AARO-23-F-0010 — FOIA: Avi Loeb email and article on Ukraine UAP "Phantoms" (October 2022)
File AARO-23-F-0010 is a declassified pdf from AARO. This page carries the original file, its official summary and its full text.
- File
- AARO-23-F-0010
- Agency
- AARO
- File type
Open original file · AARO.MIL page
TL;DR
Even the October 3 meeting agenda listed 'artillery shells' under 'extra-terrestrial'.
- FOIA pdf from AARO, Oct 2022, Ukraine UAP “Phantoms”.
- Email and article discuss Ukrainian astronomers' dark objects, likely artillery shells, plus Loeb’s interstellar work.
- No official conclusion in the file
AI summary
An email and article from October 2022 discuss unidentified aerial phenomena in Ukraine, referencing "Phantoms" reported by Ukrainian astronomers. The article, written by Avi Loeb, suggests the dark objects may be misinterpreted artillery shells rather than extraterrestrial technology. Additional sections include emails and articles by Loeb on interstellar objects and the Galileo Project, a paper co-authored by Loeb and Amir Siraj about two interstellar meteors, and emails between Loeb and Sean Kirkpatrick discussing a meeting on October 3, 2022.
Full text
Page 1
Attachments:
Avi Loeb <aloeb@cfa.harvard.edu >
Tuesday, October 4, 2022 1:32 PM
Abraham Loeb
[URL Verdict: Neutral][Non- DoD Source] "Down To Earth" Limits on Unidentified Aerial
Phenomena in Ukraine
arXiv_U.pdf
Follow Up Flag:
Flag Status:
Follow up
Completed
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
All active links contained in this email were disabled. Please verify the identity of the sender, and confirm the
authenticity of all links contained within the message prior to copying and pasting the address to a Web
browser.
The original scientific paper on which this essay is based, is available below and also at:
Caution-https://lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/,~loeb/arXiv_U.pdf < Caution
https://lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/arXiv_U.pdf >
The essay below is linked at:
Caution-https://avi-loeb.medium.com!down-to-earth-limits-on-unidentified-aerial-phenomena-in-ukraine6d8bb9f64f85 < Caution-https ://avi-loeb.medium.com!down-to-earth-limits-on-unidentified-aerial-phenomena
in-ukrainc-6d8bb9f64f85 >
u5J< Caution-https://medium.com/@avi-loeb?source=email-adb0e108a94b-1664904268122newsletter.subscribeToProfile-------------------------5274e172- 8dd0- 45f2- a372- 00ef1d103e94-------c9de49b8ef2b >
Avi Loeb < Caution-https://medium.com/@avi-loeb?source=email-adb0e108a94b-1664904268122newsletter.subscribeToProfile-------------------------527 4e172- 8dd0- 45f2- a372- 00ef1d103e94-------c9de49b8ef2b >
6 min read
View on Medium< Caution-https://medium.com/p/6d8bb9f64f85?source=email-adb0e108a94b1664904268122-newsletter.subscribeToProfile------------------------5274e172- 8dd0- 45f2- a372- 00ef1d103e94--------c9de49b8ef2b >
1
Page 2
"Down To Earth" Lilllits on Unidentified
Aerial Phenolllena in Ukraine
□
I□
An image of"pha11tom'' objects above Ukraine (C,·edit: Zhilyaev, Petukhov & Reshetnyk 2022)
I
Over the past two weeks I was bombarded by a dozen requests to read a new report < Caution
http: / /me.dm/r-qfQa1KrPLO?source=email-adboe108a94b-1664904268122newsletter .subscribeToProfile-------------------------5 274e172_ 8ddo_ 45f2_ a372_ ooehd103e94-------
c9de49b8ef2b > by astronomers on Unidentified Aerial Phenomena (UAP) in Ukraine. My response
to all of these messages was the same: "I am not sure what to make of the report. Ukraine is in a
military conflict with a lot of human-made activity in the sky. This must introduce a lot of noise for
any search for objects that are not human-made. In science we aim to maximize the signal-to-noise
ratio, and so Ukraine would be the last place on Earth where I would initiate UAP studies."
But last evening I received a special request from a high-level official in the US government to
summarize my thoughts on observable signatures of UAP and so this morning I checked the UAP
report from Ukraine and wrote a paper< Caution-http://me.dm/r-f51oscLH4J?source=email
adboe108a94b-1664904268122-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------------------5274e172_8ddo_45fa_a372_ooehd103e94--------c9de49b8efab > about it a few hours later.
The Ukranian paper< Caution-http://me.dm/r-qfQa1KrPLO?source=email-adboe108a94b1664904268122-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------------------5274e172_ 8ddo_ 45f2_ a372_ ooef1d103e94--------c9de49b8efab > reports about two types of
objects: luminous and dark. The dark objects with no visible emission were labeled as ' 'Phantoms".
2
Page 3
They were characterized by a size of 3-12 meters and speeds up to 15 kilometers per second at a
distance of up to 10-12 kilometers. If real, such objects exceed the capabilities ofhuman-made
aircrafts or rockets. I quickly realized that the distance of these dark objects must have been
incorrectly overestimated by an order of magnitude, or else their bow shock in the Earth's atmosphere
would have generated a bright fireball with an easily detectable optical luminosity.
The interest in UAP stems from their potential non-human origin. Extraterrestrial equipment could
arrive in two forms: space trash, similar to the way our own interstellar probes (Voyager 1 & 2,
Pioneer 10 & 11 and New Horizons) will appear in a billion years, or functional equipment, such as
autonomous devices equipped with Artificial Intelligence (AI). The latter would be an ideal choice for
crossing the tens ofthousands oflight years that span the scale ofthe Milky Way galaxy and could
survive even if the senders are not able to communicate.
It is likely that any functional devices embedded in the Earth's atmosphere are not carrying biological
entities because these would not survive the long journey through interstellar space and its harsh
conditions, including bombardment by energetic cosmic-rays, X-rays and gamma-rays. Interstellar
gas and dust particles deposit a kinetic energy per unit mass that exceeds the output of chemical
explosives at the speed of tens of kilometers per second characterizing rockets. However,
technological gadgets with AI can be shielded to withstand the hazards of space, repair themselves
mechanically, or even reproduce given the resources of a habitable planet like Earth. With Machine
Learning capabilities, they can adapt to new circumstances and pursue the goals of their senders
without any need for external guidance.
As argued by John von Neumann in 1939, the number of such devices could increase exponentially
with time if they self-replicate, a quality enabled by 3D printing and AI technologies. Physical artifacts
might also carry messages, as envisioned by Ronald Bracewell in 1960.
In principle, the fastest gadgets could be launched by lightsails, pushed by powerful light beams up to
the speed of light. Natural processes, such as stellar explosions or gravitational slingshot near black
hole pairs, could launch objects to similar speeds. However, it would be difficult for relativistic
payloads to slow down below the escape speed of Earth, smaller by 4.5 orders of magnitude than the
speed oflight, without having around the same facilities that generated their high initial speeds.
A better suited propulsion technique that was used in all space missions from Earth is chemical
rockets. Since rockets carry their fuel, they can navigate to a desired planet and slow down near it.
The tyranny of the rocket equation, requiring that the fuel mass must increase exponentially with
increasing terminal speed, explains why all human-made spacecraft reached a speed limit of tens of
kilometers per second, 4 orders of magnitude below the speed oflight. Interestingly, this speed is
comparable to the escape speed from the Earth's orbit around the Sun, 42 kilometers per second,
making it possible for humanity to launch probes to interstellar space by taking advantage of the
motion of the Earth around the Sun at 30 kilometers per second. Chemical propulsion may not be
sufficient for probes to escape from the habitable zone around dwarf stars, like the nearest star,
Proxima Centauri.
In summary, chemical propulsion allows escape from the habitable zone of Sun-like stars and enables
slowing down near a destination. The Ukranian report suggests objects with comparable speeds of up
to 15 kilometers per second.
Devices which need to refuel would favor a habitable planet where liquid water or combustible
organic fuel are available. Planets can be identified from a distance as they transit their star or
3
Page 4
through direct imaging. Once an Earth-like planet is targeted, an interstellar device can plunge into its
atmosphere. In principle, a multitude of tiny devices can be released from a mothership that passes
near Earth.
At a final speed of 30 kilometers per second, a probe would cross twice the distance of the Sun from
the Milky-Way center within a time of half a billion years. The fraction of all Sun-like stars that host
Earth-like planets in their habitable zone is in the range 3- 100%. This implies that self-replicating
probes could reach ten billion habitable planets around Sun-like stars in less than a billion years.
Since most stars formed more than a billion years before the Sun, it is possible that other
technological civilizations predated ours by the amount oftime needed for their devices to reach
Earth. My paper< Caution-http://me.dm/r-f51oscLH4J?source=email-adboe1o8a94b16649o4268122-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------------------5274e172_ 8ddo_ 45f2_ a372_ ooefld103e94--------c9de49b8ef2b > points out that any supersonic
motion of such devices through the Earth's atmosphere would inevitably be accompanied by optical
em1ss1on.
I showed that an object with a frontal cross-sectional area of 10 square meters, moving at a supersonic
speed of 10 kilometers per second must create a bow shock in the Earth's atmosphere and dissipate a
mechanical power of 1.5 terra-Watt at an elevation of 10 kilometers. Data on meteors implies that
about a tenth of the kinetic power which is radiated away in the optical band implying that the
reported properties ofthe Phantom objects above Ukraine would result in a fireball ofvisible
luminosity above 150 giga-Watt. For a path length 10 kilometers, the emission would last at least a
second and cannot be missed.
I concluded that the reported speeds and sizes ofthe ' 'Phantom" objects would have generated
fireballs of detectable optical luminosity at their suggested distances, and so these objects could not
have appeared dark. However, if the Phantom objects are ten times closer than suggested, then their
angular motion on the sky corresponds to a physical velocity that is ten times smaller, 1.5 kilometers
per second and their inferred transverse size would be 0.3-1.2 meters, both characteristic of artillery
shells.
The inferred fireball luminosity scales with distance to the 5th power, and is reduced to a modest level
of a few MW if the distance is shorter by a factor of ten than suggested by the Ukranian astronomers.
If the artillery shells have a frontal diameter ofonly 10 cm, then the inferred fireball luminosity is
merely 10 kilo-Watt, which at a kilometer distance would appear extremely faint like a 100-Watt light
bulb at a distance of 100 meters.
The Ukrainian astronomers also identified a luminous and variable object at an altitude of 1,170
kilometers, which was detected through two-site observations above Ukraine. This object is likely a
satellite.
Altogether "down to Earth" explanations can account for the reported UAP above Ukraine. But in
salute to my colleagues in Ukraine, let me conclude with a quote < Caution-http://me.dm/r
HcuVx1MixB?source=email-adboe108a94b-1664904268122-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile-----------
-------------5274e172_ 8ddo_ 45f2_ a372_ ooefld103e94--------c9de49b8ef2b > from Oscar Wilde:
"We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars."
4
Page 5
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
□
Avi Loeb is the head of the Galileo Project, founding director of Harvard University's-Black Hole
Initiative, director ofthe Institute for Theory and Computation at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center
for Astrophysics, and the former chair ofthe astronomy department at Harvard University (20112020). He chairs the advisory board for the Breakthrough Starshot project, and is a former member of
the President's Council of Advisors on Science and Technology and a former chair of the Board on
Physics and Astronomy ofthe National Academies. He is the bestselling author of
"Extraterrestrial: < Caution-http://me.dm/r-Ei84mwix_ w?source=email-adboe108a94b1664904268122-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------------------5274e172_ 8ddo_ 45fa_ a372_ ooef1d103e94--------c9de49b8efab > The First Sign ofIntelligent Life
Beyond Earth< Caution-http://me.dm/r-Ei84mwix_w?source=email-adboe1o8a94b1664904268122-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------------------5274e172_ 8ddo_ 45fa_ a372_ ooef1d103e94--------c9de49b8efab >"and a co-author of the textbook
"Life in the Cosmos< Caution-http://me.dm/r-nVUotn4yw6?source=email-adboe1o8a94b1664904268122-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------------------5274e172_8ddo_45fa_a372_ooef1d103e94--------c9de49b8efab >",both published in 2021.
Respond on Medium< Caution
https://medium.com/p/6d8bb9f64f85?responsesOpen=true&source=email-adb0e108a94b1664904268122-newsletter.subscribeToProfile------------------------5274e 172- 8dd0- 45f2- a372- 00ef1d103e94--------c9de49b8ef2b >
View story< Caution-https://medium.com/p/6d8bb9f64f85?source=email-adb0e108a94b1664904268122-newsletter.subscribeToProfile------------------------5274e 172- 8dd0- 45f2- a372- 00ef1d103e94--------c9de49b8ef2b >
5
Page 6
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Avi Loeb <aloeb@cfa.harvard.edu>
Monday, October 3, 2022 10:18 AM
Kirkpatrick, Sean M HQE OSD OUSD INTEL & SEC (USA)
[URL Verdict: Neutral]Re: [Non- DoD Source] SALT New York I Avi Loeb: Are We Alone
in the Universe? The Galileo Project
All active links contained in this email were disabled. Please verify the identity of the sender, and confirm the
authenticity of all links contained within the message prior to copying and pasting the address to a Web
browser.
Yes, Sean. I look forward to seeing you at 4PM today.
Here are some new essays from the last week:
*"Rogue Planets", Medium (October 3, 2022) < Caution-https://avi-loeb.medium.com/rogue-planets10066adcae36 >
*"Permanent Climate Change on Habitable Planets", Medium (October 2, 2022) < Caution-https://avi
loeb.medium.com/permanent-climate-change-on-habitable-planets-858248925dbe >
*"Do Astronomers Exist on Other Habitable Planets?", Medium (September 30, 2022) < Caution-https://avi
loeb.medium.com/do-astronomers-exist-on-other-habitable-planets-b0D2b6549f7 >
*"An Extraterrestrial Resolution to the Absurdity of Life", Medium (September 28, 2022) < Caution-https://avi
loeb. medium. com/an-extraten-estrial-resolution-to-the-absurdity-of-life-2ef7021 0b3e3 >
*"Understanding Ourselves Thanks to Sentient AI Systems", Medium (September 27, 2022) < Caution
https://avi-loeb.medium.com/understanding-ourselves-thanks-to-sentient-ai-systems-3d73d6736400 >
Abraham (Av!) Loeb
Frank B. Baird Jr. Professor ofScience
Director, Institute for Theory & Computation
Harvard University
Professional website< Caution-https://lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/ >
List of Essa s < Caution-htt s://lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/Opinion.html >
6
Page 7
ornmg,
Still good for 4 this afternoon?
Best,
Sean
a e: e nes ay, eptem er
at :
To: "Avi Loeb" <aloeb@cfa.harvard.edu < Caution-mailto:aloeb@cfa.harvard.edu > >
Subject: RE: [Non-DoD Source] SALT New York I Avi Loeb: Are We Alone in the Universe?
The Galileo Project
Thanks Avi. Looking forward to seeing you next week.
From: Avi Loeb <aloeb@cfa.harvard.edu < Caution-mailto:aloeb@cfa.harvard.edu > >
Sent: Wednesday, September 28, 2022 8:06 AM
To: Abraham Loeb <aloeb@cfa.harvard.edu < Caution-mailto:aloeb@cfa.harvard.edu > >
Subject: [Non-DoD Source] SALT New York I Avi Loeb: Are We Alone in the Universe? The
Galileo Project
Caution-https://youtu.be/Yoy_7ZVlmoM < Caution-https://youtu.be/Yoy_7ZVlmoM >
Harvard astrophysicist Avi Loeb, Frank B. Baird Jr. Professor of Science at Harvard University, sat
down with Alex Klokus, Founder & Managing Partner at Kyber Capital, to discuss Loeb's work
heading The Galileo Project. They talk about the extensive research and writing Loeb has done
around potential extraterrestrial life in the Universe. SALT is a global thought leadership and
networking forum at the intersection of finance, technology and public policy. SALT New York, the
first event held at the Javits Center Expansion, returned to Manhattan's west side September 1214, 2022 for three days of collaboration focused on innovation.
7
Page 8
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Kirkpatrick, Sean M HQE OSD OUSD INTEL & SEC (USA)
Monday, October 3, 2022 9:43 AM
Avi Loeb
Re: [Non- DoD Source] SALT New York I Avi Loeb: Are We Alone in the Universe? The
Galileo Project
Morning,
Still good for 4 this afternoon?
Best,
Sean
D OUSD INTEL & SEC (USA)"
at 9:06:00 AM
a e: e nes ay, ep em er
To: "Avi Loeb" <aloeb@cfa.harvard.edu>
Subject: RE: [Non-DoD Source] SALT New York I Avi Loeb: Are We Alone in the Universe?
The Galileo Project
Thanks Avi. Looking forward to seeing you next week.
From: Avi Loeb <aloeb@cfa.harvard.edu>
Sent: Wednesday, September 28, 2022 8:06 AM
To: Abraham Loeb <aloeb@cfa.harvard.edu>
Subject: [Non-DoD Source] SALT New York I Avi Loeb: Are We Alone in the Universe? The
Galileo Project
bttps://youtu.be/Yoy 7ZVlmoM
Harvard astrophysicist Avi Loeb, Frank B. Baird Jr. Professor of Science at Harvard University, sat
down with Alex Klokus, Founder & Managing Partner at Kyber Capital, to discuss Loeb's work
heading The Galileo Project. They talk about the extensive research and writing Loeb has done
around potential extraterrestrial life in the Universe. SALT is a global thought leadership and
networking forum at the intersection of finance, technology and public policy. SALT New York, the
first event held at the Javits Center Expansion, returned to Manhattan's west side September 12-14,
2022 for three days of collaboration focused on innovation.
8
Page 9
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Avi Loeb <aloeb@cfa.harvard.edu>
Tuesday, September 20, 2022 6:27 PM
Kirkpatrick, Sean M HQE OSD OUSD INTEL & SEC (USA)
Re: [URL Verdict: Neutral](Non- DoD Source] Discovery of a Second Interstellar Meteor:
Meter-Size Interstellar Objects Are Much Tougher than ...
All active links contained in this email were disabled. Please verify the identity of the sender, and confirm the
authenticity of all links contained within the message prior to copying and pasting the address to a Web
browser.
For !Ml, the error on the air density is negligible and the enor on the velocity measurement is
smaller than a few percent. Here is the complete information:
Original discovery paper: Caution-https://arxiv.org/pdf/1904.07224.pdf < Caution
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1904.07224.pdf >
Government confirmation Letter: Caution-https://lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/Opinion.htmJ < Caution
https://lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/Opinion.html >
Material strength paper: Caution-https://arxiv.org/pdf/2204.08482 < Caution
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2204.08482 >
The fi.rebalJ lightcurve: Caution-https://lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/lightcurve.pdf < Caution
https://lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/lightcurve.pdf >
NBC video: Caution-https://www.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/NBCPNG.mov < Caution
https://www.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/NBCPNG .mov >
NPR audio: Caution-https://www.npr.org/2022/08/ l6/l l l 77622 l l/an-astronomers-plan-to-trawl-the-ocean
floor-for-signs-of-extraterrestrial-life < Caution-https://www.npr.org/2022/08/ l 6/ l l l 7762211/an-astronomers
plan-to-trawl-the-ocean-floor-for-signs-of-extratenestrial-life >
Overview: Caution-https://avi-loeb.medium.com/the-first-interstellar-meteor-7d97bcb970cd < Caution
https://avi-loeb.medium.corn/the-first-interstellar-meteor-7d97bcb970cd >
What we know:
The meteor had a geocentric velocity vector:
(vx, vy, vz) = (- 3.4, - 43.5, - 10.3) km s- 1, located at 1.3° S 147.6° E, at an altitude of 18.7 km, at the time of
impact, 2014-01-08 17:05:34 UTC, as
reported in the CNEOS catalog.
The above localization is within 10 kilometers; we need another significant digit. If you can find it for
us, it would save us a lot of time in the expedition search area.
There are a million objects like IMl at any given time within the orbit of the Earth around the Sun.
But a thousand times more Solar system rocks.
9
Page 10
Avi
Abraham (Avt) Loeb
Frank B. Baird Jr. Professor ofScience
Directo0 Institute for Theory & Computation
Harvard University
Professional website< Caution-https://lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/ >
b.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/Opinion.html >
estimate? 10%?
In your analysis, you assume a Gaussian distribution of the interstellar population for the naturally occurring
events. Is there a situation in which a non-Gaussian distribution would come into play? Specifically an
exploding supernova's geometric cross-section overlapping with the Solar System's orientation and distance?
Are we certain the explosion is spherically symmetric?
With regard' s to artificial spacecraft, am I correct in concluding that the release of probes, microsats etc, is
based on the assumption that it is earth's atmosphere that triggers it? Have you thought about other planets
near our Habitable zone?
In any event that's exciting to find two objects. I suspect there's more.
Sean
From: "Avi Loeb" <aloeb@cfa.harvard.edu < Caution-mailto:aloeb@cfa.harvard.edu > >
Date: Tuesday, September 20, 2022 at 5:31 :26 PM
To: "Kirk atrick S an M H E OSD OUSD INTEL
Interstellar Objects Are Much Tougher than ...
All active links contained in this email were disabled. Please verify the identity of the sender, and confirm the
authenticity of all links contained within the message prior to copying and pasting the address to a Web
browser.
10
Page 12
Are Much Tougher than Solar Systelll
Rocks!
Figures from the new paper by Amir Siraj & Aui Loeb (September 20, 2022)
In a new paper< Caution-Caution-http://me.dm/r-t7rBQ5RzPo?source=email-adboe1o8a94b1663698644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------------------3d24b676_ ec62_41eo_ b8d9_ 96bff4ob5097--------c9de49b8ef2b < Caution-http:// me.dm/r
t7rBQ5RzPo?source=email-adboe108a94b-1663698644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------
------------3d24b676_ ec62_ 41eo_ b8d9_ 96bff4ob5097--------c9de49b8ef2b > > with my student,
Amir Siraj, we have identified a second interstellar meteor, IM2, in the CNEOS fireball
catalog < Caution-Caution-http://me.dm/r-EoF8XWzfiT?source=emai1-adboe108a94b1663698644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------------------3d24b676_ec62_41eo_b8d9_96bff4ob5097--------c9de49b8ef2b < Caution-http://me.dm/r
EoF8:XWzfiT?source=email-adboe108a94b-1663698644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile-----------
-------------3d24b676_ec62_41eo_b8d9_96bff4ob5097--------c9de49b8ef2b > > of NASA. The two
interstellar meteors are meter-scale objects that collided with Earth from a trajectory that was
gravitationally unbound to the Sun. In other words, the objects arrived to the Solar system from
interstellar space and were moving faster than the escape speed from the Sun when they were
collected by the "fishing net" of the Earth's atmosphere.
Aui Loeb (left) and Amir Siraj (right) at Loeb's Harvard office; Photograph taken on September 15, 2022.
The first interstellar meteor, CNEOS 2014-01-08 (IMt), that Amir and I discovered in
2019 < Caution-Caution-http://me.dm/r-BpgRCuSvgn?source=email-adboe108a94b1663698644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------------------3d24b676_ec62_41eo_b8d9_96bff4ob5097--------c9de49 b8ef2b < Caution-http://me.dm/r
BpgRCuSvgn?source=email-adboe108a94b-1663698644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile-----------
-------------3d24b676_ec62_41eo_b8d9_96bff4ob5097--------c9de49b8ef2b > >, was confirmed at
the 99.999% confidence level by a letter < Caution-Caution-http://me.dm/r
aqJrqFnno2?source=email-adboe108a94b-1663698644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------
------------3d24b676_ec62_41eo_b8d9_96bff4ob5097--------c9de49b8ef2b < Caution
http://me.dm/r-aqJrqFnno2?source=email-adboe1o8a94b-1663698644902newsletter.subscribeT0Profile-------------------------3d24b676_ec62_41eo_b8d9_96bff4ob5097------
-c9de49b8ef2b > > from the US Space Command to NASA. The second interstellar meteor we just
discovered, CNEOS 2017-03-09 (IM2), was ten times more massive and roughly a meter in size. It
was moving at a speed of 40 (compared to 60 for IM1) kilometers per second relative to the Local
Standard of Rest < Caution-Caution-http:/ /me.dm/r-u_4S4wS_ 6-?source=email-adboe108a94b1663698644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------------------3d24b676_ ec62_ 41eo_ b8d9_ 96bff4ob5097--------c9de49b8ef2b < Caution-http://me.dm/ru_ 4S4wS_ 6-?source=email-adboe108a94b-1663698644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile-----------
-------------3d24b676_ec62_41eo_b8d9_96bff40b5097--------c9de49b8ef2b > >, the local frame of
reference of the Milky Way that averages over the motions ofall the stars in the vicinity ofthe Sun.
Remarkably, both IMt and IM2 disintegrated low in the Earth's atmosphere despite their unusually
high speeds. The air ram pressure, which is the product ofthe air mass density and the square ofthe
meteors' speed when they explode into fireballs, provides an estimate for the yield strength of their
12
Page 13
material composition. The inferred material strengths of 194 Mega-Pascals (MPa) for IM1 and 75 MPa
for IM2 imply that both were tougher than iron meteorites, which have a maximum yield strength of
50 MPa.
IM1 and IM2 ranked number 1 and 3 in the distribution of material strengths among all 273 meteors
in the CNEOS catalog < Caution-Caution-http://me.dm/r-EoF8XWzfiT?source=emailadboe1o8a94b-1663 69 8 644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------------------3d24b676_ ec62_41eo_b8d9_ 96bff4ob5097--------c9de49b8efab < Caution-http://me.dm/r
EoF8XWzfiT?source=email-adboe108a94b-1663698644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile-----------
-------------3d24b676_ec62_41eo_b8d9_96bff4ob5097--------c9de49b8ef2b > > . The probability of
drawing the material strength ofthe first and second interstellar meteors out of the familiar
population of Solar system rocks is roughly the square of (3/273), or equivalently one part in 10,000.
This means that the population of interstellar meteors is different from Solar system meteors at the
99.99% confidence level. This conclusion is corroborated by fitting the distribution ofCNEOS meteors
with a Gaussian shape in the logarithm of material strength. Both IM1 and IM2 lie on the far tail of
the distribution, at 2.6 and 3.5 standard deviations away from the mean, making their combined
likelihood less than a part in a million.
This tantalizing conclusion about the extremely rare material strength of IM1 and IM2, implies that
interstellar meteors are not rocks from planetary systems like the Solar systems.
The Earth collides with interstellar objects along its orbit around the Sun. The simplest assumption to
make is that these objects arrive into the Solar system on random trajectories in the Local Standard of
Rest. Based on the detection rate of IM1 and IM2 in the CNEOS catalog, roughly once per decade, one
can infer that about 40% of all refractory elements < Caution-Caution-http: / / me.dm/rpDj2SdFiQo ?source= email-adboe1o8a94b-166369 8644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile-----------
-------------3d24b676_ ec62_ 41eo _b8d9 _ 96bff40b5097--------c9de49b8ef2b < Caution
http://me.dm/r-pDj2SdFiQo?source=email-adboe108a94b-16636986449o2newsletter.subscribeT0Profile-------------------------3d24b676_ ec62_41eo_b8d9_ 96bff4ob5097------
-c9de49b8ef2b > > in the Milky-Way galaxy are locked in meter-scale interstellar objects. This
extraordinarily high abundance again seems to defy a planetary system origin.
Interestingly, a paucity of refractory elements is observed in the gas phase in the interstellar medium,
an observation which could potentially reflect refractory elements being locked in interstellar objects.
Supernovae have been observed to produce iron-rich "bullets", which could be a possible origin of IM1
and IM2. In particular, X-ray imaging of the Vela supernova remnant revealed< Caution-Caution
http://me.dm/r-sWuuGF-wiY?source=email-adboe1o8a94b-16636986449o2newsletter.subscribeToProfile-------------------------3d24b676_ec62_41eo_b8d9_96bff4 ob5097------
-c9de49b8ef2b < Caution-http://me.dm/r-sWuuGF-wiY?source=email-adboe108a94b1663698644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------------------3d24b676_ec62_41eo_b8d9_96bff4ob5097--------c9de49b8efab > > bow shocks from bullets flying
out ofthe explosion site, a discovery that I attempted to explain < Caution-Caution-http://me.dm/r
wvfe-CixZI?source=email-adboe108a94b-1663698644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile-------------
-----------3d24b676_ ec62_41eo_b8d9_ 96bff4ob5097--------c9de49b8efab < Cautionhttp: / /me.dm/r-wvfe-ClxZI?source=email-adboe108a94b-1663698644902newsletter.subscribeToProfile-------------------------3d24b676_ec62_41eo_b8d9_96bff4 ob5097------
-c9de49b8ef2b > > three decades ago. It is possible that IM1 and IM2 were shot out of an exploding
star.
But it is also possible that IM1 and IM2 move fast and are tough because they are artificial in origin,
namely chemically-propelled interstellar spacecraft like our own interstellar probes < Caution13
Page 14
Caution-http://me.elm/r-2EoVa9nljO?source=email-adboe108a94b-1663698644902newsletter.subscribeToProfile-------------------------3d24b676_ ec62_41eo_b8d9_96bff4 ob5097------
-c9de49b8ef2b < Caution-http://me.dm/r-2EoVa9nljO?source=email-adboe1o8a94b1663698644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------------------3d24b676_ec62_41eo_b8d9_96bff4ob5097--------c9de49b8ef2b > >, but launched a billion years
ago. One can also imagine a mother craft canying CubeSats < Caution-Caution-http://me.dm/r
cfuFXPTq5B?source=email-adboe108a94b-1663698644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile-----------
-------------3d24b676_ ec62_ 41eo_ b8d9_ 96bff4ob5097--------c9de49b8ef2b < Caution
http://me.dm/r-cfuFXPTq5B?source=email-adboe1o8a94b-16636986449o2newsletter.subscribeToProfile-------------------------3d24b676_ec62_41eo_b8d9_96bff4 ob5097------
-c9de49b8ef2b > > or micro-devices in its belly, which like Dandelion seeds automatically get
released through friction with the atmosphere of a habitable planet.
The inferred abundance of interstellar objects could be smaller by 16 orders of magnitude < Caution
Caution-http://me.dm/r-vZ8ia_wRGb?source=email-adboe108a94b-16636986449o2newsletter.subscribeT0Profile-------------------------3d24b676_ ec62_41eo_ b8d9_ 96bff4ob5097------
-c9de49b8ef2b < Caution-http://me.dm/r-vZ8ia_wRGb?source=email-adboe108a94b1663698644902-newsletter.subscribeT0Profile------------------------3d24b676_ ec62_ 41eo_ b8d9_ 96bff4ob5097--------c9de49b8ef2b > > for functional devices that are
designed to visit the habitable regions of stars. This large factor is the ratio between the interstellar
volume associated with the Sun (half-way to the nearest stars) -which would be uniformly populated
Next: AARO-23-F-0204 — FOIA: List of AARO UAP case serial numbers (December 2022)