Home › Archive › DoW

DOW-UAP-D095 — Joint U.S.-Canadian Aviation Projects and UFO Sighting Reports, 1954-1955

File DOW-UAP-D095 is a declassified pdf from Department of War, recording an incident dated 1955 at Various, published in Release 04 (2026-07-10). This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.

File
DOW-UAP-D095
Agency
Department of War
Incident date
1955
Location
Various
Released in
Release 04 (2026-07-10)
File type
PDF

This file contains reports, memoranda, and correspondence concerning various then-developmental vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) aircraft. The file includes assessments of the experimental potential of the “Avro Project Y2,” a joint U.S.-Canadian near-circular VTOL aircraft that is similar in appearance to contemporary popular descriptions of unidentified flying objects (UFO). A 1954 memorandum opines that VTOL aircraft with a circular planform may be mistaken for UFOs to observers unfamiliar with such technologies. It also recommends that UFO reports in the vicinity of Soviet military operations or assets be re-examined to assess whether they may be attributable to previously unknown advanced VTOL aircraft of foreign design.

The file also contains correspondence relating to a UFO incident involving a U.S. Air Force (USAF) KC-97 flying near Newfoundland, Canada in July 1955. A USAF committee found that the characteristics described in the report were inconsistent with those of known Soviet, American, or Canadian military systems. The committee was also “unable to explain the simultaneous ground radar returns and aircrew visual sightings.”

It also contains correspondence relating to the potential value of data from incidental radar collection of meteors entering the atmosphere. USAF Air Research and Development Command recommended using that data to improve the performance of the AN/FPS-17 radar system. Finally, the file contains correspondence indicating support for the Communications Instructions for Reporting Vital Intelligence Sightings (CIRVIS) program, a joint U.S.-Canadian civil-military program to standardize reporting methods for unusual or unidentified airborne and maritime hazards and threats.

Open original file · WAR.GOV page

TL;DR

The memo says 1955, but the UFO still missed the memo deadline.

  • DoW, 1955, various sites
  • Details Avro Y2 VTOL design and KC-97 Newfoundland sighting with radar/visual mismatch
  • No official conclusion in the file

AI summary

A classified report dated December 10, 1954, details the evaluation of the Avro "Saucer" project by a scientific advisory board, discussing technical challenges and limited support. It includes analysis of aircraft design and propulsion systems. Additional sections cover a 1954–1955 joint U.S.-Canadian project investigating flying saucers, mentioning reports of a Canadian company's saucer, German wartime projects, and Soviet capabilities. Classified aviation project documents and UFO sighting reports from 1954–1955 discuss flying saucers, technical feasibility, and intelligence recommendations, referencing eyewitness accounts and Soviet activities. Memorandums from 1955 include a KC-97 crew's report of an unidentified object near Newfoundland and radar returns, discussing evaluations and recommendations. A declassified document from November 3, 1955, discusses the CIBVIS program, involving U.S. and Canadian aviation, and acknowledges efforts in promoting the program, mentioning UFO sighting reports and aviation projects.

Full text

Page 3

,

f

DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE
Head.quarters United States Air Force

Washington 25 1 D. C.

SCIENTIFIC ADVISORY BOARD TO THE CHIEF OF STAFF, tJSAF'

scn;NrIFIC ADVISORY BOARD :REPORT ON AVRO PROJECT Y2
~

Novembex· 1951+

----------:"

This document consists of ______ pages
Copy Number~-- of _,l.1,, ··- copies.

0

ECRB±'

Page 4

.

....
,

DEPARTMENT OF TBE AIR FORCE

t

Head.quarters United States Air Foree
Washington 25, D. C.
10 December 1954

Lieutenant General Donald I.. Pu·tt
Deputy Chi et of Staff, Development

Headquarters United States Air Force
Washington, D. C..

Dear Don:
In response to your request tor BAB commen·t,s on the Avco
"Saucer'' project, the SAB baa taken the following action:

The Aircraft and Propulsion Panels were brieted on September
28 ·by represente.tivea ot Bq. ARDC, at ·the time of the Fall meet~j.ng
of the Board in Omaha. The tentat:ive conclusions ot bo·tb panels
immediately atter this briefing were to the ettect that th.is pro­
.Ject warranted no more than limited support. l!oveve:r, to assu1·e
·thoro\lgb. consideration ot this project, I requested rt:?presentatives
of these two panels to supplement. the briefings given 'to -them at
~ by a. Tisi·t to A. V. Roe- Canada Ltd., Malton., Ontario.
With the advice of Clark Millikan and Dean Soderberg., a select

committee ,ms choaen to conclude this study. It was c~sed ot
Dean Soderberg, Chairman of the Propulsion Panel and senior member
o'f the group; Professor Markham, of the Aircraft Panel; and Mr .
Donovan, who has been serving both as a member or 'the Aircraft Panel
and as lie..:I.son member with the Propulsi,on Panel.
The attached report ot this ,group is ~orwarded with my «.PPt•oval,

representing the results ot the SAB's ccapleted study.

Sincerely,

/a/
J. H. DOOLr.rTLE

Actins Chairman
Scient.itic Advisory Board
Office ot the Chief of Sta.ff

Inclosure
•

-

S E C Ft B 'f

Page 5

" W
w he he O
, Toronto on
on svailablo to
moot courtoous and vell-pl: ng the fullest possi-
ble use or the available tirs
% milt
around a radisl flow turbojot with 1 capable of being do-
Clooted dowud lovering near
869 rplano is dos flight at bigh
altitude, under vhich oondition the ot is directed horizont
ally rearverde. The air is 1 sosty y tron the above for
NIW 91198 Doe181:34745775
Page 236

Page 6

8
8
hovering; for leval flight the intake is changed to a normal
frontal inlet by a set of alides and doors, In later veraions the
redial enging ne has been ropleced by radially diaposed axial flow
oventional ty Thie was originally
intermediato orolon which dight simplify tho devols
edures, but ae the radial ongine has been more realisti-
It is now looked % g Itornative form of
·% ds
It is ovidont thet the invention involves a whole array of fo
midable problems of resoarch and det 30 ont, Ivon in the smallest
vereions the oute Diamoter of of the radial flov turbine is about
, The entire rotor must be oir bearinge in
the redial as woll as the axial direotion, S and it is evident that
the eocompanying problems of mochanical dosign are very difrioul t.
The desig requires that very lerge air flow (a minimum of about
800 lb/a) be regulated by a complicet I system of mechanical sbuttors
on the inlet as vell as on the outlet side, The problems of stability
in hovering, in forwerd flight, and in the transition between the two
codes naturally demand considerablo attontion, The many etructural
problems of an unconventional nature likowis require much study. It
is ovidant, even wi.th only a casual atudy , the process of devel-
opmont would bo lengthy and costly in tho ertromo, even by prosent
standards in military aireraft." − The justification for entering into
SEGRET
NW 91198 [oed134745775
Page 207

Page 7

&
such an undertaking muat dopend on (a) the aigniticance of ths obw
jootivos which the now airplane claias to fill end (b) the soumd-
noss of the means proposed to attain these objoctives.
The key feature on which the design of tho I2 is based is the
utllication. 8 up in tho conter or
a 4 Jot stream, , This prossure build-up increases the lift
at standatill olose to tho ground in such a faahion as to indicate
the practicability 8 of hovering a fow foet off the ground with on…
gines whose static sea level thrust without this augmentation from
ground effect, would bo loss than the airplane gross Weight. Also,
pocause of the pature of the ground ; aircraft vould bo
stable with respect to height when hovering; that is, it would not
roquire pilot attention to hold a boight above the ground, although
it vould require control to maintain its attitude The thrust aug-
montation for hovering obtained by A, V. Ros in small scale teats is
of the order of 60 to B0;, Because th riables woro
not inveatigated and the pertinent measurements not made during the
tests, data are not availablo to extrapolate this result proporly to
prediet accurately full acale eugmontation factors, There are many
features which could make tho full scale augnentation fectors omaller
but very littlo likelihood of thair boing larger than in the modol.
The posaibility of stable hovering is, nevertheless, an engeging
featuro, Unfortumately, it has dominated th evolution of the con
s n o R a 1
NW 91198 Doeld1:34745775
Page 208

Page 8

Teey oa soupe "Joaemoy snoTros 2sou on4 on o4 sreedde Borp o4 goedsax
WTa votavm te ouJ. prot Aed ou qtn souerd punor opoa uoeq earq
a3 o9 suojssnoerp tte aeq 2oug ou on onp ared ut or vere touorj
aed aenr yrq oq outaoe oq uo pesvq sutto ou pauaqduens 10u
sey aT anq "uopaenars oq pereate "osmoo Jo 'sey s2efoqmy Teuopauea
-uoo o4 aJTye oqI eda noty Tepre eu mya uostredroo ur uopadumsuoo
Tony poos o4 Tenuoarctop o.re qotqn sopouototIJe gusuodroo pus oTaex
emesond uf suotva put auarequt urenreo sossosaod outane turpex oqu
reaoeson gueudotoasp outaue terped on f3rasnf rrosat ut 3ou ptnon
pue rensnum JeBuot ou ot aqaten outSuo orJroods ou "eurceto oson J0
serq Tte of noradeoxe ore, of petredroo on on 'eautod esom 3o tTe
olaos on orqurreas or toravutoyut qnoue gou elrum "orquroasy Area
ore ouetd ou 3o sorasyreioareyo Darp ou aup pue "udry Arrenonon sT
(sepenuy aTe Durpatoxe "oo9 anoqu) erotd on Jo vor petooford eu uo
2man otrtoede op 2eq ' (zz anoqu) oraet aupten on aoniq olqedoauy
Lra ssq eutane aots Terpex oq aou eyseq oq uo sotaspregopreno
3qprt3 praro) otqeJoay JoJ 8
"oreo amor J
sotastaogosreqo 30prt o4 doy ututo s,dognoaut on o4at eupuere og
pegdweaas oavy on 'ouetdrre fue yo uopoung ausaJoday oq "trw roa,J
sT au9TtI pxenroy o .. postuoiduo3 stmoyuor uoeq eavy o, sreed
·.
Goueutoyzed aot aueaxo te qons
3 the

Page 9

y 006
lengthy and expensive experiments are noeded to settle these questions
with finality.
on tor has aseumod th mprovemon't si ta
ation might be obtained through boundary layer suction. The alleged
gain from this eource is associated with the diatribution of the ex-
• t he trailing airplane. It is not wholly
imposaible that such a gain might in fact bo present, but no reliable
test information is available at the prosent time on this point. In
ventional types only
becauso the exhaust jot ie distributed over the trailing edge of the
wing. The circular plan form offers no particular advantage in this
. refore, with an airplane dovelopment which
does not appear to poscess any intrinsic advantages either with the
original radial engine or with t arrangemont of conventional
turbojets. The pro induction aido is certain
to bo poor for both altornetivos; evon with the utmost dovelopmont
of details it could not approach the performance of conventional air-
planes. The ducting or side presents cqually formidable
difficultios fron the point of viow of losses, and the gain due to
boundary layer suotion is only conjectural, These thinge might have
been compensatod for if the dreg charactaristics of the plane con-
Iiguration could bo demonstrated to favorable. There is no
5
08
NW 91198 Do01d134745775
Page 240

Page 10

19
informeti.on indi0s this io so. No basie law we appoar to have
sis o s hovering any assurance
88
Air Forco, We have attompte of foous several
a place, and
an G
.
*
roulld b pot
The developrant of an engine such as ths X be cou
tuds th Wo do not
feel that the invent ins he bas made tor it,
particularly with
sorious lack of attenpt at a syet
loy corodymamio ph also bo a set of
goals for the
SRGRET
NW 91198 D0e1d:34745775
Page 241

Page 11

∞
8 other dovelopments in performance, if the basie idoas ahould be
capsble of realisation. We do not fool tr . · objectivos of
the development bave been clearly
feal that thore has been a prooccupation with the bovoring char-
acteristics to such an extent that the more direct essentials of
the aircraft have been lost sight of s
We do not quastion the ability of the A, V. Roe Company to
" ·? − ks succosafully( woll*conceit oject in the aireraft
field which lies within their material resources. Our visit con-
firmed our high opinion of their design and production activities
in jet aircraft and engines. We have developed the suspicion, how-
over, that the reaponsible designere in the A, V. Roe engineering
groups are not thoroughly sold on the I2 projeet. It is mani-
feetly impossible for us to prove this contontion or to make this
assertion officially with tho company. We reel convinced, hovever,
that tho best talente of the A. Vo Roe organisation have not been
drawm upon in the evaluation of this project, This statement is
mado wi thout prejudice toverd tho inventor, who inprossed us as a
telonted and sincere man with a great deal of imagination, but who
for this very reason cannot bo expected to prosent a fully impartial
critiqus. Full support fron some of the leading designers outside
of this particular group could perhaps have presented a more con-
vinoing argumant for support.
NW 91198 D0e8k34745775
Fage 242

Page 13

2. In the Magazine Section of the Washington Post, dated 13 December
1953, there appeared an article which reported the development of a flying
saucer by the A.V. Roe Canada, Limi ted of Toronto. The article stated that
Lt. Gen. Donald L. Putt, Director of Ardc, had visited this company and had
viewed this flying saucer. Other information given in the article impressed
Mr. Bollum with the thought that here was the first factual evidence that it
was possible to build a flying saucer. If it was possible for Canada to
build a flying saucer, then it was also possible for the Soviets to build
one. Mr. Bollum requested that he be authorized to initiate a special pro-
ject for the purpose of detormining Soviet capabilities in this field. Such
permission was granted by Col. T. W. Wolfe, Chief of the Future Estimates
Branch.
3. With the aid and assistance of Squadron Leader George C. Wainwright.
RAF, the project was launched by going to the U.s. Patent Office and reading
a patent filed by the A.V. Roo people on a device entitled "A Gas-Turbine
Engine Aireraft", The patent application for this device was first filed in
the U. K. on 2l August I952. This patent pointed out the feasibility of the
pro,ject. Bollum and Wainwright then traveled to Baltimore to discuss the
pro,ject with personnel of ARDC. It was on this visit that Lt. Col. V. L.
Gossick first disclosed the information regarding the application of the
Coanda Effect to the Project "y" design. Several more visits were made to
ARDC and after disoussing the projeot with several engineers and officers,
Mr. Bollum and Squadron Leader Wainwright decided that there was little
doubt that a "state of the art" capability did, in fact, sxist, and that
their next step was to investigate the possibility that the Soviets already
had possession of such information.
4. Through contacts with intelligence officers in the Office of the
Director of Air Intelligence, Ottawa, Canada, Squadron Leader Wainwright
learned of the existence of intelligence information concerning possible
German Flying Saucer projects. These were rumored to have existed at the
end of World War II. TDY was authorized for Bollum and Wainwright to travel
to Ottawa to discuss the subjeet with the Air Intelligence personnel. As a
result of this trip copies of the pertinent information were forwarded to
Mr. Bollum from D.A. I. Ottawa. In brief, there is information on four
Germans.
..
5
DS SS-03a3-3
NW91198 Doel1d:34745775
Page 244

Page 14

SECRET
a. George Klein who, as of April l953 resided in Hamburg.
claims to bave been chief engineer of all flying disc projects. How-
ever, his prineipal importance seems to be that he kmew of the exist-
ence of such projeets and has called attention to other Germans in this
fiold.
b. Otto Habermohl, who has not been heard of since the end of
the war, is reported to have had a projeet for a l6 meter diameter fly-
ing saucer which was test flighted on 14 February l945 at Holice.
C. Rudolf Schriever, who died in l945, vas a designer/test pilot
at BMw Works at Prague. He is reported to have constructed a flying
saucer, which at a trial in April l945 failed to leave the ground.
d. Robert Miethe, who is supposed to have entered the U.S. in
1953, is reported to have constructed a 43 meter diameter flying saucer
called the "y-7", which is reported to have flown with a crew of three
in 1944. In August 1944 the Cesko-Moravske Works in Prague is reported
to have received a production order for a short series, but none had been
finiahed by the end of the war. Miethe remained in Breslaw, whence he
escaped in an ME-l63 one jump ahead of the Russians. The Russians captured
three of Methe's principal assistants and his workshops. Miethe, according
to the Canadians, came into this country as an emigrant.
It is of interest to note that in March of l954, a man using the name Bruno
Berberich and who claims to have entered this country in l953, forwarded to
a Senator from Ohio a manuscript and drawings depieting how he would build
a flying saucer. These were in turn forwarded to the Legislation and Liaison
Division of Headquarters, USAF, who sent them to AFoIN. AnoIN forwarded the
documents to ATIc for translation and evaluation. Mr. Bollum was assured by
Mr. Arcier of AtIlO that he would receive a copy of the results as soon as
ATIC had completed the translation. To date no such information has been
reeoived and therefore Mr. Bollum is not able to report the results obtained.
The big question would seem to be whether or not this man Berberich could be
Miethe.
5. Upon return to Washington Bollum and Wainwright again went to ARDO
Baltimore where they were briefed on the U.S. interest in Canada's pro,jeet
and informed of the political and international complication involved. At
this time both were requested to handle the whole project on a sensitive
basis until notified by ARdC that arrangements between U.S. and Canada had
been completed, In accordance with such request, briefings were limited to
General Samford. General Lewis, Colonel Morrow, Golonel Eriksen, Colonel
True, Colonel Wolfe, Captain Reoney, USN, and Lt. Colonel Farrior.
6. In April Colonel True received permission for an Air Room briefing
of key AroIN personnel, which was attended by the Branch and Division Chiefs.
About the lst of May a request came for briefing the Classen Committee, who
were considering the future material requirements for the Strategio Air
Conmand. On 26 May 1954 key analysts of the Rand Corporation, Santa Monica.
California. were briefed at the request of Colonel True and permission was
JLUIET
NW/-911198Do0l8:34745775
Plage 245

Page 15

crennr
JLGI
X.
given 'to brief the engineering personnel of the Los Angelen Air Force
Development Office.
An "Air Force Only" restriction was dropped in June l954 and the
following have been briefed since: Chief of Naval Operations and Staff,
Chief of Staff U. S. Army and Staff, Commandant of ths Marine Corps and
Staff, Key Personnel of CIA-OSI, Mr. Eiselstein of ATIC, Intelligence per-
sonnel of SAC, TAO, ADC, ARDC, AFSS, AFSSOP, NSA, and Requirements Officer
of the Air War College. A copy of the briefing is attached as TAB A.
On 15 June 1954, Bollum and Wainwright visited the A. V. Ros Limited
Toronto, Canada. One day was spent discussing Project "y" and information of
German and/or Soviet interest in such unconventional aircraft. Mr. Frost,
the Chief Engineer on the project and designer of the radial flow jet engine
demonstrated by use of laboratory models all the principles of the Coanda
Effeet, the air bearings, and the control system contemplated. Such demon-
stratlons left little doubt in the minds of anyone present that the project
would be a success. Mr. Frost had prevlously gone to Europe to interrogate
George Klein and in addition had had access to many flying saucer reports
from Europe. He firmly stated that there was no doubt in his mond that the
Soviets are ahead of the Western Nations in the development of a true verti-
cal take-off aircraft.
9.1 Recent news articles indicate that both the U.S. and U. K. have other
projects in being which are in the field of Vertical Take-Off Aireraft (vto).
CONGLUSIONS:
10. In conclusion, it appears that the chances of success are good for
Project "y" or Project "Ladybird" as it is knowm in the USAF. If this is the
case a breakthrough in the aeronautical "State of the Art" has occurred which
will revolutionize aircraft design and air warfare. If we accept the possi-
bilities of such designs then ve must also conclude that the Soviets must at
the least have the capability to have such aircraft almost as soon as the
Western Nations. At the other end of the possibilities, we must consider
the chance that the Soviets are several years ahead of the U.S. at this time.
Perhaps one of the most important results of this investigation has been thst
such unconventional aircraft are not considered as fantastic as previoud and
the emphasis will shift from disproving flying saucer reports to proving such
reports. The effect of a successful flight will be far reaching. A new look
will have to be taken at the design of many categories of military equipment;
i.e. radars, guided missiles, armament, entiaircraft artillery, etc. It is
possibls that such capabilities could very radically change estimates for the
period of 1960-65.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
1l. In the last part of the briefing (Tab A) certain recommendations have
been made. It was folt at the time that the various offices of the Directorate
of Intelligonce would take some action as a result of the briofing. As of this
date Mr. Bollum is unaware of any action being taken by any other office to
3
CEONET
2 JEGNCI
NW 91198 Dadld1:34745775
Page 246

Page 16

oe adutreaq 1o peajeex er ssonbex ue setouSe
W s - T T '
ry sb pu ooy ey e o q
seuase suudnbo xeno uo esn yons yo soes oua pu
aro peds xons Io esn tuotaxedo 3o Aattrqrssod ou uo auws
e o po 9-0 o ss ut
uy sejouee tte uo poetd oq prnos queuenbe uotnottoo V 1
popntouy q sauoueapbe ptotire uo esoosrp aoys qeoid
sius Jo ared sy pagoore eq Pon aueudpnbs Arerrw roo soy sujsep
qqo as o poqe q Pos rd v
o sn o puo uy
serouos queuurod rono Io peasonb q Prnos goddns A.russoon
0- T T o
aufps Atoavrpout sr t 8, 0n Io sutaqs Jo saxodea TTv q
I/ stou eudnbe pe Te tou no
petpuy q Pnoqs sousrtteaur 10 sw qons OIv 4v 4ttao m ou4 mox
Baoones Supt poonpod qe jo sesjase pue epsteue 'ssrode eu eoroapp
o e a do penq ar sa en opod
eTqrssod u a suquou BT Jo reaqv ur uoT asen eq I xoonvs Puti 8
o 0- T e n
*oouo9rTTo2uI xo xoasertq ou q poasenbo1
q o Soo p eo
eTaarT AreA Aq TATqovuT su J0 amsex v sy Teuuosred (Om) 2ooqo PuTT
ppn Aq en no o e 1o as
rea s "&u 1oofoxd 1o ssooons eu auun uojupdo mnttog n o4 penvorpuT
8

Page 18

sen ajt u qons Surpoas setoen eu o atroun ssouooy ous
:
-
-q s aoe a uas o pd suse Tsn u
* * * * * ** *** * **
-DurgeTaq seTnaex
1o pue u2 a septts uqt eetdoo uojssnsp petp suou osu
-o eo ssp r rno yeq 4 as
mo dn e o3 aou rapro u areuoats u yons At ttnrsseoons o2 uopu
4aI o4 0q 2ou 2 aTTTqrss0d pooS ea T 4 44 Mous
ns sv pue eorog aTy sn u Aq peouur Futeq aoroxd o no I
04 ade TT4 I saa pto1-omq s1 Suroaq su4 I0 es0dmd eu
096T I8
*
4 Va avu
THE 8
..

Page 19

e ueengeq ip ro opno Tgrenod seonpord gon wpuo u Sugsn a
e TTe q stoo egs ou s usp resa u etq suot 0
storquoo eoeyns pexpbex utsop ssxr eu e st supsop onq eu ueengeq
eu oq telternd spx Turpnaruot sar puet pue Io elea os poujsop
euersodde o a e yo dee Surpuet v q pexodcns se pu puno
euu qa soo1dop 09 Teq vupxoudds yo otau u v spx tuurpnqruot sa
auyen/asnayn u4 Jo eouenbesuo auegxodrt 2sow e Suyeq
P
ou
en/ o e n :
sotdme ya ueq a u Aq pogoddns osrp 2ogo ouoq degourp sa
r 1o peqs pun o o4 uo-pn T on poujsop oa souu eu
eupaue go-oqan puno.re poutsop
oq uo 2q 4 u o q o4 ps s ua Su oy og
poxeao pue pods Aqapns ouTaue euqnq s ot Trp rt Aea 1o
uotqontgsuoo eun do tesodord etdute Atrerauesse s oeord no pous
p ou ood p o p
J0- T T 10
oq odays u ets pue 4e u uo 4 uq e po qnq ( s)
eutSue ouss un posn eay pTnon otu vonon doofod o uIn 4oefoag
petto Topo sertse uy eujrqns v moay Suyyont q esn ougru 1o
Taeu uao 10 sodId Io pt s ( pTs) spTa
pousrquso ue revto mo sjo-e pue sujput aodop oq s epts su
03 rt PTon no 10 omos our sp4 g 9g6t 1o SuTds e u sosTd es
PTon Topou asur u J0 3se arT eu4 aun peodro sn a1 sn oq umom
Atarssod pue sSupaerp Io uotaeedid eu uy en oua Suot Ttea eem Aou
n o o p p
don o pe tp ae
ope suy avsn eu rouoos satnsex pepsop oun aaotuoe qutu sn e o4
:

Page 20

o ou uoraarqmoo tvp ATstnpad v s oupreuqns
q4a esn sa1 I0 uot4deuon 2svar eu arodsura 1o requoq eouetnque
uee saqdo yons on a sopna pu rqranoue
Jo s I o e o o
autos Jo Tosa T Ay so 4rT d Mo on Jo po N
sop puy sasrq aj aod se pu oy e at otarp u1
speeds ury Aroa a stnro o tq pue euya Io poted arous turpeoxe ue
a00 00o's9 04 punors eua moxy qurto 04 out
so uetoprrs seux pu. g noen os dn speeds eay o poedre sr uojse
Topow 1eat V (en uo) °u 00t I0 u ay pu aeey 00o'98 o dn
sepna t s° oen o dn speeds eay o4 tq eq o4 peadxe sT pagss
9q 0a Tepou 48xt eu
perrrdms V ajeorte ou u potugsut eq ttra quoudpbe pu sauoumsouy
etaraoeaex ou sr oeu pue pegvotqnt dpe s eujSus eu s yonuseuy wegss
y ou o o u 4
o ars o no ot en o seu teo (9 )
eSpe suq wou
saxe eu o pgno Tp u
us o sed queedue s punor e e Ie udo exy do
os s rre Ton e q u pox ge pas
'td uy retnoo ost er senauy I u sdt pouoe o prrvpow
eq oq peou eu oy etd etno e eoutq pue tsep Tutr ou uo uppued
pegso s a1 sua oraaueouoo onq ueongeq pesodsrp eutue upqiq s Aos
10 s3s 4 psd T (9 )
oSoavo qrodsuas ou uy araxos oun 1o esn oua seaolduy 21
:SMOTTOI
se ee onbuye yons 1o seequeapy punor eu ree stp a v y0 aaq
.. *

Page 21

p q po o d e og
u 002 o4 0e wo poyoum ss ppn 1o no uu 00 wo qn
K/O HONWT HNS
eq pnon susep uesd quoy amos au
o e
1o topou rodeornuy m redaeq euop eq ptnon qo eu qrsd r
21 o o4 p 1e e ou 0/v 1odo Suta u tp o2
artrqudeo pooa psy seqmoq asoun J1 itutoedey aI ooo'o8 4v Pupt
Sg ue oq dn speods nata sequoq seues een 1o enbepe q Atpy
PTon sutsop N/o uou Tuserd eu -
TUOSn ISA q PTRON PTOT SI OTQUTIA
sesodrnd asou roj seotesn 9q
qupu auemdnbe repx punor poujsop Ataueseid mo sepna rate pue speeds
edq auesord ou aeq etqrssod st ar peatoaut spesds eu oa eng
aueredde eq
a seuo t 1o s e nu 1o udb
I Io sed 1oso ue roy s ueuenbe pu usp su o 3o aa v
eu aqnop ou T 1 sas q eod uq sq a e u done ue
etqtssodmy eq on reedds 3ou op
xoy Ts ta s a o ep dp ou eups pee eq o4 Aterun
sr peods doy Sujtteo puv eSuer peonper auqemos v ter oq Atuo exo1
at o a to/2n Io uteu tdre ue sey pngs ropun o ou
eu eptsut eqvnbope peroptsuoo sr ueos IT 1o pod esou u petteaauy eq
u rep aTts euy o 1o ano a o do eou ou u peaou
eq A seo 1o sn ap tds u qusid o os gou
.
:

Page 22

Pezelbad
ea ose ou q yons 1I ou stu p upeue 1o peoe sre on s yon
so a a ps eeq s aarre earas o a pasre eq
a a uo sooo q aq q s pn s
usonb q sTu 0 ee o oatsu ro 0v o s eu
uosa uos pue oqjot oq qs u eren s ons Sua
B p pn o o su pue jn o o osg u o
oung Jo u ou q e y6t Jo yon uI sdoynon s pu sue
puee dun ouo ct-an u ur podoso ou oouon aetsog u pauyvwe euevn
ren ou4 Io pue ou q poututy s euou anq sotos 3oys soy ropro
S°n eu poruo eay o pesoddns sr oun onorn aeqon punors eu saet
02 PolTy Sv6T Tidy Tepx v 3 utqa reonss SupTI peson suoo eAey
u pr o eots Jp aton nq uo p 2
- sr rn oo Io pe o us yo py q 4ou s on oq o40
ter u su roqo ot pt s pue seod yons 1o
eouspe u jo o y a q on sms ouodmy Tedjoud su reano
P s u osoddns suer 20 I PToM Sup P s u
rus s o a pooto q ou arqso
ou pevoq q saode uons a paatp s a tr aupruy
s peode pu pods auou eu snoa-o , e s paqs
asroe 3o ano pequto suosed
o 1o uo pe a o sup sos p 3e pad
- p q uy pp ar pd-rons o o ea
auemeavas ou Supw s peaonb eoq say asog an pouee sn peeds u
-reo Taum uoaox spayoto reamoo aurTs u peautnqqon opnrat pu
sj t Io uo u p o op too Su
2
Bp s, o q o s uon 4 1o oo u '&
d

Page 23

8
* SECET
PARTIV
SUMMARY
* We have presented to you some evidence that flying saucers are within
the capabilities of the existing "state of the art" in this country and
Canada. The "atate of the art" is well kmown in European countries. The
Coanda effect has been known to all countries and ths application is not
beyond the capabilities of the Soviets. It is possible that German projeets
for flying saucers existed at the end of the war. The man considered
possible tops in this field is supposed to be in the U.S. now. We have
reports on eye witnesses of flying saucers in Soviet territory.
PARTY
RECOMMENDATIONS
It is recommended that:
The entire intelligence cemmunity be alerted to a possible Soviet
activity in this field.
2. All exiating files on foreign flying saucers should be reviewed
and analyzed.
3. Bruno Berberich should be interrogated by intelligence analysts
who have a full background on existing intelligence.
4. Robert Miethe should be found. Possibly Miethe could have changed
his name to Bruno Berberich or some other alias.
5. A collection requirement should bs placed on all agencies in the
field including the Attaches.
.:
:
6
SECR ET
NW 91198 Dod81:34745775
Page 254

Page 24

S2Z928P00866MN
BAOTTOn
h dry ur aromr an no comeurpuoos yo aneare on
anranput oua soug bnpunrdma ban yo gdyepau cqa eours
rporanoprend arorad panbotuoxo Arcegard sma morun
Sua bomacogane Tauna Ay Arbsdsumoayo Aaoa pomuwy uoaq p Suoy
-ogbaoy poorond eu neu any purous pros ooran an aun ponborpuy
8%
maxd caen nou u I soure pos.ayam roun eun. pe
Teura oun ar aorota I avan poarodghe pus s,oun mo saajd norutdndo
"ary se yons cotoryoa pelrpeuato Sunenroxe Sou saayarrgnd as
988
Innrogur dry eua wy eon aoy dpavareoeto Atceaayrd 's, dan u
ary ana ao snser roqusosg ur oupa DurAra eun stomay tusarans
88Lns/Sra/JSnDoTr.TOD a1/x-NTOaV

Page 25

(lnDnon noaron Touoron rd creny touoroo) reAonddy
reuosrad maa anoimra pogenrduosoe Dq pmmeus sosferd erun do roaraaras
198
an yus aou. sea goefoud erua abus pg-no ur Purtear y
Aqy ponrnad eah Atretad torua aperard srun oaui S-tro an cmque ara Jn
can upra enoya pnoerod ar br Aranaa caonsm poe ony ro dowaond
-omos ear no evndoag nox og usre on raonynr ay yotun anq bruns
cuunornghos Aay etayeuodsoa nrodau pureog Arosjapy

Page 28

SECRET
() Despite the unfavorable tone of the Scientific
Advisory Board, report,responsible key technicians
within Dcs/D are split into tvo groups on the
feasibility of the project.
(2) In view of this feeling within Dcs/D, Ceneral
Putt's letter to ARDC the last week in December
was, in effect, a compromise position. The
letter directed ArDc to award a contraet to
A. V. Roe, Ltd., for certain wind tunnel tests,
and further indicated that additional U. S.
development funds would be decided on the
basis of the data analysis produced
5. During General Watson's last visit here he discussed with me
a letter (Tab B) which had been prepared for his signature by one of his
staff but which he refused to sigm to you because of its tone. He feels
strongly, however, that the monitorship of this projeet should be the
provinee of ArIc and differs greatly in his personal views with the
artiele in AlD.
6. The Memorandum for Record (Tab C) explains the full background
of the entry of oiN-2 into this project which briefly was governed by
two considerations:
a. A feeling in OIN-2c that this project was "hot" and that
no one else was acting for oIN.
b. Availability and "entree" afforded oIN-2 by Squadron Leader
Wainwright.
No action has been taken on any of the recommendations made
in the M/R by Colonel Morrow and he has instructed Mr. Bollum verbally
to discontinue further work and briefings on the project.
7. In view of the above I offer the following recommendations:
a. Because of the divided opinions within and outside of the 6K
Air Staff on the feasibility of Project "Y", no further articles or
briefings on this project should be aceomplished without your personal
approval. (Colonel Adams and Colonel Morrow coneur.)
b. No attempt should be made in an early issue of ATD to
state the case for Project "y" in more objective terms since any attempt
to do so would only serve to further "muddy the waters." OIN-2 and
DCS/D concur.
Morrow should bave a discussion directed toward the transition of
responsibility for monitorship of Project "y" from OIN-2C to ATIC. 1N-2D
Colonel Morrow and General Watson concur.
:
2
SECRET
NW 911198 E001:34745775
Page 259

Page 30

DEPARTMENT .OF THE AIR FORCE
HEADQUARTERS UNITE£) STATES AIR··FORCE
WASHINGTON 25. D. C.

14 December 1954

MIIDWIDUM JOI. DIBl&TCll 07 IIDLLIGDCI, DOIi

SUBJJCT:

Scientitio Advisor, Board bport on .A.VIO •n11nc Saucer"

Project.

1. J.ttached tor yora: intonation. ia a cow of a recent n­
port of the Scientitic Mriaor, Board on their atud7 ot the •t17ing aaw»r• project ot .A.. v. aoe, Cu.ad&.

2. Your attention ia particul.arl.7 iDTited to ta. generally
negative tiDdiDga vit.b reprd to technical feasibility expreaaed
1D thia report, in contrut to~ pnenJ. 1.lqateaeion ot techni­
cal aouadDeaa ad optiJliatic expectation.a COllff,-d in the article.
on "The Pl1ing Diec• publiahed in the Decaber, 1954, iasue ot
1ihe .l1r Intelligence Dipat.

3. Thia report vu eul:aitted to Lt. Gen. D. L. Putt on
10 Deouber in reaponae to hie pretlou reqU11at tor SlB oaamta.

-,,,
Incloaure
l . .lvro rpt, 07 2

.'

CBIS!II I. IWDT
._cutiw Secretary

lcien.titic .Adrlaor, Board
- ottice ot 'tM Ohief ot Statt

Text continues in the original file (57 pages).

Previous: DOW-UAP-D094 — Analysis of Flying Object Incidents in the United States, 1949 · Next: DOW-UAP-D096 — Correspondence Relating to Project Blue Book, 1955

Same topic: title & summary match

Same location: Various

Same period: 1955

Same release: Release 04

Same agency: DoW