Home › Archive › NASA

NASA UAP Independent Study Team — Final Report

File NASA-uap-independent-study-team-final-report is a declassified pdf from NASA. This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.

File
NASA-uap-independent-study-team-final-report
Agency
NASA
File type
PDF

The 36-page final report of the NASA UAP Independent Study Team (Sep 2023). Recommends a unified data-collection strategy, expanded use of NASA Earth-observing assets, and AI/ML for anomaly detection. Led by astrophysicist David Spergel.

Open original file · SCIENCE.NASA.GOV page

TL;DR

Who knew 36 pages could cause more speculation than a runway?

  • NASA UAP Independent Study Team final report, Sep 2023, 36 pages, led by David Spergel.
  • Recommends unified data-collection, expanded Earth-observing assets, AI/ML for anomaly detection.
  • No official conclusion in the file.

AI summary

The NASA UAP Independent Study Team — Final Report, dated October 2025, outlines the team's objectives, members, and methods for studying Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena. It describes NASA's role in data collection and analysis, including the use of Earth-observing satellites and commercial remote-sensing data. The report discusses the need for improved data strategies, AI, and machine learning to analyze UAP. It highlights findings related to UAP reported by military aviators and mentions specific events like "GoFast," analyzed by Navy aviators. The document emphasizes challenges in data collection, sensor calibration, and integration across agencies. It also touches on NASA's search for extraterrestrial life and technosignatures, though UAPs are not directly linked to this effort. The report recommends enhancing data standards and collaboration with government and commercial entities.

Full text

Page 2

Members of the NASA Unidentified Anomalous
Phenomena Independent Study Team
Chair
Dr. David Spergel
Simons Foundation

Designated Federal Official
Dr. Daniel Evans
NASA Headquarters

Panelists
Dr. Anamaria Berea
George Mason University

Capt. Scott Kelly, USN, Ret.
NASA Astronaut, Ret.

Dr. Federica Bianco
University of Delaware
Dr. Reggie Brothers
AE Industrial Partners
Dr. Paula Bontempi
University of Rhode Island
Dr. Jennifer Buss
Potomac Institute of Policy Studies
Dr. Nadia Drake
Science Journalist
Mr. Mike Gold
Redwire Space
Dr. David Grinspoon
Planetary Science Institute

Dr. Matt Mountain
Association of Universities
for Research and Astronomy
Mr. Warren Randolph
Federal Aviation Administration
Dr. Walter Scott
Maxar Technologies
Dr. Joshua Semeter
Boston University
Dr. Karlin Toner
Federal Aviation Administration
Dr. Shelley Wright
University of California, San Diego

Front and back cover photos: views of the earth as photographed
from the Earth-orbital Apollo 4 unmanned space mission.
All photos are from NASA unless otherwise indicated.

Page 3

TABLE OF CONTENTS
3

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

7

FOREWORD

9

INTRODUCTION

11

RESPONSES TO STATEMENT OF TASK

21

OVERALL CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

23

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

24

WORK PRODUCTS: DISCUSSION

Group Photo: Members of the NASA Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena Independent Study Team.

Page 5

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

NASA is in an excellent position
to contribute to UAP studies
within the broader whole-ofgovernment framework.

The study of Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP) presents a unique
scientific opportunity that demands a rigorous, evidence-based approach.
Addressing this challenge will require new and robust data acquisition methods,
advanced analysis techniques, a systematic reporting framework and reducing
reporting stigma. NASA – with its extensive expertise in these domains and
global reputation for scientific openness – is in an excellent position to contribute
to UAP studies within the broader whole-of-government framework led by the
All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO).
NASA has a variety of existing and planned Earth- and space-observing assets,
together with an extensive archive of historic and current data sets, which
should be directly leveraged to understand UAP. Although NASA’s fleet of
Earth-observing satellites typically lack the spatial resolution to detect relatively
small objects such as UAP, their state-of-the-art sensors can be directly utilized
to probe the state of the local earth, oceanic, and atmospheric conditions that
are spatially and temporally coincident with UAPs initially detected via other
methods. Thus, NASA’s assets can play a vital role by directly determining
whether specific environmental factors are associated with certain reported UAP
behaviors or occurrences.
Next, the U.S. commercial remote-sensing industry offers a potent mix of
Earth-observing satellites that offer imagery at sub- to several-meter spatial
resolution, which is well-matched to the typical spatial scales of known UAP.
Although every point on Earth does not have constant high-resolution coverage,
the panel finds nonetheless that such commercial constellations could offer
a powerful complement to the detection and study of UAP when coincident
collection occurs.
At present, analysis of UAP data is hampered by poor sensor calibration, the
lack of multiple measurements, the lack of sensor metadata, and the lack of
baseline data. Making a concerted effort to improve all aspects is vital, and
NASA’s expertise should be comprehensively leveraged as part of a robust and
systematic data acquisition strategy within the whole-of-government framework.
Moving forward, NASA should contribute to a comprehensive, government-wide
approach to collecting future data. The importance of detecting UAP with multiple,
well-calibrated sensors is paramount, and NASA could potentially leverage its
considerable expertise in this domain to utilize multispectral or hyperspectral
data as part of a rigorous data acquisition campaign.
The panel finds that artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) are
essential tools for identifying rare occurrences, potentially including UAP,
within vast datasets. However, these powerful techniques will only work on
well-characterized data gathered with respect to strong standards. NASA’s
extensive experience in the application of state-of-the-art computational and

3

Page 6

data-analysis techniques should therefore be leveraged to provide critical
assistance. Once again, appropriate data collection, curation, and distribution
are paramount; NASA, with its world-leading experience in these aspects is
well-positioned to play a leading role.
Engaging the public is also a critical aspect of understanding UAP. The panel
sees several advantages to augmenting data collection efforts using modern
crowdsourcing techniques, including open-source smartphone-based apps that
simultaneously gather imaging data and other smartphone sensor metadata
from multiple citizen observers worldwide. NASA should therefore explore the
viability of developing or acquiring such a crowdsourcing system as part of its
strategy. In turn, the panel finds that there is currently no standardized system
for making civilian UAP reports, resulting in sparse and incomplete data devoid
of curation or vetting protocols. NASA should play a vital role by assisting
AARO in its development of this Federal system.
The negative perception surrounding the reporting of UAP poses an obstacle to
collecting data on these phenomena. NASA’s very involvement in UAP will play
a vital role in reducing stigma associated with UAP reporting, which almost
certainly leads to data attrition at present. NASA’s long-standing public trust,
which is essential for communicating findings about these phenomena to
citizens, is crucial for destigmatizing UAP reporting. The scientific processes
used by NASA encourage critical thinking; NASA can model for the public how
to best approach the study of UAP, by utilizing transparent reporting, rigorous
analysis, and public engagement.
Finally, the threat to U.S. airspace safety posed by UAP is self-evident. The
panel finds that a particularly promising avenue for deeper integration within
a systematic, evidenced-based framework for UAP is the Aviation Safety
Reporting System (ASRS), which NASA administers for the FAA. This confidential and voluntary reporting system for pilots, air traffic controllers, and
other professional aviation staff, receives approximately 100,000 reports per
year. Although not initially designed for UAP collection, better harnessing it for
commercial pilot UAP reporting would provide a critical database that would be
valuable for the whole-of-government effort to understand UAP. In turn, NASA’s
long history of partnership with the FAA should be leveraged to investigate how
advanced, real-time analysis techniques could be applied to future generations
of air traffic management (ATM) systems.

4

Page 7

FRAMEWORK OF RECOMMENDATIONS
Although AARO leads the whole-of-government response to UAP, the
panel recommends that NASA play an essential role within that framework.
NASA should leverage its core capabilities and expertise to determine
whether it should take a leading or supporting role in implementing a
given recommendation.

ORGANIZATION OF THIS REPORT
This report is organized as follows. We present a systematic response
to the eight charge elements that formed the Terms of Reference that
NASA provided to the Independent Study Team, followed by a detailed
set of conclusions and recommendations. These responses stemmed
from a series of sub-panel reports that the entire team deliberated in full
at the public meeting held on May 31, 2023, all of which are included
as work products toward the end of this report for full public transparency.

An orbital sunrise photographed by an Expedition 40 crew member on the International Space Station.

5

Page 9

FOREWORD
Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP) are one of our planet’s greatest
mysteries. Observations of objects in our skies that cannot be identified as
balloons, aircraft, or natural known phenomena have been spotted worldwide,
yet there are limited high-quality observations. The nature of science is to
explore the unknown, and data is the language scientists use to discover our
universe’s secrets. Despite numerous accounts and visuals, the absence of
consistent, detailed, and curated observations means we do not presently have
the body of data needed to make definitive, scientific conclusions about UAP.
At NASA, we use data and the tools of science to explore the unknown in the
atmosphere and space. In June 2022, NASA established an external independent
study team to find a way we can use our open-source data and resources to
help shed light on the nature of future UAP. Much like a team of peer reviewers,
NASA commissions independent study teams as a formal part of NASA’s
scientific process, and such teams provide the agency external counsel and
an increased network of perspectives from esteemed scientific experts.
NASA’s UAP Independent Study Team is made up of 16 experts from diverse
backgrounds in science, technology, data, artificial intelligence, space exploration, aerospace safety, media and commercial innovation. They were assigned
to pinpoint the data available around UAP and produce a report that outlines
a roadmap for how NASA can use its tools of science to obtain usable data
to evaluate and categorize the nature of UAP going forward. This is not a review
of previous UAP incidents.
We thank the UAP Independent Study Team members for their service on the
study and for their contributions towards the advancement of our nation’s
understanding of UAP. While we are still evaluating the report and assessing
the team’s findings and recommendations, NASA’s Science Mission Directorate
and the Agency are committed to keeping a clear and open pipeline for
communication and resources with the Department of Defense’s AllDomain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO) to support its whole-of-government
approach towards understanding and resolving UAP cases. NASA is appointing
a Director of UAP Research to centralize communications and leverage
NASA’s extensive resources and expertise to actively engage in the whole-ofgovernment UAP initiative. This individual will also ensure that the agency’s vast
analytical capabilities, including its proficiency in data management, machine
learning and artificial intelligence, are contributed to the government’s unified
UAP effort.
At NASA, we are committed to openness, transparency, and scientific integrity
and they are a central part of our operations. By setting up this independent
study team, NASA gained important external perspectives from leading experts
in our nation for how we can use our resources to advance the study of UAP
data and explore the unknown in air and space for the benefit of all.

Dr. Nicola Fox, Associate Administrator, Science Mission Directorate
7

Page 11

INTRODUCTION
Recently, many credible witnesses, often military aviators, have reported seeing
objects they did not recognize over U.S. airspace. Most of these events have
since been explained, but a small handful cannot be immediately identified as
known human-made or natural phenomena. These events are now collectively
referred to as Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena, or UAP1.
A vital part of NASA’s mission is exploring the unknown using the rigorous
process of the scientific method. This means scrutinizing our assumptions
and intuition; transparently and diligently collecting data; reproducing results;
seeking independent evaluation; and finally, reaching a scientific consensus
about the nature of an occurrence. The scientific method challenges us to solve
problems by impartially evaluating our own ideas, by being willing to be wrong,
and by following the data.
It is increasingly clear that the majority of UAP observations can be attributed to
known phenomena or occurences. When it comes to studying such phenomena,
our overarching challenge is that the data needed to explain these anomalous
sightings often do not exist; this includes eyewitness reports, which on their
own can be interesting and compelling, but are not reproducible and usually
lack the information needed to make any definitive conclusions about a UAP’s
provenance. Thus, to understand UAP, a rigorous, evidence-based, data-driven
scientific framework is essential.
This report offers a vision of how NASA could contribute to understanding
the phenomena and how the agency’s approach will complement the whole-ofgovernment effort to understand UAP.

1 At the time that this study was initiated, Congress
defined UAP as Unidentified Aerial Phenomena.
After this study began, the term UAP was redefined
as Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena.

9

Page 13

RESPONSES TO STATEMENT
OF TASK
1

FINDING
NASA'S fleet of earth-observing satellites
should play a powerful supporting role
to determine the environmental conditions
that coincide with UAP.

FINDING
It is essential to note the pivotal role that
structured data curation plays in a rigorous
and evidence-based framework to better
understand UAP.

What types of scientific data currently collected and archived by NASA or
other civilian government entities should be synthesized and analyzed to
potentially shed light on the nature and origins of Unidentified Anomalous
Phenomena (UAP)?
NASA has a variety of existing and planned Earth- and space-observing assets,
together with an extensive archive of historic and current data sets, which
should be used to address the challenges of detecting and/or understanding
UAP. NASA’s fleet of Earth-observing satellites collect the most data within the
Earth system, yet they typically lack the spatial resolution to detect relatively
small objects such as UAP. However, they still should play a powerful supporting
role to determine the environmental conditions that coincide with UAP. For
example, the advanced sensors on the Terra and Aqua missions should be
directly utilized to retroactively probe the state of the local earth, ocean, and
atmospheric conditions that are spatially and temporally coincident with UAP
initially detected via other methods. Thus, NASA can help determine whether
specific environmental factors are associated with reported UAP properties
or occurrences.
There are other promising civilian capabilities that can be employed to scrutinize
UAP. Assets such as the NEXRAD Doppler radar network (160 weather radars
jointly operated by the FAA, U.S. Air Force, and National Weather Service) or
the Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellites will be essential for
distinguishing interesting objects from airborne clutter. Furthermore, forthcoming
large-sky surveys enabled by ground-based telescopes such as the Vera C.
Rubin Observatory will offer powerful complements in the search for anomalous
objects beyond the Earth’s atmosphere.
NASA also has substantial experience in Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR),
which can provide much higher angular resolution images of Earth, as well as
confirm surface motion and change. The panel sees particular promise in future
SAR-based Earth-observing satellites such as NISAR (NASA-ISRO Synthetic
Aperture Radar) mission, a partnership with the Indian Space Research Organization. The excellent resolution of NISAR will provide valuable radar data that
will potentially be critical for examining UAP directly, in addition to their environmental context. SAR systems will also provide critical validation of any truly
anomalous properties, such as rapid acceleration or high-G maneuvers through
the Doppler signatures they produce.
Irrespective of the source of the observation, it is essential to note the pivotal
role that structured data curation plays in a rigorous and evidence-based
framework to better understand UAP. To date, UAP data often consist of
observations initially acquired for other purposes, which often lack adequate

11

Page 14

metadata and are not optimized for systematic scientific analysis. Here, NASA
– with its world-leading expertise in curation, archiving, and distribution of large
volumes of data – can play a key role. NASA’s adherence to FAIR (Findability,
Accessibility, Interoperability and Reusability) data principles when generating
curated data repositories enables both scientists and citizen scientists to
conduct data-mining and meaningful analysis. In addition, due to the absence
of a comprehensive system for gathering civilian UAP reports, there are inconsistencies in how data is collected, processed, and curated. The application
of NASA’s rigor to UAP data protocols will ultimately be essential for a detailed
understanding of these phenomena.

South Asian Object (Image 1)
Footage taken by an MQ-9 of an unidentified object in South Asia with an apparent
atmospheric wake or cavitation, later assessed as a likely commercial aircraft by the
All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office. The cavitation is likely a sensor artifact resulting
from video compression.
The appearance of U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) visual information does not imply or constitute DoD endorsement.

2

FINDING
The U.S. commercial remote-sensing
industry offers a potent mix of Earthobserving sensors that have the collective
potential to directly resolve UAP events.

What types of scientific data currently collected and held by non-profits and
companies should be synthesized and analyzed to potentially shed light on
the nature and origins of UAP?
The U.S. commercial remote-sensing industry offers a potent mix of Earthobserving sensors that have the collective potential to directly resolve UAP
events. For instance, commercial satellite constellations provide imagery at
sub- to several-meter spatial resolution, which is well-matched to the typical
spatial scales of known UAP. In addition, the high temporal cadence offered by
commercial remote-sensing networks can substantially increase the likelihood
of providing retroactive coverage of UAP events that are initially observed via
other means. The limitation on this data is that at any given time most of the
Earth’s surface is not covered by commercial satellites at high resolution — for
a particular UAP event, we will need to be fortunate to obtain high-resolution
observations from space.
Beyond this, the panel applauds the efforts undertaken in the private sector and
U.S. academic community to employ one or more inexpensive ground-based
sensors that are capable of surveying large areas of the sky. Such sensors,
which could potentially be rapidly deployed to areas of known UAP activity may
play a key role in establishing so-called “pattern-of-activity” trends, as well as
potentially the physical characteristics of UAP themselves.

12

Page 15

Once more, however, robust data calibration is vital, and here NASA again can
play an important advisory role. The calibration process ensures that information gathered from sensors and instruments is precise, dependable and devoid
of any systematic errors or biases. In the case of UAP studies, where data
often originates from instruments not specifically designed for detecting such
objects, proper calibration becomes even more crucial. In turn, metadata, which
provides contextual information such as sensor type, manufacturer details,
noise characteristics and time of acquisition, must simultaneously be present
for an accurate characterization of both a potential UAP as well as the sensor
itself. Indeed, several apparent UAP have been demonstrated to be sensor
artifacts once appropriate calibration and metadata scrutiny were applied.
Although a substantial investment, the standardization of collected information
via well-crafted calibration will make it possible to carry out a rigorous scientific
investigation into UAP. NASA’s experience in this area will be essential.

FINDING
The standardization of collected
information via well-crafted calibration
will make it possible to carry out a rigorous
scientific investigation into UAP. NASA's
experience in this area will be vital.

3

FINDING
NASA should leverage its considerable
expertise in this domain to potentially utilize
multispectral or hyperspectral data as part
of a rigorous campaign.

What other types of scientific data should be collected by NASA to enhance
the potential for developing an understanding of the nature and origins
of UAP?
To improve our understanding of UAP, NASA should contribute to a comprehensive approach to collecting data within the broader whole-of-government
framework to understand UAP. The importance of detecting UAP with multiple,
well-calibrated sensors is paramount, and NASA should leverage its considerable expertise in this domain to potentially utilize multispectral or hyperspectral
data as part of a rigorous campaign to acquire additional data on future UAP.
In addition, forthcoming large-sky surveys enabled by Federal ground-based
assets including the Vera C. Rubin Observatory will collect vast quantities of
data, which can be directly used to search for anomalous objects beyond the
Earth’s atmosphere.
Data signatures are vast, and theories that predict novel signatures help guide
our searches. It is imperative to set clear evidence thresholds to avoid errors,
especially with automated methods. Furthermore, purpose-built future sensors
for UAP detection should be designed to adjust on millisecond timescales to aid
better detection. In lockstep, alert systems should detect and share transient
information quickly and uniformly.
The panel notes that, at present, gathering data on UAP is hampered by sensor
calibration challenges and a lack of sensor metadata. In short, calibration
ensures that future data gathered are reliable and accurate, while gathering
metadata – such as the time, location, and sensor observing modes – ensures
that the contextual and environmental factors of a recorded UAP event are well

13

Page 16

known. Both, in turn, allow for systematic analyses of UAP events, and critically
will enable the elimination of false positives due to sensor artifacts. Making a
concerted effort to improve both aspects will be vital when gathering future data,
and here NASA’s expertise should be comprehensively leveraged as part of a
robust and systematic data strategy within the whole-of-government framework.

FINDING
NASA’s expertise should be
comprehensively leveraged
as part of a robust and systematic
data strategy within the whole-ofgovernment framework.

The panel also sees several advantages to augmenting potential data collection efforts using modern crowdsourcing techniques, including open-source
smartphone-based apps that simultaneously gather imaging data and other
smartphone sensor data from multiple citizen observers. NASA should therefore
explore the viability of developing or acquiring such a crowdsourcing system
as part of a future data strategy.
As stated above, NASA’s fleet of Earth-observing satellites must also play a
key role in collecting future data on environmental conditions coinciding with
UAP sightings. Despite the mismatch in spatial resolution between the present
generation of satellites and typical UAP events, by gathering and analyzing
future satellite data, we will undoubtedly gain insights into the typical environmental factors associated with UAP. Future missions, such as the NOAA/NASA
Geostationary Extended Observations (GeoXO) satellite system, will provide
even more robust data that will prove important in UAP analysis. NASA should
also leverage sensors that expand its observational reach, such as penetrating
deeper into the ocean or at the air/sea interfaces.
Next, collection efforts from radio and optical astronomy that are designed for
technosignature searches should be expanded from the Earth's atmosphere to
the whole solar system. Additionally, near-Earth objects (NEO) programs also
have significant data collections about phenomena close to Earth’s atmosphere,
which constitutes an untapped repository of data both for characterizing natural
phenomena and anomalies. NASA should consider integrating these elements
as part of a robust future-data strategy.
Finally, NASA’s very involvement in gathering future data will play an important
role in reducing stigma associated with UAP reporting, which very likely leads
to data attrition at present. NASA’s long-standing public trust, which is essential
for communicating findings about these phenomena to citizens, is crucial for
destigmatizing UAP reporting and scientific research. The scientific processes
used by NASA encourage critical thinking; NASA can model for the public how
to approach a topic, such as UAP, by applying transparent reporting and
rigorous analyses when acquiring future data.

14

Page 17

Middle East Object
Footage taken by an MQ-9 of an
apparent silver, orb-like object in
the Middle East. Due to limited data,
the object remains unidentified.
The appearance of U.S. Department of Defense
(DoD) visual information does not imply or constitute
DoD endorsement.

4

FINDING
AI and ML, combined with NASA's
extensive expertise, should be utilized
to investigate the nature and origins
of UAP.

Which scientific analysis techniques currently in production could be
employed to assess the nature and origins of UAP? Which types of
analysis techniques should be developed?
Artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) have proven to be essential
tools for identifying rare occurrences within vast datasets. These methodologies, combined with NASA’s extensive experience and expertise, should
be utilized to investigate the nature and origins of UAP by examining data from
sources such as satellites and radar systems. However, the effectiveness of
AI and ML in studying UAP depends critically upon the quality of the data used
to train the AI and in subsequent analysis. At present, UAP analysis is more
limited by the quality of data than by the availability of techniques. As a
consequence, it is a higher priority to obtain better quality data than it is to
develop new analysis techniques.
Once AARO and other agencies, including NASA, accumulate an extensive
and well-curated catalog of baseline data, these can be used to train neural
networks so that they can characterize deviations from normal. The panel finds
that standard techniques that are routinely applied in astronomy, particle
physics, and other areas of science can be adapted for these analyses.
When it comes to detecting anomalies – such as UAP – within datasets, there
are two approaches. The first approach involves constructing a model that
represents the expected signal characteristics then searching for any matches
against this model. The second approach involves using a model of the background properties and searching for anything that deviates from that model.
The panel notes that the first approach is difficult as we do not possess a
consistent description of the physical characteristics of UAP. The second

15

Page 18

approach, on the other hand, requires an understanding of what is considered
normal and known in a given search area, which can then be distinguished from
what is unusual and unknown. AARO has already begun this task by studying
what “normal” phenomena such as solar glint or balloons look like to military
sensors. The program of systematically calibrating observations of “normal” is
an essential step before starting to search for the abnormal.
A third potential avenue for scientific analysis is to cross-correlate NASA’s
extensive databases with the locations and times of reported UAP events.
Once an extensive list of UAP reports is made available, the panel regards this
as a promising method for future analysis. Again, NASA's expertise in AI and
ML will allow it to make a prominent contribution.

FINDING
NASA, with its expertise in data calibration,
management, and advanced analysis is
well-positioned to take a central role in
these efforts.

For any scientific analysis purposes, including UAP analysis, it is essential that
the data used for AI and ML are collected according to rigorous standards. The
data must be collected using calibrated instruments tailored to their respective
use cases accompanied by metadata to facilitate calibration and contextual
comprehension. Proper curation and integration of data are also critical for
enabling scientific analysis. To establish a baseline understanding, an examination of known events with precisely calibrated instruments is also necessary. NASA, with its expertise in data calibration, management, and advanced
analysis is well-positioned to take a central role in these efforts within the
whole-of-government framework to assess UAP.

5

In considering the factors above, what basic physical constraints
can be placed on the nature and origins of UAP?
Observations of UAP to date are inconsistent and do not adhere to similar
characteristics. As a consequence, it is difficult to put physical constraints on
them at present, which provides a strong motivation for the rigorous, evidencebased framework articulated in this report. The strongest physical constraints
are not on the anomalous events but on the conventional events: we know the
range of velocities and accelerations that can be achieved by state-of-the art
platforms, drones, balloons and planes. Deviations from this behavior, such as
any well-characterized observation of velocities and accelerations outside of
that range, are scientifically interesting for UAP assessment and analysis. The
panel emphasizes that clearly determining distances is key to understanding
and corroborating any claimed anomalous high-velocity and high-acceleration
events, a fact borne out by AARO’s findings that the vast majority of UAP have
prosaic explanations.

16

Page 19

If the whole-of-government framework to understanding UAP – with NASA
playing a crucial role – were to implement the preponderance of steps
prescribed above, then the panel regards placing physical constraints on UAP,

Text continues in the original file (36 pages).

Same topic: title & summary match

Same agency: NASA