Home › Archive › DoW

DOW-UAP-D153 — AAWSAP DIRD, Quantum Tomography of Negative Energy States in the Vacuum, January 2011

File DOW-UAP-D153 is a declassified pdf from Department of War, recording an incident dated 1/11/11 at Las Vegas, Nevada, published in Release 06 (2026-09-18). This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.

File
DOW-UAP-D153
Agency
Department of War
Incident date
1/11/11
Location
Las Vegas, Nevada
Released in
Release 06 (2026-09-18)
File type
PDF

Topics: AAWSAP & DIRDs

This document is a Defense Intelligence Reference Document (DIRD), a technical reference format used by the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) to capture baseline knowledge on a specific topic for later analytic use. DIRDs are best understood as reference and synthesis products rather than as original research. It is one of 38 DIRDs produced under the Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Applications Program (AAWSAP) between 2009 and 2011. Because AAWSAP’s scope permitted a broad range of supporting topics, not every DIRD in the series directly concerns aerospace systems or future threat assessment. The following summary reflects the DIRD’s scope and framing at the time of writing and should not be read as implying current validation of the concepts discussed.

This DIRD examines how negative-energy, or “sub-vacuum,” states in quantum fields might be detected and mapped. Its practical scope is limited to the laboratory-scale measurement of minute quantum effects, though it extrapolates from those effects to consider theoretical relevance to concepts such as warp drives, wormholes, or gravitational control. By reviewing previously identified laboratory examples such as the Casimir effect and squeezed light states, the report identifies the core technical challenge as mapping their spatial and temporal structures reliably. To address this, it proposes quantum optical homodyne tomography as a method to reconstruct and quantify the vacuum fluctuations associated with these states. The document acknowledges that only microscopic, transient negative-energy effects have been realized in laboratory settings. It remains unknown whether larger or longer-lived distributions of such effects can be generated or stabilized, particularly given the experimentally unresolved constraints imposed by quantum inequalities. Overall, this DIRD functions as a measurement- and diagnostics-oriented review intended to lay experimental groundwork for a far more ambitious, highly speculative negative-energy research agenda.

Open original file · WAR.GOV page

TL;DR

Even the vacuum needed a PR spin in 2011.

  • DIRD D153, DoW, Jan 2011, Las Vegas lab study on negative-energy quantum states.
  • Describes homodyne tomography to map Casimir and squeezed-light negative-energy fluctuations.
  • No official conclusion in the file.

AI summary

A classified defense document titled "Quantum Tomography of Negative Energy States in the Vacuum," prepared by the Defense Intelligence Agency in January 2011. It outlines quantum field theory, negative energy states, and experiments involving the Casimir effect and squeezed light. The document discusses exotic matter required for faster-than-light travel and antigravity, focusing on sub-vacuum energy, quantum vacuum fluctuations, and energy density fluctuations. It covers quantum optics, vacuum states, zero-point energy, operators, quadratures, and squeezed light. The text includes technical discussions of quantum mechanics, Wigner functions, phase shifts, and quantum states, along with equations, figures, and experimental data. It describes methods for detecting negative energy densities using balanced homodyne detection and references studies on squeezed light and sub-vacuum fluctuations. The document concludes with references to academic papers and books related to physics, energy states, and quantum field theory, spanning from 1948 to 2009. No UAPs or unidentified objects are reported.

Full text

Page 2

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOA OlifilGIAk WSE 8HLV

Quantum Tomography of Negative Energy States in the
Vacuum

The Defense Intelligence Reference Document provides non-substantive but
authoritative reference information related to intelligence topics or methodologies.

Prepared by:
Technology Warning Division (DW0-4)
Defense Warning Office
Directorate for Analysis
Defense Intelligence Agency

Author:

AAP Person 58

COPYRIGHT WARNING: Further dissemination of the photographs in this publication is not authorized.
This product is one of a series of advanced technology reports produced in FY 2010 under the Defense
Intelligence Agency, Defense Warning Office's Advanced Aerospace Weapons System Applications
AAWSA Pro ram. Comments or questions pertaining to this document should be addressed to
MP Person 1
AAWSA Program Manager, Defense Intelligence Agency, ATTN: JUIAF ashington D.C. 20340-5100.

ii

UNCLASSIFIED/ }FQA QFFIGl,t.L: W&ii 9tlb¥

Page 3

UNCLASSIFIED/ /EOR OFFIEIAk W&liii 8PtLY

Contents
Introduction ........................................................................................................... 1
REVIEW OF NEGATIVE (or SUB-VACUUM) ENERGY ................................................. 3

Overview ........................................................................................................ 3
Examples of Negative (Sub-Vacuum) Energy Found in Nature ....................... 4
Basic Notions of the Quantum Field Theory of Light ................................... 5
Basic Notions on the Origin of the Quantum Vacuum Zero-Point

Fluctuations ............................................................................................... 7
Negative (Sub-Vacuum) Energy in Squeezed Light .................................... 8
Negative (Sub-Vacuum) Energy in the Casimir Effect................................ 13
QUANTUM OPTICAL HOMODYNE TOMOGRAPHY .................................................... 15

Observing Negative Energy in the Lab .......................................................... 15
Basic Notions of Quantum Optical Homodyne Tomography .......................... 16
Wigner Functions ..................................................................................... 17
Beam Splitters.......................................................................................... 24
Photodiodes ............................................................................................. 27
Balanced Homodyne Detection ................................................................. 27
Outline of Experimental Procedure ........................................................... 32
BALANCED HOMODYNE SYSTEMS FOR MEASURING NEGATIVE
(SUB-VACUUM) ENERGY ....................................................................................... 33

Time-Domain Balanced Homodyne System .................................................. 33
Balanced Homodyne System for Casimir Cavities ......................................... 36
CONCLUSION ........................................................................................................ 43
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ......................................................................................... 45
REFERENCES ........................................................................................................ 46

iii

UNCLASSIFIED// FOR OFFICIAL U:!I! fJHLY

Page 4

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOA QFFI@IAL l:l!H! 9HLY

Figures
Figure 1. Illustration of a Squeezed State of Light ............................................... 13
Figure 2. Schematic of the Casimir Effect ............................................................. 14
Figure 3. Illustration of Quantum Optical Homodyne Tomography ....................... 16
Figure 4. Wigner Function for a Vacuum and for a Coherent State ....................... 19
Figure 5. Wigner Function of a Squeezed Vacuum ................................................ 20
Figure 6. Wigner Function of a Single Photon ....................................................... 21
Figure 7. Quantum Tomography of Schrodinger-Cat States .................................. 22
Figure 8. Schematic of an Ideal Lossless Beam Splitter ........................................ 25
Figure 9. Illustration of a Fictitious Beam Splitter ................................................ 26
Figure 10. Schematic of a Balanced Homodyne Detector...................................... 29
Figure 11. Balanced Homodyne Detector Using Fictitious Beam Splitters ............. 31
Figure 12. Balanced Homodyne Detector Using A Single Effective Fictitious Beam
Splitter ................................................................................................................. 32
Figure 13. Time-Domain Balanced Homodyne Detector........................................ 34
Figure 14. Experimentally Measured Squeezed State ........................................... 35
Figure 15. Balanced Homodyne Detector with a Local Oscillator .......................... 38
Figure 16. Diagram of Casimir Cavity with BHD Photodiodes ............................... 40
Figure 17. Experimental Setup of BHD Photodiodes and LO Field ......................... 40
Figure 18. Detailed Schematic of Experimental BHD Apparatus ........................... 41
Figure 19. Predicted Casimir Spectral Density ...................................................... 41
Figure 20. Predicted Suppression of Vacuum Fluctuations in dB.......................... 42

iv

UNCLASSIFIED/ /EOR OEEICl.1.1. Uiliii ONI.¥

Page 5

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR. OFFICIAL tt.!I!! OHL¥

Quantum Tomography of Negative Energy States in the
Vacuum
Introduction
Future aerospace vehicles could have an advanced propulsion system that uses
negative quantum vacuum energy to modify the spacetime geometry in the immediate
vicin ity surrounding the vehicle in order to induce faster-than -l ight motion via
traversable wormholes or warp drives, or even levitation via antigravity [1, 2]. These
exotic propulsion concepts are well-known in mainstream general relativity and
quantum field theory research. The notion of a physical state with negative energy is
not familiar in the realm of classical physics. However, it is not rare in quantum field
theory to have quantum states with negative energy density or a negative energy flux.
Even for a quantum scalar field in the flat Minkowski spacetime, it can be proved that
the existence of quantum states with negative energy density is inevitable [3].
Although all known forms of classical matter have non-negative energy density, it is not
so in quantum field theory. A general quantum state can be a superposition of particle
number eigenstates and may have a negative expectation value of energy density in
certain spacetime regions due to quantum coherence effects [3]. These considerations
remain true even for quantum fields in a curved spacetime where the effects of
gravitational fields, or equivalently, accelerations, can be observed due to the mass of
astronomical bodies or the motions of astronomical bodies.
There are two key examples of specially prepared quantum vacuum states that are
known to produce small amounts of negative energy density in the laboratory. These
are the well-known Casimir effect and the squeezed vacuum states of the
electromagnetic field. The former is a static quantum vacuum effect wh ile the latter is
a time-domain quantum vacuum effect. There are several other examples of special
quantum vacuum or particle states that produce negative energy density, but they are
beyond the scope of this report because they remain mathematical curiosities or are not
practicable to im plement in the laboratory in the foreseeable future.
We already make small amounts of negative energy in the laboratory via the Casimir
effect and squeezed electromagnetic vacuum states, but we do not yet know if we can
access larger amounts for extended periods of time over extended spatial distributions
for the purpose of modifying spacetime for aerospace propulsion applications. It will be
necessary to first explore the quantum natu re of the Casimir effect and squeezed
electromagnetic vacuum states to determine whether we can measure and spatially
map their negative energy density. This is a necessary first step to take before
beginning any study on producing large quantities of negative energy because we will
first need to know how to measure and spatially map negative energy in order to
properly control it after producing it. This is the motivation for this report.
We need to firm up our understanding of how lab detectors will respond to negative
energy in situ. A first step in this direction was already taken by Hansen et al. [4] in
2001 for the time-domain negative energy pulses in squeezed electromagnetic vacuum
states, and more recently Marecki [5, 6] generalized the analysis of the output of
balanced homodyne detectors (BHDs) for t he case of static negative energy states

1

UNCLASSIFIED// FOR OFFICIAL U.!I!! or~L'

Page 6

UNCLASSIFIED/ }FOA OFFl&IAl WSE er•tv
inside Casimir cavities. The most important feature of these devices is their abi lity to
quantify the quantum vacuum fluctuations of the electric field because the output of
BHDs provides information on the one- and two-point functions of arbitrary states of
quantum fields. Marecki computed the two -point function and the associated spectral
density for the ground state of the quantum electric field in Casimir geometries, and
predicts a position- and frequency-dependent pattern of BHD responses if a device of
th is type is placed inside a Casimir cavity. The proposed device allows for the direct
detection of quantum vacuum fluctuations and provides a spatial mapping of the
negative energy contained inside the cavity, wh ich will be summarized in this report.

2

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFICIAL U.!! 8HLY

Page 7

UNCLASSIFIED/ /iOR QFFl&IAL l:ISI!!! Brit I

REVIEW OF NEGATIVE (or SUB-VACUUM) ENERGY
Overview
The implementation of faster-than-light (FTL) interstellar travel via traversable
wormholes or warp drives or other antigravity forces for propulsion, generally requires
the engineering of spacetime into very specialized local geometries surrounding the
immediate vicinity of the aerospace vehicle undergoing this type of motion. The
analysis of these via the general relativistic field equation plus the resultant source
matter equations of state demonstrates that such geometries require the use of
"exotic" matter in order to produce the requisite FTL or antigravity spacetime
modification . Exotic matter is generally defined by general relativity physics to be
matter that possesses (renormalized) negative energy density (sometimes negative
stress-tension = outward pressure, a.k.a. gravitational repulsion or antigravity), and
this is a very misunderstood and misapplied term by the non-general relativity
community. We clear up this misconception by defining what negative energy is, where
it can be found in nature, and we also review the two primary experimental concepts
that are known to produce negative energy in the laboratory. Also, it has been claimed
that FTL and antigravity spacetimes are not plausible because exotic matter violates the
general relativistic energy conditions. However, it has been shown that this is a
spurious issue. The identification, magnitude, and production of exotic matter is seen
to be a key technical challenge, however. FTL and antigravity spacetimes also possess
features that challenge the notions of causality and there are alleged constraints placed
upon them by quantum effects. Reference [1] reviews and summarizes these issues
with an assessment on the present state of their resolution.
What exactly is "exotic" matter? In classical physics the energy density of all observed
forms of matter (fields) is non-negative. What is exotic about the type of matter that
must be used to produce traversable wormhole, warp drive, or antigravity spacetimes is
that it must have negative energy density and/or negative flux [7]. The energy density
is "negative" in the sense that the configuration of matter fields we must deploy to
produce a traversable wormhole, warp drive, or antigravity effect must have an energy
density, PE (= pc2, where pis the rest-mass density), that is less t han or equal to its
pressures/tensions, pi [8, 9]. * In many cases, these equations of state are also known
to possess an energy density that is algebraically negative, i.e., the energy density and
flux are less than zero. It is on the basis of these conditions that we call this material
property "exotic." The condition for ordinary, classical (non-exotic) forms of matter
that we are all familiar with in nature is that PE> pi and/or PE;:::,: 0. These conditions
represent two examples of what are variously called the "standard" energy conditions
which are computed from the trace of the matter stress-energy tensort : Weak Energy
Condition (WEC: PE;:::,: 0, PE+ Pi;:::,: 0), Null Energy Condition (NEC: PE+ Pi;:::,: 0),
Dominant Energy Condition (DEC), and Strong Energy Condition (SEC). These energy
conditions forbid negative energy density between material objects to occur in nature,
but they are mere hypotheses. Hawking and Ellis [10] formulated the energy conditions
in order to establish a series of mathematical hypotheses governing the behavior of
• From this point forward, all Latin letters (e.g ., i, j, k = 1... 3) that appear as indices on physical quantities denote
the usual 3-dimensional space coordinates, x•...x3 , indicating the spatial components of vector or tensor quantities .
t The stress-energy-momentum tensor is a matrix quantity that encodes the density and fl ux of energy and
momentum for any type of matter under study .

3

UNCLASSIFIED/ ;<fQA OFFI@IAL l:ISf! 9Htl'

Page 8

UNCLASSIFIED/ /POI': orr1c11tt U.!I! Oflt I
collapsed-matter singularities in their study of cosmology and black hole physics. More
specifically, classical general relativity allows one to prove lots of general theorems
about the behavior of matter in gravitational fields.
However, real physica l matter is not "reasonable" because the energy conditions are in
general violated by semiclassical quantum effects ( occurring at order Tl) [9]. * More
specifically, quantum effects generically violate the average NEC (ANEC). Furthermore,
it was discovered in 1965 that quantum field theory has the remarkable property of
allowing states of matter containing local regions of negative energy density or negative
fluxes [3]. This violates the WEC, which postulates that the local energy density is non ­
negative for all observers. And there are also general theorems of differential geometry
that guarantee that there must be a violation of one, some, or all of the energy
conditions (meaning exotic matter is present) for all FTL and antigravity spacetimes.
However, all of the energy condition hypotheses have been experimentally tested in the
laboratory and experimentally shown to be false - 25 years before their formulation
[11].
In quantum field theory, negative energy is a manifestation of what is now called the
"sub-vacuum" levels of the quantum zero-point (or vacuum ground state) fluctuations
that correspond to any particular quantum field of matter under study. Hence, the
energy corresponding to sub-vacuum quantum fluctuations is now called "sub-vacuum
energy": sub-vacuum energy= negative energy. Further investigation into this technical
issue showed that violations of the energy conditions are widespread for all forms of
both "reasonable" classical and quantum matter [12-16]. Furthermore, Visser [9)
showed that all (generic) spacetime geometries violate all the energy conditions. So
the condition that PE> Pi and/or PE~ 0 must be obeyed by all forms of matter in nature
is spurious. Negative energy has been produced in the laboratory and th is wil l be
discussed in the follow ing sections.

Examples of Negative (Sub-Vacuum) Energy Found in Nature
The exotic (energy condition- violating) fields that are known to occur in nature are :
1. Static, radially-dependent electric or magnetic fields. These are borderline exotic,
if their tension were infinitesimally larger, for a given energy density [10, 17].
2. Squeezed quantum vacuum states: electromagnetic and other (non - Maxwellian)
quantum fields [8, 18].
3. Gravitationally squeezed electromagnetic vacuum fluctuations [19).
4. Casimir effect, i.e., the Casimir vacuum in flat, curved, and topological spaces
[20 -28).
5. Other quantum fields/states/effects. In general, the local energy density in
quantum field theory can be negative due to quantum coherence effects [3].
Other examples that have been stud ied are Dirac field states: the superposition
of two single particle electron states and the superposition of two multi-electron­
positron states [29, 30]. In the former (latter), the energy densities can be
negative when two single (multi-) particle states have the same number of

* Planck's reduced constant, TJ "' 1.055 x 10-34 J.s.

4

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOA QFFI&IAL 1:1!11! Oflt I

Page 9

UNCLASSIFIED/ /EAR AfifilCIAk Wlili 9PtLY
electrons (electrons and positrons) or when one state has one more electron
(electron-positron pa ir) than the other.
Cosmological inflation [9], cosmologica l particle production [9], classical scalar fields
[9], the conformal anomaly [9], and gravitational vacuum polarization [12-15] are
among many other examples that also violate the energy conditions. Since the laws of
quantum field theory place no strong restrictions on negative energies and fluxes, then
it might be possible to produce exotic phenomena such as faster-than- light travel [3133], traversable wormholes [8, 9, 34], violations of the second law of thermodynamics
[35, 36], and time machines [9, 34, 37]. There are several other exotic phenomena
made possible by the effects of negative energy, but they lie outside the scope of this
report. In what follows, we consider only items 2 and 4 in the previous list for the
purpose of this report due to their ready applicability and technical maturity. We will
not examine the other items in the list because they are theoretical curiosities that
remain under study by investigators.

Basic Notions of the Quantum Field Theory of Light
Before going further, it will be helpful to briefly outline the basic notions and
terminology of the quantum field theory of light (i.e., quantum optics) because the
content of this report focuses on those aspects.
Classically, light is electromagnetic radiation that can be pictured as waves flowing
through space at the speed of light, c (= 3.0 x 10 8 m/s). The waves are not waves of
anything substantive, but are in fact ripples in the state of a field. These waves carry
energy, and each wave has a specific direction, frequency and polarization state. This
is called a "propagating mode of the electromagnetic field." A simple model for th is is
the electromagnetic oscillator. One complex-valued vector function u(x,t) called a
spatial-temporal mode comprises all classical wave aspects including polarization. The
sim plest example of a spatial-temporal mode is a plane wave
u(x,t) = u0 exp[i(kx-wt)] of polarization vector uo, angular frequency co, and wave
vector k (definition: k 2 =u}/c2 ), where i is the unit complex number, and x is the
space coord inate and tis the time coordinate .
This mode defines a framework in space and time that may be excited by the quantum
field "light." The mode function quantifies the strength of one excitation in space and
time. Also, the mode function obeys the laws of classical waves given by Maxwell's
equations of electrodynamics. The choice of u(x,t) is made by the observer. The
observer singles out one mode, one quantum object from the rest of the world to make
a specific observation or measurement. This object turns out to be a harmonic
oscillator described by the ann ihilation operator a. A useful tool for modeling the
propagating mode of the electromagnetic field in quantum mechanics is the ideal
quantum mechanical harmonic oscillator: a hypothetical charged mass on a perfect
spring oscillating back and forth under the action of the spring's restoring force. The
operator stands for the quantized amplitude with which u(x,t) can be excited. In
classical optics it would be just a complex number a of magnitude lal and phase
arg(a) . The quantized amplitude a is neither predetermined nor given by the observer

a

5

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFICIICL tl.!l!! 9HLY

Page 10

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR 8FFl&IAk le:ISE 8Hk¥
but depends on the state of u(x,t). This state exists even if literally nothing is in the
mode chosen by the observer. In this case, the light is just in the vacuum state. §
However, this "nothing" can indeed cause significant physical effects as will be
discussed in later sections.
To make all this more precise, we postulate that the electric field strength E of the light
field is given by E= u*(x, t)a + u(x, t)a 1 and that the amplitude operator a is a bosonic**
annihilation operator that obeys the quantum mechanical commutation relation

[a, at]=1, where u*(x, t) is the complex conjugate of u(x,t) and at is the adjoint (or
conjugate) of a called the creation operator.t t The hat symbol appearing over
quantities denotes that they are quantum operators (or observables). Another key
element of quantum-oscillator physics is the photon number operator fi, which
accounts for the number of photons (quantized light particles) in the chosen u(x,t) and
is given by the quantum mechanical counterpart of a classical modulus-squared
amplitude: n= a t cz.
Let us now introduce a pair of operators, q and p, called quadratures. They are

a) and jJ = i2- at - a) , which can be inverted to provide the

defined as q = 2- 112 (at+

I12 (

additional useful definitions a= T 112 ( q+ ip) and at =T I12 ( q- ip). In optics q and jJ
correspond to the in -phase and the out-of-phase component of the electric field
amplitude of u(x,t) (with respect to a reference phase). The bosonic commutation
relation demonstrates that q and /J are canonically conjugate observables, [ q,p] = ih.
The quadratures q and p can be regarded as the position and the momentum of the
quantum electromagnetic oscillator. They do not appear in real space but in the phase
space spanned by the complex vibrational amplitude a of the quantum electromagnetic
oscillator, and they have nothing to do with the position and the momentum of a
photon. However, the canon ical commutation relation entitles us to treat q and p as
perfect examples of position- and momentum-like quantities in quantum optics. Finally,
we express the photon number operator
in terms of the quadratures q and p and
obtain, using the bosonic commutation relation, the standard Hamiltonian (or total
energy) of the quantum harmonic ( electromagnetic) oscillator with unit mass and
frequency:

n

"

- "

1

H ose= n+2

(1)

§ Here we always mean by " vacuum" simply "no light" and not an evacuated system.
•· Boson or bosonic refers to quantum particles that have integer quantum spin .
., In quantum mechanics, the vacuum is defined to be a state of no (or zero) particles and is denoted by the

quantum state eigenvector

I0) . By definition a "annihilates" the vacuum state: aI0) = 0 .

6

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOA OFFIGIAk lel&E 8Ptk\S

Page 11

UNCLASSIFIED/ /POI\ OPPICIAL YSIE 8Htlf
where the first and second terms in the second line are the kinetic and potential
energies of the oscillator, respectively. The additional 1/2 appearing in the first line of
Eq. (1) is called the vacuum zero-point energy for the reason to be explained in the
next section . The first line of Eq. (1) is more common ly expressed in units of energy
(Joules) in quantum mechanics, which is obtained simply by multiplying the right-hand
side by the photon energy nw so that H ose = hw

(ii +½).

It is beyond the scope of this report to elaborate further on the entire subject of the
quantum optics. The reader should consult Reference [38] for more information.

Basic Notions on the Origin of the Quantum Vacuum Zero-Point Fluctuations
Here we discuss the basic notions of the quantum vacuum zero-point fluctuations
(ZPF), which is an important feature in quantum optics. The orig in of the ZPF is
attributed to the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle. According to this principle, q and
pare any two conjugate observables that we are interested in measuring, and they
obey the commutation relation already shown in the previous section. Their
corresponding uncertainty relation is !1q!1p?:. h/2, where !1q is the variance (a.k.a.
uncertainty) of observable q and !1p is that of the conjugate observable p. This
relation states that if one measures observable q with very high precision (i.e., its
uncertainty !1q is very small), then a simultaneous measurement of observable p will
be less precise (i.e., its uncertainty !1p is very large), and vice versa . In other words,
it is not possible to simultaneously measure two conjugate observable quantities with
infinite precision.
This minimum uncertainty is not due to any correctable flaws in measurement, but
rather reflects the intrinsic fuzziness in the quantum nature of energy and matter.
Substantial theoretical and experimental work has shown that in many quantum
systems the limits to measurement precision is imposed by the quantum vacuum ZPF
embodied within the uncertainty principle. Nowadays we rather see the Heisenberg
Uncertainty Principle as a necessary consequence, and therefore, a derived result of the
wave nature of quantum phenomena. The uncertainties are just a consequence of the
Fourier nature of conjugate pairs of quantities (observables). For example, the two
Fourier-wave-conjugates time and frequency become the pair of quantum-particle
conjugates time and energy and the two Fourier-wave-conjugates displacement and
wave number become the pair of quantum-particle conjugates position and momentum.
The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle dictates that a quantized electromagnetic
oscillator (a.k.a. a photon state) can never come entirely to rest, since that would be a
state of exactly zero energy, which is forbidden by the commutation relation given in
the previous section. Instead, every mode of the field has liw/2 as its average minimum
energy in the vacuum, and this is called the zero-point energy (ZPE) .** This ZPE term
is added to the classical blackbody spectral radiation energy density p(w)dro [i.e., the
energy per unit volume of radiation in the frequency interval (ro,w + dro)] [25]:

*" hw is the energy of a single mode (or photon).

7

UNCLASSIFIED/ /EOA QFFI&IAL YSE!! 9HL I

Page 12

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR OFFICl"L tJ.!l!!! 8HL¥

hro - - + -hco ] dco
p(ro)dro = - oi [ - - rc 2 c3 exp(hco/ k 8 T) - 1 2

J

3
hro
= - hro-2 3 coth ( - dro,
2n c
2k8 T

(2)

where kp, is Boltzmann's constant ( 1. 3807 x 10- 23 J/K) and Tis the absolute
temperature. The factor outside the square brackets in the first line of Eq. (2) is the
density of mode (or photon) states (i.e., the number of states per unit frequency
interval per unit volume); the first term inside the square brackets is the standard
Planck blackbody radi ation energy per mode; and the second term inside the square
brackets is the quantum zero-point energy per mode. Equation (2) is called the Zero­
Point Planck (ZPP) spectral radiation energy density. Planck first added the ZPE term to
the classical blackbody spectral radiation energy density in 1912, although it was
Einstein, Hopf, and Stern who actually recognized the physical significance of th is term
in 1913 [25]. Direct spectroscopic evidence for the reality of ZPE was provided by
Mulliken's boron monoxide spectral band experiments in 1924, several months before
Heisenberg first derived the ZPE for a harmonic oscillator from his new quantum matrix
mechanics theory [39].
Following this line of reasoni ng, quantum physics predicts that all of space must be
filled with quantum electromagnetic ZPF creating a universal sea of zero-point energy.
The other quantum forces of nature also have their own vacuum ZPF which contributes
to the universal sea of zero-point energy. But that is beyond the scope of this report.
Negative (Sub-Vacuum) Energy in Squeezed Light

Substantial theoretical and experimental work has shown that in many quantum
systems the limits to measurement precision imposed by the quantum vacuum ZPF can
be breached by decreasing the noise in one observable (or measurable quantity) at the
expense of increasing the noise in the conjugate observable; at the same time the
variations in the first observable, say the energy, are reduced below the ZPF such that
the energy becomes "negative." "Squeezing" is t hus the control of quantum
fluctuations and corresponding uncertainties, whereby one can squeeze/reduce the
variance of one (physically important) observable quantity provided the variance in the
(physically unimportant) conjugate variab le is stretched/increased. The squeezed
quantity possesses an unusually low variance, meaning less variance than would be
expected on the basis of the equipartition theorem . One can in principle exploit
quantum squeezing to extract energy from one place in the ordinary vacuum at the
expense of accumulating excess energy elsewhere [8].
The squeezed state of the electromagnetic field is a primary example of a quantum fie ld
that has negative energy density and negative energy flux. Such a state became a
physical reality in the laboratory as a result of the nonlinear-optics techn ique of
"squeezing," i.e., of moving some of the quantum-fluctuations of laser light out of the

8

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOA OFFI&iIAL YSIE 8HLY

Page 13

UNCLASSIFIED/ /FOR 8FFI@IAL 1::191!! 8HLY
cos[w(t- z!c )] part of the beam and into the sin[w(t- z!c)] part [18, 40-44].§§ The
observable that gets squeezed will have its fluctuations reduced below the vacuum ZPF.
The act of squeezing transforms the phase space circular noise profile characteristic of
the vacuum into an ellipse, whose semimajor and semiminor axes are given by unequal

Text continues in the original file (51 pages).

Previous: DOW-UAP-D152 — AAWSAP DIRD, Negative Mass Propulsion, January 2011 · Next: DOW-UAP-D154 — Transcript of a Presentation by Captain Edward J. Ruppelt, 1952

Same topic: title & summary match

Same location: Las Vegas, Nevada

Same period: 2011

Same release: Release 06

Same agency: DoW