Home › Archive › DoW

DOW-UAP-D185 — Review of AAWSAP Special Access Program Request, November 2009

File DOW-UAP-D185 is a declassified pdf from Department of War, recording an incident dated 11/13/09 at Washington, D.C., published in Release 08 (2026-11-20). This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.

File
DOW-UAP-D185
Agency
Department of War
Incident date
11/13/09
Location
Washington, D.C.
Released in
Release 08 (2026-11-20)
File type
PDF

Topics: AAWSAP & DIRDs

This document is an administrative or programmatic record related to the Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Applications Program (AAWSAP), a Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA)-administered program active from 2008 to 2012. AAWSAP’s official scope of work identified 12 technical research areas relating to potential aerospace threats over a time horizon of more than 40 years. As an administrative record, the file documents how AAWSAP was scoped, organized, tasked, funded, or described at a particular point in time.

This November 2009 DIA information memorandum evaluates Senator Harry Reid’s June 2009 request (DOW-UAP-D183) to place portions of the AAWSAP contract, described in his letter under the alternate name “Advanced Aerospace Threat and Identification Program” (AAITP), into a restricted Special Access Program (SAP). The memorandum concludes that DIA could not find adequate justification for such a step, stating that all first-year program documents had been unclassified, that the contractor had not established a secure facility during that period, and that DIA was unaware of any delivered report containing information sensitive enough to warrant additional compartmentation. It further argues that the available material did not meet the threshold for original classification, in part because much of it consisted of publicly available scientific or technical information, and it characterizes Reid’s claims of highly sensitive findings as more plausibly referring to future phases of the effort than to the reports already delivered. In effect, the document is a formal internal finding that Senator Reid’s SAP request was not warranted, grounded in DIA’s view that the program’s first-year outputs did not justify heightened protection beyond normal classification procedures.

Open original file · WAR.GOV page

AI summary

This unclassified information memorandum, dated November 13, 2009, was written by the Director of the Defense Intelligence Agency for the Director of Special Programs at the Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence. The document evaluates a request from Senator Harry Reid to establish a restricted Special Access Program for the Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Application Program. The Defense Intelligence Agency concludes that there is inadequate justification for such a program because most deliverables remain unclassified, and future classified reports will be protected under standard procedures. The memo states that the information does not meet criteria for original classification or alternative control measures, noting that the agency is unaware of any reports containing information sensitive enough to require extraordinary protection.

Full text

Page 1

UNCLASSIFIED.'.'l>OiWO

DEFENSE INTELLIGENCE AGENCY
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20340-5100

INFO MEMO

NOV 132009

U-09-2660/CE

FOR: DIRECTOR, SPECIAL PROGRAMS, OFFICE OF THE UNDER SECRETARY
OF DEFENSE FOR INTELLIGENCE
FROM: ��� Director, Defense Intelligence Agency
SUBJECT: (U) Review of Special Access Program Request
(U/.'FOUO, This info memo responds to your request for the Defense Intelligence
Agency (DIA) Defense Warning Office (DWO) to evaluate a request from Senator Harry
Reid (enclosure 1) to establish a restricted special access program (SAP) for the
Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Application Program Contract, referred to in
Senator Reid's letter as the Advanced Aerospace Threat and Identification Program
(AAITP). In reviewing the deliverables to date and looking ahead to planned production
in fiscal year (FY) 2010, DIA cannot find adequate justification to establish a restricted
SAP.
(U//fOUO� All program documents delivered to DWO during FY 2009 (the first year of
the program) were unclassified because the contractor had not established a secure
facility, and program employees were being vetted for clearances. In FY 20 I 0, most
research products will remain at the unclassified level. However, four to six of the
original technical reports will be expanded to included classified data. These reports will
focus on foreign research in a particular technology area and will likely be derivatively
classified at the secret level. Based on classification levels of current and projected
program deliverables, there are insufficient grounds to classify this open program, invoke
alternative or compensatory control measures (ACCM), or establish a restricted SAP.
• (U/,'fQUO) Classifying the overall program by derivative means is impractical given
Department of Defense Regulation, DoD 5200.1-R Information Security Program
guidance: No reports produced thus far have extracted, paraphrased, or restated
information obtained from previously classified material (para C3 .1.1 ). Future reports
that contain classified information will be marked and protected according to the
original classification authority (para C3 .1 .2. l . l ).
• (U/;1fOUO) Classifying the overall program by original means is inadvisable:
Information contained in the repo11s is not owned by, produced by or for, or under
control of the U.S. government (para C2.3.l . l ). DIA cannot identify any damage that

UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO

Page 2

UN CLASSIFIED/,'f:i6ti8
could result from unauthorized disclosure (para C2.3.1.3) of publically available
information. Although the information can loosely be tied to one of the eligibility
criteria for classification (scientific, technological, or economic matters relating to the
national security (para C2.3.2.5)), DIA is prohibited from classifying basic scientific
research, and its result, unless it clearly relates to national security (para C2.4.3.2).
This requirement has not been met.

• (U.'.'17�1"8' In the second paragraph of his letter, Senator Reid cites "the identification
of several highly sensitive, unconventional aerospace-related findings" that will
"require extraordinary protection." Although most of the unclassified reports discuss
unconventional aerospace technologies, DIA is unaware of any report containing
information sufficiently sensitive and vulnerable to require extra protection associated
with either ACCM or a restricted SAP (paras C6.8. l .2 and C8. l . l .3). DIA assumes
these statements are in reference to future phases of this program and highlight
security and counterintelligence concerns that appear to be the main focus of Senator
Reid's letter.

(U,'/f9l!J9) Pursuant to a request from the Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for 1843(a)(3)
Intelligence, Special Programs staff!AAP Person 1
DWO contract officer for the
Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Application Program Contract, has forwarded draft,/
copies of technical reports from the first year, which will be published in the comin
months. If you have questions about the contents of these repo1ts, please contact
--------""'
l1843(a)(3)
�he Defense Warning Office. He will an-ange to have AAP Person 1
review the reports with your staff.

!

(U) Prepared by: l1843(
_ _ a)
_ _<3)_ ___ IDefense Warning Office, 1843(a)(3)
1 _ _ _ _ _ ____,
....
__
....

2
UNCLASSIFIED/.'FO�O

Page 3

DEFENSE INTELLIGENCE AGENCY
Washington, D.C. 20340-0001

DIAC

SUBJECT: Review of Special Ac
Date Received: 4 Nov 09
o,
Date Logged-In:
5-Nov-09 09:26
TO

CS-lC
CS-1

cs

TO: DD

INITIAL

DATE

1843(a)(3)

cr-,NOV(11

1843(a)(3)

Subject: Review of Special Access Request

l:l.NDVOi

Ms. Long:
Attached please revised subject info memo to OUSD(I) for your
review and approval. This version incorporates CP comments.
Very Respectfully,
I1843(a)(3)

�tJDV

CS-1

...

CE Admin
DD-XA
DD-XO

1843(a)(3)

DD

DR-XA
DR-XO

1�� bAC:, � C9 -\o � �

I

1AJ�
J,1

.

1843(a)(3)

�

ll, I:, .07

1843(a)(3)

DR

CS-lC

(Final
Disposition)

1843(a)(3)

DIA FORM 96-1 (04·08)

I

PREVIOUS EDITTON OBSOLETE

DO NOT REMOVE FORM FROM PACKAGE

Previous: DOW-UAP-D184 — AAWSAP Talking Paper for Senator Reid Engagement, May 2009 · Next: DOW-UAP-D186 — DIA Information Memorandum on AATIP (AAWSAP), December 2010

Same topic: title & summary match

Same location: Washington, D.C.

Same period: 2009

Same release: Release 08

Same agency: DoW