Home › Archive › AARO

AARO-23-F-0922_4 — FOIA: Kirkpatrick statement to the Senate Armed Services subcommittee, 19 April 2023

File AARO-23-F-0922_4 is a declassified pdf from AARO. This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.

File
AARO-23-F-0922_4
Agency
AARO
File type
PDF

Open original file · AARO.MIL page

TL;DR

April 19, 2023: finally a UFO briefing without any UFOs.

  • Statement by Dr. Sean Kirkpatrick, AARO Director, to Senate Armed Services subcommittee, 19 April 2023
  • Describes AARO’s UAP mission, stresses science, says most reports mundane, no credible extraterrestrial evidence
  • States no credible extraterrestrial evidence found

AI summary

This is a statement for the record by Dr. Sean Kirkpatrick, Director of the All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO), presented to the Senate Armed Services Committee on Emerging Threats and Capabilities on April 19, 2023. The document outlines AARO's mission to investigate Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP) and emphasizes the importance of scientific rigor, data collection, and interagency collaboration. It states that most UAP reports can be explained by mundane sources, and no credible evidence of extraterrestrial activity has been found. The statement highlights AARO's commitment to transparency and scientific standards in resolving UAP cases.

Full text

Page 1

Dr. Sean Kirkpatrick
Director, All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office
Statement for the Record
Senate Armed Services Committee on Emerging Threats and Capabilities
April 19, 2023
Thank you, Chairwoman Gillibrand, Ranking Member Ernst, and distinguished
members of the Subcommittee and Congress. It is a privilege to be here today to
testify on the Department of Defense’s efforts to address Unidentified Anomalous
Phenomena.
First, I want to thank Congress for its extensive and continued partnership as the
Department works to better understand and respond to UAP in an effort to
minimize technical and intelligence surprise. Unidentified objects in any domain
pose potential risks to safety and security, particularly for military personnel and
capabilities. Congress and DoD agree that UAP cannot remain unexamined or
unaddressed.
We are grateful for sustained congressional engagement on this issue, which paved
the way for DoD’s establishment of the All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office in
July of last year. Though AARO is still a young office, the spotlight on UAP in
recent months underscores the importance of its work and the need for UAP to be
taken seriously as a matter of national security. All leadership that I’ve had the
pleasure of working with, whether DoD, IC, DOE, Civil, Scientific or Industrial,
view Congress as a critical partner in this endeavor.
AARO has accomplished much in the 9 months since it was established. The
AARO team of more than three dozen experts is organized around four functional
areas: operations, scientific research, integrated analysis, and strategic
communications. In the nine months since AARO’s establishment, we have taken
important steps to improve UAP data collection, standardize the Department’s
UAP internal reporting requirements, and implement a framework for rigorous
scientific and intelligence analysis, resolving cases in a systematic and prioritized
manner. Meanwhile, consistent with legislative direction, AARO is also carefully
reviewing and researching the U.S. Government’s UAP-related historical record.
AARO is leading a focused effort to better characterize, understand, and attribute
UAP, with priority given to UAP reports by DoD and IC personnel in or near areas
of national security importance. DoD fully appreciates the eagerness from many
Version 1-10 1

Page 2

quarters, including here in Congress and in the American public, to quickly resolve
every UAP encountered across the globe, from the distant past through today.
It is important to note, however, that AARO is the culmination of decades of DoD,
Intelligence Community, and congressionally-directed efforts to successfully
resolve UAP encountered first and foremost by U.S. military personnel,
specifically Navy and Air Force pilots.
The law establishing AARO is ambitious, and it will take time to realize the full
mission. We cannot answer decades of questions about UAP all at once, but we
must begin somewhere. While I assure you that AARO will follow scientific
evidence wherever it leads, I ask for your patience as DoD first prioritizes the
safety and security of our military personnel and installations, in all domains.
After all, UAP encountered first by highly capable DoD and IC platforms,
featuring the nation’s most advanced sensors, are those UAP most likely to be
successfully resolved by my office assuming data can be collected. If AARO
succeeds in first improving the ability of military personnel to quickly and
confidently resolve UAP that they encounter, I believe that in time we will have
greatly advanced the capability of the entire United States Government, including
its civilian agencies, to resolve UAP. However, it would be naive to believe that
the resolution of all UAP can be solely accomplished by the DoD and IC alone.
We will need to prioritize collection and leverage authorities for monitoring all
domains within the continental United States. AARO’s ultimate success will
require partnerships with the interagency, industry, academia, the scientific
community, and the public.
AARO is partnering with the Services, Intelligence Community, DOE and across
the U.S. government to tap into the resources of the interagency. The UAP
challenge is more an operational and scientific issue than an intelligence issue. As
such, we are also working with industry, academia, and the scientific community,
which bring their own resources, ideas, and expertise to this challenging problem
set. Robust collaboration and peer-review across a broad range of partners will
promote greater objectivity and transparency in the study of UAP.
I want to underscore today that only a very small percentage of UAP reports
display signatures that could reasonably be described as ‘anomalous.’ The majority
of unidentified objects reported to AARO demonstrate mundane characteristics of
balloons, unmanned aerial systems, clutter, natural phenomena, or other readily
explainable sources. While a large number of cases in our holdings remain
Version 1-10 2

Page 3

technically unresolved, this is primarily due to a lack of data associated with these
cases. Without sufficient data, we are unable to reach defendable conclusions that
meet the high scientific standards we set for resolution, and I will not close a case
that we cannot defend the conclusions of.
I recognize that this answer is unsatisfying to those who in good faith assume that
what they see with their eyes, with their cameras, or with their radars is
incontrovertible evidence of extraordinary characteristics and performance. Yet,
time and again, with sufficient scientific-quality data, it is fact that UAP often, but
not always, resolve into readily-explainable sources. Humans are subject to
deception and illusions, sensors to unexpected responses and malfunctions, and in
some cases intentional interference. Getting to the handful of cases that pass this
level of scrutiny is the mission of AARO.
That is not to say that UAP once resolved are no longer of national security
interest, however. On the contrary, learning that a UAP isn’t of exotic origin but is
instead “just a quadcopter” leads to the question of who is operating that
quadcopter, and to what purpose. The answers to those questions will inform
potential national security or law enforcement responses.
AARO is a member of the Department’s support to the Administration’s “Tiger
Team” effort to deal with stratospheric objects such as the PRC High Altitude
Balloon. When previously unknown objects are successfully identified, it is
AARO’s role to quickly and efficiently hand off such readily-explainable objects
to the Intelligence or Law Enforcement Communities for further analysis and
appropriate action. The U.S. Government—and DoD and the IC in particular—
has tremendous capabilities to deal with those encountered objects. In the wake of
the PRC HAB event, the interagency is working to better integrate and share
information to address identifiable stratospheric objects, but that is not AARO’s
lane.
Meanwhile, for the few cases in all domains that do demonstrate potentially
anomalous characteristics, AARO exists to help the DoD, IC, and interagency
resolve those anomalous cases. In doing so, AARO is approaching these cases
with the highest level of objectivity and analytic rigor. This includes physically
testing and employing modeling and simulation to validate our analyses and
underlying theories, then peer reviewing the results within the U.S. Government,
industry partners, and with appropriately-cleared academic institutions before
reaching any conclusions.
Version 1-10 3

Page 4

I should also state clearly for the record that in our research AARO has found no
credible evidence thus far of extraterrestrial activity, off-world technology, or
objects that defy the known laws of physics. In the event sufficient scientific data
were ever obtained that a UAP encountered can only be explained by
extraterrestrial origin, we are committed to working with our interagency partners
at NASA to appropriately inform the U.S. Government’s leadership of its findings.
For those few cases that have been leaked to the public previously, and
subsequently commented on by the U.S. Government, I encourage those who hold
alternative theories or views to submit your research to credible peer-reviewed
scientific journals. AARO is working to do the same. That is how science works,
not by blog or social media.
We know that there is tremendous public interest in UAP and a desire for answers
from AARO. By its very nature, the UAP challenge has for decades lent itself to
mystery, sensationalism, and even conspiracy. For that reason, AARO remains
committed to transparency, accountability, and to sharing as much with the
American public as we can, consistent with our obligation to protect intelligence
sources and methods and U.S. and Allied capabilities. However, AARO’s work
will take time if we are committed to doing it right. It means adhering to the
scientific method and the highest standards of research integrity. It means being
methodical and scrupulous. It means withholding judgment in favor of evidence. It
means following the data where it leads, wherever it leads. It means establishing
scientific, peer reviewed theoretical underpinnings of observed data. AARO is
committed to those standards.
I am proud of AARO’s progress over the last nine months. Much remains to be
done, but the hard work is under way.
Thank you for your continued support, and I look forward to your questions.

Version 1-10 4

Previous: AARO-23-F-0922_3 — FOIA: AARO mission briefing slides (2023)

Same topic: title & summary match

Same agency: AARO