DOW-UAP-D120 — AAWSAP DIRD, Materials for Advanced Aerospace Platforms, January 2010
File DOW-UAP-D120 is a declassified pdf from Department of War, recording an incident dated 1/12/10 at Las Vegas, Nevada, published in Release 06 (2026-09-18). This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.
- File
- DOW-UAP-D120
- Agency
- Department of War
- Incident date
- 1/12/10
- Location
- Las Vegas, Nevada
- Released in
- Release 06 (2026-09-18)
- File type
Topics: AAWSAP & DIRDs
This document is a Defense Intelligence Reference Document (DIRD), a technical reference format used by the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) to capture baseline knowledge on a specific topic for later analytic use. DIRDs are best understood as reference and synthesis products rather than as original research. It is one of 38 DIRDs produced under the Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Applications Program (AAWSAP) between 2009 and 2011. Because AAWSAP’s scope permitted a broad range of supporting topics, not every DIRD in the series directly concerns aerospace systems or future threat assessment. The following summary reflects the DIRD’s scope and framing at the time of writing and should not be read as implying current validation of the concepts discussed.
This DIRD surveys the structural materials needed for advanced aerospace platforms and argues that material choice cannot be separated from overall vehicle design, because launch vehicles, space vehicles, reusable systems, and propulsion hardware each face different temperature, durability, weight, and manufacturing constraints. The report reviews a range of candidate material classes, including advanced aluminum alloys; polymer-, aluminum-, and titanium-matrix composites; titanium alloys; nickel-base alloys; refractory metals; ceramic-matrix composites; carbon-carbon composites; and titanium aluminides. It emphasizes that balancing performance against practical limits such as fabrication methods, cost, inspection, contamination control, and service environment remains a major challenge. Its overall conclusion is that many promising materials exist, but their usefulness depends on application-specific tradeoffs and on closer integration of material selection with design and manufacturing, with some systems judged to be more valuable targets for development than others.
Open original file · WAR.GOV page
TL;DR
Even in 2010 they couldn’t settle on a favorite metal.
- DIRD by DoW Jan 2010, Las Vegas incident 1/12/10.
- Surveys alloys, composites, and matrices for launch, reusable, and propulsion platforms.
- Conclusion: many promising materials, usefulness hinges on application tradeoffs and design integration.
AI summary
A classified document titled "Materials for Advanced Aerospace Platforms," prepared by the Defense Intelligence Agency in January 2010, outlines materials used in launch vehicles, reusable spacecraft, and propulsion systems, focusing on advanced alloys and composites. It discusses friction stir welding for aluminum alloys, composite fabrication methods, and challenges in manufacturing. The document covers titanium alloys, thermal protection systems, and various advanced materials such as polymer matrix composites, nickel-base alloys, and ceramic matrix composites, detailing their properties, applications, and manufacturing challenges.
Full text
Page 2
UNCLASSIFIED/ /Pel\ OPPICIAL USE ONLY
Materials for Advanced Aerospace Platforms
Prepared by:
Acquisiti on Support Di vision (DW0-3)
Defense warning Office
Directorate for Analysis
Defense Intelligence Agency
Author:
AAP Person 66
Administrative Note
COPYRIGHT WARNING: Further dissemination of the photographs in this publication is not authorized.
This product is one in a series of advanced technology reports produced in FY 2009
under the Defense Intelligence Agency, Defense Warning Office's Advanced Aerospace
Weapon System Applications (AAWSA Program. Comments or questions pertaining to
this document should be addressed toiMP Person 1
! AAWSA Program
Manager, Defense Intelligence Agency, ATTN: CLAR/DW0-3, Bldg 6000, Washington,
DC 20340-5100.
ii
UNCLASSIFIED/ /liOA OFFIOIAL li91!! erttI
Page 3
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFI@IAl W&lii 9PU.Y
Contents
Introduction ...........................................................................................................iv
Launch Vehicles ................................................................................................. 1
Reusable Crew Modules...................................................................................... 9
Reusable Single-Stage-to-Orbit Vehicles ...................................................... 10
Advanced Al Alloys ....................................................................................... 11
Polymer Matrix Composites .......................................................................... 11
Al Matrix Composites .................................................................................... 12
Ti Alloys ....................................................................................................... 12
Ti Matrix Composites .................................................................................... 14
Ni-base Alloys .............................................................................................. 16
Refractory Metal Alloys ................................................................................ 18
Ceramic Matrix Composites .......................................................................... 18
Carbon-Carbon Composites .......................................................................... 19
Titanium Aluminides .................................................................................... 20
Propulsion Systems .......................................................................................... 21
Summary and Recommendations ..................................................................... 22
Figures
1. Schematic Diagram of Friction Stir Welding ....................................................... 2
2. Specially Modified 747 Transporter Unloading a Boeing 787 Composite
Fuselage Barrel Section ..................................................................................... 4
3. Micrograph Showing Phase Formation at the Surface of a Ti Alloy That has
Been Exposed to Air at Elevated Temperature ................................................. 13
4. Cross-Section Micrograph of a Ti Matrix Composite .......................................... 15
Tables
1. Potential Materials by Use Temperature Regime and Property ......................... 10
2. Example of Properties of Ti Matrix Composites ................................................ 14
iii
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR 0FFI€1Ak Uili ,u1k¥
Page 4
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOA OFFI€1Ak Ulilii ONkY
Materials for Advanced Aerospace Platforms
Introduction
"Advanced aerospace platforms" is a broad topic that can be divided into
several narrower subtopics to enable a more concise discussion of materials
advances, challenges, and opportunities. Consequently, this document
discusses the areas of launch vehicles, space vehicles, and space propulsion
systems separately because their key requirements are often application
specific, which affects materials selection decisions. In addition, single-use
and reusable boosters have different durability requirements that directly
impinge on design and materials selection. Furthermore, current engineering
practice has evolved to the point that design synthesis must integrate the
structure and construction materials to achieve optimum product performance.
For example, the space shuttle was designed to meet customer-imposed
mission requirements (range, payload, empty weight, landing capability, and
so forth) without significant real-time consideration of materials capability.
This approach led to significant compromises at later stages in the shuttle's
development and maturation. (Arguably, the shuttle could be designed as a
more efficient vehicle today.) In the extreme, a spectacular engineering
failure was the National Aerospace Plane (also dubbed the Orient Express),
which was launched as a military project and was intended to be a mach 12
reusable strike vehicle. This project rapidly became materials limited and was
canceled in 1993, after about $750 million in federal R&D expenditures and a
substantial private sector investment. The point is that any "clean sheet of
paper design" must start with an assessment of the requirements for
construction materials and be accompanied by a realistic assessment of the
capability of currently available materials to meet these needs. If these two
assessments indicate a gap between requirements and existing materials
capability, a risk assessment and a risk-mitigation plan must be developed
before expending engineering hours and funds.
Since the inception of manned space flight, the approach to design has
changed to include the concept of damage tolerance. This shift in design
philosophy was prompted by the (eventual) recognition that complex
structures cannot be designed and produced with zero defects. With the
maturation of fracture mechanics and means of reducing these concepts to
practice, the transition from zero defects to defect tolerance became the norm.
This new approach in turn led to recognition that high-performance materials
required not only high specific strength and stiffness but pacing increases in
strength with simultaneous improvements in fracture toughness and fatigue
crack growth resistance. The introduction of damage tolerance was
accompanied by a renewed emphasis on nondestructive inspection capabilities.
This latter thrust was driven by the need to demonstrate the capability to
reproducibly locate small flaws that could become failure initiation sites,
either because of static or because of cyclic loading conditions. In the case of
atmospheric flight, the U.S. Air Force has introduced standards for airframes
(the Aircraft Structural Integrity Program) and propulsion systems (the
Engine Structural Integrity Program) that tie structural life and reliability to
iv
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOA OFFl&IAI:: U&li &Ptl::lf
Page 5
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFl@IAL l:ISl!!! 9HtY
this demonstrated inspections capability. Implementation of these standards,
starting with the B-1 bomber and the F-100 and F-110 engines, has
dramatically reduced (but not eliminated) the incidence of catastrophic
failures of critical components that endanger crews, vehicles, or both.
Taking these changes into account, this document outlines the current
situation regarding the design and production of high-performance structures
for aerospace platforms, including launch vehicles, space vehicles, and
propulsion systems for transporting space vehicles (and payloads) into orbit.
V
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR. OFFISIAI: YSE OHL\«
Page 6
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR 8FFI@IAL t:191!! l>flt I
Materials for Advanced Aerospace Platforms
LAUNCH VEHICLES
For the purposes of this document, launch vehicles are defined as the structure that
supports and/or encloses the propulsion system, the fuel supply, and the crew or
payload module. Launch vehicles today are either single use or multiple use after
recovery and extensive refurbishment. This approach adds considerably to the cost of
transporting a pound of payload into earth orbit, regardless of whether an unmanned
satellite or a manned orbiting crew module that must withstand the temperatures and
loads associated with safe reentry to earth. Furthermore, the larger the payloads are,
the greater are the reaction forces the launch veh icle must withstand during launch.
With the total weight of the payload, the empty weight of the launch vehicle, and fuel
all needing to be lifted initially, fuel-efficient propulsion and lightweight launch vehicles
are essential to maximizing the payload. Except in the area around the propulsion
system exhaust, the temperatures experienced by launch vehicles during launch are not
demanding. Therefore, advanced, high-strength aluminum (Al} alloys and polymer
matrix carbon fiber composites (PMCs) are prime candidates for the parts of the
structure that experience aerodynamic loads and where aerodynamic heating does not
exceed about 125 °Celsius. One class of advanced Al alloys is the lithium (Li)-bearing
alloys, such as Al alloy 2090. This alloy contains enough Li to reduce its density by 8
percent while increasing the elastic modulus (E) by 10 percent. Other, newer advanced
Al alloys, such as 7050 and 2050, have been developed to have improved damage
tolerance. These alloys have excellent specific strength at or near room temperature
and experience no major loss of ductility at cryogenic temperatures. The newer variants
of the 2000 and 7000 Al alloys also have substantially improved resistance to most
types of corrosion, including exfoliation and stress corrosion cracking. This can be
important in a reusable vehicle.
Perhaps the most important aspect of the improved Al alloys is their higher fracture
toughness, accomplished through a combination of alloy composition control and
improved processing. In alloy composition control, the concentrations of the residual
elements iron (Fe), chromium (Cr), manganese (Mn), and silicon (Si) are reduced at
the ingot stage. These elements combine with Al to form hard, brittle intermetallic
compounds known as constituent phases. The advanced alloys contain fewer, smaller
constituent phases, leading to improved fracture resista nce and higher fracture
toughness values. In applications such as body skins for commercial aircraft, this
improved toughness has enabled an increase in t he spacing of the circumferential
fuselage frames, or "hat sections," that serve both as stiffeners and as crack stoppers
to prevent a catastrophic failure during pressurization. For any given operating stress
in this case the pressurization stress-the spacing of the frames is directly related to
the critical crack size of the body skin . Higher toughness alloys have larger critical crack
sizes, and the frames can be spaced further apart without increasing t he risk of
catastrophic fa ilure. The increased spacing ultimately allows a fuselage design that
requires fewer frames. Consequently, the airplane benefits from a commensurate
reduction both in weight and in manufacturing cost. Similar possibilities exist for the
design of a fail-safe launch vehicle that has a lower empty weight. Clearly, the
advanced Al alloys offer intrinsic improvements over the alloys used in the Saturn
launch vehicle and introduce the prospect of new, more efficient launch vehicle designs.
1
UNCLASSIFIED/ ,'FOR 8FFI&i1Ak Uili ODIL\'
Page 7
UNCLASSIFIED/} FOR OFFICil<L l:191!!! 8HL1/
The newer Al alloys also can be specially processed to render them superplastically
formable . This capability opens a realm of possibilities to replace structures that, in the
absence of this capability, are machined from thick plate. Very large structures are
produced in sections that must be joined. Conventional fusion welding techniques do
not work for high-strength Al alloys such as 7075, 7050, 2024, or 2050 because either
the welds lead to cracks or the welds made under conditions that avoid cracking have
greatly reduced tensile properties. Because these alloys are not amenable to welding,
heavier, fatigue-prone mechanically fastened joints must be used. Recently, scientists
developed a joining process that permits joining of Al alloys such as 7050. This process,
called friction stir welding (FSW), allows joint designs in a variety of configurations that
were not considered possible when fusion welding was the only alternative.
In FSW, a rotating steel tool is inserted into the seam between the two Al alloy pieces
to be joined. As the rotating tool is driven forward, the friction between the tool and the
work piece generates enough heat to soften the Al alloy without melting it. A schematic
of this process is shown in Figure 1.
Tool
/
retreating
side
Figure 1. Schematic Diagram of Friction Stir Welding
The combined action of the rotation and the traversing of the tool essentially kneads
the two pieces together, leaving a mechanically sound joint. Although the weld
properties may be somewhat inferior to those of the base metal, they are good enough
that a relatively small increase in thickness at the joint position can compensate .
Although substantial development of the FSW process is ongoing, FSW already has
been put into practice. For example, the current external propellant tank on the space
shuttle is made from an Al-Li alloy fabricated through FSW. The weight advantage of
using welded as opposed to bolted joints in a large structure such as a launch vehicle is
considerable. With earlier high-strength alloys such as 7075, concerns about fracture
toughness in conjunction with monolithic structures would have caused a welded
2
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR. OFFl&IAI:: W&li &Ptl::lf
Page 8
UNCLASSIFIED//POlt OPPl@IAL YSI!! 8HLY
construction to be considered too risky. Today, the combination of higher toughness
alloys and FSW opens up the possibility of greater design flexibility resulting in lighter
large structures with equal or greater reliability than ear lier ones.
In sum, metallic, nonreusable (at least nominally so) launch vehicles made from
advanced Al alloys and fabricated through FSW constitute an incremental but significant
improvement over earlier versions .
In recent years, PM Cs have matured significantly. For many components that are not
exposed to elevat ed temperatures, PMCs provide a degree of design flexibility not
read ily available in meta ls. Consequently, PMC materials have begun to supplant Al
alloys in the construction of commercial subson ic aircraft. The use of PMCs in the
empennage of the Boeing 777 was one of the first examp les of Al alloys being
displaced. Subsequently, the new Boeing 787 has more structure made from
composites than from metallic materials. Once PMCs are introduced into a structure in
sign ificant quantit ies, a constraint related t o galvanic incompatibility between the PMC
st ructure and any adjoining Al all oys also is introduced. When a PMC structure is in
direct contact with an Al alloy structure, catastrophic corrosion of the Al alloy
components can occur. In the Boeing 787, the remedy for this concern is the use of
titan ium (Ti) all oys in areas where there is direct contact between t he metallic and the
PMC structures. This is directly analogous to the plastic bushing a plumber puts in the
j oint between copper and iron piping. Notwithstanding this constra int, the specific
strength and stiffness of PMC structures make a compell ing argument for their
appl ication in high-performance structures, such as launch veh icles .
Composite structures can be manufactured using one of th ree methods: hand layup of
pre-preg, automated tow placement, and resin transfer molding.
•
The most rudimentary of these, but also the most flexible, is hand layup of pre -preg.
This method uses sheets of material that contain both the fiber and the polymeric
matr ix (called pre-preg). The polymeric matrix can be either a thermoset (for
example, epoxy) or a thermoplastic. Individual plies are cut from the pre-preg
typica lly using a numerically controlled laser or mechanical cutting device and are
la id up to form the desired shape. Areas that have heavier loads contain more plies
locally, and the plies are cut in an or ientation with respect to the fiber direction in
the pre-preg to ach ieve the desired strength relative to the principa l load path.
These plies are carefully placed according to a drawing (blueprint), making hand
layup a labor-intensive process and, therefore, making parts made using th is
method expensive . During ply placement, it is crit ical that no ply wrinkles are
introduced, as these create severe reductions in the local load-bearing capability of
the fina l component. Once all the plies are in their proper places , the article is
placed in a vacuum-tight bag that is evacuated and placed in an autoclave for curing
of the epoxy matrix or fusing of the thermoplastic. A disadvantage of a pre-preg
whose matrix is a thermoset is limited shelf life. In practice, this is managed to a
degree by storing the pre-preg in a freezer to slow the rate of chemica l reaction t hat
sets the epoxy. However, th is does not completely halt the reaction, causing these
materials to have a shelf life beyond wh ich they are not easily manipulated during
layup and do not develop full strength after curing in the autoclave. An additional
issue is out t ime-the time the pre-preg can be out of the freezer during layup
before the reaction proceeds at an accelerated rate and reaches a point at which the
3
UNCLASSIFIED//F8R 8FFUiil>I. 11 &5 ON! X
Page 9
UNCLASSIFIED// FOR OFFICll<L l:l!H!! 8PtLY
material is not suitable for the reasons stated earlier. Clearly, the time required for
layup places practical limitations on component size.
•
In automated tow placement, thin ribbons of a pre-preg are fed off a drum or rolled
into a computer numerically controlled machine that places them in the desired
position. In principle, this process trades recurring labor cost for up-front capital
investment (the tow placement machine) and programming time . If the anticipated
volume of identical parts is high enough to amortize the capital investment and,
particularly, the programming cost, this can be an attractive means of reducing
manufacturing costs. For axisymmetric shapes, such as cylinders, this essentially
becomes a winding process and is quite efficient. An example of a finished
composite fuselage barrel section for the Boeing 787 is shown in Figure 2. For more
irregular three -dimensional shapes, such as a spar or a strut, placing the tows
becomes much more difficult and presents a fundamental limitation. Consequently,
PMC structures with complex shapes are still for the most part made using the hand
layup process. A variant of automated t ow placement is compression, whereby a
preform, made by automated tow placement, is forced by a press into a preshaped
die. This process allows fabrication of more complex shapes, but the rigidity of the
fiber and the extreme anisotropy of the tows can lead to wrinkles, which are not
acceptable because of the reductions in properties these cause.
Figure 2. Specially Modified 747 Transporter Unloading a Boeing 787 Composite Fuselage Barrel
Section
•
The third main composite fabrication method, resin transfer molding (RTM), begins
with a woven fiber mat or preform. The polymeric matrix is injected into this mat to
create a fully dense composite. The major benefit of RTM is that it permits use of a
three-dimensional weave that minimizes the risk of delamination between plies.
Note that, with the other two methods, the material is reinforced in only two
dimensions (the plane of the pre-preg or tows). RTM's limitations include the
viscosity of the resins used. If the resin is too viscous, injecting it will either distort
the fiber architecture of the woven preform or not fully penetrate the preform,
4
UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR 8FFI@IAL YSE erttl/
Page 10
UNCLASSIFIED/ /POI': OPPlelAL l:ISE 8PtLY
leaving voids. This limitation makes it difficult to use many thermoplastic resins that
are otherwise attractive because they are recyclable and have much longer shelf
lives than thermosets (epoxies). Another, more obvious limitation of RTM is
component size. This is in part because weaving of very large fiber preforms is
challenging and requires a very large weaving machine. It also requires a large
injection mach ine capable of multiple injection sites to ensure the complete
infiltration necessary to avoid formation of voids.
In practice, there are several significant challenges associated with manufacturing large
PMC structures today. Among these, perhaps the most significant are manufacturing
cost and the difficulty associated with making large, nonaxisymmetric components.
Large axisymmetric components that can be produced by winding tows of pre-preg are
clearly possible today, as demonstrated by the Boeing 787 fuselage whose section is
shown in Figure 2. For other shapes, because the load-bearing capability of PMCs
depends on the transfer of externally imposed loads to the strong, stiff fibers, joints
that intersect the principal load path become problematic. This is because the fibers
and, as a direct consequence, the load path are discontinuous, requiring local section
size adjustments to offset this local structural inefficiency. Thus, achieving the most
structurally efficient use of PMCs requires monolithic structures with continuous fibers.
In large structures, this is at best a challenge. Even in the Boeing 787's PMC fuselage,
mechanically fastened joints are used to connect adjacent barrel sections. In the
fuselage, as in any cylindrical pressure vessel, the principal stresses are hoop stresses
stemming from pressurization during flight. However, the compromise in structural
efficiency is minimized by the circumferential orientation of the joints. Although these
bolted joints add weight, the overall structural efficiency of the PMC structure is still
better, albeit considerably more expensive, than a longitudinally and circumferentially
stiffened Al structure. The circumferential joints also create discontinuous longitudinal
crack paths that improve the structure's damage tolerance. Some of the added expense
of the PMC fuselage stems from the use of Ti alloy fasteners because of the galvanic
coupling issues that would accompany Al or steel fasteners.
For other applications, which are limited by different material properties, the PMC
system can be tailored to optimize structural performance. This is possible because
both the matrix and the fiber can be independently selected. Moreover, the fiber
"architecture" (fiber orientation, weave geometry, and fiber volume fraction) can be
varied spatially to optimize load-bearing capability under complex stress states. For
example, again drawing on recent applications in commercial aircraft, the fan blades of
the large, high-bypass-ratio turbofan engine {GE90) produced by General Electric for
the Boeing 777 are made from PMCs. The limiting design consideration for these fan
blades is resistance to bird strikes. To optimize the PMCs' impact resistance, a medium
modulus, high-tensile-strength carbon fiber was selected in combination with a
thermoplastic toughened epoxy matrix. Furthermore, the fiber architecture was set to
optimize the bending strength under the impact of a bird. The GE90 fan blades are
produced by hand layup and are quite costly to produce. In the 10-plus years that
these fan blades have been in service, not a single unscheduled engine removal related
to the PMC fan blades has occurred. The competitive fan blade technology for B-777class engines is hollow Ti, which is used by both Pratt & Whitney and Rolls Royce. By all
informal accounts, these blades are cost intensive. This example supports the unwritten
rule that the pathways leading to high-performance, high-value structures typically are
5
UNCLASSIFIED/ ,sroR. OFFl&IAL W&li 8Ptllf
Page 11
UNCLASSIFIED// POI': OPPlelAL l:ISE 8PtLY
not technology dependent but are cost intensive, no matter what technology is
employed to meet the requirements.
An additional characteristic of PMC structures-one related to the laminated
construction of components made by hand layup or automated tow placement
methods-is their susceptibility to formation of delaminations when impacted
perpendicular to the plane of the plies. This is due to the mismatch in bending stiffness
between adjacent plies that have different unidirectional fiber orientations. This
mismatch causes shear stresses to develop that can exceed the shear strength of the
interlaminate bonds, causing small, embedded cracks to form. Under subsequent
inplane compression loading, the laminates bow because of the Poisson stresses and
separate because of the lack of an interlaminar bond to hold them together. In
significant compression loads, the laminates buckle, and this leads to structural failure.
This phenomenon, called compression after impact, is an insidious failure mode because
the delaminations are not externally detectable unless ultrasonic inspection methods
are used. Sources of such an impact include dropped tools, foreign objects (for
example, meteorites), and, perhaps most commonly, hail storms. Ultrasonic inspection,
if required, is expensive and time consuming. The latter concern in turn affects vehicle
availability and turnaround time. PMC parts made using RTM typically have reinforcing
fibers in the through-thickness direction, so concerns about compression after impact
are minimal.
The maximum temperature at which PMCs can be used is limited by PMCs' susceptibility
to oxygen degradation of the polymeric matrix. The maximum-use temperature for
prolonged exposure is determined by the thermal oxidative stability (TOS) of a
particular resin. The TOS, like any chemical reaction, is determined by both time and
temperature . The glass transition temperature (T9 ) of the polymeric matrix also
imposes strength and dimensional stability limitations independent of the TOS limits.
This is particularly true for thermoplastics. However, the TOS limits usually impose
lower temperature limits than T9 if prolonged thermal exposure is contemplated. Three
distinct classes or groups of resins exist, each with a successively higher temperature
capability. These are conventional epoxies and most thermal plastics, bismaleimides
(BMis), and linear polyimides. The first class is limited by TOS to about 125° Celsius.
BMis can be used to about 175° Celsius. Linear polyimides, such as the in situ
polymerization of monomer reactants (PMR) group of thermosetting formulations, can
be used to about 300° Celsius. Many of the PMR resins contain the hazardous
compound methylenedianiline, which requires special care during use, including
protective clothing to limit personnel exposure (for example, during ply cutting and
hand layup). This requirement reduces productivity, adds cost, and creates a degree of
liability concern for the manufacturer of the PMC components. For RTM, the BMis and
PMR resins typically have higher viscosity and require commensurately higher injection
temperatures to reduce the viscosity to manageable levels for reasons discussed
earlier. New resins are constantly being developed, including some with attractive
properties. However, many of the sources of these resins are startup companies that
exist on R&D fund in g, often in the form of U.S. government SBIR (Small Business
Innovative Research) projects. Such companies are good at innovation but often have
limited experience transitioning new products from the laboratory to large -scale
production. Furthermore, in the current economic climate, access to sufficient capital to
set up production-scale capacity can be a form idable problem for a small company.
Larger companies (for example, BASF, DuPont, GE Plastics) typically are not interested
6
UNCLASSIFIED/ .{FOR OFFICilAL l:ISE 8HLY
Page 12
UNCLASSIFIED// POI\ OPPICl"L U.!I! Oflt I
in materials with small annual sales volume, so even licensing the new material to one
of these companies may not be commercially feasible .
This foregoing discussion highlights a commonly encountered inconsistency between
technical innovation and commercial progress. Until a production-scale source exists,
pricing of new materials is at best highly uncertain and potentially unstable over time.
This is in part due to the uncertainty surrounding demand and the associated volume of
material that will be required. Taken together, these factors act as a clear deterrent to
the adoption of new materials of literally all classes (polymers, metals, and ceramics).
For heavily loaded structures or structures that will experience temperatures higher
than about 200 °Celsius, Ti alloys are the preferred material class. Ti alloys are about
half as dense as steel or Ni-base alloys and possess a density-corrected strength and
stiffness competitive with that of other metallic materials. Numerous grades of Ti alloys
are in use today, and a strong domestic industrial base of suppliers exists for nearly all
these grades . Ti alloys for structural applications can be divided into three groups based
on their metallurgy: near a alloys, a+p alloys, and metastable p alloys (commonly called
p alloys for short) . Both the aircraft and propulsion original equipment manufacturers
and several private engineering firms have extensive design experience with Ti alloys.
Although most of this experience is with Ti-6Al-4V (Ti-6-4 ), other alloys also are widely
used, particularly in jet engines and liquid-fueled rocket engines. The alloy most likely
to be used in a launch vehicle, Ti-6-4, has been available and in use for more than 40
years but is still highly competitive with newer grades in large part because of its
versatility. Potential applications of other alloys that have particularly attractive
characteristics, such as a higher temperature capability, are discussed in the Reusable
Reentry Vehicle and Propulsion Systems sections of this document.
The most commonly used structural grade of Ti alloy today, Ti-6-4, can be readily
Previous: DOW-UAP-D119 — AAWSAP DIRD, Biomaterials, January 2010 · Next: DOW-UAP-D121 — AAWSAP DIRD, Pulsed High-Power Microwave Source Technology, January 2010
Same topic: title & summary match
Same location: Las Vegas, Nevada
- DOW-UAP-D174 — Utah Ranch Investigation Report, April 2010
- DOW-UAP-D166 — MUFON Reports Prepared for BAASS, November 2008
- DOW-UAP-D168 — BAASS Project Management Plan, December 2008
- DOW-UAP-D169 — BAASS Monthly Report, March 2009
- DOW-UAP-D170 — BAASS Monthly Report, April 2009
- DOW-UAP-D171 — BAASS Monthly Report, June 2009
Same period: 2010
- DOW-UAP-D114 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00003, May 2010
- DOW-UAP-D113 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00002, February 2010
- DOW-UAP-D115 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00004, May 2010
- DOW-UAP-D116 — AAWSAP Contract Modification P00005, September 2010
- DOW-UAP-D133 — AAWSAP DIRD, The Space Communication Implications of Quantum Entanglement and Nonlocality, March 2010
- DOW-UAP-D134 — AAWSAP DIRD, Maverick Inventor Versus Corporate Inventor: Where Will the Next Major Innovations Arise, March 2010
Same release: Release 06
- DOW-UAP-PR159 — Historical Film of Reported UFOs, Utah, 1952
- LLE-UAP-PR001 — Unresolved UAP Report, Colorado, 2023
- LLE-UAP-PR002 — Unresolved UAP Report, Colorado, October 2023
- DOW-UAP-PR133 — Unresolved UAP Report, Middle East, 2025
- DOW-UAP-PR135 — Unresolved UAP Report, Middle East, 2025
- DOW-UAP-PR140 — Unresolved UAP Report, Middle East, 2022
Same agency: DoW
- DOW-UAP-D094 — Analysis of Flying Object Incidents in the United States, 1949
- DOW-UAP-D097 — Project Sign Progress Report, 1948
- DOW-UAP-D084 — US Army-Flying-Saucer-Study 1949
- DOW-UAP-D155 — Air Intelligence Information Report, Saudi Arabia, 1957
- DOW-UAP-D176 — Triangular UAP AARO Memorandum for Record, 2026
- DOW-UAP-D177 — Unresolved UAP Report, Catalina Island, 1955