defined at very low levels of demand (dotted lines). At the other end,
as demand increases, the subject can exert effort to keep up with demand (A3) .
Additional effort maintains performance until degradation begins (B), and in the
overload condition, region C, performance is degraded beyond acceptable levels.
While effort is maintained in overload, some low level of performance exists.
2
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFI@IAI: WSE OHl:l/
C
Page 8
UNCLASSIFIED/ j POI\ OFFICIAL ttSl!! 8HLY
Chapter 2: Measurement of Mental Workload
There are three approaches to measuring mental workload in a subject performing a
primary task. The first is subjective evaluation, either post-hoc self-report
questionnaires concentrating on how "busy" one may have felt, or an experimental
observation of activity. The second is performance measures, an objective evaluation of
how well the subject completes the primary task, a secondary task, or an
experimentally inserted reference task. The final approach is to record real-time
physiological measures, with the assumption that increased workload increases anxiety
and this will be exhibited by changes in the autonomic nervous system (ANS).
SUBJECTIVE MEASUREMENTS
Self-report measures are appealing because they get inside the mind that was
performing the task. There is no absolute objective scale to measure one person's "fully
occupied" from another person's view of the same state; however, through rating
scales and self-drawn graphs, one can obtain an accurate picture of how perceived
workload evolved during the experiment. Perceived workload is important because it is
what needs to be maintained between a subjective minimum, where attention may
wander, and a subjective maximum, where increased emotion may decrease
performance capacity.
The most frequently used standardized self-report tools are the NASA Task Load Index
(NASA-TLX or just TLX) and the Subjective Workload Assessment Technique
(SWAT) .1 , 2 , 3 .4 The TLX is a subjective workload assessment based on a multi
dimensional rating questionnaire. An overall workload score is derived based on a
weighted average of ratings on six subscales: mental demands, physical demands,
temporal demands, own performance, effort, and frustration. SWAT is a two-step
assessment of three workload factors: time load, mental effort load, and psychological
stress load. In t he first step, hypothetica l activities are ra nked according to perceived
workload. In the second step, the experimental task is eva luated post-hoc, using a 1-3
rating scale for each of the three dimensions. An interval scale of workload is derived,
from 0-100, based on the reference data collected for each subject in the first step, and
the evaluation of t he experimental task. A custom self-report can also be designed by
the experimenter to specifically focus on the research questions in a given experiment.
The second type of subjective measure is evaluation by an expert observer. In this type
of measurement, assumptions are made on the mental activity of the subject based on
the activities being performed. The advantage of th is approach is that there is minimal
variance per-to-person if the same evaluator is employed. The disadvantage of this
approach is the outside observer can miss workload mu ltiplyi ng factors such as task
complexity contributing to an overwhelmed feeling by the subject. An example of this
approach is the concept of utilization. In ca lculating utilization it is assumed that the
subject must cognitively address one issue at a time in serial order. The measure of
utilization is percent t ime busy, or addressing any issue, as opposed to waiting or
monitoring for the next event. In general is it observed for control and supervisory
tasks that at around 70% utilization performance begins to degrade. 5 Arguably not a
perfect measure of workload, utilization has the advantage of simplicity, objectivity,
3
UNCLASSIFIED/ /EOA OFFI&IAL l:ISI! er•t I
Page 9
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OSSICIAl WSE 8HLY
and a quantitative scale, allowing it to be used in threshold detection and prediction, as
well as in computer-assisted workload balancin g.
PERFORMANCE MEASURES
Laboratory, reaction time to an event stimulus is a typical real-time measure of speed.
Outside the laboratory, in a more natural environment, speed is an indirect measure of
a subject's ability to keep up with a given rate of events. a Accuracy is measured in
both the laboratory and naturalistic environments: for example, in an air-traffic control
task, properly handing off a plane to the next controller, as it leaves the first
controller's monitored airspaceb, is measured as a successful task completion.
Performance, when utilizing a secondary task, is accompl ished following two paradigms.
First, in the dual -task paradigm, performance on the secondary task is required and
primary task performance is thus an indication of workload. For the second paradigm,
instruction is given to maintain the primary task performance, and performance on the
secondary task is thus a measure of "space capacity" for additional workload.
Care is required in selection of secondary tasks in order to ensure they affect the
resources one wishes to probe. For example, in a driving scenario, a minimally
intrusive task is to push a button on the floor or steering wheel when a light flashes in
the field-of-view of the driver. This visual "detect-and-respond" task adds to what is
primarily a complex visual and motor coordination task that probes the capacity of
visual attention. 6 This is different than a seconda ry task utilizing different resources,
such as having a conversation while driving. When planning the paradigm, a model
needs to be developed that treats (or explicitly ignores) individual tasks and
interactions among them.
Reference tasks are executed before and after primary tasks. Typically reference tasks
focus on trending in performance due to effects such as fatigue. One important case of
reference tasks is to normalize an individual's current capacity for mental workload.
Such a pre-performance measure can be used to adjust maximum workload to
compensate for day-to-day variation.
PHYSIOLOGICAL MEASURES
The human nervous system is anatomically divided into the Central Nervous System
(CNS) - and the Peripheral Nervous System (PNS). The CNS includes the brain and the
spinal cord. The PNS is made up of the somatic division, which innervates the skin,
voluntary muscle, and joints, and the autonomic division, which mediates visceral
sensation as well as executes motor control of smooth muscle, viscera, and endocrine
glands. The autonomic division consists of sympathetic, parasympathetic, and enteric
systems. The sympathetic system mediates response to stress, wh ile the
parasympathetic system works to maintain homeostasis and conserve body resources.
• Reaction time is not typically measured in real-time in the field as events occur at unplanned ti mes. Post-hoc
analysis can resolve reaction times down to a comparable resolution to innate motor reaction variance, on the
order or lO's of msec.
b Contrary to what a layperson may think, the vast majority of errors in air traffic control do not result in coll isions
or even near misses; rathe r they are mistakes In procedure.
4
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFI&I:wk WS&: ONlY
Page 10
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FAR AEEICl.'1.k W8f! er•tt
The enteric system executes control of smooth muscle. Although the CNS and PNS are
anatom ically distinct, they are functiona lly intertwined. When discussing the function of
the autonomic division, it is customary to refer to it as the Autonomic Nervous System,
or ANS .7
Changes in global arousal or activation through changing workload can result in
changes in physiological activity. These measures are advantageous as changes are
measurable continuously, in real-time, and usually unobtrusively in a naturalistic
setting. The drawback of using physiology alone is that there is no direct measure of
primary task performance.
Cardiac Function
Normal beating of the human heart produces a distinct and repeating pattern of
electrical activity measurable throughout the body for any two sample points that cross
the chest.c The typical electrocard iogram signal is shown in Figure 2.
R
T
p
Q
s
Figure 2. Typical EKG Signal for a Normal Heartbeat. Portions of the waveform are labeled P, Q,
R, S, and T.
Detection of the R-wave allows measurement of frequency, time,d and amplitude. For
continuous monitoring, heart rate measurements will vary considerably and in a non
linear fashion; therefore, the measurement of inter-beat-interval (IBI), the time
between R peaks, is more normally distributed in the absence of signal, reducing noise
in the measurement. 8 Averaging the heart rate over minutes of task performance and
comparing to baseline yields a reliable estimate of increased metabolic function. 9 An
additional measure is the heart rate variability (HRV), calculated by dividing the
standard deviation of IBI by an average value of IBI within a sample period. Additional
measurements can be made by decomposin g the spectra of HRV into low, mid, and
c In fact,
a typical introductory physics course for life science students will include a laboratory experiment where
the heart rhythm is measured between electrodes located on the right wrist and left ankle.
d This time measurement is properly a phase measure ment, with the phase relative to some reference event.
5
UNCLASSIFIED/ /POI\ OfflelAL WS& €OIL¥
Page 11
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR QFFl&IAL l:ISI!!! Brit I
high frequency components which have different noise contributions (for example, core
temperatu re changes, blood pressure or speech, and respiration, respectively) .10
Blood pressure and its variability can also be measured. For continuous monitoring, a
finger cuff filled with water match the inner-arterial pressure and can be used to
monitor variability . 11
CNS Measurements
Measurement of brain activity can be unobtrusively recorded using low -cou nt
electroencephalography (EEG),e or the minimally obtrusive techniques of EEG, near
infrared spectrometry (NIRS), trans-cranial Doppler sonography (TCDS), or the non
invasive laboratory techniques of functional MRI (fMRI), magnetoencephalography
(MEG), or positron emission tomography (PET). The latter three techniques are for
brain research only and do not have any current naturalistic research studies (although
see Genik 12 for a prognosis on generation-after-next technologies including NIRS, PET,
fMRI, and MEG).
EEG measurements are typically divided into spectra and the relative power in the
bands 0-4 Hz(!\), 4-8 Hz (0), 8-13 Hz (a ), 13-30 Hz(~), and 30-100 Hz (y). NIRS
measures the BOLD effectt and is related to localized y activity . TCDS measures CO2 as
the byproduct of localized increased metabolism and is also an indirect measure of
neural activity which has been shown to be related to vigilance. 13 For EEG experiments
in mental workload, changes are typically reported in the 0 and a bands, though more
recently ~ and y bands have shown sensitivity .14
Event-related potentials (ERP) are peaks of activity measured at the skin indicative of
several tens of thousands of neurons firing coherently for a short time. For example, a
well-studied cognitive ERP is P300, a lO's-of-msec-wide bump in the EEG signal
occurring 200-400 msec after an event. Some success in utilizing a task-irrelevant
secondary aud io stimulation and NlOO has been shown, 15 but little further development
to this approach has been found in the last 15 years.
Ocular Measurements
Measurements involving eye fixations, dwell t ime (temporal length of a fixation), and
pupillary changes are well established metrics of workload in visual searching tasks. 16
Add itiona l measures of ocular changes include bl ink rate, blink duration, bl ink latency,
and eye movement. These are recorded using one of various types of eye-tracking (ET)
or electrodes to measure an electrooculogram (EOG). ET data will include position of a
fixation and the time of each eye movement (or saccade), whereas an EOG on ly
identifies the time that the muscle controlling eye blinks or eye position activated.
• Low-count EEG is generally less than 10 electrodes, and usually 3 or 5.
r The Blood Oxygen Level Dependent (BOLD) effect is a local change in the oxygen saturation ratio near neural
activity due to metabolic and vascu lar action . This change is detectlble in the infrared spectra .
6
UNCLASSIFIED/ j FOR OPPICI.AL l:ISlii &PU,¥
Page 12
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR 8FFI@IAL tt.!l! 014Ei
Skin Measurements
The ANS controls the opening and closing of sweat glands in response to stress and
anxiety. These changes can be observed by measuring electrodermal activity, typically
skin conductance response (SCR), 17 but also skin potentials (SP) and skin temperature
(ST). A standard score of these measures can be calculated by collecting resting state
data prior to the task interval.
Serum Levels of Hormones
Hormone levels are direct results of activity in the ANS. It is natural to want to
continuously monitor certain stress hormones such as adrenaline or cortisol. The
difficulty lies in measurement time - typical fast assays of salivary cortisol still require
about 15 minutes. 18 Until reliable in-situ monitoring is available, serum levels of
hormones will only play a supporting role in establishing baseline capacities or post
incident analysis.
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFICIAL OSI! or•tv
7
Page 13
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOA QFFI@IAL l:l!H! 9HLY
Chapter 3: Studies in Cognitive Workload for Air Traffic
Controllers
There are a few areas of research applicable as analogues to the piloting of several
aircraft. The largest of these areas analyzes the supervisory functions of air traffic
controllers (ATC). In a typical ATC duty environment, a single operator is responsible
for many fully-autonomous aircraft. ATC is either airport- based or en-route. Airport
based facilities include ground control, local control for active runways (Tower control),
and approach control, which in the US is called Terminal Radar Approach Control, or
TRACON. A zone of air-controlled space assigned to a specific control center is that
center's sector; similarly, a given controller is responsible for a sector of airspace.
Between airport-controlled sectors, aircraft are monitored by an en-route facility.
TRACON is the most cognitively demanding function in this chain. Terminal controllers,
as ATCs are called at TRACON facilities, are responsible for departures after take-off,
and approaches and flyovers within about a SO-m ile radius of the airport.9 Approaching
aircraft need to be vectored by the controller into an appropriate flight path for landing,
avoiding all other aircraft in the air or soon to be in the air, and then handed off to the
Tower controller for landing and ground instruction. Departing flights and flyover traffic
mainly need to be monitored for conflicts. Approaching aircraft are by far the most
cognitively challenging in the ATC task. Images of air traffic controller environment and
displays are shown in Figure 3.h
Errors in flight control are called anomalies in the industry. The most common aircraft
anomaly is deviation from flightpath in en-route sectors. This anomaly is corrected by
pilots themselves or after instruction from the appropriate ATC. The most common ATC
error is miscommunication between controllers in an aircraft handoff between sectors. 19
A study in 1997 by the National Academies showed that ATC errors occurred in both
high and low workload conditions, as predicted by overload and disengagement. 20
In looking at the cognitive limits in ATC, we should seek where typical controllers enter
the B region of workload. Traffic load defined as simply the number of aircraft does not
by itself show the complete picture of ATC workload. In a study of professional
controllers in 2006, Boag recorded subjective measures of workload and reaction time
when static air traffic displays were presented. Displays included air traffic conflicts of
differing complexity that required resolution. Complexity in the display was objectively
ranked using the Method of Analysis of Relational Complexity (MARC). 21 Results showed
that a relatively small number of aircraft can greatly increase the perceived workload.
Boag concludes that perceived complexity is the number one factor in determining
workload, and that although conflicts are the major source of complexity in the ATC
task, and these can be modeled somewhat using a combination of aircraft separation
and trans ition 1 variables, individual differences still have significant impact on when a
controller may reach overload. 22
9 Each
facility will vary in TRACON sector radius. For smaller airports, TRACON functions may be performed by a
nearby en-route fac ility.
h Of historical note in the US Air traffic Control industry was the industry -wide strike begun on August 3, 1981 , by
the nearly 13,000 ATC specialists. Only 1300 obeyed a Presidential order to return to work under the " peril to
national safety" provision of the 1947 Taft-Hartley Act. On August 5, 1981 the remaining 11,345 controllers were
fired and banned for life from federal service. The FAA rebu ilt the force to pre-strike levels during the rest of the
1980s. This event resulted in a dearth of research during the 1980s on air traffic control professionals.
1 An aircraft transition is an event such as landing, hand -off to another controller, or entering/leaving a sector,
where a sector is defined as a controller's airspace of responsibility.
8
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FAR AEEICl\k W&li 8HLY
Page 14
UNCLASSIFIED//EOR QfiFIQl.lik 1!181! er•t I
In a post-hoc examination of sources of human error in taped controller data, Chang
developed a conceptual model of ATC task within a system of human, software,
hardware, and environment using the SHEL23 approach of ergonomics. This study also
examined several aspects of personnel management, but when overload was exam ined
Previous: DOW-UAP-D150 — AAWSAP DIRD, Quantum Computing and Utilizing Organic Molecules in Automation Technology, December 2010 · Next: DOW-UAP-D152 — AAWSAP DIRD, Negative Mass Propulsion, January 2011
Same topic: title & summary match
Same location: Las Vegas, Nevada
- DOW-UAP-D174 — Utah Ranch Investigation Report, April 2010
- DOW-UAP-D166 — MUFON Reports Prepared for BAASS, November 2008
- DOW-UAP-D168 — BAASS Project Management Plan, December 2008
- DOW-UAP-D169 — BAASS Monthly Report, March 2009
- DOW-UAP-D170 — BAASS Monthly Report, April 2009
- DOW-UAP-D171 — BAASS Monthly Report, June 2009
Same period: 2010
- DOW-UAP-D114 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00003, May 2010
- DOW-UAP-D113 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00002, February 2010
- DOW-UAP-D115 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00004, May 2010
- DOW-UAP-D116 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00005, September 2010
- DOW-UAP-D131 — AAWSAP DIRD, The Role of Superconductors in Gravity Research, March 2010
- DOW-UAP-D133 — AAWSAP DIRD, The Space Communication Implications of Quantum Entanglement and Nonlocality, March 2010
Same release: Release 06
- DOW-UAP-PR159 — Historical Film of Reported UFOs, Utah, 1952
- LLE-UAP-PR001 — Unresolved UAP Report, Colorado, 2023
- LLE-UAP-PR002 — Unresolved UAP Report, Colorado, October 2023
- DOW-UAP-PR133 — Unresolved UAP Report, Middle East, 2025
- DOW-UAP-PR135 — Unresolved UAP Report, Middle East, 2025
- DOW-UAP-PR140 — Unresolved UAP Report, Middle East, 2022
Same agency: DoW
- DOW-UAP-D094 — Analysis of Flying Object Incidents in the United States, 1949
- DOW-UAP-D097 — Project Sign Progress Report, 1948
- DOW-UAP-D084 — US Army-Flying-Saucer-Study 1949
- DOW-UAP-D155 — Air Intelligence Information Report, Saudi Arabia, 1957
- DOW-UAP-D176 — Triangular UAP AARO Memorandum for Record, 2026
- DOW-UAP-D177 — Unresolved UAP Report, Catalina Island, 1955