Transportation Research Board Brief (Jan 2023)
File AARO-AARO_Brief_at_Annual_Transportation_Research_Board-January_ is a declassified pdf from AARO. This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.
- File
- AARO-AARO_Brief_at_Annual_Transportation_Research_Board-January_
- Agency
- AARO
- File type
AARO brief delivered at the Annual Transportation Research Board.
Open original file · AARO.MIL page
TL;DR
Turns out even slide decks need a runway for their own mysteries.
- AARO slide, Jan 2023, at Transportation Research Board annual meeting, Case 23-S-0802.
- Describes mission to resolve UAP via operational, scientific, intelligence integration and reporting improvements.
- No official conclusion in the file.
AI summary
This is an unclassified slide presentation from the All-Domain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO) under the U.S. Department of Defense and the Office of the Director of National Intelligence. It was created by Seán Kirkpatrick, Ph.D., the director of AARO, and is labeled as DoD PPR Approved Slide, Case 23-S-0802. The document outlines AARO's mission to resolve unidentified anomalous phenomena (UAP) by integrating operational, scientific, and intelligence capabilities. It describes UAP as observations that are not yet attributable to known actors or causes and emphasizes the need for rigorous analysis to address national security concerns. The text also discusses AARO's efforts to improve reporting mechanisms and collaboration with aviation and other stakeholders.
Full text
Page 1
UNCLASSIFIED
A L L - D O M A I N A N O M A L Y R E S O L U TI O N O F F I C E
The Defense Department’s
UAP Mission & Civil Aviation
Seán Kirkpatrick, Ph.D.
Director
DoD PPR Approved Slide, Case 23-S-0802
UNCLASSIFIED
U.S. Department of Defense &
Office of the Director of National Intelligence
Page 2
UNCLASSIFIED
AARO emerged from Congressional and Departmental recognition that UAP present
complex hazards and threats across service, regional, and domain boundaries.
What is the ALL-DOMAIN ANOMALY
RESOLUTION OFFICE (AARO)?
What outcomes does AARO aim to
produce?
How will AARO resolve phenomena?
Anomalous observation smaterial, behavioral, or capability attributes perceived to be beyond known
performance envelops
UNIDENTIFIED ANOMALOUS PHENOMENA
UAP are sources of anomalous spaceborne, airborne,
seaborne, or transmedium
observations that are not yet attributable to known actors
or causes
How are AARO’s mission
responsibilities applicable to you?
2
DoD PPR Approved Slide, Case 23-S-0802
UNCLASSIFIED
U.S. Department of Defense &
Office of the Director of National Intelligence
Page 3
UNCLASSIFIED
AARO is a uniquely-capable, Defense Department organization that integrates
operational, scientific, and intelligence capabilities to resolve UAP.
our mission
key scientific and intelligence questions
Physical, technical, behavioral, and contextual
characteristics of phenomena, their composition, and
their movement
minimize technical and intelligence surprise, by
synchronizing scientific, intelligence, and
operational detection, identification, attribution,
and mitigation of unidentified, anomalous objects
in the vicinity of national security areas
Capabilities, limitations, and vulnerabilities of
phenomena and any assessed technological gap
between phenomena and the United States
Indications and characteristics of hazards, risks and/or
threats by phenomena to the United States, its people,
its equities, and/or its instruments of national power
our vision
unidentified, anomalous objects are effectively and
efficiently detected, tracked, analyzed, and
managed by way of normalized DoD, IC, and civil
business practices; by adherence to the highest
scientific and intelligence-tradecraft standards; and
with greater transparency and shared awareness
3
DoD PPR Approved Slide, Case 23-S-0802
Attribution of phenomena to natural and/or artificial
sources
Indications of foreign observation of and reaction to
phenomena
The disposition of observed phenomena
UNCLASSIFIED
U.S. Department of Defense &
Office of the Director of National Intelligence
Page 4
UNCLASSIFIED
The potentially ubiquitous presence of UAP defines the national-security
implications and drives the broad range of stakeholders and demand for
rigorous scientific understanding of and intelligence on phenomena
US Territory & Operating Areas
DoD observations and reporting of
UAP most often in the vicinity of US
military facilities and operating areas
Threats to the immediate safety of US
citizens and Government facilities,
across domains, is priority
Safety and security risks of UAP
heighten US Government awareness
and drives research and mitigation
efforts
Key partners and stakeholders include
DoD, IC, DoJ, NASA, FAA
4
DoD PPR Approved Slide, Case 23-S-0802
US Strategic Capabilities
Reporting on UAP proximity to
strategic capabilities and critical
infrastructure primarily historical;
analysis limited by information currency
and source reliability
Consequence of UAP in the vicinity of
strategic capabilities is high, potentially
threatening strategic deterrence and
safety of civil society
Reporting on UAP activity in foreign
territory or operating areas limited by
source reliability
Consequence of such moderate-tohigh, potentially leading to adversarial
misattribution of UAP to the United
States
DoD strengthening observations and
reporting capabilities near US strategic
capabilities and critical infrastructure
Allies and strategic competitors apply
resources to observe, identify, and
attribute UAP (open source)
Key partners and stakeholders include
DoD, IC, DoE and NNSA, DoJ, DHS
Key partners and stakeholders include
DoD, IC, STATE, international partners
UNCLASSIFIED
U.S. Department of Defense &
Office of the Director of National Intelligence
Page 5
UNCLASSIFIED
AARO leads integration of the Department’s UAP operations, research, analyses, and
strategic-communications to deliver exquisite data, advanced sensors, sound analytics,
and shared mission awareness and ownership
synchronizing and
sequencing Theater, IC,
and other capabilities for
optimized, crossfunctional UAP
detection, tracking,
mitigation, and recovery
revealing and exploiting
elusive and enigmatic
signatures through
advanced technologies
and focused, crosssector partnerships
delivering peer-reviewed
conclusions through
deliberate syntheses of
scientific and intelligence
method, tradecraft,
tools, and expertise
driving shared awareness
across mission partners,
oversight authorities,
and stakeholders—
normalizing cross-sector
partnerships and
building trust with
transparency
Integrated-Operations
S&T Research & Application
Interdisciplinary Analyses
Focused Communications
5
DoD PPR Approved Slide, Case 23-S-0802
UNCLASSIFIED
U.S. Department of Defense &
Office of the Director of National Intelligence
Page 6
UNCLASSIFIED
Our mission success and our ability to contribute to
aviation safety depends on observations and insights
from the aviation community
Educate Aviators and Crews
The subject of UAP is laden with decades
of imprecise—and often sensational—
information
Promulgating accurate information about
UAP, their implications to flight safety and
national security, and our commitment to
resolving them is foundational to our
partnership with the community.
Sharing what UAP data is criticallyimportant for scientific and intelligence
analyses allows aviators and crews to
optimize the value of their observations
and reporting of phenomena
Encourage Reporting
Historically, reticence to UAP reporting
has limited the Government’s ability to
guard against aerial safety and security
threats
Aviators and crews informed about UAP
and willing to report have historically had
few official channels to submit
observational data
Destigmatizing discussion about and
reporting of UAP is essential for tracking,
resolving, and defending against such
phenomena
We are working with military, civil, and
industry partners to develop and field
reporting mechanisms available to
aviators and crews
Government efforts to encourage military
aviators and crews to report phenomena
have substantially increased the quantity
and quality of UAP data
By leveraging our systems, we will be able
to quickly incorporate aviators’ and crews’
reporting into the corpus of data, to
optimize scientific and intelligence
analyses, and to provide feedback to the
reporting individual and/or organization
Updating Civil Aviation Reporting Mechanism
6
DoD PPR Approved Slide, Case 23-S-0802
Leverage Our Expertise & Systems
UNCLASSIFIED
U.S. Department of Defense &
Office of the Director of National Intelligence
Page 7
UNCLASSIFIED
What kind of information would be necessary and
sufficient for UAP analyses?
about the phenomenon
UAP-event description or narrative
UAP location relative to the observer,
with as much precision as practicable
Number of UAP-objects observed
during the phenomenon and
indications of intra UAP-object
coordination and/or communication
Indications of advanced and/or
enigmatic capabilities
about the observer
UAP characteristics, including physical
state (e.g., solid, liquid, gas, plasma);
description (e.g., size, shape, color);
signatures; propulsion means; payload
Observer’s date, time, location, and travel
path for first and last observation of the
UAP, with as much precision as practicable
UAP performance envelope, including
altitude and/or depth; travel path and
trajectory; velocity; maneuverability
Sensors that detected the phenomenon
(e.g., visual, radar)
UAP behavior, including whether under
apparent intelligent control, apparent
response to observation and/or
observer presence, and apparent
indications of indifference or hostility
Observer’s behavior toward the UAP
Any physiological, psychological, or other
effects apparently corresponding to the
UAP observation
Observer’s assessment of the UAP,
including the nature of the phenomenon
and whether it was benign, a hazard, or a
threat
Identification of any other observers
7
DoD PPR Approved Slide, Case 23-S-0802
UNCLASSIFIED
U.S. Department of Defense &
Office of the Director of National Intelligence